CDConstance M. Doty

Constance M. Doty

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Constance M. Doty has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Practicing Physicist s Perception of the Viability of Physics Teacher and Professor Careers for Individuals with Disabilities

    by Daniel Oleynik, Erin M. Scanlon, Constance M. Doty, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    The perceptions that physics mentors have about disability in physics influences how they interact with their mentees, and negative biases against disability can influence students to feel discouraged within the physics community. We administered the Disability and Physics Career Survey (DPCS) through physicsspecific listservs and at physics-specific conferences to measure practicing physicists' knowledge about disability and their beliefs about the viability of physics careers for individuals with a variety of disability diagnoses. This study uses Cochran's Q and McNemar's R to compare how practicing physicists' perceptions of the viability for the careers of teacher and professor depend on the impairment that an individual is diagnosed with. We find that practicing physicists view these careers as non-viable for those with cognitive impairments and hold other unconscious biases that we outline and interrogate.

  • Open Access

    Physics Graduate Teaching Assistant Use of Error Framing in Recitations and Laboratories

    by Daniel Sharkey, Constance M. Doty, Tong Wan, Erin K. H. Saitta, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    Despite the positive gains towards student learning outcomes and engagement, active learning has been shown to potentially increase student anxiety due to a fear of negative evaluation. A pedagogical strategy proposed to mediate this issue is known as error framing; it asks instructors to encourage a perception of errors as being a natural part of the learning process. Previous work on this project investigated how graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) operationalized error framing during their training in a mixed-reality simulator but did not investigate their usage of it in their classrooms. This analysis characterizes the error framing statements made by GTAs during a set of classroom observations. We find that GTAs who employ error framing effectively avoid statements that might decrease student comfort and instead tend towards implicit, indirect strategies.

  • Open Access

    Using clusters of models of disabilities to describe support for mentees with disabilities

    by Constance M. Doty, Daniel Oleynik, Erin M. Scanlon, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    Students with disabilities involved in postsecondary physics education may benefit from research opportunities and mentorship. However, the literature documenting supports provided by physics mentors to disabled students is limited. In this study, we analyze interviews with five mentors who either instruct physics courses or lead a research group for examples of how they support disabled students doing research or seeking career advice. Furthermore, we contextualize the examples of supports using six models of disability. Models include the cause of disability (medical/social), the effect of impairment on well-being (tragedy/affirmative), and the dichotomy of dis/ability (minority/universal). We find mentors discuss supports provided to disabled students in research settings that align with clusters of models of disability. While there is not one set of models that yields a one-size-fits-all solution, the universal model plus social model cluster can help mentors design useful and durable supports.


  • Open Access

    Three axes for expressing disability models and experiences: The cause, the effect, and the ability/disability dichotomy

    by Daniel Oleynik, Constance M. Doty, Erin M. Scanlon, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    In interviews with physics students and early career physicists, we ask about their experiences with having impairments in the physics setting and physics culture. In this paper, we highlight how experiences shared by participants as disabled people in physics represent clusters of models of disability. Specifically, we apply a theoretical framing of a three-dimensional disability model space, with axes defined as medical versus social (i.e., cause); tragedy versus affirmative (i.e., effect); and minority group versus universal (i.e., ability/disability dichotomy). For example, in this framework, providing accommodations is described by a cluster of the social and minority models of disability. By analyzing participants' experiences in physics through this disability framework, we aim to identify the models that underpin supportive experiences and support the development of policies and professional development for the physics community towards benefiting disabled people. Through analysis and comparison of these models and participants' narratives, we offer a discussion and possible guidelines for instructors interacting with students with disabilities, opportunities for those with disabilities to deconstruct their own prior experiences and analyze potential misinterpretations that may arise from the models. .


  • Open Access

    Impact of high-intensity training with a mixed-reality simulator on graduate teaching assistants use of questioning

    by Constance M. Doty, Ashley A. Geraets, Tong Wan, Christopher A. Nix, Erin K. H. Saitta, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    Physics graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) are tasked with multifaceted teaching assignments, such as leading tutorials and inquiry-based laboratories, yet their professional development rarely includes opportunities to rehearse complex pedagogical skills or receive feedback on their teaching. In this study, physics GTAs practiced specific pedagogical skills during four sessions in a mixed-reality classroom simulator; here, we focus on GTAs’ use of a specific questioning strategy called “Stretch-It.” GTAs can apply Stretch-It by asking students to explain their logic (Explain Logic), either by explaining their work or providing evidence for their claim; or by asking students to take the content further (Follow-Up), either by applying it in an analogous situation or answering the initial question in another way. We found GTAs used all four types of Stretch-It subcategories during simulator sessions that incorporated facilitator feedback about their use of questioning. We also compared the use of Stretch-It questioning in the classroom for a pretraining semester cohort and the high-intensity simulator training cohort and found that the high-intensity cohort’s average use of Explain Logic questions in the observation immediately following the Stretch-It rehearsal was meaningfully higher than the pretraining cohort’s average use of Explain Logic. However, the high-intensity cohort’s use of Explain Logic is unstable, and values fall back within the pretraining average in subsequent classroom observations. We did not find a significant difference between the cohorts’ use of Follow-Up. We discuss the implications of our findings for science, technology, engineering, and medicine GTA professional development and the significance of providing feedback to GTAs about their teaching.


  • Open Access

    Impact of changing physical learning space on GTA and student behaviors

    by Constance M. Doty, Tong Wan, Ashley A. Geraets, Christopher A. Nix, Erin K. H. Saitta, Jacquelyn J. Chini

  • Open Access

    Characterizing graduate teaching assistants teaching practices in physics mini-studios

    by Tong Wan, Constance M. Doty, Ashley A. Geraets, Erin K. H. Saitta, Jacquelyn J. Chini


  • Open Access

    Student perspective of GTA strategies to reduce feelings of anxiousness with cold-calling

    by Constance M. Doty, Ashley A. Geraets, Tong Wan, Erin K. H. Saitta, Jacquelyn J. Chini

    We investigated student perceptions of cold calling on their feelings of anxiousness and how graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) alleviated these feelings when students shared their ideas publicly in the context of tutorial and laboratory sessions. Physics and chemistry GTAs who led active-learning tutorials and labs practiced cold calling paired with error framing with avatar-students in a mixed-reality simulator at the beginning of the semester. Then, we observed the GTAs teaching real students in their actual classroom. We recruited eleven students from sections led by GTAs who were observed to use cold calling in their classroom to participate in semi-structured interviews. Several students reported that cold calling increased their feelings of anxiousness. However, students also reported that GTAs used strategies paired with cold calling that reduced their feelings of anxiousness, such as acknowledging student responses as valuable and remembering student names. We discuss implications for professional development on active learning strategies.


  • Open Access

    Differences between the SCALE-UP model and instructors' perceptions of implementation

    by Brian Zamarripa Roman, Constance M. Doty, Matthew Wilcox, Noel Klinger, Jarrad W. T. Pond, Joshua S. Von Korff, Jacquelyn J. Chini