Sandra Ziegler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Sandra Ziegler has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kayvan Bozorgmehr
Department of Population Medicine & Health Services Research, School of Public Health, Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany
5 shared publications K Bozorgmehr
Section for Health Equity Studies & Migration, Heidelberg University Hospital , Heidelberg, Germany
4 shared publications- Albrecht Jahn
Heidelberg Institute of Global Health, Heidelberg University, Heidelberg, Germany
3 shared publications - Claudia Beiersmann
Heidelberg Institute of Global Health, Heidelberg University Hospital, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany
3 shared publications - Janine Benson-Martin
Gesundheitsamt Enzkreis, The Public Health Office Enzkreis, 75177 Pforzheim, Germany
3 shared publications - Temesghen Gebresilassie
Heidelberg Institute of Global Health, Heidelberg University Hospital, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal for Equity in Health
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-22
Translating restrictive law into practice: An ethnographic exploration of the systemic processing of legally restricted health care access for asylum seekers in Germany
Background: Access to health services for asylum seekers is legally restricted in Germany. The law is subject to interpretation, therefore the chance of receiving care is not equally distributed among asylum seekers. What services are provided to whom is ultimately decided by health professionals and government employees. The respective prioritization processes and criteria are not transparent. We sought to understand how legal restrictions are translated into daily practices and how this affects the health system. We aimed to outline the complex process of cost coverage for health services for asylum seekers and provide insights into common decision-making criteria. Methods: We conducted an ethnographic exploration of routines in two outpatient clinics in two federal states over the course of three months, doing participant and non-participant observation. Additionally, we interviewed 21 professionals of health care and government organizations, and documented 110 applications for cost coverage of medical services and their outcome. In addition to qualitative data analysis and documentation, we apply a system-theoretical perspective to our findings. Results: To perform legal restrictions a cross-sectoral prioritization process of medical services has been implemented, involving health care and government institutions. This changes professional practices, responsibilities and (power) relations. Involved actors find themselves at the intersection of several, oftentimes conflicting priorities, since “doing it right” might be seen differently from a legal, medical, economic, or political perspective. The system-theoretical analysis reveals that while actors have to bring different rationales into workable arrangements this part of the medical system transforms, giving rise to a sub-system that incorporates migration political rationales. Conclusions: Health care restrictions for asylum seekers are implemented through an organizational linking of care provision and government administration, resulting in a bureaucratization of practice. Power structures at this intersection of health and migration policy, that are uncommon in other parts of the health system are thereby normalized. Outpatient clinics provide low-threshold access to health services, but paradoxically they may unintentionally stabilize health inequities, if prioritization criteria and power dynamics are not made transparent. Health professionals should openly reflect on conflicting rationales. Training, research and professional associations need to empower them to stay true to professional ethical principles and international conventions.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal for Equity in Health
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-22
Open AccessTranslating restrictive law into practice: An ethnographic exploration of the systemic processing of legally restricted health care access for asylum seekers in Germany
Background: Access to health services for asylum seekers is legally restricted in Germany. The law is subject to interpretation, therefore the chance of receiving care is not equally distributed among asylum seekers. What services are provided to whom is ultimately decided by health professionals and government employees. The respective prioritization processes and criteria are not transparent. We sought to understand how legal restrictions are translated into daily practices and how this affects the health system. We aimed to outline the complex process of cost coverage for health services for asylum seekers and provide insights into common decision-making criteria. Methods: We conducted an ethnographic exploration of routines in two outpatient clinics in two federal states over the course of three months, doing participant and non-participant observation. Additionally, we interviewed 21 professionals of health care and government organizations, and documented 110 applications for cost coverage of medical services and their outcome. In addition to qualitative data analysis and documentation, we apply a system-theoretical perspective to our findings. Results: To perform legal restrictions a cross-sectoral prioritization process of medical services has been implemented, involving health care and government institutions. This changes professional practices, responsibilities and (power) relations. Involved actors find themselves at the intersection of several, oftentimes conflicting priorities, since “doing it right” might be seen differently from a legal, medical, economic, or political perspective. The system-theoretical analysis reveals that while actors have to bring different rationales into workable arrangements this part of the medical system transforms, giving rise to a sub-system that incorporates migration political rationales. Conclusions: Health care restrictions for asylum seekers are implemented through an organizational linking of care provision and government administration, resulting in a bureaucratization of practice. Power structures at this intersection of health and migration policy, that are uncommon in other parts of the health system are thereby normalized. Outpatient clinics provide low-threshold access to health services, but paradoxically they may unintentionally stabilize health inequities, if prioritization criteria and power dynamics are not made transparent. Health professionals should openly reflect on conflicting rationales. Training, research and professional associations need to empower them to stay true to professional ethical principles and international conventions.
