SSScott Smalley

Scott Smalley

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Scott Smalley has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Guiding Professional Development Through Perceived Barriers, Motivation, and Attitudes in Biotechnology Education

    by Stacie Turnbull, Scott Smalley, Joe Ramstad

    With recent advancements in science and technology inside and outside of the agriculture industry, biotechnology is becoming an increasingly relevant topic within school-based agricultural education (SBAE). The purpose of this study was to explore SBAE teachers’ background in teaching biotechnology concepts, their professional experiences within biotechnology, and their motivation and perceived barriers to including biotechnology concepts within their curriculum. We utilized a case study approach, treating the individual perspectives and ideas shared by participants as their own individualized cases. A total of 12 semi-structured, one-on-one interviews were scheduled. Data were analyzed using open coding, and generated six overarching themes. Participating educators possessed working knowledge and were able to discuss connections between key biotechnology terms, including genetic engineering and transgenic, and spoke fondly of any professional development experiences they were able to engage in, such as courses, CASE training, workshops offered by NAAE, and more. Despite training and resources available to them, some educators do not implement biotechnology into their curriculum; teachers reported barriers including limited time, knowledge, and funding to implement biotechnology within their curriculum. However, despite these barriers, educators shared great enthusiasm and success in implementing biotechnology, recognizing biotechnology helps students advance their career skills, along with their ability to be well-informed and agriculturally-literate consumers. It is recommended that professional development resources and curriculum continue to be developed to support agricultural educators in implementing biotechnology within the classroom, and that further research addresses the barriers to teachers attending and engaging in these professional development experiences.

  • Attitudes Toward Biotechnology: Snapshot of Professional Development, Barriers, and Motivation in Agricultural Education

    by Stacie Turnbull, Scott Smalley, Joe Ramstad

    With the anticipated surge in the global population over the next 25 years and beyond, there is a significant need for agriculturalists to produce more using less. Biotechnology is one way we can ensure that the ever-growing population will continue to be sustained in satisfying global food, fiber, and fuel demands. However, in order to enter careers in this career area, and be aware of these innovative technologies so that consumers of today and tomorrow can make informed decisions, education about biotechnology is essential. The purpose of this study was to review teachers’ confidence level in teaching biotechnology concepts, professional development activities, motivation to teach the concepts, and perception of available resources. The study was conducted utilizing a quantitative instrument administered to a group of 74 agricultural educators representing 19 states, who indicated interest in teaching biotechnology, or participation in biotechnology professional development experiences. Findings revealed teachers’ strong desire to incorporate additional biotechnology-centered activities into curriculum, but barriers such as cost, lack of supplies, or lack of general biotechnology knowledge needed to facilitate biotechnology learning experiences pose concerns. To address this, additional research should be done investigating what types of professional development experiences might best serve agricultural educators as they teach students about biotechnology. This research could examine professional development needs, structure, and delivery style that is most conducive to educators. These low-cost and engaging professional development experiences can then be developed and provided to agricultural educators to increase their confidence in developing and delivering biotechnology curriculum for their students.

  • Evaluating Retention Factors of Teachers Implementing CASE Curriculum in Agricultural Education Programs

    by Scott Smalley, Amber H. Rice, Joe Ramstad

    Across the United States, there continues to be a significant shortage of agricultural educators. As a result, retaining quality and qualified agricultural educators is an urgent need. The Curriculum for Agricultural Science Education (CASE) provides agricultural educators the opportunity to earn curriculum certification in a range of agriculturally focused content areas. Teachers can receive training and access to teaching materials and resources to implement the CASE curriculum within their agricultural education programs, providing students with rich, inquiry-based learning experiences. The purpose of this study was to determine if there is a connection between SBAE teachers’ earning of at least one CASE certification and their reports of satisfying a multitude of retention factors within the school-based agricultural education (SBAE) profession. As such, this study examined perceptions associated with CASE implementation, which connect to retention factors, as opposed to causal effects on retention in and of itself. All CASE-certified educators were emailed a questionnaire via Qualtrics. Results indicated that teachers’ implementation of CASE resulted in several beneficial factors that can assist in retaining teachers, including improved work-life balance, greater comfort with implementing new teaching methodologies, and enhanced teacher networking. Results also revealed barriers that CASE can address to strengthen the CASE curriculum and better assist educators. Future research should explore the impact of the CASE curriculum on teachers’ work-life balance, perceived teaching ability, and facilitating quality inquiry-based learning experiences for students.

