Lucas Einig
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Lucas Einig has a total of 92 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
David Languignon
LUX, Observatoire de Paris, PSL Research University, CNRS, Sorbonne Universités
10 shared publications- Javier R. Goicoechea
Instituto de Física Fundamental (CSIC)
10 shared publications - Maryvonne Gerin
LUX, Observatoire de Paris, PSL Research University, CNRS, Sorbonne Universités
10 shared publications - Miriam G. Santa-Maria
Department of Astronomy, University of Florida , PO Box 112055, Gainesville, FL 32611
10 shared publications - Dariuscz C. Lis
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology
9 shared publications - Emeric Bron
LUX, Observatoire de Paris, Université PSL, CNRS, Sorbonne Université
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 713, A137
Chemical diversity of dense cores in Orion B: The role of the environment
Context. Pre-stellar cores are the sites of the earliest stages of star formation. Dust continuum observations are often used to identify and characterise their properties yet only a small fraction of them have been observed and studied in terms of their composition and dynamical status. Pre-stellar cores are often analysed as being analogous to template objects such as L1544 in Taurus, which could create an observational bias if this template were not representative of all possible pre-stellar cores. Aims. We explore the chemical diversity of pre-stellar cores and protostellar cores residing in the Orion B giant molecular cloud selected on their dust continuum emission to provide an unbiased view of their line emission properties and how they vary as function of the core parameters and environment. Methods. We made use of the large-scale maps of Orion B in 25 molecular lines, from which we extracted information for a sample of 1001 cores selected using positions extracted from Herschel dust continuum observations. The main properties of the core sample were derived using principal component analysis (PCA) and additional maps of physical parameters: the column density, N H 2 , far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation field, G 0 , and mean volume gas density, n . Additional high-spectral-resolution observations of C 18 O(1–0) served to evaluate the dynamical status of cores. Results. The average line width of the cores is larger than what is typically expected for pre-stellar cores of closer star-forming regions, which suggests that cores in Orion B are subjected to stronger turbulence affecting their stability. The first factor of the PCA analysis explaining the variation in the detected line intensities is the core column density of molecular gas. The second factor explains how the core chemical composition is strictly linked to their environment, which can be traced by the ratio of the external FUV radiation field over the core volume density, G 0 / n . Cold and shielded cores exhibit strong emission of N 2 H + , CH 3 OH, and deuterated species, whereas cores exposed to radiation are devoid of typical core tracers, but exhibit emission of 12 CN, HCO + , and HCN. The third factor explaining the core chemical diversity is the mean density along the core line of sight, which is also associated with freeze-out and fractionation signatures. Conclusions. Pre-stellar cores selected based on their dust emission exhibit a wide range of line emission patterns, which can be related to their intrinsic properties (column density, N H 2 , and mean volume density, n ) and environment (presence or lack of FUV). The key parameter that distinguishes cores of different emission patterns is G 0 / n .
- 16 September 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 713, A137
Open AccessChemical diversity of dense cores in Orion B: The role of the environment
Context. Pre-stellar cores are the sites of the earliest stages of star formation. Dust continuum observations are often used to identify and characterise their properties yet only a small fraction of them have been observed and studied in terms of their composition and dynamical status. Pre-stellar cores are often analysed as being analogous to template objects such as L1544 in Taurus, which could create an observational bias if this template were not representative of all possible pre-stellar cores. Aims. We explore the chemical diversity of pre-stellar cores and protostellar cores residing in the Orion B giant molecular cloud selected on their dust continuum emission to provide an unbiased view of their line emission properties and how they vary as function of the core parameters and environment. Methods. We made use of the large-scale maps of Orion B in 25 molecular lines, from which we extracted information for a sample of 1001 cores selected using positions extracted from Herschel dust continuum observations. The main properties of the core sample were derived using principal component analysis (PCA) and additional maps of physical parameters: the column density, N H 2 , far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation field, G 0 , and mean volume gas density, n . Additional high-spectral-resolution observations of C 18 O(1–0) served to evaluate the dynamical status of cores. Results. The average line width of the cores is larger than what is typically expected for pre-stellar cores of closer star-forming regions, which suggests that cores in Orion B are subjected to stronger turbulence affecting their stability. The first factor of the PCA analysis explaining the variation in the detected line intensities is the core column density of molecular gas. The second factor explains how the core chemical composition is strictly linked to their environment, which can be traced by the ratio of the external FUV radiation field over the core volume density, G 0 / n . Cold and shielded cores exhibit strong emission of N 2 H + , CH 3 OH, and deuterated species, whereas cores exposed to radiation are devoid of typical core tracers, but exhibit emission of 12 CN, HCO + , and HCN. The third factor explaining the core chemical diversity is the mean density along the core line of sight, which is also associated with freeze-out and fractionation signatures. Conclusions. Pre-stellar cores selected based on their dust emission exhibit a wide range of line emission patterns, which can be related to their intrinsic properties (column density, N H 2 , and mean volume density, n ) and environment (presence or lack of FUV). The key parameter that distinguishes cores of different emission patterns is G 0 / n .
