Thomas Kirchmair
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Thomas Kirchmair has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jörg Matthes
Department of Communication, University of Vienna
6 shared publications - Kevin Koban
University of Vienna, Austria
4 shared publications - Alice Binder
University of Vienna, Austria
2 shared publications - Ariadne Neureiter
Department of Communication, University of Vienna
2 shared publications - Christina Brandstetter
Department of Communication , University of Vienna , Währinger Straße 29 (R. 7.36) Vienna , Austria
2 shared publications - Jeong-Woo Jang
Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST)
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Computer Review
Profiling Digital Hate: A Multidimensional Measurement Approach Based on the Perspective API
The automatic classification of digital hate is a pressing challenge, yet many existing computational models remain opaque and insufficiently evaluated as measurement tools in social science contexts. This study examines the utility of Google’s Perspective API as a measurement instrument by modeling higher-order constructs of harmful discourse (i.e., incivility and intolerance) as outcomes of multiple lower-level behavioral indicators captured by distinct API scores rather than using a single aggregate score as a proxy for complex social behaviors while enabling the evaluation of state-of-the-art black-box classifiers beyond classification metrics. Drawing on 4,000 manually annotated English-language YouTube comments in the context of the Israel-Hamas war, we test whether multiple API scores predict incivility and intolerance using generalized linear and additive models, assess classification performance across non-hateful, uncivil, and intolerant content, and benchmark a recent deep learning model. Results show that Identity Attack is a strong predictor of intolerance, whereas Insult and Profanity are indicative of incivility. While classification performance is somewhat below state-of-the-art deep learning models, our approach offers important advantages: transparency, interpretability, accessibility for non-technical researchers, and potential cross-linguistic applicability. We argue that typology-driven, multi-indicator-based classification provides a practical and theoretically grounded complement to more aggregated black-box models, particularly in human-in-the-loop workflows that can help reduce annotator exposure through pre-filtering of content.
- 11 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Computer Review
Open AccessProfiling Digital Hate: A Multidimensional Measurement Approach Based on the Perspective API
The automatic classification of digital hate is a pressing challenge, yet many existing computational models remain opaque and insufficiently evaluated as measurement tools in social science contexts. This study examines the utility of Google’s Perspective API as a measurement instrument by modeling higher-order constructs of harmful discourse (i.e., incivility and intolerance) as outcomes of multiple lower-level behavioral indicators captured by distinct API scores rather than using a single aggregate score as a proxy for complex social behaviors while enabling the evaluation of state-of-the-art black-box classifiers beyond classification metrics. Drawing on 4,000 manually annotated English-language YouTube comments in the context of the Israel-Hamas war, we test whether multiple API scores predict incivility and intolerance using generalized linear and additive models, assess classification performance across non-hateful, uncivil, and intolerant content, and benchmark a recent deep learning model. Results show that Identity Attack is a strong predictor of intolerance, whereas Insult and Profanity are indicative of incivility. While classification performance is somewhat below state-of-the-art deep learning models, our approach offers important advantages: transparency, interpretability, accessibility for non-technical researchers, and potential cross-linguistic applicability. We argue that typology-driven, multi-indicator-based classification provides a practical and theoretically grounded complement to more aggregated black-box models, particularly in human-in-the-loop workflows that can help reduce annotator exposure through pre-filtering of content.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Fueling Environmental Anxiety, Anger, Guilt, or Efficacy? How Environmental Influencers Shape Sustainable Consumption Across the Globe
With billions of followers worldwide, environmental influencers shape sustainable behavior by turning abstract ideals into relatable lifestyles. Using survey data (N = 4,364) from Belgium, Chile, Germany, India, Malaysia, South Africa, South Korea, and Thailand, we examine how influencers’ green product recommendations are related to sustainable consumption by shaping environmental anxiety, anger, guilt, and efficacy. Results show that influencer recommendations increase anxiety, anger, guilt, and efficacy across countries. However, only efficacy consistently predicts willingness to pay more for green products, while guilt does so in all countries but Chile. Findings highlight the roles of empowerment (efficacy) and moral emotion (guilt).
