Hervé Vicari
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Hervé Vicari has a total of 91 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Johan Gaume
WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos Dorf, 7260, Switzerland
19 shared publications - Michael Lukas Kyburz
WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos Dorf, Switzerland
8 shared publications Johan Gaume
WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos, Switzerland
6 shared publications- Dieter Issler
Norwegian Geotechnical Institute, Natural Hazards Division, Oslo, Norway
5 shared publications - Lars Blatny
Institute for Geotechnical Engineering, ETH Zurich, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
5 shared publications - Brian W. McArdell
Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL, 8903 Birmensdorf, Switzerland
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1) , 722
Frictional weakening in the highly mobile 2025 Blatten rock and ice avalanche in Switzerland
Cascading slope failures are increasing as glaciers retreat and slopes adjust to a warming climate, yet reconstructing their full dynamics from precursor to deposition remains challenging. Here we show that the 28 May 2025 Blatten rock-ice avalanche, which mobilized about 9.3 million cubic metres, can be reconstructed from seismic, geomorphological, and geotechnical evidence and numerical modeling. The observations reveal the timing, source, volume, and friction of over two weeks of accelerating rockfalls and minor glacier collapses before the main failure, followed by four stages of avalanche motion. Only with drastically reduced friction can both depth-averaged and three-dimensional models reproduce the center-of-mass force history and the deposit distribution. These friction values reflect effective frictional weakening. Geotechnical observations suggest that transient excess pore pressures possibly contributed to this weakening, but are insufficient to rule out additional mechanisms such as ice frictional reduction, segregation, and fragmentation. This work provides a reproducible and robust framework for analyzing catastrophic avalanches under a changing climate.
- 7 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1) , 722
Open AccessFrictional weakening in the highly mobile 2025 Blatten rock and ice avalanche in Switzerland
Cascading slope failures are increasing as glaciers retreat and slopes adjust to a warming climate, yet reconstructing their full dynamics from precursor to deposition remains challenging. Here we show that the 28 May 2025 Blatten rock-ice avalanche, which mobilized about 9.3 million cubic metres, can be reconstructed from seismic, geomorphological, and geotechnical evidence and numerical modeling. The observations reveal the timing, source, volume, and friction of over two weeks of accelerating rockfalls and minor glacier collapses before the main failure, followed by four stages of avalanche motion. Only with drastically reduced friction can both depth-averaged and three-dimensional models reproduce the center-of-mass force history and the deposit distribution. These friction values reflect effective frictional weakening. Geotechnical observations suggest that transient excess pore pressures possibly contributed to this weakening, but are insufficient to rule out additional mechanisms such as ice frictional reduction, segregation, and fragmentation. This work provides a reproducible and robust framework for analyzing catastrophic avalanches under a changing climate.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-56
Comment on egusphere-2025-6053
We present a pilot study for intercomparison of snow avalanche flow simulation tools. Thirteen different groups participated in the study, whose models are categorized into a core group using thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, and an extended group including one with a differing shallow water approach, and one depth-resolved 3D approach. The intercomparison is performed for three simple test cases representative of typical applications: snow avalanche flow over an idealized and a real topography with a release area of constant thickness based on a Voellmy and pure Coulomb friction relation and prescribed values for the friction parameters. The aim of this pilot study is to analyse the spread in simulation results and discuss potential sources of the observed differences. A quantitative assessment of the variability is based on the distribution of scalar measures like runout length, runout angle and maximum values of flow thickness and flow velocity. Within the core group of thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, simulation results for the Voellmy test cases (idealized and real topography), excluding outliers, show a spread of roughly 55 m in derived runout length with an interquartile range of about 30/33 m, referring to total runout lengths of 2310/2082 m (median values for idealized and real topography). Runout length is for all three test cases constrained by an abrupt change in slope angle. Maximum peak flow thickness and velocity show a generally larger spread for both, the idealized and real topography test cases. Excluding outliers, differences between the simulation results are more pronounced for the real topography test case compared to the idealized topography case. The largest differences arise if only Coulomb friction is considered, as indicated by an interquartile range of 92 m in runout length. The Coulomb test case also shows a considerably larger number of outliers. This is partly due to the pronounced effect of curvature effects in this case, which is not accounted for by all participating simulations tools. Focusing on the core group, this analysis serves as a first assessment of the uncertainty introduced by the different implementation workflows (e.g., numerical schemes, ad-hoc treatments, geo-data handling, curvature treatment, etc.). However, actual attribution of variability to individual sources is beyond the scope of this preliminary study and will necessitate further testing. Performing this pilot study allowed us to identify common issues, gather information on respective requirements regarding input data and problem definition, which will help to optimize the design of a future, more comprehensive model intercomparison study.
