Elizabeth Robson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Elizabeth Robson has a total of 33 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Chiara Bonacchi
School of History, Classics and Archaeology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
2 shared publications - Elisa Broccoli
Dipartimento di Storia, Archeologia, Geografia, Arte e Spettacolo, Università di Firenze, 50121 Firenze, Italy
2 shared publications Alex Hiscock
School of History, Classics and Archaeology and Edinburgh Futures Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
1 shared publication- Ana Pastor Pérez
Getty Conservation Institute
1 shared publication - Avery
National Research Council, Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics, 5071 W. Saanich Road., Victoria, BC V8X 4M6, Canada
1 shared publication - David Barreiro
Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Assessing the Social Values of Heritage
Assessing the Social Values of Heritage considers how social values can be better understood and incorporated into the day-to-day work of managing and conserving the historic environment. Drawing together major strands of thinking from critical heritage studies, ethnography and social research, and science and technology studies, the book explores the theoretical and practical tensions that shifting discourses on value and contemporary significance have created for heritage practitioners. Presenting seven case studies of social value assessments, it discusses how qualitative methods and participatory approaches can be applied in a variety of real-world contexts, revealing the complex interactions that characterise these dynamic knowledge production processes. The book provides unique insights into methods as more-than-technical processes that determine not only how, but which knowledge is (re)produced, shaping understandings of social values. It concludes that bringing social values into heritage practice requires not only new methods and approaches, but new ways of working with emergent understandings and multiple types of expertise. In response to the challenges - and the opportunities - identified, the concept of a ‘methods assemblage’ is employed, offering an effective model for more reflexive and inclusive future practice in this area. Assessing the Social Values of Heritage provides the first systematic, comparative review of methods for social values assessment. It will be essential reading for practitioners, academics and scholars engaged in the study of heritage, participatory research, and people-centred methods.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Assessing the Social Values of Heritage
Assessing the Social Values of Heritage considers how social values can be better understood and incorporated into the day-to-day work of managing and conserving the historic environment. Drawing together major strands of thinking from critical heritage studies, ethnography and social research, and science and technology studies, the book explores the theoretical and practical tensions that shifting discourses on value and contemporary significance have created for heritage practitioners. Presenting seven case studies of social value assessments, it discusses how qualitative methods and participatory approaches can be applied in a variety of real-world contexts, revealing the complex interactions that characterise these dynamic knowledge production processes. The book provides unique insights into methods as more-than-technical processes that determine not only how, but which knowledge is (re)produced, shaping understandings of social values. It concludes that bringing social values into heritage practice requires not only new methods and approaches, but new ways of working with emergent understandings and multiple types of expertise. In response to the challenges - and the opportunities - identified, the concept of a ‘methods assemblage’ is employed, offering an effective model for more reflexive and inclusive future practice in this area. Assessing the Social Values of Heritage provides the first systematic, comparative review of methods for social values assessment. It will be essential reading for practitioners, academics and scholars engaged in the study of heritage, participatory research, and people-centred methods.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 163-186
Working with Social Values in Practice
This chapter discusses the adoption and application of qualitative methods and rapid, participatory approaches within institutional heritage management and conservation, alongside established forms of expertise and practice. Looking beyond the context of an individual assessment, it explores models for working with the complex knowledge revealed by social values assessments, identifying examples of existing practices where complex knowledge and multiple values are negotiated. The challenges that open-ended, exploratory modes of enquiry pose for practitioners working within institutional frameworks are discussed, along with potential responses, and consideration is given to the creative potential of these processes to generate shared understandings and new knowledges. Finally, the chapter outlines some of the opportunities that incorporating social values can offer organisations in meeting their core mandates, achieving greater diversity and inclusivity, and addressing historic and contemporary injustices.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 163-186
Working with Social Values in Practice
This chapter discusses the adoption and application of qualitative methods and rapid, participatory approaches within institutional heritage management and conservation, alongside established forms of expertise and practice. Looking beyond the context of an individual assessment, it explores models for working with the complex knowledge revealed by social values assessments, identifying examples of existing practices where complex knowledge and multiple values are negotiated. The challenges that open-ended, exploratory modes of enquiry pose for practitioners working within institutional frameworks are discussed, along with potential responses, and consideration is given to the creative potential of these processes to generate shared understandings and new knowledges. Finally, the chapter outlines some of the opportunities that incorporating social values can offer organisations in meeting their core mandates, achieving greater diversity and inclusivity, and addressing historic and contemporary injustices.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 147-162
Assessments in Real-World Contexts
This chapter examines how assessment methods work in different contexts and the implications for heritage management and conservation practice. Drawing examples from across all seven case studies, the chapter discusses the complex interactions between the research approaches, the degree of rapidity and the extent of community participation in the process, and the evolving research context. It includes two extended vignettes that illustrate how these interactions influenced a specific assessment. There is a focus in the discussion on research relationships and relational factors within an assessment. It is argued that applying these approaches in practice requires flexibility and responsiveness, with consideration given to the implications of methods choices and how relational aspects, power structures, and the individuals involved in the assessment shape knowledge production.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 147-162
Assessments in Real-World Contexts
