GOGhislain Otis

Ghislain Otis

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Ghislain Otis has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Applied Legal Pluralism

    by Ghislain Otis, Jean Leclair, Sophie Thériault

    This book offers a comparative study of the management of legal pluralism. The authors describe and analyse the way state and non-state legal systems acknowledge legal pluralism – defined as the coexistence of a state and non-state legal systems in the same space in respect of the same subject matter for the same population - and determine its consequences for their own purposes. The book sheds light on the management processes deployed by legal systems in Africa, Canada, Central Europe and the South Pacific, the multitudinous factors circumscribing the action of systems and individuals with respect to legal pluralism, and the effects of management strategies and processes on systems as well as on individuals. The book offers fresh practical and analytical insight on applied legal pluralism, a fast-growing field of scholarship and professional practice. Drawing from a wealth of original empirical data collected in several countries by a multilingual and multidisciplinary team, it provides a thorough account of the intricate patterns of state and non-state practices with respect to legal pluralism. As the book’s non-prescriptive approach helps to uncover and evaluate several biases or assumptions on the part of policy makers, scholars and development agencies regarding the nature and the consequences of legal pluralism, it will appeal to a wide range of scholars and practitioners in law, development studies, political science and social sciences.


  • The management of legal pluralism

    by Ghislain Otis

    This book was written by three jurists and is based primarily on data gathered in Africa, 1 Canada, 2 Central Europe, 3 and the South Pacific 4 by multi-disciplinary teams involved in a research partnership called “The State and Indigenous Legal Cultures: Law in Search of Legitimacy.” 5 This wide-ranging comparative research project draws on case studies to document how legal pluralism manifests itself in the regions studied and the relational dynamics that characterize the co-existence of legal systems. 6 By comparing the manifestations and the management of legal pluralism in Western States (such as Canada, France, and Romania) and Non-Western States (Burundi, Côte d’Ivoire, Solomon Islands, South Africa, and Zambia), the research teams aimed to look for a more complete understanding of how power dynamics between State and non-State legal systems shape the experience of legal plurality and determine strategies for managing (or not managing) such plurality.


  • General conclusion

    by Ghislain Otis

    The study of the broad variety of practices described in this book provides some insight into the practice of legal pluralism management and sheds new light on a few commonplace assumptions about the issues such management raises. The discussion, we believe, has helped reveal more clearly what changes follow – and perhaps even more clearly what changes do not follow – when processes are implemented to take legal plurality into account.

  • The effects of legal pluralism management

    by Ghislain Otis

    A sound understanding of the effects of legal pluralism management helps to assess the relevance or soundness of the premises that guide actors’ practices and choices. Drawing from the data gathered in all the regions studied (Africa, Canada, Central Europe, and the South Pacific), this chapter discusses the effects on legal systems and individuals of the processes deployed to manage legal pluralism (i.e., reception, withdrawal, imitation, and endogenous modulation). However, the effects of legal pluralism management can be measured only insofar as outcomes of non-management are apprehended. Thus, the author first considers the consequences of indifference between co-existing legal systems on individuals and on the systems themselves. The chief consequences on systems are competition and duplication while individuals find themselves in a complex legal landscape that can be either perilous or advantageous. Strategies of inter-systemic mobility can be devised but they are often thwarted. The author then examines the effects of management processes and strategies on both managing systems and systems of reference, as well as on individuals. He shows that while some processes lead to increased legal complexity others favour normative convergence between systems. Only withdrawal reduces competition and duplication. Individual strategic law-shopping often remains possible but may be less attractive when management processes lead to permissive or repressive convergence.

  • Processes of legal pluralism management

    by Ghislain Otis, Sophie Thériault

    This chapter identifies and characterizes the various processes through which State and non-State legal systems react to legal plurality and draw – or fail to draw – legal consequences from such plurality for their own purposes. The cases studied have made it possible to identify two broad categories of processes that legal systems use to manage legal pluralism: (1) management by articulation and (2) management by adaptation. Articulation takes place when the managing system acknowledges the existence of another system (the system of reference) and gives that other system some measure of direct legal effectivity. This category can be broken down into two main processes: articulation by reception, which happens when the articulating system receives and then manages within itself elements of another system, and articulation by withdrawal, where one system acknowledges another and stands back to allow that other system to govern a given conflict or situation. Adaptation takes place when the managing system, as a result of its contact with another system, adapts and transforms yet does not recognize the system of reference as a binding legal source of principles, rules, processes, or authority. This category also comprises two main processes which are not watertight categories: adaptation by imitation, which takes place when one system is inspired by solutions in another system and adapts them to its own legal context and culture, and adaptation by endogenous modulation, where a system comes into contact with another whose existence and actions it acknowledges, and draws on its own endogenous values, principles, and processes to adjust its own laws. Drawing examples from various case studies, this chapter will show that while some of these processes are employed by both State and non-State legal systems, others are used primarily by either one system or the other.

  • Open Access

    Les droits ancestraux des peuples autochtones n’ayant pas signé la Convention de la Baie-James : la thèse de l’extinction unilatérale à l’épreuve des droits fondamentaux

    by Ghislain Otis

    Certains peuples autochtones du Québec revendiquent des droits ancestraux sur le territoire visé par la Convention de la Baie-James et du Nord québécois alors qu’ils ne sont pas signataires de cette dernière. Or, la loi adoptée par le Parlement du Canada en 1977 pour donner effet à la Convention prétend éteindre les droits et les revendications territoriaux de « tous les Indiens et de tous les Inuit » dans le territoire « conventionné », et non seulement ceux des Cris et des Inuit qui sont parties à la Convention. Dans cet article, l’auteur évalue la conformité de cette disposition extinctive avec la Déclaration canadienne des droits. Il conclut qu’elle viole la Déclaration en privant, de manière injustifiée, les membres des peuples non signataires du droit de ne pas faire l’objet de discrimination raciale dans la jouissance de leur bien.

  • Le traitement des conflits

    by Ghislain Otis, Séverine Bellina

  • Open Access

    La production du droit autochtone : comportement, commandement, enseignement

    by Ghislain Otis

    Présentation Revue générale de droit La Revue générale de droit est la revue scientifique de la Section de droit civil de la Facult&e…