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-56
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-6053
We present a pilot study for intercomparison of snow avalanche flow simulation tools. Thirteen different groups participated in the study, whose models are categorized into a core group using thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, and an extended group including one with a differing shallow water approach, and one depth-resolved 3D approach. The intercomparison is performed for three simple test cases representative of typical applications: snow avalanche flow over an idealized and a real topography with a release area of constant thickness based on a Voellmy and pure Coulomb friction relation and prescribed values for the friction parameters. The aim of this pilot study is to analyse the spread in simulation results and discuss potential sources of the observed differences. A quantitative assessment of the variability is based on the distribution of scalar measures like runout length, runout angle and maximum values of flow thickness and flow velocity. Within the core group of thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, simulation results for the Voellmy test cases (idealized and real topography), excluding outliers, show a spread of roughly 55 m in derived runout length with an interquartile range of about 30/33 m, referring to total runout lengths of 2310/2082 m (median values for idealized and real topography). Runout length is for all three test cases constrained by an abrupt change in slope angle. Maximum peak flow thickness and velocity show a generally larger spread for both, the idealized and real topography test cases. Excluding outliers, differences between the simulation results are more pronounced for the real topography test case compared to the idealized topography case. The largest differences arise if only Coulomb friction is considered, as indicated by an interquartile range of 92 m in runout length. The Coulomb test case also shows a considerably larger number of outliers. This is partly due to the pronounced effect of curvature effects in this case, which is not accounted for by all participating simulations tools. Focusing on the core group, this analysis serves as a first assessment of the uncertainty introduced by the different implementation workflows (e.g., numerical schemes, ad-hoc treatments, geo-data handling, curvature treatment, etc.). However, actual attribution of variability to individual sources is beyond the scope of this preliminary study and will necessitate further testing. Performing this pilot study allowed us to identify common issues, gather information on respective requirements regarding input data and problem definition, which will help to optimize the design of a future, more comprehensive model intercomparison study.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering
- Vol. 461
A stabilized fractional-step MPM with pressure gradient projection for coupled hydromechanical extreme deformations
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering
- Vol. 461
Open AccessA stabilized fractional-step MPM with pressure gradient projection for coupled hydromechanical extreme deformations
- Open Access
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Geomorphology
- Vol. 509
Linking debris flow erosion to channel-bed parameters: Geotechnical and UAS-based investigation of ten channels in Switzerland
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Geomorphology
- Vol. 509
Open AccessLinking debris flow erosion to channel-bed parameters: Geotechnical and UAS-based investigation of ten channels in Switzerland
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Dynamics and precursors of the 2025 Blatten rock–ice avalanche: Integrating seismic analysis, granular flow simulations, and field observations
Cascading slope failures in high mountain environments are observed with increasing frequency as glaciers retreat and slope stability is impacted by warmer conditions. On 28 May 2025, a large rock-ice avalanche (~9.3x106 m3) originating from Birch Glacier, Switzerland, destroyed parts of the village of Blatten, and provided a rare, well-documented case of a rapid, highly mobile mass movement.We combine seismic observations, geomorphological mapping, grain size and permeability measurements, and granular flow modelling to reconstruct the evolution of this event, from precursory instabilities to the main collapse. Seismic data scanned with machine learning algorithms reveal a two-week period of increasing rockfall and small glacier failures preceding the main collapse. The main collapse was reconstructed using force history inversion of low-frequency seismic signals from