- Open Access
- 23 February 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Global Public Health
- Vol. 4 (2) , e0002910
“I don´t put people into boxes, but…” A free-listing exercise exploring social categorisation of asylum seekers by professionals in two German reception centres
Newly arriving asylum seekers in Germany mostly live in large reception centres, depending on professionals in most aspects of their daily lives. The legal basis for the provision of goods and services allows for discretionary decisions. Given the potential impact of social categorisation on professionals’ decisions, and ultimately access to health and social services, we explore the categories used by professionals. We ask of what nature these categorisations are, and weather they align with the public discourse on forced migration. Within an ethnographic study in outpatient clinics of two refugee accommodation centres in Germany, we conducted a modified free-listing with 40 professionals (physicians, nurses, security-personnel, social workers, translators) to explore their categorisation of asylum seekers. Data were qualitatively analysed, and categories were quantitatively mapped using Excel and the Macro “Flame" to show frequencies, ranks, and salience. The four most relevant social categorisations of asylum seekers referred to "demanding and expectant," "polite and friendly" behaviour, "economic refugees," and "integration efforts". In general, sociodemographic variables like gender, age, family status, including countries and regions of origin, were the most significant basis for categorisations (31%), those were often presented combined with other categories. Observations of behaviour and attitudes also influenced categorisations (24%). Professional considerations, e.g., on health, education, adaption or status ranked third (20%). Social categorisation was influenced by public discourses, with evaluations of flight motives, prospects of staying in Germany, and integration potential being thematised in 12% of the categorisations. Professionals therefore might be in danger of being instrumentalised for internal border work. Identifying social categories is important since they structure perception, along their lines deservingness is negotiated, so they potentially influence interaction and decision-making, can trigger empathy and support as well as rejection and discrimination. Larger studies should investigate this further. Free-listing provides a suitable tool for such investigations.
- 23 February 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Global Public Health
- Vol. 4 (2) , e0002910
Open Access“I don´t put people into boxes, but…” A free-listing exercise exploring social categorisation of asylum seekers by professionals in two German reception centres
Newly arriving asylum seekers in Germany mostly live in large reception centres, depending on professionals in most aspects of their daily lives. The legal basis for the provision of goods and services allows for discretionary decisions. Given the potential impact of social categorisation on professionals’ decisions, and ultimately access to health and social services, we explore the categories used by professionals. We ask of what nature these categorisations are, and weather they align with the public discourse on forced migration. Within an ethnographic study in outpatient clinics of two refugee accommodation centres in Germany, we conducted a modified free-listing with 40 professionals (physicians, nurses, security-personnel, social workers, translators) to explore their categorisation of asylum seekers. Data were qualitatively analysed, and categories were quantitatively mapped using Excel and the Macro “Flame" to show frequencies, ranks, and salience. The four most relevant social categorisations of asylum seekers referred to "demanding and expectant," "polite and friendly" behaviour, "economic refugees," and "integration efforts". In general, sociodemographic variables like gender, age, family status, including countries and regions of origin, were the most significant basis for categorisations (31%), those were often presented combined with other categories. Observations of behaviour and attitudes also influenced categorisations (24%). Professional considerations, e.g., on health, education, adaption or status ranked third (20%). Social categorisation was influenced by public discourses, with evaluations of flight motives, prospects of staying in Germany, and integration potential being thematised in 12% of the categorisations. Professionals therefore might be in danger of being instrumentalised for internal border work. Identifying social categories is important since they structure perception, along their lines deservingness is negotiated, so they potentially influence interaction and decision-making, can trigger empathy and support as well as rejection and discrimination. Larger studies should investigate this further. Free-listing provides a suitable tool for such investigations.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
Social categorisation of asylum seekers: Free-listing by professionals in German reception centres
Background: Newly arriving asylum seekers in Germany mostly live in large reception centres. Goods and services are provided by professionals. Their social categorisations may impact discretionary decisions and determine the scope of access to health and social services. We sought to explore what social categories were mostly applied to asylum seekers in that context. Methods: We conducted a modified, verbal free-listing with health care, security, translation, social work and administrative staff in two German reception centres, asking what kind of asylum seekers were there. After qualitative content analysis, categories were quantitatively mapped using the Excel Macro “Flame” showing frequencies, ranks and salience of those social categories. Results: 40 professionals listed on average 16 items (min = 4, max = 31). In total 624 items were analysed. Categorisations were of individual, interactional, professional, and societal nature. Professionally relevant categories like needs were not mentioned with the highest frequencies. The leading social categorisations of asylum seekers referred to asylum seekers attitudes professionals derived from their behaviour mostly in combination with socio-demographic variables, such as countries and regions of origin and sex. The most relevant social categories were “demanding and expectant” and “polite and friendly” behaviour, also the effort to adapt to the German environment was often evaluated. The category “economic refugees” ranked forth. Conclusions: Social categorisation is permeable to public and political discourses related to motives for flight, or integration efforts and chances, impacting on negotiations of deservingness. Since categorisation structures perception, it potentially influences interaction and decision-making, it can trigger empathy and support as well as rejection and discrimination. Free-listing provides a suitable tool, to explore real world categorisation without leaning on pre-given social categories. Key messages: • Public health studies on bias, racism and discrimination could benefit from free-listing as useful methodological tool to explore real world social categorisation without using pre-given categories. • Health sciences should foster awareness on political and societal discourses about migrant and minority populations seeping into professional cognition, which can trigger support or discrimination.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
