Annabelle Tenenbaum
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Annabelle Tenenbaum has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Thomas Marquillier
Department of Paediatric Dentistry University of Lille, CHU of Lille, School of Dentistry Lille France
3 shared publications - Alessandra Blaizot
Toulouse University, CERPOP laboratory (team BIOETHICS), INSERM UMR 1295, Toulouse, France
1 shared publication - Alexis Gaudin
Nantes Université, Oniris, CHU Nantes, INSERM, Regenerative Medicine and Skeleton, RMeS, UMR 1229 Nantes France
1 shared publication Aurore Margat
Sorbonne Paris Nord University, Laboratory Educations and Health Promotion, UR 3412, Villetaneuse, 93430, France
1 shared publicationAurélie Maurice
Université Sorbonne Paris Nord, UR 3971 Experice, Villetaneuse, France
1 shared publicationCatherine de la Fouchardière
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in International Endodontic Journal
Consensus‐Based Recommendations for the Management of Deep and Extremely Deep Carious Lesions and Vital Pulp Treatment in Permanent Teeth: A National Delphi Study
Aim: To develop consensus‐based recommendations for general dental practitioners on deep and extremely deep carious lesions (CLs) and vital pulp treatment (VPT) in mature and immature permanent teeth. Methodology: A national modified Delphi study was conducted with a purposively selected expert panel. Twenty‐nine statements developed from international guidance were assessed through three anonymous online rounds using a 10‐point agreement scale. Free‐text justification for scores below 7 informed revision or merging. Positive consensus was predefined as a median score ≥ 7 with an interquartile range (IQR) ≤ 2; statements with greater dispersion could also be accepted when > 90% of experts scored them ≥ 7. Statements remaining uncertain after Round 3 were discussed at an online meeting and anonymously re‐rated by the full panel. Results: Of 34 experts invited, 22 enrolled and completed every rating stage; no item‐level data were missing. Five statements reached consensus in Round 1, 10 in Round 2, and six in Round 3. Four merging procedures reduced the 29 initial statements to 24 final statements. The remaining three reached consensus after the meeting and post‐meeting rating; none was rejected. Final median scores ranged from 7 to 10, IQRs from 0 to 2, and proportions of scores ≥ 7 from 59.1% to 100%. The recommendations support comprehensive and graded pulpal assessment, selective carious tissue removal for deep CLs when pulp exposure should be avoided, management of extremely deep CLs according to root maturity, and consideration of VPT after pulp exposure and in selected cases of severe pulpitis. They also address asepsis, biomaterial selection, definitive restoration and follow‐up. Conclusions: This national Delphi study produced 24 consensus‐based recommendations and a clinical decision‐support pathway for managing deep and extremely deep CLs in permanent teeth. The framework may complement existing evidence‐based guidance; however, its acceptability, feasibility, transferability, and impact on clinical and patient‐reported outcomes require external evaluation.
