Nasir I. Bhatti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Nasir I. Bhatti has a total of 83 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Kulsoom Laeeq
Department of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A.
13 shared publicationsCharles W. Cummings
Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A.
9 shared publicationsDavid A. Diaz Voss Varela
Department of Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery Johns Hopkins University Baltimore Maryland U.S.A.
9 shared publicationsMohammad U. Malik
Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery Johns Hopkins University Baltimore Maryland U.S.A
8 shared publicationsVinciya Pandian
Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A.
8 shared publicationsHoward W. Francis
Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine Baltimore Maryland U.S.A
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 3 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 135 (3) , 1046-1053
Development of Machine Learning Copilot to Assist Novices in Learning Flexible Laryngoscopy
Objectives: Here we describe the development and pilot testing of the first artificial intelligence (AI) software “copilot” to help train novices to competently perform flexible fiberoptic laryngoscopy (FFL) on a mannikin and improve their uptake of FFL skills.Methods: Supervised machine learning was used to develop an image classifier model, dubbed the “anatomical region classifier,” responsible for predicting the location of camera in the upper aerodigestive tract and an object detection model, dubbed the “anatomical structure detector,” responsible for locating and identifying key anatomical structures in images. Training data were collected by performing FFL on an AirSim Combo Bronchi X mannikin (United Kingdom, TruCorp Ltd) using an Ambu aScope 4 RhinoLaryngo Slim connected to an Ambu® aView™ 2 Advance Displaying Unit (Ballerup, Ambu A/S). Medical students were prospectively recruited to try the FFL copilot and rate its ease of use and self‐rate their skills with and without the copilot.Results: This model classified anatomical regions with an overall accuracy of 91.9% on the validation set and 80.1% on the test set. The model detected anatomical structures with overall mean average precision of 0.642. Through various optimizations, we were able to run the AI copilot at approximately 28 frames per second (FPS), which is imperceptible from real time and nearly matches the video frame rate of 30 FPS. Sixty‐four novice medical students were recruited for feedback on the copilot. Although 90.9% strongly agreed/agreed that the AI copilot was easy to use, their self‐rating of FFL skills following use of the copilot were overall equivocal to their self‐rating without the copilot.Conclusions: The AI copilot tracked successful capture of diagnosable views of key anatomical structures effectively guiding users through FFL to ensure all anatomical structures are sufficiently captured. This tool has the potential to assist novices in efficiently gaining competence in FFL.Level of Evidence: NA Laryngoscope, 135:1046–1053, 2025
- 3 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 135 (3) , 1046-1053
Development of Machine Learning Copilot to Assist Novices in Learning Flexible Laryngoscopy
Objectives: Here we describe the development and pilot testing of the first artificial intelligence (AI) software “copilot” to help train novices to competently perform flexible fiberoptic laryngoscopy (FFL) on a mannikin and improve their uptake of FFL skills.Methods: Supervised machine learning was used to develop an image classifier model, dubbed the “anatomical region classifier,” responsible for predicting the location of camera in the upper aerodigestive tract and an object detection model, dubbed the “anatomical structure detector,” responsible for locating and identifying key anatomical structures in images. Training data were collected by performing FFL on an AirSim Combo Bronchi X mannikin (United Kingdom, TruCorp Ltd) using an Ambu aScope 4 RhinoLaryngo Slim connected to an Ambu® aView™ 2 Advance Displaying Unit (Ballerup, Ambu A/S). Medical students were prospectively recruited to try the FFL copilot and rate its ease of use and self‐rate their skills with and without the copilot.Results: This model classified anatomical regions with an overall accuracy of 91.9% on the validation set and 80.1% on the test set. The model detected anatomical structures with overall mean average precision of 0.642. Through various optimizations, we were able to run the AI copilot at approximately 28 frames per second (FPS), which is imperceptible from real time and nearly matches the video frame rate of 30 FPS. Sixty‐four novice medical students were recruited for feedback on the copilot. Although 90.9% strongly agreed/agreed that the AI copilot was easy to use, their self‐rating of FFL skills following use of the copilot were overall equivocal to their self‐rating without the copilot.Conclusions: The AI copilot tracked successful capture of diagnosable views of key anatomical structures effectively guiding users through FFL to ensure all anatomical structures are sufficiently captured. This tool has the potential to assist novices in efficiently gaining competence in FFL.Level of Evidence: NA Laryngoscope, 135:1046–1053, 2025
- 1 October 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America
- Vol. 50 (5) , 959-965