- 8 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Relationships between observables and astrophysical conditions : a statistical and learning approach to the Orion B giant molecular cloud
Relations entre observables et conditions astrophysiques : approche statistique et apprentissage du nuage moléculaire géant Orion B: Les nuages moléculaires sont les lieux de naissance des étoiles. Les mécanismes à l'œuvre dans ces régions sont encore mal connus pour plusieurs raisons. Les nuages moléculaires sont tout d'abord des milieux complexes dont l'évolution est contrôlée par de nombreux phénomènes physiques (gravité, turbulence, transfert radiatif, champ magnétique) et chimiques (réactions chimiques, en phase gazeuse ou solide, à très basse température et densité, réactions photo-induites). Les modèles sont donc complexes avec des temps de calcul longs et de nombreux paramètres incertains. De plus, ces nuages ne peuvent être étudiés que par télédétection, la vérité terrain étant inaccessible. Enfin, les données présentent une large gamme de rapports signal sur bruit (RSB) et les découvertes les plus intéressantes sont souvent faites à faible RSB.La génération actuelle de récepteurs astronomiques des instruments de l'IRAM (télescope de 30-mètres au Pico Veleta et interféromètre NOEMA au Plateau de Bure) fait entrer la radioastronomie millimétrique dans l'ère du traitement massif des données. Ces récepteurs peuvent mesurer 80 000 fréquences simultanément. Il est ainsi possible de mesurer un grand nombre de raies spectrales moléculaires qui retracent les conditions physiques et chimiques du nuage interstellaire abritant ces molécules.Cette thèse propose d'étudier les relations statistiques entre les conditions physiques du gaz émetteur et les intensités de raies, à partir d'observations et de modélisations. Afin de faciliter l'assimilation des données, un algorithme de débruitage des données hyperspectrales astrophysiques a été construit à partir d'un réseau de neurones dit autoencodeur. Cette méthode a été appliquée aux observations du nuage moléculaire géant Orion B. Parallèlement, une méthode générale d'émulation de modèles numériques complexes par apprentissage profond a été développée et appliquée sur le code Meudon PDR. Ces travaux sont ensuite utilisés pour sélectionner les observables les plusinformatives au sens de la théorie de l'information. Les objectifs sont 1) de guider les futures campagnes d'observations, 2) de permettre l'apprentissage de modèles robustes et explicables pour inférer les conditions astrophysiques sans supervision humaine, et 3) de proposer une nouvelle manière d'appréhender les relations statistiques au sein des nuages moléculaires.
- 8 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Relationships between observables and astrophysical conditions : a statistical and learning approach to the Orion B giant molecular cloud
Relations entre observables et conditions astrophysiques : approche statistique et apprentissage du nuage moléculaire géant Orion B: Les nuages moléculaires sont les lieux de naissance des étoiles. Les mécanismes à l'œuvre dans ces régions sont encore mal connus pour plusieurs raisons. Les nuages moléculaires sont tout d'abord des milieux complexes dont l'évolution est contrôlée par de nombreux phénomènes physiques (gravité, turbulence, transfert radiatif, champ magnétique) et chimiques (réactions chimiques, en phase gazeuse ou solide, à très basse température et densité, réactions photo-induites). Les modèles sont donc complexes avec des temps de calcul longs et de nombreux paramètres incertains. De plus, ces nuages ne peuvent être étudiés que par télédétection, la vérité terrain étant inaccessible. Enfin, les données présentent une large gamme de rapports signal sur bruit (RSB) et les découvertes les plus intéressantes sont souvent faites à faible RSB.La génération actuelle de récepteurs astronomiques des instruments de l'IRAM (télescope de 30-mètres au Pico Veleta et interféromètre NOEMA au Plateau de Bure) fait entrer la radioastronomie millimétrique dans l'ère du traitement massif des données. Ces récepteurs peuvent mesurer 80 000 fréquences simultanément. Il est ainsi possible de mesurer un grand nombre de raies spectrales moléculaires qui retracent les conditions physiques et chimiques du nuage interstellaire abritant ces molécules.Cette thèse propose d'étudier les relations statistiques entre les conditions physiques du gaz émetteur et les intensités de raies, à partir d'observations et de modélisations. Afin de faciliter l'assimilation des données, un algorithme de débruitage des données hyperspectrales astrophysiques a été construit à partir d'un réseau de neurones dit autoencodeur. Cette méthode a été appliquée aux observations du nuage moléculaire géant Orion B. Parallèlement, une méthode générale d'émulation de modèles numériques complexes par apprentissage profond a été développée et appliquée sur le code Meudon PDR. Ces travaux sont ensuite utilisés pour sélectionner les observables les plusinformatives au sens de la théorie de l'information. Les objectifs sont 1) de guider les futures campagnes d'observations, 2) de permettre l'apprentissage de modèles robustes et explicables pour inférer les conditions astrophysiques sans supervision humaine, et 3) de proposer une nouvelle manière d'appréhender les relations statistiques au sein des nuages moléculaires.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 702, A205
The first estimation of the ionization fraction in dense and translucent molecular gas across Orion B
Context . The ionization fraction ( f e = n e / n H ) represents a fundamental parameter of the gas in the interstellar medium. However, estimating f e relies on a deep knowledge of the underlying chemistry of molecular gas as well as observations of atomic recombination lines and electron-sensitive molecular emission, such as deuterated isotopologs of HCO + and N 2 H + , which are only detectable in the dense cores. Until now, it has been challenging to constrain the ionization fraction in the interstellar gas over a large areas because of the observational limitations on these tracers and chemistry models. Aims . Recent models have provided a set of molecular lines whose ratios (intensities and column densities) can be used to trace f e in different environments of molecular clouds. Here, we use a set of various molecular lines typically detected in the 3−4 mm range to constrain the ionization fraction across the Orion B giant molecular cloud. In this work, we derived the ionization fraction for dense and translucent gas, and we investigated its variation with the density of the gas, n , and the strength of the far-ultraviolet radiation field, G 0 , with their ratio G 0 / n . Methods . We present our results for the ionization fraction across one square degree in Orion B derived using analytical models as well as observational intensity and column density ratios of CN(1−0)/N 2 H + (1−0), 13 CO(1−0)/HCO + (1−0), and C 18 O(1−0)/HCO + (1−0) in the dense and shielded medium ( A v ≥ 10 mag). We also used ratios of C 2 H(1−0)/HNC(1−0), C 2 H(1−0)/HCN(1−0), and C 2 H(1−0)/CN(1−0) in the translucent gas (2 mag ≤ A v ≤ 6 mag). Results . We find that the ionization fraction is within the range of 10 −5.5 −10 −4 for the translucent medium and 10 −8 −10 −6 for the dense medium. Our results show that the inferred f e values are sensitive to the value of G 0 , especially in the dense, highly UV-illuminated gas. We also find that the ionization fraction in dense and translucent gas decreases with an increasing volume density ( f e ∝ n −0.227 for dense gas and f e ∝ n −0.3 in translucent gas). It increases with G 0 , which is a consequence of how sensitive the emission of selected molecular lines (e.g., CN and HCO + ) is to the UV radiation field. In the case of the translucent medium, we did not find any significant difference in the ionization fraction computed from different line ratios. The range of f e values found in translucent gas implies that the electron excitation of HCN and HNC becomes significant in this regime. Conclusions . In dense and shielded gas, we recommend using CN(1−0)/N 2 H + (1−0) to derive an upper limit on the ionization fraction f e , along with C 18 O(1−0)/HCO + (1−0) to set constraints on the lower limit. In a translucent medium, C 2 H(1−0)/HNC(1−0) serves as a good tracer of f e . The moderately high f e values found in translucent gas are consistent with the C + /CI/CO transition regime, while the values we find in the dense gas are sufficient to couple the gas with the magnetic field.