This chapter examines how assessment methods work in different contexts and the implications for heritage management and conservation practice. Drawing examples from across all seven case studies, the chapter discusses the complex interactions between the research approaches, the degree of rapidity and the extent of community participation in the process, and the evolving research context. It includes two extended vignettes that illustrate how these interactions influenced a specific assessment. There is a focus in the discussion on research relationships and relational factors within an assessment. It is argued that applying these approaches in practice requires flexibility and responsiveness, with consideration given to the implications of methods choices and how relational aspects, power structures, and the individuals involved in the assessment shape knowledge production.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 67-104
Case Study Research
This chapter focuses principally on seven examples of social values assessments for heritage places in Scotland. It begins by introducing case study research, before moving from theory to practice. The seven case studies encompass a range of social and physical environments, management contexts, and types of historic environment, including formally recognised buildings and monuments and places with no formal heritage status. The individual case study locations are described, together with the qualitative methods and more or less rapid and participatory approaches adopted − both those proposed and those ultimately implemented in each case. Engagements with heritage practitioners outside of the assessments, and the ongoing reflexive and ethical practices adopted, are also discussed. This practical discussion and orientation to the case studies lay the foundations for the following chapters, in which the research findings are discussed comparatively.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 67-104
Case Study Research
This chapter focuses principally on seven examples of social values assessments for heritage places in Scotland. It begins by introducing case study research, before moving from theory to practice. The seven case studies encompass a range of social and physical environments, management contexts, and types of historic environment, including formally recognised buildings and monuments and places with no formal heritage status. The individual case study locations are described, together with the qualitative methods and more or less rapid and participatory approaches adopted − both those proposed and those ultimately implemented in each case. Engagements with heritage practitioners outside of the assessments, and the ongoing reflexive and ethical practices adopted, are also discussed. This practical discussion and orientation to the case studies lay the foundations for the following chapters, in which the research findings are discussed comparatively.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 125-146
Methods as Ways of Knowing
This chapter discusses what different methods do, individually and in combination, and how they contribute to the understandings achieved through a social values assessment. A range of qualitative, participatory methods are discussed, highlighting the type of engagement, material, and insights generated through each. Having considered the methods individually, the chapter then explores how direct and indirect linkages between the multiple methods applied in an assessment shape the understandings gained and the research process itself. It is argued that the various methods provide different ways of knowing. In practice, they enact different forms of knowledge, engaging different communities, and manifesting different heritages. In response, a methods assemblage approach is proposed, working flexibly with multiple methods while reflecting on the realities that these (re)produce, allowing a more complex understanding of the social values of the historic environment to emerge.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 125-146
Methods as Ways of Knowing
This chapter discusses what different methods do, individually and in combination, and how they contribute to the understandings achieved through a social values assessment. A range of qualitative, participatory methods are discussed, highlighting the type of engagement, material, and insights generated through each. Having considered the methods individually, the chapter then explores how direct and indirect linkages between the multiple methods applied in an assessment shape the understandings gained and the research process itself. It is argued that the various methods provide different ways of knowing. In practice, they enact different forms of knowledge, engaging different communities, and manifesting different heritages. In response, a methods assemblage approach is proposed, working flexibly with multiple methods while reflecting on the realities that these (re)produce, allowing a more complex understanding of the social values of the historic environment to emerge.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 44-66
The Production of Knowledge
This chapter explores theories of knowledge production, participation, and the methodologies used to study social phenomena. It takes up the thread from Chapter 2 on the epistemological and methodological challenges faced in value assessment and, in so doing, surfaces the political nature of knowledge production. The chapter discusses dominant theories of knowledge production and expertise before considering the potential for public participation and collaborative research techniques to result in more inclusive decision-making. It describes some of the trends and shifts in how researchers have understood and approached social research, including who is involved and the methods deployed. Consideration is also given to issues of participant engagement and ethical approaches, including the ongoing, everyday ethics required for this type of social research.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 44-66
The Production of Knowledge
This chapter explores theories of knowledge production, participation, and the methodologies used to study social phenomena. It takes up the thread from Chapter 2 on the epistemological and methodological challenges faced in value assessment and, in so doing, surfaces the political nature of knowledge production. The chapter discusses dominant theories of knowledge production and expertise before considering the potential for public participation and collaborative research techniques to result in more inclusive decision-making. It describes some of the trends and shifts in how researchers have understood and approached social research, including who is involved and the methods deployed. Consideration is also given to issues of participant engagement and ethical approaches, including the ongoing, everyday ethics required for this type of social research.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 18-43
Bringing Social Value into Frame
This chapter provides an overview of the growing prominence of social values in heritage discourse, tracing the major developments that have informed current approaches. Starting with the wider question of valuing arts and culture, it goes on to describe the Western ideologies of value that have dominated heritage management and conservation practice. It examines how these ideas are reflected in international heritage frameworks and, as context for the case studies described later in the book, how they have influenced UK and Scottish policies. It explores perspectives on social value, the scope of the term, and how different concepts have been applied to valuing the historic environment. It identifies different theoretical positions underpinning heritage policies, academic debates, and established heritage practices, resulting in tensions for management and conservation practice.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 18-43
