Michael Mandl
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Michael Mandl has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Julian Johannes Lenz
Helmholtz-Zentrum Dresden-Rossendorf, Dresden, Germany
9 shared publications - Andreas Wipf
Theoretisch-Physikalisches Institut Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena D-07743 Jena Germany
7 shared publications - Dénes Sexty
Institute of Physics NAWI Graz University of Graz Universitätsplatz 5 8010 Graz Austria
5 shared publications - Erhard Seiler
Max-Planck-Institut für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut)
5 shared publications - Michael Westh Hansen
Institute of Physics NAWI Graz University of Graz Universitätsplatz 5 8010 Graz Austria
2 shared publications - Christof Gattringer
FWF -Austrian Science Fund 1090 Vienna Bonn Austria Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2026 (8) , 110
Correctness criteria for complex Langevin
A bstract: The complex Langevin approach is a promising method for the numerical treatment of systems with a sign problem, for which conventional lattice field theory techniques based on importance sampling cannot be applied. However, complex Langevin dynamics may fail to converge in some cases and converge to a wrong limit in others, motivating the development of various diagnostic tools over the years to assess the correctness of given simulation results. This work aims at providing a systematic comparison between the most prominent such correctness criteria. In particular, the main goal is to contrast their applicability, ease of use, and — most importantly — their predictive power. To this end, four simple but nontrivial models are considered and the criteria applied to each of them. It is found that no single correctness criterion is entirely foolproof on its own and that it is advisable in practice to employ multiple different criteria in combination. These conclusions are expected to carry over to more realistic theories as well.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2026 (8) , 110
Open AccessCorrectness criteria for complex Langevin
A bstract: The complex Langevin approach is a promising method for the numerical treatment of systems with a sign problem, for which conventional lattice field theory techniques based on importance sampling cannot be applied. However, complex Langevin dynamics may fail to converge in some cases and converge to a wrong limit in others, motivating the development of various diagnostic tools over the years to assess the correctness of given simulation results. This work aims at providing a systematic comparison between the most prominent such correctness criteria. In particular, the main goal is to contrast their applicability, ease of use, and — most importantly — their predictive power. To this end, four simple but nontrivial models are considered and the criteria applied to each of them. It is found that no single correctness criterion is entirely foolproof on its own and that it is advisable in practice to employ multiple different criteria in combination. These conclusions are expected to carry over to more realistic theories as well.
- Open Access
Complex Langevin simulations with a kernel
We discuss recent developments regarding the use of kernels in complex Langevin simulations. In particular, we outline how a kernel can be used to solve the problem of wrong convergence in a simple toy model. Since conventional correctness criteria for complex Langevin results are only necessary but not sufficient, the correct convergence of complex Langevin simulations is not always straightforward to assess. Hence, we furthermore discuss a condition for correctness that we have recently derived, which is both necessary and sufficient. Finally, we outline a machine-learning approach for finding suitable kernels in lattice gauge theories and present preliminary results of its application to the heavy-dense limit of QCD.