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in International Endodontic Journal
Open AccessConsensus‐Based Recommendations for the Management of Deep and Extremely Deep Carious Lesions and Vital Pulp Treatment in Permanent Teeth: A National Delphi Study
Aim: To develop consensus‐based recommendations for general dental practitioners on deep and extremely deep carious lesions (CLs) and vital pulp treatment (VPT) in mature and immature permanent teeth. Methodology: A national modified Delphi study was conducted with a purposively selected expert panel. Twenty‐nine statements developed from international guidance were assessed through three anonymous online rounds using a 10‐point agreement scale. Free‐text justification for scores below 7 informed revision or merging. Positive consensus was predefined as a median score ≥ 7 with an interquartile range (IQR) ≤ 2; statements with greater dispersion could also be accepted when > 90% of experts scored them ≥ 7. Statements remaining uncertain after Round 3 were discussed at an online meeting and anonymously re‐rated by the full panel. Results: Of 34 experts invited, 22 enrolled and completed every rating stage; no item‐level data were missing. Five statements reached consensus in Round 1, 10 in Round 2, and six in Round 3. Four merging procedures reduced the 29 initial statements to 24 final statements. The remaining three reached consensus after the meeting and post‐meeting rating; none was rejected. Final median scores ranged from 7 to 10, IQRs from 0 to 2, and proportions of scores ≥ 7 from 59.1% to 100%. The recommendations support comprehensive and graded pulpal assessment, selective carious tissue removal for deep CLs when pulp exposure should be avoided, management of extremely deep CLs according to root maturity, and consideration of VPT after pulp exposure and in selected cases of severe pulpitis. They also address asepsis, biomaterial selection, definitive restoration and follow‐up. Conclusions: This national Delphi study produced 24 consensus‐based recommendations and a clinical decision‐support pathway for managing deep and extremely deep CLs in permanent teeth. The framework may complement existing evidence‐based guidance; however, its acceptability, feasibility, transferability, and impact on clinical and patient‐reported outcomes require external evaluation.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth
- Vol. 26 (1)
Oral health skills framework for pregnant women: a professional consensus
Oral health during the perinatal period is essential for maternal and child oral health. Pregnancy increases vulnerability to oral conditions (periodontal disease and dental caries) associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes, while children's oral health is strongly influenced by parental-particularly maternal-knowledge, attitudes, practices, and oral health status. Although oral health education interventions may be offered during pregnancy follow-up, their effectiveness is difficult to evaluate, due to a lack of validated framework. This study aimed to develop a competency framework for oral health education during the perinatal period. A Delphi study assessed expert opinion on the competencies pregnant women should acquire to ensure good oral health for themselves and their children through oral health education interventions. The questionnaire comprises two sections (pregnant woman and child) and covered core skill domains-preventing oral diseases, monitoring oral health conditions, and seeking dental care- subdivided into 97 contributory learning objectives across knowledge, practices and attitudes. Objective were rated on a 4-point Likert scale, with consensus defined as ≥ 70%. The expert panel included 21 perinatal healthcare professionals (midwives, pediatricians, gynecologists, general practitioners, dentists, and pharmacists). In the first round, 59% of objectives were rated as very useful, and 40 were revised the second round due to lack of consensus. After three rounds, consensus was reached for all objectives except four: the links between periodontal disease and preeclampsia, impact of breastfeeding on oral health, the protective role of saliva and women's active search for oral health information. The discussion of the unresolved areas highlighted gaps in healthcare professionals' understanding of oral-general health links in the perinatal period, and in perceptions of individuals' autonomy in health information seeking. This study resulted in a consensus-based competency framework for oral health education during pregnancy, structured around three key competencies: preventing oral diseases, participating in care plans, and asserting health-related rights. Establishing consensus on women's oral health competencies supports a cross-disciplinary approach to prevention and health education during the perinatal period. Future research should focus on translating this framework into practical, implementable strategies across diverse healthcare settings.
- 17 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessOral health skills framework for pregnant women: a professional consensus
Oral health during the perinatal period is essential for maternal and child oral health. Pregnancy increases vulnerability to oral conditions (periodontal disease and dental caries) associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes, while children's oral health is strongly influenced by parental-particularly maternal-knowledge, attitudes, practices, and oral health status. Although oral health education interventions may be offered during pregnancy follow-up, their effectiveness is difficult to evaluate, due to a lack of validated framework. This study aimed to develop a competency framework for oral health education during the perinatal period. A Delphi study assessed expert opinion on the competencies pregnant women should acquire to ensure good oral health for themselves and their children through oral health education interventions. The questionnaire comprises two sections (pregnant woman and child) and covered core skill domains-preventing oral diseases, monitoring oral health conditions, and seeking dental care- subdivided into 97 contributory learning objectives across knowledge, practices and attitudes. Objective were rated on a 4-point Likert scale, with consensus defined as ≥ 70%. The expert panel included 21 perinatal healthcare professionals (midwives, pediatricians, gynecologists, general practitioners, dentists, and pharmacists). In the first round, 59% of objectives were rated as very useful, and 40 were revised the second round due to lack of consensus. After three rounds, consensus was reached for all objectives except four: the links between periodontal disease and preeclampsia, impact of breastfeeding on oral health, the protective role of saliva and women's active search for oral health information. The discussion of the unresolved areas highlighted gaps in healthcare professionals' understanding of oral-general health links in the perinatal period, and in perceptions of individuals' autonomy in health information seeking. This study resulted in a consensus-based competency framework for oral health education during pregnancy, structured around three key competencies: preventing oral diseases, participating in care plans, and asserting health-related rights. Establishing consensus on women's oral health competencies supports a cross-disciplinary approach to prevention and health education during the perinatal period. Future research should focus on translating this framework into practical, implementable strategies across diverse healthcare settings.