Bringing Social Value into Frame
This chapter provides an overview of the growing prominence of social values in heritage discourse, tracing the major developments that have informed current approaches. Starting with the wider question of valuing arts and culture, it goes on to describe the Western ideologies of value that have dominated heritage management and conservation practice. It examines how these ideas are reflected in international heritage frameworks and, as context for the case studies described later in the book, how they have influenced UK and Scottish policies. It explores perspectives on social value, the scope of the term, and how different concepts have been applied to valuing the historic environment. It identifies different theoretical positions underpinning heritage policies, academic debates, and established heritage practices, resulting in tensions for management and conservation practice.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 187-200
Future Heritage Practice
This final chapter draws together the findings and arguments made in the rest of the book and focuses on the implications for heritage practice, both with respect to individual assessments and at an institutional level. It describes the methods assemblage approach, which provides a successful model for assessments in real-world contexts, revealing and accommodating complexity, dynamism, and multiplicity. It also highlights how important reflexive practices are in identifying and attempting to address the practical barriers and political aspects of heritage that are manifest during the assessment process. The chapter provides reflections on this particular study, including how collaboration with a national heritage body contributed to a practically-engaged, intellectually-rigorous research process and on the potential that taking this work further offers for realising more people-centred, socially-relevant forms of future heritage practice.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 187-200
Future Heritage Practice
This final chapter draws together the findings and arguments made in the rest of the book and focuses on the implications for heritage practice, both with respect to individual assessments and at an institutional level. It describes the methods assemblage approach, which provides a successful model for assessments in real-world contexts, revealing and accommodating complexity, dynamism, and multiplicity. It also highlights how important reflexive practices are in identifying and attempting to address the practical barriers and political aspects of heritage that are manifest during the assessment process. The chapter provides reflections on this particular study, including how collaboration with a national heritage body contributed to a practically-engaged, intellectually-rigorous research process and on the potential that taking this work further offers for realising more people-centred, socially-relevant forms of future heritage practice.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 105-124
Understanding Values and Communities
This chapter focuses on understanding the material and knowledge generated through a social values assessment. It looks comparatively at the range of social values and communities identified during the case studies, as well as considering gaps or absences within the assessments and the steps taken to address these. Although there were notable similarities in the values identified in different cases, the findings show that processes of valuing are highly contextualised, with similar terminology or behaviour potentially masking quite diverse values. Similarly, community memberships are situational and negotiated, challenging binary categorisations, such as resident and non-resident, with intersecting identities and relative expressions. Drawing examples from across the case studies, the chapter illustrates how values and relationships are understood and enacted in different ways depending on the social context and type of engagement people have with the historic environment (e.g. formal or informal, in person or virtual).
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 105-124
Understanding Values and Communities
This chapter focuses on understanding the material and knowledge generated through a social values assessment. It looks comparatively at the range of social values and communities identified during the case studies, as well as considering gaps or absences within the assessments and the steps taken to address these. Although there were notable similarities in the values identified in different cases, the findings show that processes of valuing are highly contextualised, with similar terminology or behaviour potentially masking quite diverse values. Similarly, community memberships are situational and negotiated, challenging binary categorisations, such as resident and non-resident, with intersecting identities and relative expressions. Drawing examples from across the case studies, the chapter illustrates how values and relationships are understood and enacted in different ways depending on the social context and type of engagement people have with the historic environment (e.g. formal or informal, in person or virtual).
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-17
Valuing the Historic Environment
This chapter outlines the growing prominence of social value in heritage management policies and the problematic distance between those ambitions and day-to-day practice. It summarises the differences in approach between critical heritage studies scholarship and traditional heritage management and conservation practice, highlighting that both academics and practitioners have identified a lack of methods for the assessment of social value as a key issue. It provides an overview of how the research informing this book has responded to these challenges, introducing the Scottish heritage context, the case studies, and the approaches taken. It serves as an introduction to the major themes and key questions addressed by the book and positions the author within the research context and the study within wider scholarship, grounding the analysis and discussion to follow.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-17
Valuing the Historic Environment
This chapter outlines the growing prominence of social value in heritage management policies and the problematic distance between those ambitions and day-to-day practice. It summarises the differences in approach between critical heritage studies scholarship and traditional heritage management and conservation practice, highlighting that both academics and practitioners have identified a lack of methods for the assessment of social value as a key issue. It provides an overview of how the research informing this book has responded to these challenges, introducing the Scottish heritage context, the case studies, and the approaches taken. It serves as an introduction to the major themes and key questions addressed by the book and positions the author within the research context and the study within wider scholarship, grounding the analysis and discussion to follow.