Open AccessComplex Langevin simulations with a kernel
We discuss recent developments regarding the use of kernels in complex Langevin simulations. In particular, we outline how a kernel can be used to solve the problem of wrong convergence in a simple toy model. Since conventional correctness criteria for complex Langevin results are only necessary but not sufficient, the correct convergence of complex Langevin simulations is not always straightforward to assess. Hence, we furthermore discuss a condition for correctness that we have recently derived, which is both necessary and sufficient. Finally, we outline a machine-learning approach for finding suitable kernels in lattice gauge theories and present preliminary results of its application to the heavy-dense limit of QCD.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical
- Vol. 58 (49) , 495202
Necessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin
We derive a family of correctness conditions for complex Langevin simulations. In particular, we show that if in a given theory the expectation values of all observables within a particular space satisfy the theory’s Schwinger–Dyson equations as well as certain bounds, then these expectation values are necessarily correct. In fact, these findings are not only valid in the context of complex Langevin simulations, but they also hold for general probability densities on complex manifolds, given an initial complex density on a real manifold. We stress that, while the proposed conditions are necessary and sufficient in a mathematical sense, their practical use is not to prove the correctness of obtained simulation results. Rather, they are mainly useful for detecting incorrect convergence. In particular, we test these criteria in a few simple one- and two-dimensional toy models and find that they are indeed capable of ruling out incorrect results without the need of exact solutions.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical
- Vol. 58 (49) , 495202
Open AccessNecessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin
We derive a family of correctness conditions for complex Langevin simulations. In particular, we show that if in a given theory the expectation values of all observables within a particular space satisfy the theory’s Schwinger–Dyson equations as well as certain bounds, then these expectation values are necessarily correct. In fact, these findings are not only valid in the context of complex Langevin simulations, but they also hold for general probability densities on complex manifolds, given an initial complex density on a real manifold. We stress that, while the proposed conditions are necessary and sufficient in a mathematical sense, their practical use is not to prove the correctness of obtained simulation results. Rather, they are mainly useful for detecting incorrect convergence. In particular, we test these criteria in a few simple one- and two-dimensional toy models and find that they are indeed capable of ruling out incorrect results without the need of exact solutions.
- Open Access
- 4 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (7)
Role of integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
Complex Langevin simulations are an attempt to solve the sign (or complex-action) problem encountered in various physical systems of interest. The method is based on a complexification of the underlying degrees of freedom and an evolution in an auxiliary time dimension. The complexification, however, does not come without drawbacks, the most severe of which is the infamous “wrong convergence” problem, stating that complex Langevin simulations sometimes fail to produce correct answers despite their apparent convergence. It has long been realized that wrong convergence may—in principle—be fixed by the introduction of a suitable kernel into the complex Langevin equation, such that the conventional correctness criteria are met. However, as we discuss in this work, complex Langevin results may—especially in the presence of a kernel—still be affected by unwanted so-called integration cycles of the theory spoiling them. Indeed, we confirm numerically that in the absence of boundary terms the complex Langevin results are given by a linear combination of such integration cycles, as put forward by Salcedo and Seiler [L. L. Salcedo and E. Seiler, ]. In particular, we shed light on the way different choices of kernel affect which integration cycles are being sampled in a simulation and how this knowledge can be used to ensure correct convergence in simple toy models.
- 4 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (7)
Open AccessRole of integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
Complex Langevin simulations are an attempt to solve the sign (or complex-action) problem encountered in various physical systems of interest. The method is based on a complexification of the underlying degrees of freedom and an evolution in an auxiliary time dimension. The complexification, however, does not come without drawbacks, the most severe of which is the infamous “wrong convergence” problem, stating that complex Langevin simulations sometimes fail to produce correct answers despite their apparent convergence. It has long been realized that wrong convergence may—in principle—be fixed by the introduction of a suitable kernel into the complex Langevin equation, such that the conventional correctness criteria are met. However, as we discuss in this work, complex Langevin results may—especially in the presence of a kernel—still be affected by unwanted so-called integration cycles of the theory spoiling them. Indeed, we confirm numerically that in the absence of boundary terms the complex Langevin results are given by a linear combination of such integration cycles, as put forward by Salcedo and Seiler [L. L. Salcedo and E. Seiler, ]. In particular, we shed light on the way different choices of kernel affect which integration cycles are being sampled in a simulation and how this knowledge can be used to ensure correct convergence in simple toy models.
- Open Access
- 5 December 2024
- Published by Sissa Medialab Srl
- Vol. 466, 059
Kernels and integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium distributions. While the convergence properties of the evolution can to some extent be assessed by studying so-called boundary terms, we demonstrate in this contribution that boundary terms on their own are not sufficient as a correctness criterion. Indeed, in their absence complex Langevin simulation results might still be spoiled by unwanted so-called integration cycles. In particular, we elaborate on how the introduction of a kernel into the complex Langevin equation can - in principle - be used to control which integration cycles are sampled in a simulation such that correct convergence is restored.