- Open Access
- 17 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1073
Soft skills in dental student curricula: an evidence and gap map
Soft skills are recognised as essential for dental practitioners, but their integration into dental education is inconsistent. The aim of this evidence and gap map was to explore the use of soft skills teaching initiatives in undergraduate dental education and to clarify the key domains in this research field. An extensive search of studies from 2014 to 2024 on the PubMed database was carried out by four researchers. Inclusion criteria covered articles, including both advocacy or position papers, and studies reporting on implemented and evaluated educational interventions in soft skills in undergraduate dental education. The search is aligned with Joanna Briggs Institute and PRISMA-ScR guidelines and based on predefined coding frameworks from the literature. From the 1,449 records initially identified, 317 were included after rigorous examination. There were generally more educational programme description or evaluation papers compared to advocacy articles. More than two-thirds of the included articles were published in pedagogy-focused journals. The papers were classified into four domains (i.e. dentist-patient relationship, cooperation, life balance and clinical reasoning), with most studies falling into the dentist-patient relationship and cooperation domains. Various graphic formats present the results (i.e. a visual map, radar charts, and a geographical map), which provides a comprehensive and accessible representation, thus aiding in the exploration of the identified themes, connections, and key domains in this research field. This evidence and gap map represents an attempt to capture a picture of existing educational practises relating to soft skills in dentistry teaching and, thus, raise broader questions regarding how soft skills should contribute to redefining the role of dentistry for dentists, patients and society. However, integrating soft skills comes with various challenges, such as the training of educators, the standardisation of content and evaluations, and the development of research evaluating the impacts of soft skills teaching on dentists and patients. Ultimately, it would be beneficial to engage patients in defining the various curriculum items and prioritising the most relevant ones concerning soft skills. This collaborative approach would ensure that the educational content aligns with the needs of patients and helps address larger public health challenges.
- 17 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1073
Open AccessSoft skills in dental student curricula: an evidence and gap map
Soft skills are recognised as essential for dental practitioners, but their integration into dental education is inconsistent. The aim of this evidence and gap map was to explore the use of soft skills teaching initiatives in undergraduate dental education and to clarify the key domains in this research field. An extensive search of studies from 2014 to 2024 on the PubMed database was carried out by four researchers. Inclusion criteria covered articles, including both advocacy or position papers, and studies reporting on implemented and evaluated educational interventions in soft skills in undergraduate dental education. The search is aligned with Joanna Briggs Institute and PRISMA-ScR guidelines and based on predefined coding frameworks from the literature. From the 1,449 records initially identified, 317 were included after rigorous examination. There were generally more educational programme description or evaluation papers compared to advocacy articles. More than two-thirds of the included articles were published in pedagogy-focused journals. The papers were classified into four domains (i.e. dentist-patient relationship, cooperation, life balance and clinical reasoning), with most studies falling into the dentist-patient relationship and cooperation domains. Various graphic formats present the results (i.e. a visual map, radar charts, and a geographical map), which provides a comprehensive and accessible representation, thus aiding in the exploration of the identified themes, connections, and key domains in this research field. This evidence and gap map represents an attempt to capture a picture of existing educational practises relating to soft skills in dentistry teaching and, thus, raise broader questions regarding how soft skills should contribute to redefining the role of dentistry for dentists, patients and society. However, integrating soft skills comes with various challenges, such as the training of educators, the standardisation of content and evaluations, and the development of research evaluating the impacts of soft skills teaching on dentists and patients. Ultimately, it would be beneficial to engage patients in defining the various curriculum items and prioritising the most relevant ones concerning soft skills. This collaborative approach would ensure that the educational content aligns with the needs of patients and helps address larger public health challenges.