- 22 October 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 702, A205
Open AccessThe first estimation of the ionization fraction in dense and translucent molecular gas across Orion B
Context . The ionization fraction ( f e = n e / n H ) represents a fundamental parameter of the gas in the interstellar medium. However, estimating f e relies on a deep knowledge of the underlying chemistry of molecular gas as well as observations of atomic recombination lines and electron-sensitive molecular emission, such as deuterated isotopologs of HCO + and N 2 H + , which are only detectable in the dense cores. Until now, it has been challenging to constrain the ionization fraction in the interstellar gas over a large areas because of the observational limitations on these tracers and chemistry models. Aims . Recent models have provided a set of molecular lines whose ratios (intensities and column densities) can be used to trace f e in different environments of molecular clouds. Here, we use a set of various molecular lines typically detected in the 3−4 mm range to constrain the ionization fraction across the Orion B giant molecular cloud. In this work, we derived the ionization fraction for dense and translucent gas, and we investigated its variation with the density of the gas, n , and the strength of the far-ultraviolet radiation field, G 0 , with their ratio G 0 / n . Methods . We present our results for the ionization fraction across one square degree in Orion B derived using analytical models as well as observational intensity and column density ratios of CN(1−0)/N 2 H + (1−0), 13 CO(1−0)/HCO + (1−0), and C 18 O(1−0)/HCO + (1−0) in the dense and shielded medium ( A v ≥ 10 mag). We also used ratios of C 2 H(1−0)/HNC(1−0), C 2 H(1−0)/HCN(1−0), and C 2 H(1−0)/CN(1−0) in the translucent gas (2 mag ≤ A v ≤ 6 mag). Results . We find that the ionization fraction is within the range of 10 −5.5 −10 −4 for the translucent medium and 10 −8 −10 −6 for the dense medium. Our results show that the inferred f e values are sensitive to the value of G 0 , especially in the dense, highly UV-illuminated gas. We also find that the ionization fraction in dense and translucent gas decreases with an increasing volume density ( f e ∝ n −0.227 for dense gas and f e ∝ n −0.3 in translucent gas). It increases with G 0 , which is a consequence of how sensitive the emission of selected molecular lines (e.g., CN and HCO + ) is to the UV radiation field. In the case of the translucent medium, we did not find any significant difference in the ionization fraction computed from different line ratios. The range of f e values found in translucent gas implies that the electron excitation of HCN and HNC becomes significant in this regime. Conclusions . In dense and shielded gas, we recommend using CN(1−0)/N 2 H + (1−0) to derive an upper limit on the ionization fraction f e , along with C 18 O(1−0)/HCO + (1−0) to set constraints on the lower limit. In a translucent medium, C 2 H(1−0)/HNC(1−0) serves as a good tracer of f e . The moderately high f e values found in translucent gas are consistent with the C + /CI/CO transition regime, while the values we find in the dense gas are sufficient to couple the gas with the magnetic field.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 698, A311
BEETROOTS: Spatially regularized Bayesian inference of physical parameter maps. Application to Orion
Context. The current generation of millimeter (mm) receivers is capable of producing cubes of 800 000 pixels over 200 000 frequency channels to cover a number of square degrees over the 3 mm atmospheric window. Estimating the physical conditions of the interstellar medium (ISM) with an astrophysical model on the basis of such large datasets is challenging. Common approaches tend to converge to local minima and end up poorly reconstructing regions with a low signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) in most cases. This instrumental revolution thus calls for new scalable data analysis techniques with more advanced approaches to statistical modeling and methods. Aims. Our aim is to design a general method to reconstruct large maps of physical conditions from the rich datasets produced by new and future instruments. The requirements of the method include the ability to scale to very large maps, to be robust to varying S/N, and to escape from the local minima. In addition, we want to quantify the uncertainties associated with our reconstructions to produce reliable analyses. Methods. We present BEETROOTS, a PYTHON software that performs Bayesian reconstructions of maps of physical conditions based on observation maps and an astrophysical model. It relies on an accurate statistical model, exploits spatial regularization to guide estimations, and uses state-of-the-art algorithms. It can also assess the ability of the astrophysical model to explain the observations, providing feedback to improve ISM models. In this work, we demonstrate the power of BEETROOTS with the Meudon PDR code on synthetic data. We then apply it to estimate physical condition maps in the full Orion molecular cloud 1 (OMC-1) star-forming region based on Herschel molecular line emission maps. Results. The application to the synthetic case shows that BEETROOTS can currently analyze maps with up to ten thousand pixels, addressing large variations among the S/N values within the observations while escaping from local minima and providing consistent uncertainty quantifications. On a personal laptop, the inference runtime ranges from a few minutes for maps of 100 pixels to 28 hours for maps of 8100 pixels. Regarding OMC-1, our reconstructions of the incident UV radiation field intensity, G0, are consistent with those obtained from FIR luminosities. This demonstrates that the considered molecular tracers are able to constrain G0 over a wide range of environments. In addition, the obtained thermal pressures are high in all dense regions of OMC-1 and positively correlated with G0. Finally, the Meudon PDR code successfully explains the observations and the obtained G0 values are reasonable, which indicates that UV photons control the gas physics and chemistry across the rim of OMC-1. Conclusions. This work paves the way toward systematic and rigorous analyses of observations produced by current and future instruments. Subsequent efforts still need to be made in parallelizing the algorithm and thereby gaining two orders of magnitude for the map sizes.
