Claire Garnier
Research Subjects
Claire Garnier has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christelle Chaplais-Chouvier
Clermont School of Business
1 shared publication - Claudine Mangen
Concordia University
1 shared publication - Edwige Nortier
EMLYON
1 shared publication - Mouna Hazgui
HEC Montreal
1 shared publication Sébastien Stenger
ISG‐Institut Supérieur de Gestion Paris France
1 shared publication- Thomas J. Roulet
University of Cambridge, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 39 (6) , 1-23
Beyond the corporate ladder: rethinking promotion and departure in professional service firms
Purpose: Early departures have long characterised careers in large professional service firms (PSFs), particularly in accounting firms where high turnover among early-career professionals is common. Yet, research typically explains this turnover through burnout or the structural constraints of the up-or-out model. What remains underexplored is how this transitory nature is constructed, narrated, and made sense of by those experiencing it. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on semi-structured interviews with early-career auditors in large accounting PSFs in France, we use the concept of career scripts to examine how these professionals interpret their careers within the constraints of the up-or-out system. Findings: Participants commonly described their careers in audit as a temporary stage within a broader career trajectory, which we refer to as the “passing auditor” career script. Within this script, exit is anticipated from the outset and mobilised as a recurrent reference point in career sensemaking. Participants used this anticipated exit in three main ways: as a rationale for intensive skill development, as a resource for negotiating working conditions, and as a means of making demanding work situations more tolerable. While these uses help rationalise difficulties and allow individuals to navigate the system more flexibly, they also contribute to the reproduction of the career system by normalising departure as an expected and legitimate trajectory. Originality/value: By shifting attention from why auditors leave to how exit is anticipated and rendered meaningful over time, this study shows that departure is not simply the endpoint of a career trajectory but a constitutive horizon through which early-career professionals interpret work, effort, and future possibilities. In doing so, it reconceptualises the traditional “up-or-out” model as an “up-and-out” system in which departure is anticipated, normalised, and institutionalised as a legitimate career outcome.
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 39 (6) , 1-23
Beyond the corporate ladder: rethinking promotion and departure in professional service firms
Purpose: Early departures have long characterised careers in large professional service firms (PSFs), particularly in accounting firms where high turnover among early-career professionals is common. Yet, research typically explains this turnover through burnout or the structural constraints of the up-or-out model. What remains underexplored is how this transitory nature is constructed, narrated, and made sense of by those experiencing it. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on semi-structured interviews with early-career auditors in large accounting PSFs in France, we use the concept of career scripts to examine how these professionals interpret their careers within the constraints of the up-or-out system. Findings: Participants commonly described their careers in audit as a temporary stage within a broader career trajectory, which we refer to as the “passing auditor” career script. Within this script, exit is anticipated from the outset and mobilised as a recurrent reference point in career sensemaking. Participants used this anticipated exit in three main ways: as a rationale for intensive skill development, as a resource for negotiating working conditions, and as a means of making demanding work situations more tolerable. While these uses help rationalise difficulties and allow individuals to navigate the system more flexibly, they also contribute to the reproduction of the career system by normalising departure as an expected and legitimate trajectory. Originality/value: By shifting attention from why auditors leave to how exit is anticipated and rendered meaningful over time, this study shows that departure is not simply the endpoint of a career trajectory but a constitutive horizon through which early-career professionals interpret work, effort, and future possibilities. In doing so, it reconceptualises the traditional “up-or-out” model as an “up-and-out” system in which departure is anticipated, normalised, and institutionalised as a legitimate career outcome.
- Open Access
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 43 (1) , 370-397
Lost in Evaluation: The Intricacies of First‐ and Second‐Order Evaluations in Auditors' Promotion Committees in the Big 4 Audit Firms
The evaluation of auditors in the Big 4 audit firms has largely remained a “black box” in accounting and audit research. Little is known about how these processes operate within audit firms or how they relate to promotion decisions. This study addresses this gap by providing direct insight into promotion committee decision‐making. Drawing on the sociology of evaluation, we develop an analytical model to map this process, highlighting the role of collective deliberation, the interplay between first‐ and second‐order evaluations, and the feedback effects of evaluation. Empirically, we rely on a unique multi‐method qualitative data set that focuses on the micro‐level dynamics of auditor evaluation and promotion. Our data includes non‐participant observation of two promotion committees in the Paris office of a Big 4 firm, complemented by 61 interviews. The findings show that auditors' evaluations are not solely based on pre‐assessments made by their direct supervisors but emerge through collective negotiation. This negotiation produces second‐order judgments that determine the auditors' final rankings. In these deliberations, the supervisor's voice and the political dynamics among supervisors carry significant weight. We conclude that the evaluation process hinges less on auditors' intrinsic professional qualities than on how managers' evaluative judgments are themselves assessed. These findings generate both empirical and theoretical contributions to the literature on auditing as a profession and on social evaluation.
