Stephen F. Spear
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Stephen F. Spear has a total of 55 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David S. Pilliod
U.S. Geological Survey Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center Boise Idaho USA
3 shared publications - Yer Lor
U.S. Geological Survey, Upper Midwest Environmental Sciences Center
3 shared publications - Adam J. Sepulveda
U.S. Geological Survey Northern Rocky Mountain Science Center Bozeman Montana USA
2 shared publications - Christopher M. Merkes
U.S. Geological Survey Upper Midwest Environmental Sciences Center La Crosse Wisconsin USA
2 shared publications - Devin N. Jones
U.S. Geological Survey Northern Rocky Mountain Science Center Bozeman Montana USA
2 shared publications - Katy E. Klymus
U.S. Geological Survey, Columbia Environmental Research Center
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 36 (5) , e70290
Accounting for temporal variation and correlation in environmental DNA sampling can improve ecological inferences
Environmental DNA (eDNA) concentration varies through space and time, and measurements collected close together are often correlated. Ignoring this dependence can inflate the rate of incorrect ecological inferences (Type I error rate). Although spatial correlation in eDNA has received considerable attention, temporal correlation has been less well studied. Statistical models and study designs that account for temporal correlation are increasingly important to understand time‐dependent effects in complex systems. We developed a hierarchical model that separates temporal ecological variation from variability stemming from sampling and laboratory processes and applied it to four single‐site eDNA time series collected over 17–24 days, three of which provided sufficient information for parameter estimation. We then used the empirically estimated parameter magnitudes in a simulation study to evaluate alternative temporal sampling designs that considered (1) how a fixed number of samples are allocated across different numbers of sampling times with different levels of temporal replication and (2) equally spaced versus cluster‐spaced sampling (short bursts separated by longer gaps). Across the three time series sufficient for analysis, we observed substantial sampling variability, temporal variability, and temporal correlation, although correlation was estimated imprecisely (large coefficient of variation). Simulations showed that when sampling intervals were shorter than the effective temporal correlation range, models that ignored temporal dependence produced inflated Type I error rates and frequently detected spurious temporal trends. Accounting for temporal correlation substantially reduced this inflated Type I error rate. Optimal sampling strategies depended on study objectives. Clustered sampling most effectively estimated temporal correlation. When temporal dependence was negligible, evenly spaced sampling maximized power to detect trends. Estimating sampling variability required concentrating effort into fewer sampling times with more replicates per time, whereas estimating temporal variance was most precise with intermediate levels of replication. Together, these results indicate that temporal dependence can strongly affect inference from quantitative eDNA time series when sampling intervals approach the correlation timescale. Designs that ignore this dependence risk inferring ecological change or difference where none exists. Our framework provides practical guidance for allocating sampling effort in temporally intensive eDNA monitoring and for interpreting trends from short time series.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 36 (5) , e70290
Open AccessAccounting for temporal variation and correlation in environmental DNA sampling can improve ecological inferences
Environmental DNA (eDNA) concentration varies through space and time, and measurements collected close together are often correlated. Ignoring this dependence can inflate the rate of incorrect ecological inferences (Type I error rate). Although spatial correlation in eDNA has received considerable attention, temporal correlation has been less well studied. Statistical models and study designs that account for temporal correlation are increasingly important to understand time‐dependent effects in complex systems. We developed a hierarchical model that separates temporal ecological variation from variability stemming from sampling and laboratory processes and applied it to four single‐site eDNA time series collected over 17–24 days, three of which provided sufficient information for parameter estimation. We then used the empirically estimated parameter magnitudes in a simulation study to evaluate alternative temporal sampling designs that