Open AccessSocial categorisation of asylum seekers: Free-listing by professionals in German reception centres
Background: Newly arriving asylum seekers in Germany mostly live in large reception centres. Goods and services are provided by professionals. Their social categorisations may impact discretionary decisions and determine the scope of access to health and social services. We sought to explore what social categories were mostly applied to asylum seekers in that context. Methods: We conducted a modified, verbal free-listing with health care, security, translation, social work and administrative staff in two German reception centres, asking what kind of asylum seekers were there. After qualitative content analysis, categories were quantitatively mapped using the Excel Macro “Flame” showing frequencies, ranks and salience of those social categories. Results: 40 professionals listed on average 16 items (min = 4, max = 31). In total 624 items were analysed. Categorisations were of individual, interactional, professional, and societal nature. Professionally relevant categories like needs were not mentioned with the highest frequencies. The leading social categorisations of asylum seekers referred to asylum seekers attitudes professionals derived from their behaviour mostly in combination with socio-demographic variables, such as countries and regions of origin and sex. The most relevant social categories were “demanding and expectant” and “polite and friendly” behaviour, also the effort to adapt to the German environment was often evaluated. The category “economic refugees” ranked forth. Conclusions: Social categorisation is permeable to public and political discourses related to motives for flight, or integration efforts and chances, impacting on negotiations of deservingness. Since categorisation structures perception, it potentially influences interaction and decision-making, it can trigger empathy and support as well as rejection and discrimination. Free-listing provides a suitable tool, to explore real world categorisation without leaning on pre-given social categories. Key messages: • Public health studies on bias, racism and discrimination could benefit from free-listing as useful methodological tool to explore real world social categorisation without using pre-given categories. • Health sciences should foster awareness on political and societal discourses about migrant and minority populations seeping into professional cognition, which can trigger support or discrimination.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
“Economic migrants will anyway be deported soon”. Negotiating access and deservingness of refugees
Background: Conflicting rationales permeate the European discourse on refugee migration: inclusiveness and human rights clash with xenophobia and aims to protect territory and wealth. Against this backdrop, health care access for newly arrived refugees in many European countries is restricted. The legal frame in Germany allows for extended restrictions as well as inclusive health care. While vague legal formulations create uncertainties regarding entitlements, they allow for discretionary decisions by a plethora of health care and government actors. Methods: An ethnographic field study in two German refugee outpatient clinics including participant observation and interviews with 29 members of health care, administrative, social work and interpreting staff was conducted. By means of a qualitative content analysis we explored prioritisation criteria and negotiations about service provision to refugees by street-level decision-makers. Results: Medical decision makers adopted government criteria to increase the chances of success of requests for reimbursement. We could identify various non-medical criteria, like asylum status and logistics impacting on access to care. Political and societal discourses seeped into discussions on granting or denying medical services: Medical and government decision-makers reflected on prospects of staying associated with the countries of origin of asylum seekers and illegitimate motives for flight, such as poverty, while negotiating what services should be provided to whom. Conclusions: The vagueness of legal concepts allows for the implementation of restrictions based on non-medical grounds in practice, that would contradict international conventions if included in the legal norm unambiguously. In the face of contradictory imperatives, the state has chosen to leave policymaking to practitioners. They are in danger of being instrumentalized as agents of migration control, exclusion and deterrence, which raises practical and ethical questions. Key messages: • Legal uncertainty leads to inconsistent medical care practices, that can exacerbate health inequities. • Health professionals have to be made aware of their responsibility as gate keepers to the medical system for refugees, so they cannot be politically instrumentalized as agents of migration control.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
Open Access“Economic migrants will anyway be deported soon”. Negotiating access and deservingness of refugees