Assessment of Surgical Skills and Competency
- 1 October 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America
- Vol. 50 (5) , 959-965
Assessment of Surgical Skills and Competency
- 4 July 2017
- Published by Wiley in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
- Vol. 157 (3) , 524-529
Development and Pilot Testing of an Objective Structured Clinical Examination for Obstructive Sleep Apnea
Objective: Our aim was (1) to develop an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and (2) to test the reliability and evaluate the feasibility of this OSCE while assessing residents’ clinical skills in multiple core competencies via the standardized patient methodology.Study Design: Development of assessment tool.Setting: Johns Hopkins Medicine Simulation Center.Subjects and Methods: Residents of the Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery at The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine were invited to participate. A 2‐station OSCE was developed. The first station used a standardized patient, and the encounter was videotaped for later evaluation by medical faculty not familiar with the participants being tested. The second was a computer‐based station developed per a modified Delphi technique, based on feedback from otolaryngology and sleep medicine faculty involved in the care of patients with OSA. Checklists were developed for each station to standardize the evaluation of each trainee’s performance.Results: The OSCE that we developed is a feasible tool for assessing residents’ performance and skills to diagnose and manage a patient with OSA. Internal consistency, as assessed by Krippendorff’s alpha, was 0.699 for station 1 and 0.95 for station 2.Conclusion: This OSCE was found to be feasible for assessment of clinical competency in OSA. Our model provides targeted assessment of multiple competencies and opportunity to improve clinical knowledge and skills.
- 4 July 2017
- Published by Wiley in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
- Vol. 157 (3) , 524-529
Development and Pilot Testing of an Objective Structured Clinical Examination for Obstructive Sleep Apnea
Objective: Our aim was (1) to develop an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and (2) to test the reliability and evaluate the feasibility of this OSCE while assessing residents’ clinical skills in multiple core competencies via the standardized patient methodology.Study Design: Development of assessment tool.Setting: Johns Hopkins Medicine Simulation Center.Subjects and Methods: Residents of the Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery at The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine were invited to participate. A 2‐station OSCE was developed. The first station used a standardized patient, and the encounter was videotaped for later evaluation by medical faculty not familiar with the participants being tested. The second was a computer‐based station developed per a modified Delphi technique, based on feedback from otolaryngology and sleep medicine faculty involved in the care of patients with OSA. Checklists were developed for each station to standardize the evaluation of each trainee’s performance.Results: The OSCE that we developed is a feasible tool for assessing residents’ performance and skills to diagnose and manage a patient with OSA. Internal consistency, as assessed by Krippendorff’s alpha, was 0.699 for station 1 and 0.95 for station 2.Conclusion: This OSCE was found to be feasible for assessment of clinical competency in OSA. Our model provides targeted assessment of multiple competencies and opportunity to improve clinical knowledge and skills.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 8, 25-29
Balancing standardized testing with personalized training in surgery
Students pursuing a medical career in the US are subject to standardized testing at regular intervals. These standardized tests not only quantify the milestones students have already achieved, but also define the path for future achievements. The purpose of these examinations is to help students become self-directed, lifelong learners – an essential attribute of a medical professional. However, whether preparing for these examinations actually makes students such disciplined learners needs to be examined. Especially during residency training with its limited time and unpredictable exposure, trainees must learn in the most efficient way for their learning styles, and thus develop attributes that will be helpful to them in their medical career. In this review, we propose that a personalized, learner-centered approach tailored to residents’ educational needs and preferences can not only fulfill learning interests and objectives but also serve as a time-efficient and cost-effective approach for graduate medical education.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 8, 25-29
Open AccessBalancing standardized testing with personalized training in surgery