- Open Access
- 8 October 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 12 (10) , 322
Therapeutic Patient Education and Eating Habits: A Challenge in Caries Disease
Dietary Factors and Oral Health: Risky dietary behaviors, particularly excessive sugar consumption, significantly contribute to dental caries. Dental practitioners are tasked with detecting and managing these behaviors to effectively treat caries and prevent recurrences. Although dietary assessment tools exist to identify such behaviors, they have limits. Furthermore, traditional methods, focused on information dissemination and advice, often fall short in promoting sustainable changes in patient behavior toward oral health. From our perspective, there is a necessity to integrate educational approaches with therapeutic management for enhancing the ability current and future dental practitioners to effectively care for their patients’ oral health needs. Discussion: Specific educational models have been developed for patients with chronic diseases, through Therapeutic Patient Education (TPE), defined as helping patients acquire or maintain the skills they need to best manage their lives with a chronic disease. Future Directions: By incorporating TPE into dental practice, oral health professionals can empower patients to take control of their eating habits and reduce their risk of caries disease. This holistic approach addresses both the carious lesions and underlying causes of tooth decay, leading to better oral health outcomes for patients.
- 8 October 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 12 (10) , 322
Open AccessTherapeutic Patient Education and Eating Habits: A Challenge in Caries Disease
Dietary Factors and Oral Health: Risky dietary behaviors, particularly excessive sugar consumption, significantly contribute to dental caries. Dental practitioners are tasked with detecting and managing these behaviors to effectively treat caries and prevent recurrences. Although dietary assessment tools exist to identify such behaviors, they have limits. Furthermore, traditional methods, focused on information dissemination and advice, often fall short in promoting sustainable changes in patient behavior toward oral health. From our perspective, there is a necessity to integrate educational approaches with therapeutic management for enhancing the ability current and future dental practitioners to effectively care for their patients’ oral health needs. Discussion: Specific educational models have been developed for patients with chronic diseases, through Therapeutic Patient Education (TPE), defined as helping patients acquire or maintain the skills they need to best manage their lives with a chronic disease. Future Directions: By incorporating TPE into dental practice, oral health professionals can empower patients to take control of their eating habits and reduce their risk of caries disease. This holistic approach addresses both the carious lesions and underlying causes of tooth decay, leading to better oral health outcomes for patients.
- 24 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry
- Vol. 24 (6) , 803-806
A proposal for an oral health educational programme for the first 1000 days of life: from pregnancy to childhood
Aim The aim of this paper is to highlight the need to consider oral health during the first 1000 days of a child's life with a view to developing appropriate educational programmes. Context The first 1000 days of life represent a window of opportunity for prevention in children. This concept is built on a consideration of the overall health of mother and child, taking into account social inequalities in health. It is now established that the oral health of the mother determines the oral health of her child. Furthermore, parents' knowledge and behaviour have a direct influence on their child's health. Conclusion The majority of the population does not have the necessary skills to adopt behaviours that promote oral health. The need for oral health education begins in the first 1000 days of life. Following the model of family health education, these programmes would involve providing pregnant women and, therefore, families with the skills they need to manage their own oral health and that of their future child as early as possible.