Background: Conflicting rationales permeate the European discourse on refugee migration: inclusiveness and human rights clash with xenophobia and aims to protect territory and wealth. Against this backdrop, health care access for newly arrived refugees in many European countries is restricted. The legal frame in Germany allows for extended restrictions as well as inclusive health care. While vague legal formulations create uncertainties regarding entitlements, they allow for discretionary decisions by a plethora of health care and government actors. Methods: An ethnographic field study in two German refugee outpatient clinics including participant observation and interviews with 29 members of health care, administrative, social work and interpreting staff was conducted. By means of a qualitative content analysis we explored prioritisation criteria and negotiations about service provision to refugees by street-level decision-makers. Results: Medical decision makers adopted government criteria to increase the chances of success of requests for reimbursement. We could identify various non-medical criteria, like asylum status and logistics impacting on access to care. Political and societal discourses seeped into discussions on granting or denying medical services: Medical and government decision-makers reflected on prospects of staying associated with the countries of origin of asylum seekers and illegitimate motives for flight, such as poverty, while negotiating what services should be provided to whom. Conclusions: The vagueness of legal concepts allows for the implementation of restrictions based on non-medical grounds in practice, that would contradict international conventions if included in the legal norm unambiguously. In the face of contradictory imperatives, the state has chosen to leave policymaking to practitioners. They are in danger of being instrumentalized as agents of migration control, exclusion and deterrence, which raises practical and ethical questions. Key messages: • Legal uncertainty leads to inconsistent medical care practices, that can exacerbate health inequities. • Health professionals have to be made aware of their responsibility as gate keepers to the medical system for refugees, so they cannot be politically instrumentalized as agents of migration control.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
Mini-ethnography for medical students. Inquiry-based learning to foster transcultural competences
Background: Transcultural competences are important for health professionals in plural societies. But if ‘culture’ is addressed in medical curricula, the underlying concepts are often not up to date with constructivist approaches of social sciences. Instead of teaching multiple definitions and complex theory, medical students can be familiarized with the perspective of these sciences through a methodologically structured exposure. Objectives: An ethnographic field exercise was included in a clinical elective on refugee health care for medical students at a German university between 2016 and 2023. An anthropologist introduced the scientific perspective as well as participant-observation as qualitative method. Evaluations after introducing the task were analysed and a qualitative content analysis after completion was done to discern if learning goals were reached. Results: 130 students participated in the ethnographic exercise. Perceived relevancy for medical education varied (4-p; M = 2,6; SD = 0,7; n = 81); 47% of students regarded written reflection as enhancing competencies (5-p; M = 3,3; SD = 1,2; n = 107). Many considered the exercise as demanding, but interesting. The field protocols show it sharpened perception, ‘culture’ became one of many factors impacting on interactions. Learning to separate description from interpretation, students were able to reflect on own thoughts, evaluations, stereotypes and emotions. Awareness of context-dependency and structural embeddedness of medical encounters, critical assessment of power-dynamics, political issues, service quality and professional ethics in a resource constrained setting were fostered. Conclusions: An anthropological approach and self-experience as participant observer can provide medical students with the opportunity to cultivate situational awareness and a holistic, multi-layered, structurally sensitive perception that may be more helpful in dealing with the challenges of diversity than presumed knowledge about ‘cultures'. Key messages: • Ethnographic exercises linked with exposure to refugee settings help to foster transcultural and structural competences of medical students without the need for an extensive study of culture theory. • Essentialist culture concepts within medical education can be countered by short theoretical updates and inquiry-based learning within contexts characterised by diversity and exclusion.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 33 (Supplement)
Open AccessMini-ethnography for medical students. Inquiry-based learning to foster transcultural competences
Background: Transcultural competences are important for health professionals in plural societies. But if ‘culture’ is addressed in medical curricula, the underlying concepts are often not up to date with constructivist approaches of social sciences. Instead of teaching multiple definitions and complex theory, medical students can be familiarized with the perspective of these sciences through a methodologically structured exposure. Objectives: An ethnographic field exercise was included in a clinical elective on refugee health care for medical students at a German university between 2016 and 2023. An anthropologist introduced the scientific perspective as well as participant-observation as qualitative method. Evaluations after introducing the task were analysed and a qualitative content analysis after completion was done to discern if learning goals were reached. Results: 130 students participated in the ethnographic exercise. Perceived relevancy for medical education varied (4-p; M = 2,6; SD = 0,7; n = 81); 47% of students regarded written reflection as enhancing competencies (5-p; M = 3,3; SD = 1,2; n = 107). Many considered the exercise as demanding, but interesting. The field protocols show it sharpened perception, ‘culture’ became one of many factors impacting on interactions. Learning to separate description from interpretation, students were able to reflect on own thoughts, evaluations, stereotypes and emotions. Awareness of context-dependency and structural embeddedness of medical encounters, critical assessment of power-dynamics, political issues, service quality and professional ethics in a resource constrained setting were fostered. Conclusions: An anthropological approach and self-experience as participant observer can provide medical students with the opportunity to cultivate situational awareness and a holistic, multi-layered, structurally sensitive perception that may be more helpful in dealing with the challenges of diversity than presumed knowledge about ‘cultures'. Key messages: • Ethnographic exercises linked with exposure to refugee settings help to foster transcultural and structural competences of medical students without the need for an extensive study of culture theory. • Essentialist culture concepts within medical education can be countered by short theoretical updates and inquiry-based learning within contexts characterised by diversity and exclusion.