- 5 December 2024
- Published by Sissa Medialab Srl
- Vol. 466, 059
Open AccessKernels and integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium distributions. While the convergence properties of the evolution can to some extent be assessed by studying so-called boundary terms, we demonstrate in this contribution that boundary terms on their own are not sufficient as a correctness criterion. Indeed, in their absence complex Langevin simulation results might still be spoiled by unwanted so-called integration cycles. In particular, we elaborate on how the introduction of a kernel into the complex Langevin equation can - in principle - be used to control which integration cycles are sampled in a simulation such that correct convergence is restored.
- Open Access
Kernels and integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium distributions. While the convergence properties of the evolution can to some extent be assessed by studying so-called boundary terms, we demonstrate in this contribution that boundary terms on their own are not sufficient as a correctness criterion. Indeed, in their absence complex Langevin simulation results might still be spoiled by unwanted so-called integration cycles. In particular, we elaborate on how the introduction of a kernel into the complex Langevin equation can - in principle - be used to control which integration cycles are sampled in a simulation such that correct convergence is restored.
Open AccessKernels and integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium distributions. While the convergence properties of the evolution can to some extent be assessed by studying so-called boundary terms, we demonstrate in this contribution that boundary terms on their own are not sufficient as a correctness criterion. Indeed, in their absence complex Langevin simulation results might still be spoiled by unwanted so-called integration cycles. In particular, we elaborate on how the introduction of a kernel into the complex Langevin equation can - in principle - be used to control which integration cycles are sampled in a simulation such that correct convergence is restored.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2023
- Published by Sissa Medialab Srl
- Vol. 453, 172
The magnetized Gross-Neveu model at finite chemical potential
We study the (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at non-zero chemical potential and subjected to a homogeneous background magnetic field. We do so both analytically, in the limit of an infinite number of fermion flavors in which mean-field approaches become exact, as well as on the lattice for a single flavor. The rich and exotic phase structure observed in the mean-field limit is found to be destroyed when strong quantum fluctuations are present in the system. Instead, in the phase of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry the magnetic field enhances this breaking for all choices of parameters. As a byproduct, we find indications for a first-order phase transition in the chemical potential for vanishing magnetic field but also provide hints that this could rather be a finite-size than a finite-flavor-number effect.
- 27 December 2023
- Published by Sissa Medialab Srl
- Vol. 453, 172
Open AccessThe magnetized Gross-Neveu model at finite chemical potential
We study the (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at non-zero chemical potential and subjected to a homogeneous background magnetic field. We do so both analytically, in the limit of an infinite number of fermion flavors in which mean-field approaches become exact, as well as on the lattice for a single flavor. The rich and exotic phase structure observed in the mean-field limit is found to be destroyed when strong quantum fluctuations are present in the system. Instead, in the phase of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry the magnetic field enhances this breaking for all choices of parameters. As a byproduct, we find indications for a first-order phase transition in the chemical potential for vanishing magnetic field but also provide hints that this could rather be a finite-size than a finite-flavor-number effect.
- Open Access
The magnetized Gross-Neveu model at finite chemical potential
We study the (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at non-zero chemical potential and subjected to a homogeneous background magnetic field. We do so both analytically, in the limit of an infinite number of fermion flavors in which mean-field approaches become exact, as well as on the lattice for a single flavor. The rich and exotic phase structure observed in the mean-field limit is found to be destroyed when strong quantum fluctuations are present in the system. Instead, in the phase of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry the magnetic field enhances this breaking for all choices of parameters. As a byproduct, we find indications for a first-order phase transition in the chemical potential for vanishing magnetic field but also provide hints that this could rather be a finite-size than a finite-flavor-number effect.