Switzerland’s national seismic network. Numerical simulations constrained by both seismic data and observed deposit extents indicate that an exceptionally low effective basal friction was required to reproduce the observed deposit extent and force history. This and the field observations of low-permeability deposit materials indicate that frictional weakening contributed to the unexpectedly high mobility of the main event.Our results highlight the value of integrating seismic monitoring with field and modelling approaches to constrain the dynamics of complex rock-ice avalanches. The Blatten event illustrates how large alpine slope failures can transition into highly mobile flows. Our study provides one of the first detailed reconstructions of this hazard cascade, including precursory failure activity, and the dynamics and frictional characteristics of the main event. The frictional weakening inferred here provides a much-needed mechanistic basis for predicting runout and deposit geometry in large debris avalanches.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessDynamics and precursors of the 2025 Blatten rock–ice avalanche: Integrating seismic analysis, granular flow simulations, and field observations
Cascading slope failures in high mountain environments are observed with increasing frequency as glaciers retreat and slope stability is impacted by warmer conditions. On 28 May 2025, a large rock-ice avalanche (~9.3x106 m3) originating from Birch Glacier, Switzerland, destroyed parts of the village of Blatten, and provided a rare, well-documented case of a rapid, highly mobile mass movement.We combine seismic observations, geomorphological mapping, grain size and permeability measurements, and granular flow modelling to reconstruct the evolution of this event, from precursory instabilities to the main collapse. Seismic data scanned with machine learning algorithms reveal a two-week period of increasing rockfall and small glacier failures preceding the main collapse. The main collapse was reconstructed using force history inversion of low-frequency seismic signals from Switzerland’s national seismic network. Numerical simulations constrained by both seismic data and observed deposit extents indicate that an exceptionally low effective basal friction was required to reproduce the observed deposit extent and force history. This and the field observations of low-permeability deposit materials indicate that frictional weakening contributed to the unexpectedly high mobility of the main event.Our results highlight the value of integrating seismic monitoring with field and modelling approaches to constrain the dynamics of complex rock-ice avalanches. The Blatten event illustrates how large alpine slope failures can transition into highly mobile flows. Our study provides one of the first detailed reconstructions of this hazard cascade, including precursory failure activity, and the dynamics and frictional characteristics of the main event. The frictional weakening inferred here provides a much-needed mechanistic basis for predicting runout and deposit geometry in large debris avalanches.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Granular Flow Behavior over Complex Topography: Insights from Flume Experiments
Gravitational mass movements, such as debris flows, rock and snow avalanches, move downslope through complex terrain, where bends, undulations, and channel constrictions strongly influence flow behavior and deposition patterns. Accurate understanding and modeling of these processes are critical for effective hazard assessment and risk management. However, most experimental flume setups idealize the terrain as planar. Therefore, the verification and validation of numerical models is often performed in simplified terrain conditions, where curvature effects, flow detachment from the terrain, and slope-normal accelerations do not emerge and, thus, do not challenge the assumptions and simplifications of various numerical models.In this work, we performed flume experiments on complex topographies to generate a novel dataset of flow kinematics and depositional patterns under varied initial and boundary conditions. We used dry granular flows (quartz sand, 0.7 − 1.2 mm), released into a half circular channel with diameter 0.2 m. Along the 4 m inclined slope, complex topographical features are introduced through a modular 3D printed configuration. Slope (25°, 35°), release mass (2 − 20 kg), bed roughness (smooth and rough, 0.7 − 1.2 mm), and terrain features such as bends and bumps are tested. Flow fronts are tracked with video cameras, flow depths are measured with laser sensors, and deposition is quantified via pre- and post- experiment laser scans. We compare the