- Open Access
- 21 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-14
Diversity competence training for health professionals in Europe: a modified delphi study investigating relevant content for short or online courses
Background: Diversity is a reality in our societies, requiring health professionals to adapt to the unique needs of all patients, including migrants and ethnic minorities. In order to enable health professionals to meet related challenges and reduce health disparities, long and demanding training courses have been developed. But due to busy schedules of professionals and often scarce resources, a need for shorter training courses exists. This study aims to investigate which topics and methods should be prioritised in designing basic diversity training courses that provide health professionals the opportunity to foster this competence. Methods: The study provided an expert panel of 31 academic and clinical migrant health experts with the content and methods of an existing diversity training course. The panel was asked to prioritise training topics and teaching methods in a two-stage process, using an adapted Delphi method. In the first stage, experts rated 96 predefined items, commented on those items, provided answers to eight open-ended questions and suggested additional content for a short course. In the second stage, they commented on the ratings from Round 1, and rated new suggested content. Consensus for training topics was set to 80% and for teaching methods 70%. Results: The entire panel deemed ‘health effects of migration (pre-, during- and post-migration risk factors)’ to be important or very important to include in a short/online, basic diversity training (100% consensus). Other high-scoring items and therefore topics to be included in trainings were ‘social determinants of health’ (97%) and ‘discrimination within the healthcare sector’ (also 97%). A general trend was to focus on reflective practice since almost all items regarding reflection reached consensus. ‘Reflection on own stereotypes and prejudices’ (97%) was the highest-rated reflection item. ‘Opportunities and best practices in working with interpreters’ was the highest-scoring skills item, both on consensus (96%) and mean value (5.77). Conclusions: Experts’ prioritizations of teaching content and methods for diversity training can help the design of short (online) trainings for health professionals and reduce unnecessary course content, thereby fostering professional development and enabling diversity competence trainings to be implemented also when time and/or financial resources are limited.
- 21 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-14
Open AccessDiversity competence training for health professionals in Europe: a modified delphi study investigating relevant content for short or online courses
Background: Diversity is a reality in our societies, requiring health professionals to adapt to the unique needs of all patients, including migrants and ethnic minorities. In order to enable health professionals to meet related challenges and reduce health disparities, long and demanding training courses have been developed. But due to busy schedules of professionals and often scarce resources, a need for shorter training courses exists. This study aims to investigate which topics and methods should be prioritised in designing basic diversity training courses that provide health professionals the opportunity to foster this competence. Methods: The study provided an expert panel of 31 academic and clinical migrant health experts with the content and methods of an existing diversity training course. The panel was asked to prioritise training topics and teaching methods in a two-stage process, using an adapted Delphi method. In the first stage, experts rated 96 predefined items, commented on those items, provided answers to eight open-ended questions and suggested additional content for a short course. In the second stage, they commented on the ratings from Round 1, and rated new suggested content. Consensus for training topics was set to 80% and for teaching methods 70%. Results: The entire panel deemed ‘health effects of migration (pre-, during- and post-migration risk factors)’ to be important or very important to include in a short/online, basic diversity training (100% consensus). Other high-scoring items and therefore topics to be included in trainings were ‘social determinants of health’ (97%) and ‘discrimination within the healthcare sector’ (also 97%). A general trend was to focus on reflective practice since almost all items regarding reflection reached consensus. ‘Reflection on own stereotypes and prejudices’ (97%) was the highest-rated reflection item. ‘Opportunities and best practices in working with interpreters’ was the highest-scoring skills item, both on consensus (96%) and mean value (5.77). Conclusions: Experts’ prioritizations of teaching content and methods for diversity training can help the design of short (online) trainings for health professionals and reduce unnecessary course content, thereby fostering professional development and enabling diversity competence trainings to be implemented also when time and/or financial resources are limited.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 32 (Supplement)
Diversity Competence in Healthcare: A minimal definition