  • Determining the Antecedents of Preparation of SBAE Teachers Who Effectively Facilitate Learning in SBAE Laboratories

    by Kevin Sanders, Mark Hainline, Scott Smalley, Joe Ramstad

    The purpose of this qualitative study was to discover how expert school-based agricultural education (SBAE) teachers describe the experiences which best prepared them to have the ability to teach, manage, and facilitate learning activities in agricultural education laboratories. SBAE teachers teach technical skills and how to safely and properly use equipment associated with those skills, such as electrical, welding, woodworking, greenhouse watering and heating systems, aquaculture systems, and agricultural mechanics. All of these skills are demonstrated, practiced, and are mastered in agricultural education laboratories. Perhaps adequate training of pre-service SBAE teachers, particularly in the most common laboratories such as greenhouses, agricultural mechanics labs, carpentry labs, and welding laboratories would help mitigate the growing SBAE teacher attrition rate and ensure that proper laboratory teaching techniques and management is implemented. The teachers participating in this study had an average of 13.4 (σ = 8.5) years of teaching experience in laboratories. After conducting interviews with all teachers, two themes that emerged from this study, (1) teachers accredited their ability to teach in SBAE laboratories to experiences in informal settings, and (2) teachers accredited their ability to teach in SBAE laboratories to experiences in formal settings. The four supporting four sub-themes were mentorship, secondary agricultural education experiences, underprepared for laboratory instruction, and desire for additional training. Based on this study’s findings, it is recommended beginning teachers be placed with a mentor, and an increase in laboratory training be required for pre-service SBAE teachers.

  • Exploring the Use of Competition in School-Based Agricultural Education Classrooms: An Explanatory Sequential Mixed Methods Study

    by Joe Ramstad, Scott Smalley

    School-based agricultural education (SBAE) has been home to countless competitive events for nearly 100 years. Oftentimes, when teachers and stakeholders think about competitions, they think about competitions in FFA and SAE, rather than a classroom environment. However, competition is a teaching tool which offers connection and encouragement for students to engage in FFA and SAE competitions outside of the classroom. The purpose of this explanatory sequential mixed methods study was to explore factors which influence SBAE teachers’ ability to utilize competition within their classrooms through the lens of the pedagogical design capacity framework. To fulfill this purpose, 191 SABE teachers completed a questionnaire; data analysis occurred using descriptive and inferential statistics. After quantitative analysis, an interview guide was developed; 16 questionnaire respondents were invited to engage in a follow-up interview and submit artifacts including competition-based activities and lesson plans, providing evidence of competition within their classroom. Quantitative findings suggested teachers enjoy facilitating competition, though they may lack the training, background, or curricular and physical resources to do so effectively. While interview participants tended to consider themselves as competitive, and facilitate classroom competition at least on a monthly basis, their rationale and approaches for implementing competition varied; including preparing students for FFA events or life after high school, a desire to engage students in exciting ways, and a desire to improve their teaching practice. Based on these findings, we recommend the development of additional training and ready-to-use.

  • Open Access

    Beginning Agricultural Education Instructor Perceived Benefit of Professional Development Experiences

    by Melanie Bloom, John Tummons, Scott Smalley, Joe Ramstad

    Agricultural education instructors in the first through fifth years of experience benefit from professional development experiences tailored to individual needs. Professional development is one way we can support beginning agricultural education teachers through increasing their confidence and reducing the attrition rate and burnout. This quantitative study was guided by Mezirow’s transformative learning theory, which frames learning in adulthood as a transformative, as opposed to a functional, process. The purpose of this study was to identify the extent to which differences in the perceived positive benefit of professional development experiences of beginning agricultural education instructors can be explained by differences in gender and CASE certification. The researchers distributed an instrument to the target population and collected usable responses from 126 beginning agricultural education teachers from four Midwestern states. The most impactful professional development opportunities identified by beginning agricultural education instructors were CASE institutes and student teaching feedback. An Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) procedure was utilized to identify if any significant differences in professional development preferences can be explained by gender, CASE certification, or the interaction of gender and CASE certification, but there were no significant differences found. Based on the findings of this study, future research should seek to determine beginning teachers’ motivation for taking advantage of professional development experiences and seek to determine how beginning teachers determine the impact of various professional development experiences on their careers.