runout length and mobility angle throughout the different experiments. As expected, basal roughness reduces flow velocity and runoutdistance, and alters deposition patterns. Increasing the flow mass promotes the formation of roll waves and longer runout. Bends lead to energy dissipation, thereby promoting upstream deposition. Longitudinal terrain bumps induce the detachment of material from the channel bed at the higher slope angle or the deposition upstream of the bump at the lower slope angle.These experiments provide a unique dataset of granular flows with systematically varied terrain features and well defined boundary conditions. They are designed for direct comparison with numerical models, providing a realistic benchmark to assess model performance and to identify limitations of different approaches for simulating granular flows over real topographies.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessGranular Flow Behavior over Complex Topography: Insights from Flume Experiments
Gravitational mass movements, such as debris flows, rock and snow avalanches, move downslope through complex terrain, where bends, undulations, and channel constrictions strongly influence flow behavior and deposition patterns. Accurate understanding and modeling of these processes are critical for effective hazard assessment and risk management. However, most experimental flume setups idealize the terrain as planar. Therefore, the verification and validation of numerical models is often performed in simplified terrain conditions, where curvature effects, flow detachment from the terrain, and slope-normal accelerations do not emerge and, thus, do not challenge the assumptions and simplifications of various numerical models.In this work, we performed flume experiments on complex topographies to generate a novel dataset of flow kinematics and depositional patterns under varied initial and boundary conditions. We used dry granular flows (quartz sand, 0.7 − 1.2 mm), released into a half circular channel with diameter 0.2 m. Along the 4 m inclined slope, complex topographical features are introduced through a modular 3D printed configuration. Slope (25°, 35°), release mass (2 − 20 kg), bed roughness (smooth and rough, 0.7 − 1.2 mm), and terrain features such as bends and bumps are tested. Flow fronts are tracked with video cameras, flow depths are measured with laser sensors, and deposition is quantified via pre- and post- experiment laser scans. We compare the runout length and mobility angle throughout the different experiments. As expected, basal roughness reduces flow velocity and runoutdistance, and alters deposition patterns. Increasing the flow mass promotes the formation of roll waves and longer runout. Bends lead to energy dissipation, thereby promoting upstream deposition. Longitudinal terrain bumps induce the detachment of material from the channel bed at the higher slope angle or the deposition upstream of the bump at the lower slope angle.These experiments provide a unique dataset of granular flows with systematically varied terrain features and well defined boundary conditions. They are designed for direct comparison with numerical models, providing a realistic benchmark to assess model performance and to identify limitations of different approaches for simulating granular flows over real topographies.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Measuring the unmeasurable? Geotechnical and UAS-based investigations of landslides
The dynamics of landslides are strongly governed by their material composition and boundary conditions. When soil sediments mix with water, the fine fraction can markedly alter permeability—both within the flowing mass and in the underlying bed material—thereby influencing the generation and persistence of excess pore pressures and, consequently, shear strength. While new two-phase continuum models are increasingly capable of capturing these coupled hydro-geomechanical processes (e.g., Vicari et al., 2025b), a key challenge remains: can we reasonably measure the field material properties required to parameterize such models? Field sites are often steep, heterogeneous, and difficult to access, complicating in-situ characterization.To address this challenge, we conducted a systematic geotechnical investigation of ten debris flow channels across Switzerland (Vicari et al., 2025a). Soil samples were collected to determine grain size distributions, revealing significant variability in fine content among sites. Higher fine contents were found to reduce sediment permeability, quantified using in-situ dual-head infiltrometer tests. Complementary Unmanned Aerial System (UAS) surveys provided high-resolution erosion and deposition patterns, allowing