Background: Health professionals face a variety of professional challenges in today's plural societies. Sciences propose a specific skill set can help to meet those challenges. Various terms and sometimes extensive concepts are provided for diversity competence. The related learning processes are time-consuming and demanding to implement in hectic clinical realities, so that a basic, easy to deplore training package of essential skills would be desirable in order to enable health professionals to take equally good care of all patients including migrants and minorities. Methods: A two-round Delphi study was conducted to prioritise teaching objectives; 31 clinical and academic migrant health experts from 13 European countries participated. A round of open questions was followed by a standardised rating round of 65 items. Data was descriptively analysed (m, M, SD) and consensus defined as 80% of experts assigning high importance to a competence. Results: The process identified essential competences as well as high priority cognitive, affective and pragmatic competences, leading to a minimal definition of diversity competence for health professionals which includes respectfulness, empathy, diversity awareness and reflection, knowledge on social determinants as well as ethics and human rights; Further skills are: being able to listen, observe and communicate understandably, including professional usage of interpreters, shared decision-making and individual, need-based care. Conclusions: The panel reached consensus on many of the competences. In general, attitudes and practical skills were considered essential. Basic trainings that meet the needs of professionals and help them cope with everyday challenges can be designed on the grounds of these findings. We provide a working definition of ‘diversity competence of health professionals’ for scientific exchange and investigation and propose the conscious use of a ‘diversity’ instead of ‘intercultural” terminology. Key messages:
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 32 (Supplement)
Open AccessDiversity Competence in Healthcare: A minimal definition
Background: Health professionals face a variety of professional challenges in today's plural societies. Sciences propose a specific skill set can help to meet those challenges. Various terms and sometimes extensive concepts are provided for diversity competence. The related learning processes are time-consuming and demanding to implement in hectic clinical realities, so that a basic, easy to deplore training package of essential skills would be desirable in order to enable health professionals to take equally good care of all patients including migrants and minorities. Methods: A two-round Delphi study was conducted to prioritise teaching objectives; 31 clinical and academic migrant health experts from 13 European countries participated. A round of open questions was followed by a standardised rating round of 65 items. Data was descriptively analysed (m, M, SD) and consensus defined as 80% of experts assigning high importance to a competence. Results: The process identified essential competences as well as high priority cognitive, affective and pragmatic competences, leading to a minimal definition of diversity competence for health professionals which includes respectfulness, empathy, diversity awareness and reflection, knowledge on social determinants as well as ethics and human rights; Further skills are: being able to listen, observe and communicate understandably, including professional usage of interpreters, shared decision-making and individual, need-based care. Conclusions: The panel reached consensus on many of the competences. In general, attitudes and practical skills were considered essential. Basic trainings that meet the needs of professionals and help them cope with everyday challenges can be designed on the grounds of these findings. We provide a working definition of ‘diversity competence of health professionals’ for scientific exchange and investigation and propose the conscious use of a ‘diversity’ instead of ‘intercultural” terminology. Key messages:
- Open Access
- 5 September 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 19 (17) , 11099
Mental Wellbeing and Social Resilience of Eritrean Refugees Living in Germany
Mental health and social resilience play a significant role in refugees’ adaptation during the resettlement process in the host country. Maintaining good mental wellbeing helps the refugees to respond to stressful experiences with healthy life choices. This study aimed to explore the mental wellbeing and social resilience of Eritrean refugees living in Germany and to identify social conditions and enablers to foster adaptation. This study employs a qualitative approach with a semi-structured, in-depth interview data collection method. Informants were identified among mostly young adult refugees living in Heidelberg, Germany, with a migration history of 3–6 years. In total, 15 informants were recruited through snowball sampling. Data were sorted and analyzed using the five pillars of the Adaptation and Development after Persecution and Trauma (ADAPT) model. The findings suggest that Eritrean refugees experienced psychological distress after resettlement in Germany; however, with time, their mental health improved. The study revealed conditions that were experienced as hindrances, as well as ones that were considered to be resources of positive mental wellbeing and social resilience for resettled refugees. Resettlement challenges described by the participants were the language barrier, discrimination, unemployment, insecure residence status, loss of family and friends, conflict within the diaspora community, and isolation. The main sources of mental wellbeing and social resilience include the feeling of being welcomed by local communities, access to social services, adopting new relationships, and educational opportunities. These experiences encouraged refugees to have a favorable view of their lives and futures and were also found to facilitate better integration and adaptation. Understanding refugee mental wellbeing and social resilience requires a multidimensional perspective. Eritrean refugees living in Germany have experienced and are still experiencing resettlement challenges, such as, for example, loss of family and friends, negative perception of the German system, loss of past achievements, or unemployment. However, they have developed adaptive and resilience mechanisms, as well, such as seeing an opportunity for a better life, adopting new roles, and accepting Germany as a “second home”. In addressing those issues reported by the refugees as hindrances, these could be turned into sources of mental wellbeing and resilience.