Open AccessThe magnetized Gross-Neveu model at finite chemical potential
We study the (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at non-zero chemical potential and subjected to a homogeneous background magnetic field. We do so both analytically, in the limit of an infinite number of fermion flavors in which mean-field approaches become exact, as well as on the lattice for a single flavor. The rich and exotic phase structure observed in the mean-field limit is found to be destroyed when strong quantum fluctuations are present in the system. Instead, in the phase of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry the magnetic field enhances this breaking for all choices of parameters. As a byproduct, we find indications for a first-order phase transition in the chemical potential for vanishing magnetic field but also provide hints that this could rather be a finite-size than a finite-flavor-number effect.
- Open Access
The magnetized (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at finite density
We perform a lattice study of the ($2+1$)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model in a background magnetic field $B$ and at non-zero chemical potential $μ$. The complex-action problem arising in our simulations using overlap fermions is under control. For $B=0$ we observe a first-order phase transition in $μ$ even at non-vanishing temperatures. Our main finding, however, is that the rich phase structure found in the limit of infinite flavor number $N_\mathrm{f}$ is washed out by the fluctuations present at $N_\mathrm{f}=1$. We find no evidence for inverse magnetic catalysis, i.e., the decrease of the order parameter of chiral symmetry breaking with $B$ for $μ$ close to the chiral phase transition. Instead, the magnetic field tends to enhance the breakdown of chiral symmetry for all values of $μ$ below the transition. Moreover, we find no trace of spatial inhomogeneities in the order parameter. We briefly comment on the potential relevance of our results for QCD.Open AccessThe magnetized (2+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at finite density
We perform a lattice study of the ($2+1$)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model in a background magnetic field $B$ and at non-zero chemical potential $μ$. The complex-action problem arising in our simulations using overlap fermions is under control. For $B=0$ we observe a first-order phase transition in $μ$ even at non-vanishing temperatures. Our main finding, however, is that the rich phase structure found in the limit of infinite flavor number $N_\mathrm{f}$ is washed out by the fluctuations present at $N_\mathrm{f}=1$. We find no evidence for inverse magnetic catalysis, i.e., the decrease of the order parameter of chiral symmetry breaking with $B$ for $μ$ close to the chiral phase transition. Instead, the magnetic field tends to enhance the breakdown of chiral symmetry for all values of $μ$ below the transition. Moreover, we find no trace of spatial inhomogeneities in the order parameter. We briefly comment on the potential relevance of our results for QCD. - Open Access
- 11 October 2023
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 108 (7) , 074508
Magnetized ( )-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at finite densityWe perform a lattice study of the ()-dimensional Gross-Neveu model in a background magnetic field and at nonzero chemical potential . The complex-action problem arising in our simulations using overlap fermions is under control. For , we observe a first-order phase transition in even at nonvanishing temperatures. Our main finding, however, is that the rich phase structure found in the limit of infinite flavor number is washed out by the fluctuations present at . We find no evidence for inverse magnetic catalysis, i.e., the decrease of the order parameter of chiral symmetry breaking with for close to the chiral phase transition. Instead, the magnetic field tends to enhance the breakdown of chiral symmetry for all values of below the transition. Moreover, we find no trace of spatial inhomogeneities in the order parameter. We briefly comment on the potential relevance of our results for QCD.- 11 October 2023
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 108 (7) , 074508
Open AccessMagnetized ( )-dimensional Gross-Neveu model at finite densityWe perform a lattice study of the ()-dimensional Gross-Neveu model in a background magnetic field and at nonzero chemical potential . The complex-action problem arising in our simulations using overlap fermions is under control. For , we observe a first-order phase transition in even at nonvanishing temperatures. Our main finding, however, is that the rich phase structure found in the limit of infinite flavor number is washed out by the fluctuations present at . We find no evidence for inverse magnetic catalysis, i.e., the decrease of the order parameter of chiral symmetry breaking with for close to the chiral phase transition. Instead, the magnetic field tends to enhance the breakdown of chiral symmetry for all values of below the transition. Moreover, we find no trace of spatial inhomogeneities in the order parameter. We briefly comment on the potential relevance of our results for QCD.