  • Maintaining a Marathon Mindset: Iowa Agricultural Education Teachers’ Implementation of the SAE for All Framework Following a Yearlong Professional Development Experience

    by Joe Ramstad, Scott Smalley

    A supervised agricultural experience (SAE) program provides the opportunity for agricultural education students to apply their classroom and leadership experiences to a real-world, contextualized setting. In 2015, the National Council for Agricultural Education developed the SAE for All initiative to encourage all students to develop and maintain a quality SAE program. Since SAE for All is a newer initiative, training on how to facilitate effective SAE for All is beginning to emerge for states and agricultural educators to take advantage of. The purpose of this study was to examine the successes, barriers, and impacts of SAE for All implementation among six Iowa educators who participated in a yearlong SAE for All professional development experience in a cohort model. Iowa is among one of the first states to implement SAE for All professional development experiences for agricultural educators on a state-level. This qualitative study utilized a case study approach, where artifact submission and Zoom interviews were conducted, collected, transcribed, and coded. Findings revealed grading, the use of class time, and student mentorship as key implementation strategies, while a lack of overall teacher knowledge or confidence, limited time to coordinate SAE for All efforts, and challenges with student buy-in were the most pressing barriers. However, teachers reported positive impacts of SAE for All implementation within themselves, and within their programs. As additional states begin SAE for All implementation, resource development should be prioritized to address barriers that emerge so all agricultural education can engage in real-world, contextualized experiential learning through a SAE.


  • Determining the Effectiveness of CASE Professional Development for CASE-certified Agricultural Education Teachers

    by Anna Bowser, Scott Smalley, Joe Ramstad

    The researchers analyzed the traditional Curriculum for Agricultural Science Education (CASE) Institute professional development (PD) program as professional development can change teacher practice and improve student achievement. Researchers used the Garet et al. study which outlined the relationship between the six effective features of professional development and teacher outcome as a framework to analyze the traditional CASE Institute professional development courses. Participants who were certified in a traditional CASE Institute professional development course were surveyed, and their responses were analyzed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) to determine the mean and standard deviation of the data related to the assessment of CASE professional development and the assessment of CASE lead teachers. These data were used to determine the effectiveness of the CASE professional development program. Their responses illustrated the effectiveness of CASE as they had a firm understanding of the material and CASE model, the comfortability of implementing the learned material in their classroom, and the effectiveness of their lead teachers based on their teaching abilities. The researchers also concluded that three of the six effective features of professional development examined in this study had a positive relationship between the features of the professional development and the participants’ responses. From the findings of this study, researchers created a list of recommendations and future research that should occur to bolster CASE Institute professional development courses and curriculum further.


  • Open Access

    Building the House: Agricultural Educators’ Perceptions of Planning and Managing Agricultural Education Facilities

    by Joe Ramstad, Scott Smalley

    Facilities are a critical component of an agricultural education program. Yet, there has been limited research done on agricultural educators’ perceptions of facilities, especially since the facilities and resources of every agricultural education program can be highly variable. The purpose of this study was to understand the participants’ perceptions of agricultural education facilities for both secondary and post-secondary agricultural education. A series of individual interviews were conducted among a group of certified agricultural education teachers at both the secondary and post-secondary level in Minnesota. The findings revealed: 1) the importance for support from key partners, such as advisory boards and community businesses, 2) the need for additional training for both in-service and pre-service teachers to better understand how to effectively plan and utilize facilities, and 3) the need for facility upgrades and maintenance to ensure student safety and preparation for the agriculture, food, and natural resource workforce. Additional research is recommended to better understand participants’ perceptions of facilities in both secondary and post-secondary teacher preparation programs, which can lead to additional professional development or the creation of helpful resource guides to inform educators or administrators about agricultural education facility design and management.

  • Defining Fidelity in the Curriculum for Agricultural Science Education (CASE)

    by Scott Smalley, Mark S. Hainline, Joe Ramstad

    The purpose of the study was to explore the definition of fidelity in the delivery of the Curriculum for Agricultural Science Education (CASE). The conceptual framework utilized in this study was the key domains affecting curriculum fidelity. This framework has four parts focusing on (1) school context, (2) curriculum implementation systems, (3) curriculum implementers, and (4) audiences targeted. To address the research objectives of this study, a basic qualitative approach was used. Each participant represented a different state and were made up of teacher educators, high school educators, and state leaders for agricultural education. The participants were or previously had been high school agricultural educators. Several benefits of the CASE curriculum were identified by the participants of this study. The benefits identified included inquiry-based learning, resources for educators, and assistance for beginning or novice educators. Participants believed the curriculum was beneficial to agricultural educators no matter if they were beginning their careers or are established professionals. Future research should focus on how the lead teachers view the delivery of the CASE curriculum and to what level the curriculum needs to be delivered to reach teaching it with fidelity.