- 25 June 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 698, A311
Open AccessBEETROOTS: Spatially regularized Bayesian inference of physical parameter maps. Application to Orion
Context. The current generation of millimeter (mm) receivers is capable of producing cubes of 800 000 pixels over 200 000 frequency channels to cover a number of square degrees over the 3 mm atmospheric window. Estimating the physical conditions of the interstellar medium (ISM) with an astrophysical model on the basis of such large datasets is challenging. Common approaches tend to converge to local minima and end up poorly reconstructing regions with a low signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) in most cases. This instrumental revolution thus calls for new scalable data analysis techniques with more advanced approaches to statistical modeling and methods. Aims. Our aim is to design a general method to reconstruct large maps of physical conditions from the rich datasets produced by new and future instruments. The requirements of the method include the ability to scale to very large maps, to be robust to varying S/N, and to escape from the local minima. In addition, we want to quantify the uncertainties associated with our reconstructions to produce reliable analyses. Methods. We present BEETROOTS, a PYTHON software that performs Bayesian reconstructions of maps of physical conditions based on observation maps and an astrophysical model. It relies on an accurate statistical model, exploits spatial regularization to guide estimations, and uses state-of-the-art algorithms. It can also assess the ability of the astrophysical model to explain the observations, providing feedback to improve ISM models. In this work, we demonstrate the power of BEETROOTS with the Meudon PDR code on synthetic data. We then apply it to estimate physical condition maps in the full Orion molecular cloud 1 (OMC-1) star-forming region based on Herschel molecular line emission maps. Results. The application to the synthetic case shows that BEETROOTS can currently analyze maps with up to ten thousand pixels, addressing large variations among the S/N values within the observations while escaping from local minima and providing consistent uncertainty quantifications. On a personal laptop, the inference runtime ranges from a few minutes for maps of 100 pixels to 28 hours for maps of 8100 pixels. Regarding OMC-1, our reconstructions of the incident UV radiation field intensity, G0, are consistent with those obtained from FIR luminosities. This demonstrates that the considered molecular tracers are able to constrain G0 over a wide range of environments. In addition, the obtained thermal pressures are high in all dense regions of OMC-1 and positively correlated with G0. Finally, the Meudon PDR code successfully explains the observations and the obtained G0 values are reasonable, which indicates that UV photons control the gas physics and chemistry across the rim of OMC-1. Conclusions. This work paves the way toward systematic and rigorous analyses of observations produced by current and future instruments. Subsequent efforts still need to be made in parallelizing the algorithm and thereby gaining two orders of magnitude for the map sizes.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 696, A165
Understanding spatially unresolved measurements of molecular line emission
Context. Observations of molecular emission lines are commonly used to derive the physical properties of cold molecular gas clouds. In external galaxies, these measurements suffer from limited spatial resolution, typically averaging a complex position–position– velocity distribution of emission over several tens of parsecs. Aims. We aim to quantify the variability in the basic parameters (peak brightness and line width) of spatially unresolved (>20 pc) line profiles that can be attributed to beam averaging. We focus on the commonly observed low-J transitions of CO isotopologues, HCN, HNC, HCO+, CS, SO and N2H+. Methods. We generated a sample of 1000 toy molecular cloud observations by resampling high-resolution (Results. We find that unresolved line profiles’ parameters can vary significantly because of the sub-beam distribution of the emission. Emission lines that tend to be excited at higher densities show the most variability, up to a factor of two for N2H+ (J = 1 0). This variability in an emission line profile is related to the emission line’s covering fraction. As the spectral index of the velocity field increases, unresolved emission lines’ profiles increasingly diverge from a Gaussian shape. Conclusions. Line profile parameters exhibit non-negligible variability solely due to the sub-beam position-position-velocity distribution of the emission. This variability may exceed calibration and noise-related uncertainties.
- 25 April 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 696, A165
Open AccessUnderstanding spatially unresolved measurements of molecular line emission
Context. Observations of molecular emission lines are commonly used to derive the physical properties of cold molecular gas clouds. In external galaxies, these measurements suffer from limited spatial resolution, typically averaging a complex position–position– velocity distribution of emission over several tens of parsecs. Aims. We aim to quantify the variability in the basic parameters (peak brightness and line width) of spatially unresolved (>20 pc) line profiles that can be attributed to beam averaging. We focus on the commonly observed low-J transitions of CO isotopologues, HCN, HNC, HCO+, CS, SO and N2H+. Methods. We generated a sample of 1000 toy molecular cloud observations by resampling high-resolution (Results. We find that unresolved line profiles’ parameters can vary significantly because of the sub-beam distribution of the emission. Emission lines that tend to be excited at higher densities show the most variability, up to a factor of two for N2H+ (J = 1 0). This variability in an emission line profile is related to the emission line’s covering fraction. As the spectral index of the velocity field increases, unresolved emission lines’ profiles increasingly diverge from a Gaussian shape. Conclusions. Line profile parameters exhibit non-negligible variability solely due to the sub-beam position-position-velocity distribution of the emission. This variability may exceed calibration and noise-related uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A160
Toward a robust physical and chemical characterization of heterogeneous lines of sight: The case of the Horsehead nebula
Context. Dense and cold molecular cores and filaments are surrounded by an envelope of translucent gas. Some of the low-J emission lines of CO and HCO+ isotopologues are more sensitive to the conditions either in the translucent environment or in the dense and cold one because their intensities result from a complex interplay of radiative transfer and chemical properties of these heterogeneous lines of sight (LoSs). Aims. We extend our previous single-zone modeling with a more realistic approach that introduces multiple layers to take account of possibly varying conditions along the LoS. We used the IRAM-30m data from the ORION-B large program toward the Horsehead nebula in order to demonstrate our method’s capability and effectiveness. Methods. We propose a cloud model composed of three homogeneous slabs of gas along each LoS, representing an outer envelope and a more shielded inner layer. We used the non-LTE radiative transfer code RADEX to model the line profiles from the kinetic temperature (Tkin), the volume density (nH2), kinematics, and chemical properties of the different layers. We then used a fast and robust maximum likelihood estimator to simultaneously fit