considered (1) how a fixed number of samples are allocated across different numbers of sampling times with different levels of temporal replication and (2) equally spaced versus cluster‐spaced sampling (short bursts separated by longer gaps). Across the three time series sufficient for analysis, we observed substantial sampling variability, temporal variability, and temporal correlation, although correlation was estimated imprecisely (large coefficient of variation). Simulations showed that when sampling intervals were shorter than the effective temporal correlation range, models that ignored temporal dependence produced inflated Type I error rates and frequently detected spurious temporal trends. Accounting for temporal correlation substantially reduced this inflated Type I error rate. Optimal sampling strategies depended on study objectives. Clustered sampling most effectively estimated temporal correlation. When temporal dependence was negligible, evenly spaced sampling maximized power to detect trends. Estimating sampling variability required concentrating effort into fewer sampling times with more replicates per time, whereas estimating temporal variance was most precise with intermediate levels of replication. Together, these results indicate that temporal dependence can strongly affect inference from quantitative eDNA time series when sampling intervals approach the correlation timescale. Designs that ignore this dependence risk inferring ecological change or difference where none exists. Our framework provides practical guidance for allocating sampling effort in temporally intensive eDNA monitoring and for interpreting trends from short time series.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Genome
- Vol. 69, 1-13
Detecting bumble bees in the wild using environmental DNA: development and validation of a qPCR assay for the endangered Franklin’s bumble bee ( Bombus franklini )
Environmental DNA (eDNA) sampling is a noninvasive alternative to conventional methods of surveying insects that may be particularly useful for detecting pollinators. We developed a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) assay to detect the DNA of Franklin’s bumble bee (Bombus franklini) from flower samples and conducted an initial test of the assay using samples collected within and around the historical range of the species. We further analyzed all samples using metabarcoding. Our qPCR assay successfully amplified B. franklini DNA and exhibited no cross-reactivity with nontarget bumble bee DNA during in silico and in vitro testing. We did not detect B. franklini DNA from field-collected flower samples using either qPCR or metabarcoding. However, metabarcoding analysis revealed DNA of at least 16 other bumble bee species. This finding underscores the potential utility of eDNA sampling for surveying bumble bees. Nondetection of B. franklini from field-collected flower samples may be due to the extreme rarity of the species; B. franklini is endangered and has not been observed in the wild since 2006. Our B. franklini assay is among the first bee-specific qPCR assays ever developed and provides proof of concept for additional assays that may improve detection rates of rare and endangered bees.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Genome
- Vol. 69, 1-13
Open AccessDetecting bumble bees in the wild using environmental DNA: development and validation of a qPCR assay for the endangered Franklin’s bumble bee ( Bombus franklini )
Environmental DNA (eDNA) sampling is a noninvasive alternative to conventional methods of surveying insects that may be particularly useful for detecting pollinators. We developed a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) assay to detect the DNA of Franklin’s bumble bee (Bombus franklini) from flower samples and conducted an initial test of the assay using samples collected within and around the historical range of the species. We further analyzed all samples using metabarcoding. Our qPCR assay successfully amplified B. franklini DNA and exhibited no cross-reactivity with nontarget bumble bee DNA during in silico and in vitro testing. We did not detect B. franklini DNA from field-collected flower samples using either qPCR or metabarcoding. However, metabarcoding analysis revealed DNA of at least 16 other bumble bee species. This finding underscores the potential utility of eDNA sampling for surveying bumble bees. Nondetection of B. franklini from field-collected flower samples may be due to the extreme rarity of the species; B. franklini is endangered and has not been observed in the wild since 2006. Our B. franklini assay is among the first bee-specific qPCR assays ever developed and provides proof of concept for additional assays that may improve detection rates of rare and endangered bees.