- 24 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry
- Vol. 24 (6) , 803-806
A proposal for an oral health educational programme for the first 1000 days of life: from pregnancy to childhood
Aim The aim of this paper is to highlight the need to consider oral health during the first 1000 days of a child's life with a view to developing appropriate educational programmes. Context The first 1000 days of life represent a window of opportunity for prevention in children. This concept is built on a consideration of the overall health of mother and child, taking into account social inequalities in health. It is now established that the oral health of the mother determines the oral health of her child. Furthermore, parents' knowledge and behaviour have a direct influence on their child's health. Conclusion The majority of the population does not have the necessary skills to adopt behaviours that promote oral health. The need for oral health education begins in the first 1000 days of life. Following the model of family health education, these programmes would involve providing pregnant women and, therefore, families with the skills they need to manage their own oral health and that of their future child as early as possible.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Vol. 21 (1) , 185-198
Oral Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practices, and Literacy of Pregnant Women: A Scoping Review
Purpose: Pregnancy is a state particularly sensitive to oral pathologies (periodontal and decay). The oral health status of pregnant women can have an impact on the outcome of the pregnancy and the oral health of the child to come. As in the general population, the oral health of pregnant women is socially determined and dependent on psychosocial factors, in-cluding factors related to health behaviours. Research into the determinants of oral health in pregnant women will allow a better understanding of the mechanisms of action specific to this period of perinatality.Materials and Methods: The methodology of a scoping review was selected with the objective of investigating the contri-bution of knowledge, attitudes, practices (KAP) and oral health literacy on pregnant women's oral health.Results: Of the 67 articles selected, 52 studied the `knowledge' component, 27 the `attitude' (including the perception and beliefs concerning health), and 54 the `practice' component, while 6 articles examined literacy. The KAP components were studied in relation to socioeconomic determinants, oral health status, healthcare utilisation and oral health literacy. The level of oral health literacy of pregnant women is strongly related to their living environment and socioprofessional level which influences their attitudes and practices. Woman's oral health practices before pregnancy can be a predictor of her practices during pregnancy.Conclusion: The complex nature of the attitude component (locus of control, sense of self-efficacy, perceived impor-tance) is little discussed. The heterogeneity and exhaustiveness of topics related to KAP raises the question of how to more accurately assess KAP in pregnant women in a valid, reproducible, and transferable manner and the need to build a structured oral health consensus body of work. This review is a first step towards identifying the psychosocial factors that are essential for developing a model of educational intervention in oral health that combines the process of behavioural change and decision making while taking into account the concept of empowerment, and with the aim of reducing social inequalities in health.
- 1 January 2023
- Vol. 21 (1) , 185-198
Open AccessOral Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practices, and Literacy of Pregnant Women: A Scoping Review
Purpose: Pregnancy is a state particularly sensitive to oral pathologies (periodontal and decay). The oral health status of pregnant women can have an impact on the outcome of the pregnancy and the oral health of the child to come. As in the general population, the oral health of pregnant women is socially determined and dependent on psychosocial factors, in-cluding factors related to health behaviours. Research into the determinants of oral health in pregnant women will allow a better understanding of the mechanisms of action specific to this period of perinatality.Materials and Methods: The methodology of a scoping review was selected with the objective of investigating the contri-bution of knowledge, attitudes, practices (KAP) and oral health literacy on pregnant women's oral health.Results: Of the 67 articles selected, 52 studied the `knowledge' component, 27 the `attitude' (including the perception and beliefs concerning health), and 54 the `practice' component, while 6 articles examined literacy. The KAP components were studied in relation to socioeconomic determinants, oral health status, healthcare utilisation