the observed lines of the CO and HCO+ isotopologues. To limit the variance on the estimates, we propose a simple chemical model by constraining the column densities. Results. A single-layer model cannot reproduce the spectral line asymmetries that result from a combination of different radial velocities and absorption effects among layers. A minimal heterogeneous model (three layers only) is sufficient for the Horsehead application, as it provides good fits of the seven fitted lines over a large part of the studied field of view. The decomposition of the intensity into three layers allowed us to discuss the distribution of the estimated physical or chemical properties along the LoS. About 80% of the 12CO integrated intensity comes from the outer envelope, while ~55% of the integrated intensity of the (1 − 0) and (2 − 1) lines of C18O comes from the inner layer. For the lines of the 13CO and the HCO+ isotopologues, integrated intensities are more equally distributed over the cloud layers. The estimated column density ratio N(13CO)/N(C18O) in the envelope increases with decreasing visual extinction, and it reaches 25 in the pillar outskirts. While the inferred Tkin of the envelope varies from 25 to 40 K, that of the inner layer drops to ~15 K in the western dense core. The estimated nH2 in the inner layer is ~3 × 104 cm−3 toward the filament, and it increases by a factor of ten toward dense cores. Conclusions. Our proposed method correctly retrieves the physical and chemical properties of the Horsehead nebula. It also offers promising prospects for less supervised model fits of wider-field datasets.
- 12 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A160
Open AccessToward a robust physical and chemical characterization of heterogeneous lines of sight: The case of the Horsehead nebula
Context. Dense and cold molecular cores and filaments are surrounded by an envelope of translucent gas. Some of the low-J emission lines of CO and HCO+ isotopologues are more sensitive to the conditions either in the translucent environment or in the dense and cold one because their intensities result from a complex interplay of radiative transfer and chemical properties of these heterogeneous lines of sight (LoSs). Aims. We extend our previous single-zone modeling with a more realistic approach that introduces multiple layers to take account of possibly varying conditions along the LoS. We used the IRAM-30m data from the ORION-B large program toward the Horsehead nebula in order to demonstrate our method’s capability and effectiveness. Methods. We propose a cloud model composed of three homogeneous slabs of gas along each LoS, representing an outer envelope and a more shielded inner layer. We used the non-LTE radiative transfer code RADEX to model the line profiles from the kinetic temperature (Tkin), the volume density (nH2), kinematics, and chemical properties of the different layers. We then used a fast and robust maximum likelihood estimator to simultaneously fit the observed lines of the CO and HCO+ isotopologues. To limit the variance on the estimates, we propose a simple chemical model by constraining the column densities. Results. A single-layer model cannot reproduce the spectral line asymmetries that result from a combination of different radial velocities and absorption effects among layers. A minimal heterogeneous model (three layers only) is sufficient for the Horsehead application, as it provides good fits of the seven fitted lines over a large part of the studied field of view. The decomposition of the intensity into three layers allowed us to discuss the distribution of the estimated physical or chemical properties along the LoS. About 80% of the 12CO integrated intensity comes from the outer envelope, while ~55% of the integrated intensity of the (1 − 0) and (2 − 1) lines of C18O comes from the inner layer. For the lines of the 13CO and the HCO+ isotopologues, integrated intensities are more equally distributed over the cloud layers. The estimated column density ratio N(13CO)/N(C18O) in the envelope increases with decreasing visual extinction, and it reaches 25 in the pillar outskirts. While the inferred Tkin of the envelope varies from 25 to 40 K, that of the inner layer drops to ~15 K in the western dense core. The estimated nH2 in the inner layer is ~3 × 104 cm−3 toward the filament, and it increases by a factor of ten toward dense cores. Conclusions. Our proposed method correctly retrieves the physical and chemical properties of the Horsehead nebula. It also offers promising prospects for less supervised model fits of wider-field datasets.
- Open Access
- 11 November 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 691, A109
Quantifying the informativity of emission lines to infer physical conditions in giant molecular clouds
Context. Observations of ionic, atomic, or molecular lines are performed to improve our understanding of the interstellar medium (ISM). However, the potential of a line to constrain the physical conditions of the ISM is difficult to assess quantitatively, because of the complexity of the ISM physics. The situation is even more complex when trying to assess which combinations of lines are the most useful. Therefore, observation campaigns usually try to observe as many lines as possible for as much time as possible. Aims. We have searched for a quantitative statistical criterion to evaluate the full constraining power of a (combination of) tracer(s) with respect to physical conditions. Our goal with such a criterion is twofold. First, we want to improve our understanding of the statistical relationships between ISM tracers and physical conditions. Secondly, by exploiting this criterion, we aim to propose a method that helps observers to make their observation proposals; for example, by choosing to observe the lines with the highest constraining power given limited resources and time. Methods. We propose an approach based on information theory, in particular the concepts of conditional differential entropy and mutual information. The best (combination of) tracer(s) is obtained by comparing the mutual information between a physical parameter and different sets of lines. The presented analysis is independent of the choice of the estimation algorithm (e.g., neural network or χ2 minimization). We applied this method to simulations of radio molecular lines emitted by a photodissociation region similar to the Horsehead Nebula. In this simulated data, we considered the noise properties of a state-of-the-art single dish telescope such as the IRAM 30m telescope. We searched for the best lines to constrain the visual extinction, AVtot, or the ultraviolet illumination field, G0. We ran this search for different gas regimes, namely translucent gas, filamentary gas, and dense cores. Results. The most informative lines change with the physical regime (e.g., cloud extinction). However, the determination of the optimal (combination of) line(s) to constrain a physical parameter such as the visual extinction depends not only on the radiative transfer of the lines and chemistry of the associated species, but also on the achieved mean signal-to-noise ratio. The short integration time of the CO isotopologue J = 1 − 0 lines already yields much information on the total column density for a large range of (AVtot, G0) space. The best set of lines to constrain the visual extinction does not necessarily combine the most informative individual lines. Precise constraints on the radiation field are more difficult to achieve with molecular lines. They require spectral lines emitted at the cloud surface (e.g., [CII] and [CI] lines). Conclusions. This approach allows one to better explore the knowledge provided by ISM codes, and to guide future observation campaigns.