- 5 September 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 19 (17) , 11099
Open AccessMental Wellbeing and Social Resilience of Eritrean Refugees Living in Germany
Mental health and social resilience play a significant role in refugees’ adaptation during the resettlement process in the host country. Maintaining good mental wellbeing helps the refugees to respond to stressful experiences with healthy life choices. This study aimed to explore the mental wellbeing and social resilience of Eritrean refugees living in Germany and to identify social conditions and enablers to foster adaptation. This study employs a qualitative approach with a semi-structured, in-depth interview data collection method. Informants were identified among mostly young adult refugees living in Heidelberg, Germany, with a migration history of 3–6 years. In total, 15 informants were recruited through snowball sampling. Data were sorted and analyzed using the five pillars of the Adaptation and Development after Persecution and Trauma (ADAPT) model. The findings suggest that Eritrean refugees experienced psychological distress after resettlement in Germany; however, with time, their mental health improved. The study revealed conditions that were experienced as hindrances, as well as ones that were considered to be resources of positive mental wellbeing and social resilience for resettled refugees. Resettlement challenges described by the participants were the language barrier, discrimination, unemployment, insecure residence status, loss of family and friends, conflict within the diaspora community, and isolation. The main sources of mental wellbeing and social resilience include the feeling of being welcomed by local communities, access to social services, adopting new relationships, and educational opportunities. These experiences encouraged refugees to have a favorable view of their lives and futures and were also found to facilitate better integration and adaptation. Understanding refugee mental wellbeing and social resilience requires a multidimensional perspective. Eritrean refugees living in Germany have experienced and are still experiencing resettlement challenges, such as, for example, loss of family and friends, negative perception of the German system, loss of past achievements, or unemployment. However, they have developed adaptive and resilience mechanisms, as well, such as seeing an opportunity for a better life, adopting new roles, and accepting Germany as a “second home”. In addressing those issues reported by the refugees as hindrances, these could be turned into sources of mental wellbeing and resilience.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Mental Wellbeing and Social Resilience of Eritrean Refugees living in Germany
Mental health and social resilience play a significant role in refugees’ adaptation during the resettlement process in the host country. Maintaining good mental wellbeing helps the refugees to respond to stressful experiences with healthy life choices. This study aimed to explore the mental wellbeing and social resilience of Eritrean refugees living in Germany and to identify social conditions and enablers to foster adaptation. This study employs a qualitative approach with a semi-structured, in-depth interview data collection method. Informants were identified among mostly young adult refugees living in Heidelberg, Germany, with a migration history of 3-6 years. In total, 15 informants were recruited through snowball sampling. Data were sorted and analyzed using the five pillars of the Adaptation and Development after Persecution and Trauma (ADAPT) model. The findings suggest that Eritrean refugees experience psychological distress after resettlement in Germany, however with time, their mental health has improved. The study revealed conditions that were experienced as hindrances, as well as ones that were considered to be resources of positive mental wellbeing and social resilience for resettled refugees. Challenges described were the language barrier, discrimination, unemployment, insecure residence status, loss of family and friends, conflict within the diaspora community, and isolation. The main sources of mental wellbeing and social resilience include the feeling of being welcomed by local communities, access to social services, adopting new relationships, and educational opportunities. These experiences encouraged refugees to have a favorable view of their lives and futures as well as also found to facilitate better integration and adaptation. Understanding refugee mental wellbeing and social resilience require a multidimensional perspective. Eritrean refugees living in Germany have experienced and still are experiencing resettlement challenges, as for example loss of family and friends, negative perception of the German system, loss of past achievements, or unemployment. But they have developed adaptive and resilience mechanisms, too, such as seeing an opportunity for a better life, adopting new roles, and accepting Germany as a “second home”. In addressing those by the refugees as hindrances reported issues, these could be turned into sources of mental well-being and resilience.
- 1 August 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessMental Wellbeing and Social Resilience of Eritrean Refugees living in Germany
Mental health and social resilience play a significant role in refugees’ adaptation during the resettlement process in the host country. Maintaining good mental wellbeing helps the refugees to respond to stressful experiences with healthy life choices. This study aimed to explore the mental wellbeing and social resilience of Eritrean refugees living in Germany and to identify social conditions and enablers to foster adaptation. This study employs a qualitative approach with a semi-structured, in-depth interview data collection method. Informants were identified among mostly young adult refugees living in Heidelberg, Germany, with a migration history of 3-6 years. In total, 15 informants were recruited through snowball sampling. Data were sorted and analyzed using the five pillars of the Adaptation and Development after Persecution and Trauma (ADAPT) model. The findings suggest that Eritrean refugees experience psychological distress after resettlement in Germany, however with time, their mental health has improved. The study revealed conditions that were experienced as hindrances, as well as ones that were considered to be resources of positive mental wellbeing and social resilience for resettled refugees. Challenges described were the language barrier, discrimination, unemployment, insecure residence status, loss of family and friends, conflict within the diaspora community, and isolation. The main sources of mental wellbeing and social resilience include the feeling of being welcomed by local communities, access to social services, adopting new relationships, and educational opportunities. These experiences encouraged refugees to have a favorable view of their lives and futures as well as also found to facilitate better integration and adaptation. Understanding refugee mental wellbeing and social resilience require a multidimensional perspective. Eritrean refugees living in Germany have experienced and still are experiencing resettlement challenges, as for example loss of family and friends, negative perception of the German system, loss of past achievements, or unemployment. But they have developed adaptive and resilience mechanisms, too, such as seeing an opportunity for a better life, adopting new roles, and accepting Germany as a “second home”. In addressing those by the refugees as hindrances reported issues, these could be turned into sources of mental well-being and resilience.
