Heather V. Graham
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Heather V. Graham has a total of 196 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christopher H. House
Department of Geosciences, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA
3 shared publications - Daniel Seth Jones
Earth and Environmental Science, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology
3 shared publications - Jason P. Dworkin
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Greenbelt Maryland USA
3 shared publications - Jennifer C. Stern
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center
3 shared publications - Jose Carlos Aponte
Solar System Exploration Division NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Greenbelt Maryland USA
3 shared publications - Maurizio Mainiero
Gruppo Speleologico Marchigiano
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 August 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (34)
Potential survivable niches for microbial life on the lunar south pole
Most lunar surface conditions are incredibly harsh for microbial survival. High ultraviolet radiation, temperatures, and energetic particle radiation limit survival over most unprotected lunar surfaces, particularly in equatorial regions where all previous crewed exploration occurred. However, whether these harsh conditions are widespread at lunar poles has not been examined considering topographical effects. Here, we show that recent microorganism survivability data and lunar surface remote sensing reveal likely survivable niches in lunar polar regions. Analysis of topography and latitude-driven surface conditions using remote sensing data and high-resolution illumination models indicates the lunar south pole has substantial regions with persistent low temperatures and ultraviolet flux. Comparing these conditions to survivability data of specific microorganisms, we find that significant lunar polar areas likely have surface conditions amenable to microbial survival. Our findings suggest that lunar polar regions may be less hostile to microbial survival than previously assumed. This does not encompass growth likelihood, but survival in a cryptobiotic state where growth would be possible if habitable conditions were present. Potential microbial survivability at lunar poles is particularly significant given many examined microbes will likely be transported to the Moon during crewed lunar south pole exploration planned in numerous near-term missions. Thoughtfully planning exploration and tracking its impact is key to limiting and understanding potential unintended life transfer to the Moon.
- 21 August 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (34)
Open AccessPotential survivable niches for microbial life on the lunar south pole
Most lunar surface conditions are incredibly harsh for microbial survival. High ultraviolet radiation, temperatures, and energetic particle radiation limit survival over most unprotected lunar surfaces, particularly in equatorial regions where all previous crewed exploration occurred. However, whether these harsh conditions are widespread at lunar poles has not been examined considering topographical effects. Here, we show that recent microorganism survivability data and lunar surface remote sensing reveal likely survivable niches in lunar polar regions. Analysis of topography and latitude-driven surface conditions using remote sensing data and high-resolution illumination models indicates the lunar south pole has substantial regions with persistent low temperatures and ultraviolet flux. Comparing these conditions to survivability data of specific microorganisms, we find that significant lunar polar areas likely have surface conditions amenable to microbial survival. Our findings suggest that lunar polar regions may be less hostile to microbial survival than previously assumed. This does not encompass growth likelihood, but survival in a cryptobiotic state where growth would be possible if habitable conditions were present. Potential microbial survivability at lunar poles is particularly significant given many examined microbes will likely be transported to the Moon during crewed lunar south pole exploration planned in numerous near-term missions. Thoughtfully planning exploration and tracking its impact is key to limiting and understanding potential unintended life transfer to the Moon.
- Open Access
Compositional Heterogeneity Structures Microbial Microhabitats across Distinct Mineral Substrates
Microbial communities living on and in rocks operate at the microscale, where interactions with minerals fundamentally shape community structure and function. Yet the relationship between micron scale mineralogical configurations and microbial distributions remains poorly understood. We tested the hypothesis that microbial biomass spatially correlates with areas of heightened mineralogical heterogeneity by applying Raman microspectroscopy to rock samples from three geologically distinct substrates: authigenic carbonates from a marine methane seep, volcanic basalt from Iceland, and polymetallic nodules from the abyssal seafloor. Using spectral decomposition and multiple complementary metrics of compositional heterogeneity, we evaluated intra-pixel and inter-pixel heterogeneity patterns in relation to biomass distribution. Our analyses reveal three patterns across all sample types. 1) When spectra are deconstructed into their constituent components, biomass zones are disproportionately dominated by the biomass spectral component compared with primary mineral components in zones of different minerals. 2) Biomass spectra have more homogeneous compositional profiles than mineral spectra. 3) Biomass is surrounded by more heterogeneous microhabitats than mineral pixels. These findings demonstrate that biomass exerts a distinctive and consistent influence on Raman spectral signatures, both within and between pixels, in ways that mineral components do not. Our results establish generalizable principles linking microscale mineralogical properties to microbial biogeography; these properties could be used as a potential biosignature and may provide a standardized workflow applicable to diverse rock systems and astrobiological exploration strategies.