- 11 November 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 691, A109
Open AccessQuantifying the informativity of emission lines to infer physical conditions in giant molecular clouds
Context. Observations of ionic, atomic, or molecular lines are performed to improve our understanding of the interstellar medium (ISM). However, the potential of a line to constrain the physical conditions of the ISM is difficult to assess quantitatively, because of the complexity of the ISM physics. The situation is even more complex when trying to assess which combinations of lines are the most useful. Therefore, observation campaigns usually try to observe as many lines as possible for as much time as possible. Aims. We have searched for a quantitative statistical criterion to evaluate the full constraining power of a (combination of) tracer(s) with respect to physical conditions. Our goal with such a criterion is twofold. First, we want to improve our understanding of the statistical relationships between ISM tracers and physical conditions. Secondly, by exploiting this criterion, we aim to propose a method that helps observers to make their observation proposals; for example, by choosing to observe the lines with the highest constraining power given limited resources and time. Methods. We propose an approach based on information theory, in particular the concepts of conditional differential entropy and mutual information. The best (combination of) tracer(s) is obtained by comparing the mutual information between a physical parameter and different sets of lines. The presented analysis is independent of the choice of the estimation algorithm (e.g., neural network or χ2 minimization). We applied this method to simulations of radio molecular lines emitted by a photodissociation region similar to the Horsehead Nebula. In this simulated data, we considered the noise properties of a state-of-the-art single dish telescope such as the IRAM 30m telescope. We searched for the best lines to constrain the visual extinction, AVtot, or the ultraviolet illumination field, G0. We ran this search for different gas regimes, namely translucent gas, filamentary gas, and dense cores. Results. The most informative lines change with the physical regime (e.g., cloud extinction). However, the determination of the optimal (combination of) line(s) to constrain a physical parameter such as the visual extinction depends not only on the radiative transfer of the lines and chemistry of the associated species, but also on the achieved mean signal-to-noise ratio. The short integration time of the CO isotopologue J = 1 − 0 lines already yields much information on the total column density for a large range of (AVtot, G0) space. The best set of lines to constrain the visual extinction does not necessarily combine the most informative individual lines. Precise constraints on the radiation field are more difficult to achieve with molecular lines. They require spectral lines emitted at the cloud surface (e.g., [CII] and [CI] lines). Conclusions. This approach allows one to better explore the knowledge provided by ISM codes, and to guide future observation campaigns.
- Open Access
- 20 June 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 686, A255
Bias versus variance when fitting multi-species molecular lines with a non-LTE radiative transfer model
Context. Robust radiative transfer techniques are requisite for efficiently extracting the physical and chemical information from molecular rotational lines. Aims. We study several hypotheses that enable robust estimations of the column densities and physical conditions when fitting one or two transitions per molecular species. We study the extent to which simplifying assumptions aimed at reducing the complexity of the problem introduce estimation biases and how to detect them. Methods. We focus on the CO and HCO+ isotopologues and analyze maps of a 50 square arcminutes field. We used the RADEX escape probability model to solve the statistical equilibrium equations and compute the emerging line profiles, assuming that all species coexist. Depending on the considered set of species, we also fixed the abundance ratio between some species and explored different values. We proposed a maximum likelihood estimator to infer the physical conditions and considered the effect of both the thermal noise and calibration uncertainty. We analyzed any potential biases induced by model misspecifications by comparing the results on the actual data for several sets of species and confirmed with Monte Carlo simulations. The variance of the estimations and the efficiency of the estimator were studied based on the Cramér-Rao lower bound. Results. Column densities can be estimated with 30% accuracy, while the best estimations of the volume density are found to be within a factor of two. Under the chosen model framework, the peak 12CO (1 – 0) is useful for constraining the kinetic temperature. The thermal pressure is better and more robustly estimated than the volume density and kinetic temperature separately. Analyzing CO and HCO+ isotopologues and fitting the full line profile are recommended practices with respect to detecting possible biases. Conclusions. Combining a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium model with a rigorous analysis of the accuracy allows us to obtain an efficient estimator and identify where the model is misspecified. We note that other combinations of molecular lines could be studied in the future.
- 20 June 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 686, A255
Open AccessBias versus variance when fitting multi-species molecular lines with a non-LTE radiative transfer model
Context. Robust radiative transfer techniques are requisite for efficiently extracting the physical and chemical information from molecular rotational lines. Aims. We study several hypotheses that enable robust estimations of the column densities and physical conditions when fitting one or two transitions per molecular species. We study the extent to which simplifying assumptions aimed at reducing the complexity of the problem introduce estimation biases and how to detect them. Methods. We focus on the CO and HCO+ isotopologues and analyze maps of a 50 square arcminutes field. We used the RADEX escape probability model to solve the statistical equilibrium equations and compute the emerging line profiles, assuming that all species coexist. Depending on the considered set of species, we also fixed the abundance ratio between some species and explored different values. We proposed a maximum likelihood estimator to infer the physical conditions and considered the effect of both the thermal noise and calibration uncertainty. We analyzed any potential biases induced by model misspecifications by comparing the results on the actual data for several sets of species and confirmed with Monte Carlo simulations. The variance of the estimations and the efficiency of the estimator were studied based on the Cramér-Rao lower bound. Results. Column densities can be estimated with 30% accuracy, while the best estimations of the volume density are found to be within a factor of two. Under the chosen model framework, the peak 12CO (1 – 0) is useful for constraining the kinetic temperature. The thermal pressure is better and more robustly estimated than the volume density and kinetic temperature separately. Analyzing CO and HCO+ isotopologues and fitting the full line profile are recommended practices with respect to detecting possible biases. Conclusions. Combining a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium model with a rigorous analysis of the accuracy allows us to obtain an efficient estimator and identify where the model is misspecified. We note that other combinations of molecular lines could be studied in the future.