and oral health literacy. The level of oral health literacy of pregnant women is strongly related to their living environment and socioprofessional level which influences their attitudes and practices. Woman's oral health practices before pregnancy can be a predictor of her practices during pregnancy.Conclusion: The complex nature of the attitude component (locus of control, sense of self-efficacy, perceived impor-tance) is little discussed. The heterogeneity and exhaustiveness of topics related to KAP raises the question of how to more accurately assess KAP in pregnant women in a valid, reproducible, and transferable manner and the need to build a structured oral health consensus body of work. This review is a first step towards identifying the psychosocial factors that are essential for developing a model of educational intervention in oral health that combines the process of behavioural change and decision making while taking into account the concept of empowerment, and with the aim of reducing social inequalities in health.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by OpenEdition in Revue internationale de pédagogie de l’enseignement supérieur
- Vol. 37 (3)
Formation interdisciplinaire à la pédagogie dans l’enseignement supérieur : de l’expérience individuelle à la dynamique collective pour impulser une transformation pédagogique
Cet article est le fruit d'une collaboration réflexive de cinq enseignants de champs disciplinaires et de structures universitaires différents, avec l’aide de deux conseillères pédagogiques. Il s'agit d'un retour d'expérience à la suite de la participation de ces enseignants à un parcours de formation à la pédagogie universitaire intitulé CertifiENS. Notre propos est surtout de témoigner de cette expérience originale et interdisciplinaire, en décrivant les caractéristiques de notre groupe d’enseignants, le parcours CertifiENS que nous avons suivi puis les transformations pédagogiques que nous avons opérées dans nos enseignements. Nous avons sollicité a posteriori deux de nos conseillères pédagogiques (formatrices dans le cadre du parcours CertifiENS et enseignantes-chercheuses en sociologie et sciences de l’éducation) pour un entretien de groupe (focus group) visant à expliciter nos intentions et motivations initiales et mettre en lumière l'émergence d'une dynamique collective. Cet entretien de groupe nous a permis de porter une analyse réflexive individuelle puis collective sur le processus de transformation individuelle et sur la transition pédagogique effectuée et toujours en devenir.Cette analyse a montré que l’interdisciplinarité a été un atout majeur et une source de synergies, permettant de nous focaliser sur le commun : la pédagogie. Le groupe a été porteur d’une transformation durable des pratiques enseignantes, chacun sur son terrain respectif a souhaité continuer à porter ce changement de paradigme, tout en réfléchissant à la construction d’une communauté de pratiques.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by OpenEdition in Revue internationale de pédagogie de l’enseignement supérieur
- Vol. 37 (3)
Open AccessFormation interdisciplinaire à la pédagogie dans l’enseignement supérieur : de l’expérience individuelle à la dynamique collective pour impulser une transformation pédagogique
Cet article est le fruit d'une collaboration réflexive de cinq enseignants de champs disciplinaires et de structures universitaires différents, avec l’aide de deux conseillères pédagogiques. Il s'agit d'un retour d'expérience à la suite de la participation de ces enseignants à un parcours de formation à la pédagogie universitaire intitulé CertifiENS. Notre propos est surtout de témoigner de cette expérience originale et interdisciplinaire, en décrivant les caractéristiques de notre groupe d’enseignants, le parcours CertifiENS que nous avons suivi puis les transformations pédagogiques que nous avons opérées dans nos enseignements. Nous avons sollicité a posteriori deux de nos conseillères pédagogiques (formatrices dans le cadre du parcours CertifiENS et enseignantes-chercheuses en sociologie et sciences de l’éducation) pour un entretien de groupe (focus group) visant à expliciter nos intentions et motivations initiales et mettre en lumière l'émergence d'une dynamique collective. Cet entretien de groupe nous a permis de porter une analyse réflexive individuelle puis collective sur le processus de transformation individuelle et sur la transition pédagogique effectuée et toujours en devenir.Cette analyse a montré que l’interdisciplinarité a été un atout majeur et une source de synergies, permettant de nous focaliser sur le commun : la pédagogie. Le groupe a été porteur d’une transformation durable des pratiques enseignantes, chacun sur son terrain respectif a souhaité continuer à porter ce changement de paradigme, tout en réfléchissant à la construction d’une communauté de pratiques.