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 43 (1) , 370-397
Open AccessLost in Evaluation: The Intricacies of First‐ and Second‐Order Evaluations in Auditors' Promotion Committees in the Big 4 Audit Firms
The evaluation of auditors in the Big 4 audit firms has largely remained a “black box” in accounting and audit research. Little is known about how these processes operate within audit firms or how they relate to promotion decisions. This study addresses this gap by providing direct insight into promotion committee decision‐making. Drawing on the sociology of evaluation, we develop an analytical model to map this process, highlighting the role of collective deliberation, the interplay between first‐ and second‐order evaluations, and the feedback effects of evaluation. Empirically, we rely on a unique multi‐method qualitative data set that focuses on the micro‐level dynamics of auditor evaluation and promotion. Our data includes non‐participant observation of two promotion committees in the Paris office of a Big 4 firm, complemented by 61 interviews. The findings show that auditors' evaluations are not solely based on pre‐assessments made by their direct supervisors but emerge through collective negotiation. This negotiation produces second‐order judgments that determine the auditors' final rankings. In these deliberations, the supervisor's voice and the political dynamics among supervisors carry significant weight. We conclude that the evaluation process hinges less on auditors' intrinsic professional qualities than on how managers' evaluative judgments are themselves assessed. These findings generate both empirical and theoretical contributions to the literature on auditing as a profession and on social evaluation.
- Open Access
- 16 February 2024
- Published by American Accounting Association in Accounting Horizons
- Vol. 38 (1) , 79-93
Men’s Experiences of Paternity Leaves in Accounting Firms
SYNOPSIS: Accounting researchers and practitioners have made strides in addressing persistent gender inequalities in the accounting profession. However, these efforts have largely sidestepped men and masculinities. Our study considers the role of men and masculinities in gender inequalities by exploring how men in accounting experience paternity leaves. We conduct interviews with 13 men in audit firms in France. We find that fathers are reluctant to take leaves, which they view as vacation periods incompatible with their professional work. They see audit firms as offering less support to fathers than mothers, with support for fathers growing but still marginal. Finally, they experience a variety of emotions, including positive emotions around fatherhood and negative emotions around difficulties in reconciling fatherhood with professional responsibilities and paternity leaves. Practically, our findings imply that to address gender inequalities further, accounting firms need to change the norms around care work, including paternity leaves.
- 16 February 2024
- Published by American Accounting Association in Accounting Horizons
- Vol. 38 (1) , 79-93
Open AccessMen’s Experiences of Paternity Leaves in Accounting Firms
SYNOPSIS: Accounting researchers and practitioners have made strides in addressing persistent gender inequalities in the accounting profession. However, these efforts have largely sidestepped men and masculinities. Our study considers the role of men and masculinities in gender inequalities by exploring how men in accounting experience paternity leaves. We conduct interviews with 13 men in audit firms in France. We find that fathers are reluctant to take leaves, which they view as vacation periods incompatible with their professional work. They see audit firms as offering less support to fathers than mothers, with support for fathers growing but still marginal. Finally, they experience a variety of emotions, including positive emotions around fatherhood and negative emotions around difficulties in reconciling fatherhood with professional responsibilities and paternity leaves. Practically, our findings imply that to address gender inequalities further, accounting firms need to change the norms around care work, including paternity leaves.
- 1 September 2016
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Health History
- Vol. 33 (2) , 561-563
L'Hôtel-Dieu de Clermont-Ferrand, histoire d'un établissement hospitalier par Bernard Dompnier (dir.)
- 1 September 2016
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Health History
- Vol. 33 (2) , 561-563
L'Hôtel-Dieu de Clermont-Ferrand, histoire d'un établissement hospitalier par Bernard Dompnier (dir.)