Students pursuing a medical career in the US are subject to standardized testing at regular intervals. These standardized tests not only quantify the milestones students have already achieved, but also define the path for future achievements. The purpose of these examinations is to help students become self-directed, lifelong learners – an essential attribute of a medical professional. However, whether preparing for these examinations actually makes students such disciplined learners needs to be examined. Especially during residency training with its limited time and unpredictable exposure, trainees must learn in the most efficient way for their learning styles, and thus develop attributes that will be helpful to them in their medical career. In this review, we propose that a personalized, learner-centered approach tailored to residents’ educational needs and preferences can not only fulfill learning interests and objectives but also serve as a time-efficient and cost-effective approach for graduate medical education.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Survey of Anesthesiology
- Vol. 60 (1) , 18-19
Difficult Airway Response Team
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Survey of Anesthesiology
- Vol. 60 (1) , 18-19
Difficult Airway Response Team
- 7 July 2015
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 125 (S8) , S1-14
Improving skills development in residency using a deliberate‐practice and learner‐centered model
Objectives/Hypothesis: Work‐hour restrictions, increased workload, and subjective assessment of competency are major threats to the efficacy of the traditional apprenticeship model of surgical training in modern surgical practice. In response, medical educators are developing time‐ and resource‐efficient competency‐based models of surgical training. The purpose of our project was to develop, implement, and measure the outcomes of such objective and structured programs in otolaryngology. We also investigated factors affecting the learning curve, especially deliberate practice, formative feedback, and learners' autonomy.Study Design: Prospective, longitudinal study.Methods: To measure the surgical skills of residents, we first developed and tested objective tools for otolaryngology procedures. Based on these instruments, we identified milestones of the procedures. Training on a virtual‐reality simulator was validated to shorten the learning curve. We also studied a learner‐centered approach of training, factors affecting the learning curve, and barriers to a competency‐based model.Results: The objective tools were found to be a feasible, reliable, and valid opportunity for measuring competency in both the laboratory and operating room. With the formative assessment from these tools, residents had a remediation target to be achieved by deliberate practice. The milestones helped identify the threshold of competency, and deliberate practice on the simulator gave an opportunity for improving skills. The learner‐centered approach allowed flexibility and personalized learning by shifting the responsibility of the learning process to the learners.Conclusion: The competency‐based model of residency, based on the principles of deliberate practice and a learner‐centered approach, is a feasible model of residency training that allows development of competent surgeons and hence improves patient outcomes. Despite these advantages, challenges to this model require a concerted effort to overcome and fully implement these principles of training beyond just technical skills, ultimately creating well‐rounded medical professionals and leaders in the surgical field.Level of Evidence: N/A. Laryngoscope, 125:S1–S14, 2015
- 7 July 2015
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 125 (S8) , S1-14
Improving skills development in residency using a deliberate‐practice and learner‐centered model
Objectives/Hypothesis: Work‐hour restrictions, increased workload, and subjective assessment of competency are major threats to the efficacy of the traditional apprenticeship model of surgical training in modern surgical practice. In response, medical educators are developing time‐ and resource‐efficient competency‐based models of surgical training. The purpose of our project was to develop, implement, and measure the outcomes of such objective and structured programs in otolaryngology. We also investigated factors affecting the learning curve, especially deliberate practice, formative feedback, and learners' autonomy.Study Design: Prospective, longitudinal study.Methods: To measure the surgical skills of residents, we first developed and tested objective tools for otolaryngology procedures. Based on these instruments, we identified milestones of the procedures. Training on a virtual‐reality simulator was validated to shorten the learning curve. We also studied a learner‐centered approach of training, factors affecting the learning curve, and barriers to a competency‐based model.Results: The objective tools were found to be a feasible, reliable, and valid opportunity for measuring competency in both the laboratory and operating room. With the formative assessment from these tools, residents had a remediation target to be achieved by deliberate practice. The milestones helped identify the threshold of competency, and deliberate practice on the simulator gave an opportunity for improving skills. The learner‐centered approach allowed flexibility and personalized learning by shifting the responsibility of the learning process to the learners.Conclusion: The competency‐based model of residency, based on the principles of deliberate practice and a learner‐centered approach, is a feasible model of residency training that allows development of competent surgeons and hence improves patient outcomes. Despite these advantages, challenges to this model require a concerted effort to overcome and fully implement these principles of training beyond just technical skills, ultimately creating well‐rounded medical professionals and leaders in the surgical field.Level of Evidence: N/A. Laryngoscope, 125:S1–S14, 2015