- Open Access
- 6 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 22 (1) , 1-12
Opening up a tailored tutor qualification program for medical students to other healthcare students – a mixed-method study
Background: Peer-led tutorials are widely used in medical education to promote practical skills acquisition and support faculty staff. Typically, student tutors are custom trained for this specific task. We investigated whether opening up an existing medical tutor qualification program to other degree programs is successful in terms of acceptance among students, acquisition of tutor-specific and interprofessional competencies, and which factors contribute to success or failure. Methods: We developed a two-day tutor qualification program and conducted it annually from 2016 to 2020 with medical and other healthcare students. At the end of each course, we administered a written survey in which the participants rated the following items: their attitudes towards interprofessional learning (using the UWE-IP-D Interprofessional Learning Scale), the interprofessional learning setting, the teaching approach, and their competency acquisition (each on a five-point Likert scale; 1 = strongly agree, 5 = strongly disagree). Furthermore, we assessed participants’ qualitative feedback in free-text fields and performed inductive content analyses. Results: The study participation rate was high (response rate 97%; medical students: n = 75; healthcare students: n = 22). Participants stated high levels of competency acquisition (total M = 1.59, individual items’ M’s ranging from 1.20 to 2.05) and even higher satisfaction with the teaching approach (total M = 1.28, individual items’ M’s ranging from 1.43 to 1.05). Overall satisfaction with the training was M = 1.22; SD = 0.58. No significant differences in ratings were found between the student groups. The qualitative results showed that students appreciated the interprofessional setting and experienced it as enriching. The most positive feedback was found in didactics/teaching methods on role-plays and group work; most suggestions for improvement were found in the area of structure and organisation on breaks and time management. Conclusions: Opening up an existing medical tutor qualification program to other student groups can be seen as fruitful to teach not only tutor-related aspects but also interprofessional competencies. The results demonstrate the importance of detailed planning that considers group composition and contextual conditions and provides interactive teaching methods to promote interprofessional experiences. This study offers important information about prerequisites and methodological implementation that could be important for the interprofessional redesign of existing training programs.
- 6 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 22 (1) , 1-12
Open AccessOpening up a tailored tutor qualification program for medical students to other healthcare students – a mixed-method study
Background: Peer-led tutorials are widely used in medical education to promote practical skills acquisition and support faculty staff. Typically, student tutors are custom trained for this specific task. We investigated whether opening up an existing medical tutor qualification program to other degree programs is successful in terms of acceptance among students, acquisition of tutor-specific and interprofessional competencies, and which factors contribute to success or failure. Methods: We developed a two-day tutor qualification program and conducted it annually from 2016 to 2020 with medical and other healthcare students. At the end of each course, we administered a written survey in which the participants rated the following items: their attitudes towards interprofessional learning (using the UWE-IP-D Interprofessional Learning Scale), the interprofessional learning setting, the teaching approach, and their competency acquisition (each on a five-point Likert scale; 1 = strongly agree, 5 = strongly disagree). Furthermore, we assessed participants’ qualitative feedback in free-text fields and performed inductive content analyses. Results: The study participation rate was high (response rate 97%; medical students: n = 75; healthcare students: n = 22). Participants stated high levels of competency acquisition (total M = 1.59, individual items’ M’s ranging from 1.20 to 2.05) and even higher satisfaction with the teaching approach (total M = 1.28, individual items’ M’s ranging from 1.43 to 1.05). Overall satisfaction with the training was M = 1.22; SD = 0.58. No significant differences in ratings were found between the student groups. The qualitative results showed that students appreciated the interprofessional setting and experienced it as enriching. The most positive feedback was found in didactics/teaching methods on role-plays and group work; most suggestions for improvement were found in the area of structure and organisation on breaks and time management. Conclusions: Opening up an existing medical tutor qualification program to other student groups can be seen as fruitful to teach not only tutor-related aspects but also interprofessional competencies. The results demonstrate the importance of detailed planning that considers group composition and contextual conditions and provides interactive teaching methods to promote interprofessional experiences. This study offers important information about prerequisites and methodological implementation that could be important for the interprofessional redesign of existing training programs.