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessFueling Environmental Anxiety, Anger, Guilt, or Efficacy? How Environmental Influencers Shape Sustainable Consumption Across the Globe
With billions of followers worldwide, environmental influencers shape sustainable behavior by turning abstract ideals into relatable lifestyles. Using survey data (N = 4,364) from Belgium, Chile, Germany, India, Malaysia, South Africa, South Korea, and Thailand, we examine how influencers’ green product recommendations are related to sustainable consumption by shaping environmental anxiety, anger, guilt, and efficacy. Results show that influencer recommendations increase anxiety, anger, guilt, and efficacy across countries. However, only efficacy consistently predicts willingness to pay more for green products, while guilt does so in all countries but Chile. Findings highlight the roles of empowerment (efficacy) and moral emotion (guilt).
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies
- Vol. 2026 (1)
Annotation in Action: Experimental Perspectives on Perceiving and Labeling Digital Hate Across Four European Countries
Digital hate annotation constitutes an important task for training automatic classification algorithms that are robust across country contexts yet also sensitive to their unique conditions. However, perceptual heterogeneity in how hateful content is evaluated introduces a great challenge for consistent rating and labeling, as interpretations of norm violations are shaped by individual and contextual factors. In this study, we conduct a 2 (uncivil vs. intolerant content) × 2 (ingroup vs. outgroup targeting) × 2 (annotator vs. user role) mixed online experiment in Austria, France, Hungary, and Sweden ( N = 1,718), in which participants rate and label social media comments. Intolerance is consistently perceived as more severe and labeled more often as hateful compared to incivility across all countries. However, we find mixed support for differences between ingroup and outgroup targeting, only limited cross‐country evidence that explicitly assigning participants an annotator role influences their severity ratings, and no evidence that it affects their labeling decisions compared to when they act as regular users. While the influence of sociodemographics on perception is highly dependent on the country context, we find migration attitudes to be a country‐invariant predictor.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies
- Vol. 2026 (1)
Open AccessAnnotation in Action: Experimental Perspectives on Perceiving and Labeling Digital Hate Across Four European Countries
Digital hate annotation constitutes an important task for training automatic classification algorithms that are robust across country contexts yet also sensitive to their unique conditions. However, perceptual heterogeneity in how hateful content is evaluated introduces a great challenge for consistent rating and labeling, as interpretations of norm violations are shaped by individual and contextual factors. In this study, we conduct a 2 (uncivil vs. intolerant content) × 2 (ingroup vs. outgroup targeting) × 2 (annotator vs. user role) mixed online experiment in Austria, France, Hungary, and Sweden ( N = 1,718), in which participants rate and label social media comments. Intolerance is consistently perceived as more severe and labeled more often as hateful compared to incivility across all countries. However, we find mixed support for differences between ingroup and outgroup targeting, only limited cross‐country evidence that explicitly assigning participants an annotator role influences their severity ratings, and no evidence that it affects their labeling decisions compared to when they act as regular users. While the influence of sociodemographics on perception is highly dependent on the country context, we find migration attitudes to be a country‐invariant predictor.
- Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Communication Research
- Vol. 53 (6) , 867-896
The State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review
Digital hate poses a threat to citizens, communities, and societies. Despite numerous studies and reviews on the concept of digital hate, we lack a systematic view of the entire body of scholarship. The aim of this umbrella review is therefore to evaluate the scope, definitions, main findings, and identified gaps of digital hate research. An umbrella review allows one to examine, compare, and evaluate the state of the research across all available reviews in order to point to larger, overarching patterns, shortcomings, and contradictions. We analyzed N = 206 narrative, systematic, and meta-analytical reviews. Findings suggest a lack of conceptual clarity, a need to study platform and age differences as well as a need to study digital hate across actors. Also, the analyzed reviews consistently call for experimental, longitudinal, and non-Western, cross-country research. We call for a coordinated cross-disciplinary effort to restructure and harmonize digital hate research.