- 30 July 2014
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 125 (4) , 837-841
Effect of distractions on operative performance and ability to multitask—A case for deliberate practice
Objectives/Hypothesis To measure the effect of distractions on the operative performance and analyze if practice and experience are the factors that can help to overcome the distractions. Study Design Prospective observational study. Methods Ten postgraduate year (PGY) 2‐6 residents and two faculty members from Johns Hopkins' otolaryngology department were recruited and asked to deepen the dissection at the sinodural angle on the Voxel‐man mastoidectomy simulator. They were asked to perform the task under four conditions: 1) no distractors, 2) differentiation and counting of a specific alarm sound among different sounds played in the background while performing the surgical task, 3) simultaneous performance of simple arithmetic task of moderate difficulty, and 4) simultaneous performance of the task with both sets of distractors combined. Results Time taken for the task (P = .02) and error scores (P = .002) increased under the third and fourth conditions. The ability to multitask and response to surgical and cognitive tasks improved with increasing level of experience of the participants. Conclusions Distractions lead to impaired dexterity and an increase in the incidence of errors. However, experience and deliberate practice can help achieve the ability to multitask without compromising the operative performance. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 125:837–841, 2015
- 30 July 2014
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 125 (4) , 837-841
Effect of distractions on operative performance and ability to multitask—A case for deliberate practice
Objectives/Hypothesis To measure the effect of distractions on the operative performance and analyze if practice and experience are the factors that can help to overcome the distractions. Study Design Prospective observational study. Methods Ten postgraduate year (PGY) 2‐6 residents and two faculty members from Johns Hopkins' otolaryngology department were recruited and asked to deepen the dissection at the sinodural angle on the Voxel‐man mastoidectomy simulator. They were asked to perform the task under four conditions: 1) no distractors, 2) differentiation and counting of a specific alarm sound among different sounds played in the background while performing the surgical task, 3) simultaneous performance of simple arithmetic task of moderate difficulty, and 4) simultaneous performance of the task with both sets of distractors combined. Results Time taken for the task (P = .02) and error scores (P = .002) increased under the third and fourth conditions. The ability to multitask and response to surgical and cognitive tasks improved with increasing level of experience of the participants. Conclusions Distractions lead to impaired dexterity and an increase in the incidence of errors. However, experience and deliberate practice can help achieve the ability to multitask without compromising the operative performance. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 125:837–841, 2015
- 5 October 2013
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 123 (12) , 2932-2934
Achievement of competency in endoscopic sinus surgery of otolaryngology residents
Objectives/Hypothesis: The goal of our study is to identify the number of Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (ESS) cases required to obtain competency in ESS, using a previously validated assessment tool.Study Design: Prospective observational study.Methods: Seventeen residents from Johns Hopkins Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery residency program were evaluated as they performed endoscopic sinus surgery in the operating room. Global and checklist parts of the ESS instrument were used for assessment purposes. Items on the tool were grouped into three different milestones for analysis of data (Milestone 1 = Maxillary Antrostomy + Anterior Ethmoidectomy, Milestone 2 = Posterior Ethmoidectomy + Sphenoidostomy, Milestone 3 = Frontal Sinusotomy). Residents were deemed competent if they achieved a minimum score of 3 on a 5‐point Likert scale on each step of the surgery.Results: A total of 73 evaluations were completed for 17 residents (Postgraduate Level 2–5) by eight evaluators between 2009 and 2011. A 60% probability of achieving competency in performance of all milestones of ESS is obtained with performing 42 ESS procedures and the probability is increased to a 100% with performance of 55 endoscopic sinus surgery procedures. On average it took residents 23 cases to become competent in performance of maxillary antrostomy and anterior ethmoidectomy.Conclusions: Our results suggest that it requires 42 ESS procedures to attain a 60% probability of competency in ESS. These results have implications for otolaryngology residency programs when developing curriculum and benchmarks for the training residents. Laryngoscope, 123:2932–2934, 2013
- 5 October 2013
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 123 (12) , 2932-2934
Achievement of competency in endoscopic sinus surgery of otolaryngology residents
