EIElena Ignovska

Elena Ignovska

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Elena Ignovska has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    BETWEEN THE CHILD WISH AND CHILDREN’S RIGHTS IN EUROPEAN GLOBALIZED GAMETE DONATION: FROM DIVERGENT TO CONVERGENT REGULATORY MODELS

    by Elena Ignovska

    Technological procreation has profoundly transformed the legal architecture of filiation,shifting the foundation of parenthood from genetic facts to reproductive intentions and contractualconsent. Because family law remains a matter of domestic jurisdiction, divergent national approaches have emerged. This comparative study evaluates North Macedonia, which representsa liberal legislative baseline, alongside Italy, a jurisdiction that initially enforced deep restrictions but subsequently experienced court driven liberalization.Accelerated by transnational gamete banks, cross border reproductive care has exposed deep fractures between diverse national donor anonymity regimes, displacing traditional biological and marital presumptions of parenthood. Consequently, while adult reproductive autonomy has expanded, the legal position of the newborn has become fragmented and precarious. Drawing uponEuropean Court of Human Rights jurisprudence and contemporary bioethical debates, this article argues that technological procreation has produced a structural imbalance between adult reproductive liberty and children’s independent rights to identity and genealogical integrity.Ultimately, this article contends that the law must re center the newborn as a primary bearer of rights rather than a byproduct of market transactions. It proposes a harmonized European regulatory framework featuring a unified donor registry, enforceable donation caps, and a procedural bifurcation between parentage establishment and informational identity proceedings to restore normative coherence.

  • Open Access

    FROM MANDATORY CONCILIATION TO MANDATORY MEDIATION IN FAMILY DISPUTES INVOLVING CHILDREN: NORTH MACEDONIA IN LIGHT OF EUROPEAN HUMAN RIGHTS STANDARDS

    by Elena Ignovska

    This article examines the implications of eventual mandatory mediation in family disputes involving children in North Macedonia, assessed against European human rights and children rights standards. It argues that the existing institute of (re)conciliation (мирење) is outdated and fails to meet European requirements. Introducing a mandatory mediation session in such disputes could increase mediation uptake, de-escalate conflicts, and better safeguard children’s interests. However, mandatory mediation also raises concerns regarding voluntariness, access to courts, and procedural fairness. Through a critical review of international human rights treaties and European legal instruments, alongside national regulation, including the Law on Mediation, the Law on the Family, and the family-related provisions of the Draft Civil Code, the article assesses whether mandatory mediation can effectively “revive” mediation while also advancing the best interests of the child and respecting fundamental rights more broadly.


  • Sex in recent gender policies: Interdisciplinary reflections on the X v. North Macedonia case before the ECTHR

    by Elena Ignovska, Todor Arsov

    This article was initially prompted by the inconsistent use of the terms sex and gender in the landmark case X v. the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (now Republic of North Macedonia) before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). Although the judgment was delivered several years ago, national legal implementation remains incomplete and, to some extent, problematic. This topic remains timely more broadly, given the limited engagement of English legal discourse with the ECtHR's evolving approach to gender recognition. The authors investigate why a seemingly straightforward legal adjustment, such as introducing a gender marker on birth certificates, has proven so contentious. Their inquiry revealed that the term gender, originally introduced to distinguish from sex, has been increasingly subsumed into the concept of sex, often being used interchangeably. The Court's judgment reflects this conflation: at times it refers to sex, at others to gender, and frequently to both (e.g., sex/gender) without clear differentiation. This raises critical questions, foremost among them: Why was there such a concerted effort to establish gender as distinct from sex when some of the same actors now assert that the two are effectively synonymous? While the X v. North Macedonia judgment marks a significant step in affirming transgender rights, it also exposes the ECtHR's ongoing terminological ambiguity. In the absence of clear and consistent language, and in pursuit of fulfilling human rights obligations, particularly under articles 8 and 14 of the ECtHR, a legal compromise has emerged: recognizing gender identity as a fundamental aspect of personal identity, protected under the right to respect for private life.


  • Open Access

    Mandatory Vaccination Against COVID-19 in Europe: Public Health Versus ‘Saved by the Bell’ Individual Autonomy

    by Elena Ignovska

    The text aims to reconcile the bioethical principles (autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice) (Beauchamp TL, Childress JF in Principles of biomedical ethics, 6th edn. Oxford University Press, 2009) with the principles used by legal institutions (primarily, the European Court of Human Rights) to evaluate possible human rights infringements due to mandatory vaccination against Covid-19 (legality, necessity, proportionality and legitimate aim) (This is the so-called ‘structural approach’ that the ECtHR follows when considering interferences of the qualified right and is also stipulated in article 26 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (Oviedo Convention).) by National Public Health policies of the Member States of the Council of Europe. (Even more, the idea is to bring closer the methodology of teaching/learning and researching via the HELP platform of the Council of Europe in the course on Bioethics to the law students.) The trigger is to test these principles using deductive reasoning in the pioneering Austrian case of mandatory vaccination, while inductive methodology is used to evaluate how recent similar cases (such as Vavřička and Others v. Czech Republic) contributed to support the theory that next to human rights, there are also duties. Since circumstances with the pandemic are rather turbulent and constantly changing (even as this article is being written), the time factor significantly influences the conclusions drawn. Namely, the author holds the opinion that with a carefully chosen methodology and model, any severe disease that significantly threatens the individual and public health at particular time, period or might constantly be a reason to restrict individual autonomy with scientifically proven, safe and efficient vaccines. Nevertheless, regarding Covid-19, at the current time, even if the means of coercion do not include applying direct physical force (As in the case of Vavřička or in the pioneering but suspended legislation for mandatory vaccination in Austria.), they are not proportionate to the possible infringement on one’s private life and individual consent for the sake of public health, or at least not anymore.