- 4 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Wildlife Management
- Vol. 89 (8)
Placing environmental DNA monitoring for new detections into perspective: Fishes in the Milwaukee River, Wisconsin
Invasive species management frameworks, such as the early detection of and rapid response to invasive species, use monitoring programs to detect new species occurrences. Resource managers use environmental DNA (eDNA) as one tool for these monitoring programs. An eDNA detection in a new location may lack perspective for resource managers and researchers because of the rarity of potential invaders and the randomness in their dispersal and detection. An example monitoring program is the eDNA‐based sampling approach used by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service for bigheaded carps Hypophthalmichthys spp. in the upper Mississippi River and Great Lakes Basins that collects hundreds of water samples per event. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service detected a single positive sample for Bighead Carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis during the spring 2021 sampling event in the Kinnickinnic River within the Milwaukee River Basin, and detected a second single positive sample for bigheaded carps during the fall 2021 sampling event in the Milwaukee River. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service did not detect any bigheaded carps in previous years (2015 to 2020) or in either the spring or fall 2022 sampling events. These detections lacked perspective, such as detection numbers for other species. We reanalyzed the 2021 and 2022 samples for four existing species of fish: two fairly common species (Common Carp Cyprinus carpio and Gizzard Shad Dorosoma cepedianum ) and two fairly rare species (Burbot Lota lota and Grass Carp Ctenopharyngodon idella ). We detected Common Carp during all four sampling events, Gizzard Shad during three of four sampling events, and Burbot and Grass Carp during two of four sampling events. These results demonstrated that current sampling efforts could detect other species, and bigheaded carp eDNA was not common in the Milwaukee River compared to these species. More specifically, this finding indicates bigheaded carp eDNA detections are as rare as, or rarer than, Grass Carp eDNA detections, a recent invader to the basin. Our findings also demonstrated how reanalyzing eDNA samples after positive detections for targeted species can help managers understand the context of the detections and provide perspective for the relative abundance of the targeted species. Additionally, our results highlight the importance of completing long‐term eDNA‐based monitoring rather than a single sampling or inventory event. These detections may have been missed in a single year or sampling event, whereas a multiyear monitoring program provides an opportunity to observe trends through time.
- 4 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Wildlife Management
- Vol. 89 (8)
Placing environmental DNA monitoring for new detections into perspective: Fishes in the Milwaukee River, Wisconsin
Invasive species management frameworks, such as the early detection of and rapid response to invasive species, use monitoring programs to detect new species occurrences. Resource managers use environmental DNA (eDNA) as one tool for these monitoring programs. An eDNA detection in a new location may lack perspective for resource managers and researchers because of the rarity of potential invaders and the randomness in their dispersal and detection. An example monitoring program is the eDNA‐based sampling approach used by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service for bigheaded carps Hypophthalmichthys spp. in the upper Mississippi River and Great Lakes Basins that collects hundreds of water samples per event. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service detected a single positive sample for Bighead Carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis during the spring 2021 sampling event in the Kinnickinnic River within the Milwaukee River Basin, and detected a second single positive sample for bigheaded carps during the fall 2021 sampling event in the Milwaukee River. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service did not detect any bigheaded carps in previous years (2015 to 2020) or in either the spring or fall 2022 sampling events. These detections lacked perspective, such as detection numbers for other species. We reanalyzed the 2021 and 2022 samples for four existing species of fish: two fairly common species (Common Carp Cyprinus carpio and Gizzard Shad Dorosoma cepedianum ) and two fairly rare species (Burbot Lota lota and Grass Carp Ctenopharyngodon idella ). We detected Common Carp during all four sampling events, Gizzard Shad during three of four sampling events, and Burbot and Grass Carp during two of four sampling events. These results demonstrated that current sampling efforts could detect other species, and bigheaded carp eDNA was not common in the Milwaukee River compared to these species. More specifically, this finding indicates bigheaded carp eDNA detections are as rare as, or rarer than, Grass Carp eDNA detections, a recent invader to the basin. Our findings also demonstrated how reanalyzing eDNA samples after positive detections for targeted species can help managers understand the context of the detections and provide perspective for the relative abundance of the targeted species. Additionally, our results highlight the importance of completing long‐term eDNA‐based monitoring rather than a single sampling or inventory event. These detections may have been missed in a single year or sampling event, whereas a multiyear monitoring program provides an opportunity to observe trends through time.