us to relate observed geomorphic changes to both channel and catchment morphology and sediment properties. Simple correlations suggest that higher fine contents correspond to enhanced erosion and more frequent debris flow activity, though these relationships are strongly modulated by channel geometry and sediment availability. Combining geotechnical and geomorphological parameters enabled us to classify the investigated channels into four distinct behavioral groups, ranging from small, coarse gullies through intermediate coarse- and fine-rich channels to large, fine-rich systems.The methods developed and trained through this study proved invaluable for the investigation of the 28 May 2025 Blatten landslide. Modeling results indicate that a substantial frictional reduction was required to explain the extreme mobility of this event, implicating transient excess pore pressures as a likely mechanism. Geotechnical analyses of the landslide material revealed low permeability and high fine content, suggesting that excess pore pressure dissipation times may have greatly exceeded the event duration if even a 1 m flow layer became liquefied.Our results highlight the importance of integrating geotechnical measurements with remote sensing to constrain key parameters for next generation two-phase numerical models.ReferencesVicari, H., Bründl, F., Frieß, P., Ringenbach, A., Stoffel, A., Bühler, Y., Aaron, J., Mcardell, B., Walter, F., Graf, C., Herzog, R., Bebi, P., Gaume, J., 2025a. Linking debris flow erosion to channel-bed parameters: Geotechnical and remote sensing investigation of ten channels in Switzerland. ESS Open Archive. https://doi.org/10.22541/essoar.176126762.20405430/v1Vicari, H., Tran, Q.-A., Metzsch Juel, M., Gaume, J., 2025b. The role of dilatancy and permeability of erodible wet bed sediments in affecting erosion and runout of a granular flow: Two-phase MPM–CFD simulations. Computers and Geotechnics 185, 107307. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compgeo.2025.107307
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMeasuring the unmeasurable? Geotechnical and UAS-based investigations of landslides
The dynamics of landslides are strongly governed by their material composition and boundary conditions. When soil sediments mix with water, the fine fraction can markedly alter permeability—both within the flowing mass and in the underlying bed material—thereby influencing the generation and persistence of excess pore pressures and, consequently, shear strength. While new two-phase continuum models are increasingly capable of capturing these coupled hydro-geomechanical processes (e.g., Vicari et al., 2025b), a key challenge remains: can we reasonably measure the field material properties required to parameterize such models? Field sites are often steep, heterogeneous, and difficult to access, complicating in-situ characterization.To address this challenge, we conducted a systematic geotechnical investigation of ten debris flow channels across Switzerland (Vicari et al., 2025a). Soil samples were collected to determine grain size distributions, revealing significant variability in fine content among sites. Higher fine contents were found to reduce sediment permeability, quantified using in-situ dual-head infiltrometer tests. Complementary Unmanned Aerial System (UAS) surveys provided high-resolution erosion and deposition patterns, allowing us to relate observed geomorphic changes to both channel and catchment morphology and sediment properties. Simple correlations suggest that higher fine contents correspond to enhanced erosion and more frequent debris flow activity, though these relationships are strongly modulated by channel geometry and sediment availability. Combining geotechnical and geomorphological parameters enabled us to classify the investigated channels into four distinct behavioral groups, ranging from small, coarse gullies through intermediate coarse- and fine-rich channels to large, fine-rich systems.The methods developed and trained through this study proved invaluable for the investigation of the 28 May 2025 Blatten landslide. Modeling results indicate that a substantial frictional reduction was required to explain the extreme mobility of this event, implicating transient excess pore pressures as a likely mechanism. Geotechnical analyses of the landslide material revealed low permeability and high fine content, suggesting that excess pore pressure dissipation times may have greatly exceeded the event duration if even a 1 m flow layer became liquefied.Our results highlight the importance of integrating geotechnical measurements with remote sensing to constrain key parameters for next generation two-phase numerical models.ReferencesVicari, H., Bründl, F., Frieß, P., Ringenbach, A., Stoffel, A., Bühler, Y., Aaron, J., Mcardell, B., Walter, F., Graf, C., Herzog, R., Bebi, P., Gaume, J., 2025a. Linking debris flow erosion to channel-bed parameters: Geotechnical and remote sensing investigation of ten channels in Switzerland. ESS Open Archive. https://doi.org/10.22541/essoar.176126762.20405430/v1Vicari, H., Tran, Q.-A., Metzsch Juel, M., Gaume, J., 2025b. The role of dilatancy and permeability of erodible wet bed sediments in affecting erosion and runout of a granular flow: Two-phase MPM–CFD simulations. Computers and Geotechnics 185, 107307. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compgeo.2025.107307