Objectives/Hypothesis: The goal of our study is to identify the number of Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (ESS) cases required to obtain competency in ESS, using a previously validated assessment tool.Study Design: Prospective observational study.Methods: Seventeen residents from Johns Hopkins Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery residency program were evaluated as they performed endoscopic sinus surgery in the operating room. Global and checklist parts of the ESS instrument were used for assessment purposes. Items on the tool were grouped into three different milestones for analysis of data (Milestone 1 = Maxillary Antrostomy + Anterior Ethmoidectomy, Milestone 2 = Posterior Ethmoidectomy + Sphenoidostomy, Milestone 3 = Frontal Sinusotomy). Residents were deemed competent if they achieved a minimum score of 3 on a 5‐point Likert scale on each step of the surgery.Results: A total of 73 evaluations were completed for 17 residents (Postgraduate Level 2–5) by eight evaluators between 2009 and 2011. A 60% probability of achieving competency in performance of all milestones of ESS is obtained with performing 42 ESS procedures and the probability is increased to a 100% with performance of 55 endoscopic sinus surgery procedures. On average it took residents 23 cases to become competent in performance of maxillary antrostomy and anterior ethmoidectomy.Conclusions: Our results suggest that it requires 42 ESS procedures to attain a 60% probability of competency in ESS. These results have implications for otolaryngology residency programs when developing curriculum and benchmarks for the training residents. Laryngoscope, 123:2932–2934, 2013
- Open Access
- 22 July 2013
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 123 (12) , 3162-3167
Determinants of resident competence in mastoidectomy: Role of interest and deliberate practice
Objectives/Hypothesis: This study explores the influence of selected factors on achievement of competency in mastoid surgery.Study Design: A prospective study of surgical performance and a retrospective survey of learner and training factors.Methods: The longitudinal performance of 15 residents was evaluated using the mastoidectomy task‐based checklist (TBC). The influence of surgical experience, resident interest, and training factors (course attendance, voluntary use of simulation laboratory) was also examined and compared for the acquisition of distinct levels of technical skill difficulty (cortical mastoidectomy vs. facial recess).Results: Ninety‐six observations made during the first otology rotation were analyzed. Cortical mastoidectomy tasks showed positive associations with cumulated case numbers (OR 1.13, CI 1.04–1.23,P = .003) and interest in otology (OR 3.86, CI 1.21–12.27,P = .022). Facial recess tasks showed a larger positive association with interest in otology (OR 10.38, CI 2.25–47.94,P = .003), and negative association with extra time spent in laboratory practice (OR .05, CI 0.011–0.23,P = .000).Conclusions: Learning trajectory for cortical mastoidectomy and facial recess may be influenced by different factors. Interest in otology, in particular, may have a moderating effect on the acquisition of more complex skills in mastoid surgery. A negative association between self‐directed laboratory simulation and performance may reflect the impact of assessment‐guided feedback in promoting deliberate practice. Further investigations are suggested to explore the interactions between individual trainee differences, educational models, and learning outcomes.Level of Evidence: N/A.Laryngoscope, 123:3162–3167, 2013
- 22 July 2013
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 123 (12) , 3162-3167
Open AccessDeterminants of resident competence in mastoidectomy: Role of interest and deliberate practice
Objectives/Hypothesis: This study explores the influence of selected factors on achievement of competency in mastoid surgery.Study Design: A prospective study of surgical performance and a retrospective survey of learner and training factors.Methods: The longitudinal performance of 15 residents was evaluated using the mastoidectomy task‐based checklist (TBC). The influence of surgical experience, resident interest, and training factors (course attendance, voluntary use of simulation laboratory) was also examined and compared for the acquisition of distinct levels of technical skill difficulty (cortical mastoidectomy vs. facial recess).Results: Ninety‐six observations made during the first otology rotation were analyzed. Cortical mastoidectomy tasks showed positive associations with cumulated case numbers (OR 1.13, CI 1.04–1.23,P = .003) and interest in otology (OR 3.86, CI 1.21–12.27,P = .022). Facial recess tasks showed a larger positive association with interest in otology (OR 10.38, CI 2.25–47.94,P = .003), and negative association with extra time spent in laboratory practice (OR .05, CI 0.011–0.23,P = .000).Conclusions: Learning trajectory for cortical mastoidectomy and facial recess may be influenced by different factors. Interest in otology, in particular, may have a moderating effect on the acquisition of more complex skills in mastoid surgery. A negative association between self‐directed laboratory simulation and performance may reflect the impact of assessment‐guided feedback in promoting deliberate practice. Further investigations are suggested to explore the interactions between individual trainee differences, educational models, and learning outcomes.Level of Evidence: N/A.Laryngoscope, 123:3162–3167, 2013