- Open Access
- 22 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Global Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 62
A 21st Century butterfly net: using eDNA to detect the imperiled Dakota skipper
- 22 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Global Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 62
Open AccessA 21st Century butterfly net: using eDNA to detect the imperiled Dakota skipper
- Open Access
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 7 (4)
Evaluation of Rapid DNA Extraction Methods to Better Enable Point‐of‐Use Environmental DNA Detection
Recent developments in molecular testing have created the opportunity for biologists and managers to detect environmental DNA (eDNA) of target species rapidly and without the requirement of a laboratory. These point‐of‐use protocols may be especially useful for early detection and rapid response for invasive species or surveillance for at‐risk native species, where timely management decisions are critical. Point‐of‐use eDNA protocols also facilitate wider and less expensive implementation of eDNA methods. One of the key components to an effective point‐of‐use protocol is a rapid DNA extraction method. Several rapid extraction protocols are suitable for implementation in the field, but information regarding their relative effectiveness is lacking. We evaluated extraction efficiency of four DNA rapid extraction protocols using filters spiked with primary cultured grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) gill cells. The extraction methods included two syringe‐based column extractions, a lysis and extraction solution, and a divalent cation chelation resin (Chelex) extraction protocol alongside a laboratory‐based control kit. We estimated DNA yield using a newly designed quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) assay targeting the grass carp nuclear genome. We evaluated two additional factors, filter type (mixed cellulose ester [MCE] and polyethersulfone [PES]) and background eDNA source (aquaculture or river). The lysis and extraction solution and Chelex extraction both had the highest overall yield, with MCE filters further increasing Chelex yield while the enzyme extraction yield was dependent on interaction with both filter and eDNA source. Our results indicate that rapid extraction protocols, such as solutions with short heating steps, are effective for DNA isolation and help to increase the overall accessibility of eDNA analyses.
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 7 (4)
Open AccessEvaluation of Rapid DNA Extraction Methods to Better Enable Point‐of‐Use Environmental DNA Detection
Recent developments in molecular testing have created the opportunity for biologists and managers to detect environmental DNA (eDNA) of target species rapidly and without the requirement of a laboratory. These point‐of‐use protocols may be especially useful for early detection and rapid response for invasive species or surveillance for at‐risk native species, where timely management decisions are critical. Point‐of‐use eDNA protocols also facilitate wider and less expensive implementation of eDNA methods. One of the key components to an effective point‐of‐use protocol is a rapid DNA extraction method. Several rapid extraction protocols are suitable for implementation in the field, but information regarding their relative effectiveness is lacking. We evaluated extraction efficiency of four DNA rapid extraction protocols using filters spiked with primary cultured grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) gill cells. The extraction methods included two syringe‐based column extractions, a lysis and extraction solution, and a divalent cation chelation resin (Chelex) extraction protocol alongside a laboratory‐based control kit. We estimated DNA yield using a newly designed quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) assay targeting the grass carp nuclear genome. We evaluated two additional factors, filter type (mixed cellulose ester [MCE] and polyethersulfone [PES]) and background eDNA source (aquaculture or river). The lysis and extraction solution and Chelex extraction both had the highest overall yield, with MCE filters further increasing Chelex yield while the enzyme extraction yield was dependent on interaction with both filter and eDNA source. Our results indicate that rapid extraction protocols, such as solutions with short heating steps, are effective for DNA isolation and help to increase the overall accessibility of eDNA analyses.
- Open Access
- 30 December 2024
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Metabarcoding and Metagenomics
- Vol. 8, e128689-518
The MIEM guidelines: Minimum information for reporting of environmental metabarcoding data
Environmental DNA (eDNA) and RNA (eRNA) metabarcoding has become a popular tool for assessing biodiversity from environmental samples, but inconsistent documentation of methods, data and metadata makes results difficult to reproduce and synthesise. A working group of scientists have collaborated to produce a set of minimum reporting guidelines for the constituent steps of metabarcoding workflows, from the physical layout of laboratories through to data archiving. We emphasise how reporting the suite of data and metadata should adhere to findable, accessible, interoperable and reproducible (FAIR) data standards, thereby providing context for evaluating and understanding study results. An overview of the documentation considerations for each workflow step is presented and then summarised in a checklist that can accompany a published study or report. Ensuring workflows are transparent and documented is critical to reproducible research and should allow for more efficient uptake of metabarcoding data into management decision-making.