- Open Access
- 29 April 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 684, A212
The magnetic field in the Flame nebula
Context.Star formation drives the evolution of galaxies and the cycling of matter between different phases of the interstellar medium and stars. The support of interstellar clouds against gravitational collapse by magnetic fields has been proposed as a possible explanation for the low observed star formation efficiency in galaxies and the Milky Way. ThePlancksatellite provided the first all-sky map of the magnetic field geometry in the diffuse interstellar medium on angular scales of 5–15′. However, higher spatial resolution observations are required to understand the transition from diffuse, subcritical gas to dense, gravitationally unstable filaments.Aims.NGC 2024, also known as the Flame nebula, is located in the nearby Orion B molecular cloud. It contains a young, expanding HIIregion and a dense supercritical filament. This filament harbors embedded protostellar objects and is likely not supported by the magnetic field against gravitational collapse. Therefore, NGC 2024 provides an excellent opportunity to study the role of magnetic fields in the formation, evolution, and collapse of dense filaments, the dynamics of young HIIregions, and the effects of mechanical and radiative feedback from massive stars on the surrounding molecular gas.Methods.We combined new 154 and 216 μm dust polarization measurements carried out using the HAWC+ instrument aboard SOFIA with molecular line observations of12CN(1−0) and HCO+(1−0) from the IRAM 30-m telescope to determine the magnetic field geometry, and to estimate the plane of the sky magnetic field strength across the NGC 2024 HIIregion and the surrounding molecular cloud.Results.The HAWC+ observations show an ordered magnetic field geometry in NGC 2024 that follows the morphology of the expanding HIIregion and the direction of the main dense filament. The derived plane of the sky magnetic field strength is moderate, ranging from 30 to 80 μG. The strongest magnetic field is found at the eastern edge of the HIIregion, characterized by the highest gas densities and molecular line widths. In contrast, the weakest field is found toward the main, dense filament in NGC 2024.Conclusions.We find that the magnetic field has a non-negligible influence on the gas stability at the edges of the expanding HIIshell (gas impacted by stellar feedback) and the filament (site of current star formation).
- 29 April 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 684, A212
Open AccessThe magnetic field in the Flame nebula
Context.Star formation drives the evolution of galaxies and the cycling of matter between different phases of the interstellar medium and stars. The support of interstellar clouds against gravitational collapse by magnetic fields has been proposed as a possible explanation for the low observed star formation efficiency in galaxies and the Milky Way. ThePlancksatellite provided the first all-sky map of the magnetic field geometry in the diffuse interstellar medium on angular scales of 5–15′. However, higher spatial resolution observations are required to understand the transition from diffuse, subcritical gas to dense, gravitationally unstable filaments.Aims.NGC 2024, also known as the Flame nebula, is located in the nearby Orion B molecular cloud. It contains a young, expanding HIIregion and a dense supercritical filament. This filament harbors embedded protostellar objects and is likely not supported by the magnetic field against gravitational collapse. Therefore, NGC 2024 provides an excellent opportunity to study the role of magnetic fields in the formation, evolution, and collapse of dense filaments, the dynamics of young HIIregions, and the effects of mechanical and radiative feedback from massive stars on the surrounding molecular gas.Methods.We combined new 154 and 216 μm dust polarization measurements carried out using the HAWC+ instrument aboard SOFIA with molecular line observations of12CN(1−0) and HCO+(1−0) from the IRAM 30-m telescope to determine the magnetic field geometry, and to estimate the plane of the sky magnetic field strength across the NGC 2024 HIIregion and the surrounding molecular cloud.Results.The HAWC+ observations show an ordered magnetic field geometry in NGC 2024 that follows the morphology of the expanding HIIregion and the direction of the main dense filament. The derived plane of the sky magnetic field strength is moderate, ranging from 30 to 80 μG. The strongest magnetic field is found at the eastern edge of the HIIregion, characterized by the highest gas densities and molecular line widths. In contrast, the weakest field is found toward the main, dense filament in NGC 2024.Conclusions.We find that the magnetic field has a non-negligible influence on the gas stability at the edges of the expanding HIIshell (gas impacted by stellar feedback) and the filament (site of current star formation).