- 28 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Communication Research
- Vol. 53 (6) , 867-896
Open AccessThe State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review
Digital hate poses a threat to citizens, communities, and societies. Despite numerous studies and reviews on the concept of digital hate, we lack a systematic view of the entire body of scholarship. The aim of this umbrella review is therefore to evaluate the scope, definitions, main findings, and identified gaps of digital hate research. An umbrella review allows one to examine, compare, and evaluate the state of the research across all available reviews in order to point to larger, overarching patterns, shortcomings, and contradictions. We analyzed N = 206 narrative, systematic, and meta-analytical reviews. Findings suggest a lack of conceptual clarity, a need to study platform and age differences as well as a need to study digital hate across actors. Also, the analyzed reviews consistently call for experimental, longitudinal, and non-Western, cross-country research. We call for a coordinated cross-disciplinary effort to restructure and harmonize digital hate research.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2025
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Online Media and Global Communication
- Vol. 4 (3) , 387-409
Does social media use make us more environmentally knowledgeable or more eco-anxious? A multi-country investigation
Purpose: Social media has a great mobilizing power and is considered to be an important vehicle to raise the awareness for the climate crisis across the globe. Despite this undisputed relevance, however, we lack studies exploring the relations between social media use, environmental knowledge, and environmental anxiety, particularly using a non-Western, global approach. Design/methodology/approach: We conducted a quota-based general population survey in Germany, Belgium, South Africa, Thailand, Chile, Malaysia, South Korea, and India. Findings: Using Structural Equation Modeling with partial measurement invariance across countries, we found that the relationship between social media use and environmental knowledge was remarkably different across countries. However, in all countries, social media use was a significant positive predictor of environmental anxiety, albeit the size of the effect differed across countries. Furthermore, knowledge was found to be a negative predictor of anxiety. Practical and social implications: By and large, findings suggest that the widespread hopes of social media being a facilitator of learning are ungrounded. Rather, social media seems to make individuals anxious about climate change. Originality/value: The study tests the role of social media beyond Western countries demonstrating the limited role of social media use for making individuals more knowledgeable.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Online Media and Global Communication
- Vol. 4 (3) , 387-409
Open AccessDoes social media use make us more environmentally knowledgeable or more eco-anxious? A multi-country investigation
Purpose: Social media has a great mobilizing power and is considered to be an important vehicle to raise the awareness for the climate crisis across the globe. Despite this undisputed relevance, however, we lack studies exploring the relations between social media use, environmental knowledge, and environmental anxiety, particularly using a non-Western, global approach. Design/methodology/approach: We conducted a quota-based general population survey in Germany, Belgium, South Africa, Thailand, Chile, Malaysia, South Korea, and India. Findings: Using Structural Equation Modeling with partial measurement invariance across countries, we found that the relationship between social media use and environmental knowledge was remarkably different across countries. However, in all countries, social media use was a significant positive predictor of environmental anxiety, albeit the size of the effect differed across countries. Furthermore, knowledge was found to be a negative predictor of anxiety. Practical and social implications: By and large, findings suggest that the widespread hopes of social media being a facilitator of learning are ungrounded. Rather, social media seems to make individuals anxious about climate change. Originality/value: The study tests the role of social media beyond Western countries demonstrating the limited role of social media use for making individuals more knowledgeable.
- Open Access
- 4 September 2024
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Communications
- Vol. 49 (3) , 468-490
Four eyes, two truths: Explaining heterogeneity in perceived severity of digital hate against immigrants
Drawing on theories related to interpersonal and intergroup behavior, this study investigated effects of personality traits (i.e., empathy and identity insecurity) and attitudes (i.e., anti-migration attitudes and social dominance orientation) on the perceived severity of digital hate against immigrants in Austria. Findings of autoregressive path modeling using two-wave panel data revealed that empathic suffering and egalitarianism positively predicted perceived severity, while anti-migrant attitudes exhibited a negative prediction. In terms of interactions between personality and attitudes, we observed that the prediction of empathic suffering becomes less relevant for egalitarian individuals, which indicates an overwriting process that might be a promising way to counteract socially harmful digital hate perceptions. Implications for research on annotation tasks and hate interventions are discussed.
- 4 September 2024
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Communications
- Vol. 49 (3) , 468-490
Open AccessFour eyes, two truths: Explaining heterogeneity in perceived severity of digital hate against immigrants
Drawing on theories related to interpersonal and intergroup behavior, this study investigated effects of personality traits (i.e., empathy and identity insecurity) and attitudes (i.e., anti-migration attitudes and social dominance orientation) on the perceived severity of digital hate against immigrants in Austria. Findings of autoregressive path modeling using two-wave panel data revealed that empathic suffering and egalitarianism positively predicted perceived severity, while anti-migrant attitudes exhibited a negative prediction. In terms of interactions between personality and attitudes, we observed that the prediction of empathic suffering becomes less relevant for egalitarian individuals, which indicates an overwriting process that might be a promising way to counteract socially harmful digital hate perceptions. Implications for research on annotation tasks and hate interventions are discussed.
- 11 November 2002
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- Vol. 1, 893-899
Soft-commissioning: hardware-in-the-loop-based verification of controller software
- 11 November 2002
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- Vol. 1, 893-899
Soft-commissioning: hardware-in-the-loop-based verification of controller software