- 30 December 2024
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Metabarcoding and Metagenomics
- Vol. 8, e128689-518
Open AccessThe MIEM guidelines: Minimum information for reporting of environmental metabarcoding data
Environmental DNA (eDNA) and RNA (eRNA) metabarcoding has become a popular tool for assessing biodiversity from environmental samples, but inconsistent documentation of methods, data and metadata makes results difficult to reproduce and synthesise. A working group of scientists have collaborated to produce a set of minimum reporting guidelines for the constituent steps of metabarcoding workflows, from the physical layout of laboratories through to data archiving. We emphasise how reporting the suite of data and metadata should adhere to findable, accessible, interoperable and reproducible (FAIR) data standards, thereby providing context for evaluating and understanding study results. An overview of the documentation considerations for each workflow step is presented and then summarised in a checklist that can accompany a published study or report. Ensuring workflows are transparent and documented is critical to reproducible research and should allow for more efficient uptake of metabarcoding data into management decision-making.
- Open Access
- 7 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (6) , 1148-1162
Dead‐end hollow fiber ultrafiltration capture of environmental DNA for freshwater mussel (Unionidae) species detection with metabarcoding
Insufficient water sample volumes can be a limiting factor for detecting species with environmental DNA (eDNA) from aquatic habitats. We compared detections of freshwater mussel (Unionidae) communities using large water sample volumes and dead‐end hollow fiber ultrafiltration (D‐HFUF or DEUF) with traditional eDNA filtration methods that use relatively small water sample volumes. Unionid species were detected in approximately 50‐L D‐HFUF eDNA samples with two mitochondrial DNA metabarcoding markers (COI and ND1) and compared to species detection results from eDNA captured from commonly used 1‐L samples filtered with polyethersulfone (PES) filters at three lotic sites in Georgia and Missouri. Of the 431,560 COI and 1,035,472 ND1 reads from all environmental samples of both filter types that passed quality control, 95% (410,755 reads) of COI reads and 85% (883,472 reads) of ND1 reads were assigned to a unionid species. Nineteen different freshwater mussel species were detected across all D‐HFUF samples, and 11 species were detected across all PES samples. Reads assigned to the genus Elliptio could not be resolved beyond the genus level with either marker. From D‐HFUF samples, 15 and 16 mussel species were detected with the COI and ND1 markers, respectively. From PES samples, nine and seven species were detected with the COI and ND1 markers, respectively. More mussel species were detected at each site in D‐HFUF samples than in PES samples regardless of whether results from both markers were combined or evaluated separately. Our results demonstrate the merit of further exploration and optimization of D‐HFUF for capturing eDNA from high‐volume water samples to facilitate detection of unionids and likely other aquatic organisms.
- 7 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (6) , 1148-1162
Open AccessDead‐end hollow fiber ultrafiltration capture of environmental DNA for freshwater mussel (Unionidae) species detection with metabarcoding
Insufficient water sample volumes can be a limiting factor for detecting species with environmental DNA (eDNA) from aquatic habitats. We compared detections of freshwater mussel (Unionidae) communities using large water sample volumes and dead‐end hollow fiber ultrafiltration (D‐HFUF or DEUF) with traditional eDNA filtration methods that use relatively small water sample volumes. Unionid species were detected in approximately 50‐L D‐HFUF eDNA samples with two mitochondrial DNA metabarcoding markers (COI and ND1) and compared to species detection results from eDNA captured from commonly used 1‐L samples filtered with polyethersulfone (PES) filters at three lotic sites in Georgia and Missouri. Of the 431,560 COI and 1,035,472 ND1 reads from all environmental samples of both filter types that passed quality control, 95% (410,755 reads) of COI reads and 85% (883,472 reads) of ND1 reads were assigned to a unionid species. Nineteen different freshwater mussel species were detected across all D‐HFUF samples, and 11 species were detected across all PES samples. Reads assigned to the genus Elliptio could not be resolved beyond the genus level with either marker. From D‐HFUF samples, 15 and 16 mussel species were detected with the COI and ND1 markers, respectively. From PES samples, nine and seven species were detected with the COI and ND1 markers, respectively. More mussel species were detected at each site in D‐HFUF samples than in PES samples regardless of whether results from both markers were combined or evaluated separately. Our results demonstrate the merit of further exploration and optimization of D‐HFUF for capturing eDNA from high‐volume water samples to facilitate detection of unionids and likely other aquatic organisms.