- Open Access
- 30 October 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 679, A4
HCN emission from translucent gas and UV-illuminated cloud edges revealed by wide-field IRAM 30 m maps of the Orion B GMC
Context. Massive stars form within dense clumps inside giant molecular clouds (GMCs). Finding appropriate chemical tracers of the dense gas (n(H2) > several 104 cm−3 or AV > 8 mag) and linking their line luminosity with the star formation rate is of critical importance. Aims. Our aim is to determine the origin and physical conditions of the HCN-emitting gas and study their relation to those of other molecules. Methods. In the context of the IRAM 30m ORION-B large program, we present 5 deg2 (~250 pc2) HCN, HNC, HCO+, and CO J =1–0 maps of the Orion B GMC, complemented with existing wide-field [C I] 492 GHz maps, as well as new pointed observations of rotationally excited HCN, HNC, H13CN, and HN13C lines. We compare the observed HCN line intensities with radiative transfer models including line overlap effects and electron excitation. Furthermore, we study the HCN/HNC isomeric abundance ratio with updated photochemical models. Results. We spectroscopically resolve the HCN J = 1–0 hyperfine structure (HFS) components (and partially resolved J = 2−1 and 3−2 components). We detect anomalous HFS line intensity (and line width) ratios almost everywhere in the cloud. About 70% of the total HCN J = 1−0 luminosity, L′(HCN J = 1−0) = 110 K km s−1 pc−2, arises from AV < 8 mag. The HCN/CO J = 1−0 line intensity ratio, widely used as a tracer of the dense gas fraction, shows a bimodal behavior with an inflection point at AV < 3 mag typical of translucent gas and illuminated cloud edges. We find that most of the HCN J = 1−0 emission arises from extended gas with n(H2) < 104 cm−3, and even lower density gas if the ionization fraction is χe ≥ 10−5 and electron excitation dominates. This result contrasts with the prevailing view of HCN J = 1−0 emission as a tracer of dense gas and explains the low-AV branch of the HCN/CO J = 1−0 intensity ratio distribution. Indeed, the highest HCN/CO ratios (~ 0.1) at AV < 3 mag correspond to regions of high [C I] 492 GHz/CO J = 1−0 intensity ratios (>1) characteristic of low-density photodissociation regions. The low surface brightness (≲ 1 K km s−1) and extended HCN and HCO+ J = 1−0 emission scale with IFIR – a proxy of the stellar far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation field – in a similar way. Together with CO J = 1−0, these lines respond to increasing IFIR up to G0 ≃ 20. On the other hand, the bright HCN J = 1−0 emission (> 6 K km s−1) from dense gas in star-forming clumps weakly responds to IFIR once the FUV field becomes too intense (G0 > 1500). In contrast, HNC J = 1−0 and [C I] 492 GHz lines weakly respond to IFIR for all G0. The different power law scalings (produced by different chemistries, densities, and line excitation regimes) in a single but spatially resolved GMC resemble the variety of Kennicutt-Schmidt law indexes found in galaxy averages. Conclusions. Given the widespread and extended nature of the [C I] 492 GHz emission, as well as its spatial correlation with that of HCO+, HCN, and 13CO J = 1−0 lines (in this order), we argue that the edges of GMCs are porous to FUV radiation from nearby massive stars. Enhanced FUV radiation favors the formation and excitation of HCN on large scales, not only in dense star-forming clumps, and it leads to a relatively low value of the dense gas mass to total luminosity ratio, α (HCN) = 29 M⊙/(K km s−1pc2) in Orion B. As a corollary for extragalactic studies, we conclude that high HCN/CO J = 1−0 line intensity ratios do not always imply the presence of dense gas, which may be better traced by HNC than by HCN.
- 30 October 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 679, A4
Open AccessHCN emission from translucent gas and UV-illuminated cloud edges revealed by wide-field IRAM 30 m maps of the Orion B GMC
Context. Massive stars form within dense clumps inside giant molecular clouds (GMCs). Finding appropriate chemical tracers of the dense gas (n(H2) > several 104 cm−3 or AV > 8 mag) and linking their line luminosity with the star formation rate is of critical importance. Aims. Our aim is to determine the origin and physical conditions of the HCN-emitting gas and study their relation to those of other molecules. Methods. In the context of the IRAM 30m ORION-B large program, we present 5 deg2 (~250 pc2) HCN, HNC, HCO+, and CO J =1–0 maps of the Orion B GMC, complemented with existing wide-field [C I] 492 GHz maps, as well as new pointed observations of rotationally excited HCN, HNC, H13CN, and HN13C lines. We compare the observed HCN line intensities with radiative transfer models including line overlap effects and electron excitation. Furthermore, we study the HCN/HNC isomeric abundance ratio with updated photochemical models. Results. We spectroscopically resolve the HCN J = 1–0 hyperfine structure (HFS) components (and partially resolved J = 2−1 and 3−2 components). We detect anomalous HFS line intensity (and line width) ratios almost everywhere in the cloud. About 70% of the total HCN J = 1−0 luminosity, L′(HCN J = 1−0) = 110 K km s−1 pc−2, arises from AV < 8 mag. The HCN/CO J = 1−0 line intensity ratio, widely used as a tracer of the dense gas fraction, shows a bimodal behavior with an inflection point at AV < 3 mag typical of translucent gas and illuminated cloud edges. We find that most of the HCN J = 1−0 emission arises from extended gas with n(H2) < 104 cm−3, and even lower density gas if the ionization fraction is χe ≥ 10−5 and electron excitation dominates. This result contrasts with the prevailing view of HCN J = 1−0 emission as a tracer of dense gas and explains the low-AV branch of the HCN/CO J = 1−0 intensity ratio distribution. Indeed, the highest HCN/CO ratios (~ 0.1) at AV < 3 mag correspond to regions of high [C I] 492 GHz/CO J = 1−0 intensity ratios (>1) characteristic of low-density photodissociation regions. The low surface brightness (≲ 1 K km s−1) and extended HCN and HCO+ J = 1−0 emission scale with IFIR – a proxy of the stellar far-ultraviolet (FUV) radiation field – in a similar way. Together with CO J = 1−0, these lines respond to increasing IFIR up to G0 ≃ 20. On the other hand, the bright HCN J = 1−0 emission (> 6 K km s−1) from dense gas in star-forming clumps weakly responds to IFIR once the FUV field becomes too intense (G0 > 1500). In contrast, HNC J = 1−0 and [C I] 492 GHz lines weakly respond to IFIR for all G0. The different power law scalings (produced by different chemistries, densities, and line excitation regimes) in a single but spatially resolved GMC resemble the variety of Kennicutt-Schmidt law indexes found in galaxy averages. Conclusions. Given the widespread and extended nature of the [C I] 492 GHz emission, as well as its spatial correlation with that of HCO+, HCN, and 13CO J = 1−0 lines (in this order), we argue that the edges of GMCs are porous to FUV radiation from nearby massive stars. Enhanced FUV radiation favors the formation and excitation of HCN on large scales, not only in dense star-forming clumps, and it leads to a relatively low value of the dense gas mass to total luminosity ratio, α (HCN) = 29 M⊙/(K km s−1pc2) in Orion B. As a corollary for extragalactic studies, we conclude that high HCN/CO J = 1−0 line intensity ratios do not always imply the presence of dense gas, which may be better traced by HNC than by HCN.