- Open Access
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
A Stabilized Fractional-Step MPM with Pressure-Gradient Projection for Coupled Hydromechanical Extreme Deformations
We present a novel stabilized fractional-step two-phase double-point Material Point Method (MPM) for robust and computationally efficient simulations of extreme-deformation hydromechanical problems. Existing fractional-step models employ either a non-incremental pressure discretization, which is suitable for large deformations but inaccurate under low permeability conditions, or an incremental formulation that improves accuracy yet relies on stabilization methods that are currently inadequate for large deformations. To overcome these limitations, we present the first adaptation of the Stabilized Pressure by Gradient Projection (SPGP) method to the MPM framework and propose a Taylor Particle-in-Cell (TPIC) pressure mapping for improved free-surface treatment. A generalized temporal discretization for pressure and drag is developed, providing new insights into the numerical behavior of non-incremental and incremental fractional-step schemes. In particular, we demonstrate that the non‑incremental formulation remains inherently sensitive to permeability, whereas the incremental formulation achieves superior accuracy with permeability‑independent timesteps, eliminating the need for complex drag discretizations. The proposed method is implemented in the high-performance Taichi programming language, leveraging GPU acceleration and sparse grid capabilities, combined with a matrix-free conjugate gradient algorithm to efficiently solve the pressure–Poisson system. Our model is validated against a series of benchmark problems covering large deformations and phase separation phenomena, demonstrating high accuracy and robustness without case‑specific tuning of stabilization parameters. This advancement establishes a unified and robust foundation for simulating coupled hydromechanical processes, such as water-rich geophysical mass flows.
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessA Stabilized Fractional-Step MPM with Pressure-Gradient Projection for Coupled Hydromechanical Extreme Deformations
We present a novel stabilized fractional-step two-phase double-point Material Point Method (MPM) for robust and computationally efficient simulations of extreme-deformation hydromechanical problems. Existing fractional-step models employ either a non-incremental pressure discretization, which is suitable for large deformations but inaccurate under low permeability conditions, or an incremental formulation that improves accuracy yet relies on stabilization methods that are currently inadequate for large deformations. To overcome these limitations, we present the first adaptation of the Stabilized Pressure by Gradient Projection (SPGP) method to the MPM framework and propose a Taylor Particle-in-Cell (TPIC) pressure mapping for improved free-surface treatment. A generalized temporal discretization for pressure and drag is developed, providing new insights into the numerical behavior of non-incremental and incremental fractional-step schemes. In particular, we demonstrate that the non‑incremental formulation remains inherently sensitive to permeability, whereas the incremental formulation achieves superior accuracy with permeability‑independent timesteps, eliminating the need for complex drag discretizations. The proposed method is implemented in the high-performance Taichi programming language, leveraging GPU acceleration and sparse grid capabilities, combined with a matrix-free conjugate gradient algorithm to efficiently solve the pressure–Poisson system. Our model is validated against a series of benchmark problems covering large deformations and phase separation phenomena, demonstrating high accuracy and robustness without case‑specific tuning of stabilization parameters. This advancement establishes a unified and robust foundation for simulating coupled hydromechanical processes, such as water-rich geophysical mass flows.
- Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026
ISeeSnow v1.0 – a pilot study for snow avalanche model intercomparison of thickness-integrated shallow flow approaches and beyond
We present a pilot study for intercomparison of snow avalanche flow simulation tools. Thirteen different groups participated in the study, whose models are categorized into a core group using thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, and an extended group including one with a differing shallow water approach, and one depth-resolved 3D approach. The intercomparison is performed for three simple test cases representative of typical applications: snow avalanche flow over an idealized and a real topography with a release area of constant thickness based on a Voellmy and pure Coulomb friction relation and prescribed values for the friction parameters. The aim of this pilot study is to analyse the spread in simulation results and discuss potential sources of the observed differences. A quantitative assessment of the variability is based on the distribution of scalar measures like runout length, runout angle and maximum values of flow thickness and flow velocity. Within the core group of thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, simulation results for the Voellmy test cases (idealized and real topography), excluding outliers, show a spread of roughly 55 m in derived runout length with an interquartile range of about 30/33 m, referring to total runout lengths of 2310/2082 m (median values for idealized and real topography). Runout length is for all three test cases constrained by an abrupt change in slope angle. Maximum peak flow thickness and velocity show a generally larger spread for both, the idealized and real topography test cases. Excluding outliers, differences between the simulation results are more pronounced for the real topography test case compared to the idealized topography case. The largest differences arise if only Coulomb friction is considered, as indicated by an interquartile range of 92 m in runout length. The Coulomb test case also shows a considerably larger number of outliers. This is partly due to the pronounced effect of curvature effects in this case, which is not accounted for by all participating simulations tools. Focusing on the core group, this analysis serves as a first assessment of the uncertainty introduced by the different implementation workflows (e.g., numerical schemes, ad-hoc treatments, geo-data handling, curvature treatment, etc.). However, actual attribution of variability to individual sources is beyond the scope of this preliminary study and will necessitate further testing. Performing this pilot study allowed us to identify common issues, gather information on respective requirements regarding input data and problem definition, which will help to optimize the design of a future, more comprehensive model intercomparison study.
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026
Open AccessISeeSnow v1.0 – a pilot study for snow avalanche model intercomparison of thickness-integrated shallow flow approaches and beyond
We present a pilot study for intercomparison of snow avalanche flow simulation tools. Thirteen different groups participated in the study, whose models are categorized into a core group using thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, and an extended group including one with a differing shallow water approach, and one depth-resolved 3D approach. The intercomparison is performed for three simple test cases representative of typical applications: snow avalanche flow over an idealized and a real topography with a release area of constant thickness based on a Voellmy and pure Coulomb friction relation and prescribed values for the friction parameters. The aim of this pilot study is to analyse the spread in simulation results and discuss potential sources of the observed differences. A quantitative assessment of the variability is based on the distribution of scalar measures like runout length, runout angle and maximum values of flow thickness and flow velocity. Within the core group of thickness/depth-integrated shallow flow approaches, simulation results for the Voellmy test cases (idealized and real topography), excluding outliers, show a spread of roughly 55 m in derived runout length with an interquartile range of about 30/33 m, referring to total runout lengths of 2310/2082 m (median values for idealized and real topography). Runout length is for all three test cases constrained by an abrupt change in slope angle. Maximum peak flow thickness and velocity show a generally larger spread for both, the idealized and real topography test cases. Excluding outliers, differences between the simulation results are more pronounced for the real topography test case compared to the idealized topography case. The largest differences arise if only Coulomb friction is considered, as indicated by an interquartile range of 92 m in runout length. The Coulomb test case also shows a considerably larger number of outliers. This is partly due to the pronounced effect of curvature effects in this case, which is not accounted for by all participating simulations tools. Focusing on the core group, this analysis serves as a first assessment of the uncertainty introduced by the different implementation workflows (e.g., numerical schemes, ad-hoc treatments, geo-data handling, curvature treatment, etc.). However, actual attribution of variability to individual sources is beyond the scope of this preliminary study and will necessitate further testing. Performing this pilot study allowed us to identify common issues, gather information on respective requirements regarding input data and problem definition, which will help to optimize the design of a future, more comprehensive model intercomparison study.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Engineering Geology
- Vol. 361
Two-phase SPH-DEM modeling of the superelevation phenomenon of debris and mud flows
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Engineering Geology
- Vol. 361
Open AccessTwo-phase SPH-DEM modeling of the superelevation phenomenon of debris and mud flows