Open AccessCompositional Heterogeneity Structures Microbial Microhabitats across Distinct Mineral Substrates
Microbial communities living on and in rocks operate at the microscale, where interactions with minerals fundamentally shape community structure and function. Yet the relationship between micron scale mineralogical configurations and microbial distributions remains poorly understood. We tested the hypothesis that microbial biomass spatially correlates with areas of heightened mineralogical heterogeneity by applying Raman microspectroscopy to rock samples from three geologically distinct substrates: authigenic carbonates from a marine methane seep, volcanic basalt from Iceland, and polymetallic nodules from the abyssal seafloor. Using spectral decomposition and multiple complementary metrics of compositional heterogeneity, we evaluated intra-pixel and inter-pixel heterogeneity patterns in relation to biomass distribution. Our analyses reveal three patterns across all sample types. 1) When spectra are deconstructed into their constituent components, biomass zones are disproportionately dominated by the biomass spectral component compared with primary mineral components in zones of different minerals. 2) Biomass spectra have more homogeneous compositional profiles than mineral spectra. 3) Biomass is surrounded by more heterogeneous microhabitats than mineral pixels. These findings demonstrate that biomass exerts a distinctive and consistent influence on Raman spectral signatures, both within and between pixels, in ways that mineral components do not. Our results establish generalizable principles linking microscale mineralogical properties to microbial biogeography; these properties could be used as a potential biosignature and may provide a standardized workflow applicable to diverse rock systems and astrobiological exploration strategies.
- Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences
- Vol. 54 (1) , 585-604
Agnostic Biosignatures: Expanding the Search for Life in the Solar System
The search for life beyond Earth has long been a scientific goal, but as this quest expands, astrobiologists must grapple not only with where life may be but also with what life can be. Researchers now realize that our descriptions of biosignatures—the physical and chemical clues used to discern the presence of life—must expand to reflect fundamental features of living systems, not just analog expressions that assume a common heritage with Earth. These new biosignatures are thus agnostic in their relationship to life on Earth. New interdisciplinary endeavors now design generalized biosignatures that first consider the criteria and functions of life in any physical setting. These frameworks challenge the way we both seek and define life. Here we summarize the history of these efforts from their disciplinary roots and provide the conceptual foundations of the pursuit to sufficiently describe life without relying on definitions or familiar features. ▪ Agnostic biosignatures are indications of past or present biology that are not based on molecular or metabolic signs of life on Earth. ▪ The generalized search for life is rooted in both paleobiology and physics, where life is discerned from context and fundamental first principles. ▪ This work summarizes universal features and theories of life that recognize how biological systems differ from abiotic chemical systems. ▪ Proposed frameworks for a generalized search for life are described, as well as systematic needs for effective extraplanetary deployment.
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences
- Vol. 54 (1) , 585-604
Open AccessAgnostic Biosignatures: Expanding the Search for Life in the Solar System
The search for life beyond Earth has long been a scientific goal, but as this quest expands, astrobiologists must grapple not only with where life may be but also with what life can be. Researchers now realize that our descriptions of biosignatures—the physical and chemical clues used to discern the presence of life—must expand to reflect fundamental features of living systems, not just analog expressions that assume a common heritage with Earth. These new biosignatures are thus agnostic in their relationship to life on Earth. New interdisciplinary endeavors now design generalized biosignatures that first consider the criteria and functions of life in any physical setting. These frameworks challenge the way we both seek and define life. Here we summarize the history of these efforts from their disciplinary roots and provide the conceptual foundations of the pursuit to sufficiently describe life without relying on definitions or familiar features. ▪ Agnostic biosignatures are indications of past or present biology that are not based on molecular or metabolic signs of life on Earth. ▪ The generalized search for life is rooted in both paleobiology and physics, where life is discerned from context and fundamental first principles. ▪ This work summarizes universal features and theories of life that recognize how biological systems differ from abiotic chemical systems. ▪ Proposed frameworks for a generalized search for life are described, as well as systematic needs for effective extraplanetary deployment.
- Open Access
Volatilized ammonia supports extremophilic cave ecosystems with unusual nitrogen isotopic signatures
The sulfidic Frasassi cave system hosts a robust, subterranean ecosystem based on microbial lithoautotrophy. Curiously, acidic biofilms forming above degassing sulfidic cave streams, and the invertebrates that feed on them, are extremely depleted in nitrogen-15 (δ 15 N values less than -20‰). In this study, we tested the hypothesis that these low δ 15 N values result from the volatilization, trapping, and uptake of ammonia degassed from the circumneutral streams. We found that dissolved ammonium in the streams had δ 15 N values near +3‰, whereas NH 3 ( g ) in the cave atmosphere above streams exhibited δ 15 N values as low as -27‰, consistent with fractionation by NH 3 volatilization. Extremely acidic condensation droplets on cave walls efficiently trapped airborne NH 3 , accumulating up to 4 mM NH 4 + with δ 15 N values as low as -29‰, thereby confirming volatilized and trapped ammonia as the primary N source to cave wall biofilms and the extensive subsurface ecosystem they support. Airborne ammonia trapping represents a novel mechanism for biological N acquisition and provides abundant N for growth in an extreme subsurface environment that otherwise receives very limited nutrient input. Significance: Nitrogen is one of the most abundant elements in organic molecules, and is a key limiting nutrient in many ecosystems. We showed that acidic microbial biofilms in sulfidic caves scavenge trace amounts of airborne ammonia, enabling microbial primary production and supporting associated food webs, including animals, in an environment where nitrogen is otherwise extremely scarce. This process represents a novel mechanism of biological nutrient acquisition and results in biomass and organic matter more depleted in the heavy isotope of nitrogen ( 15 N) than almost all other biological materials on Earth. Extreme 15 N isotope depletion is therefore a potential signature of acidic underground ecosystems on Earth and other planetary bodies.
Open AccessVolatilized ammonia supports extremophilic cave ecosystems with unusual nitrogen isotopic signatures
The sulfidic Frasassi cave system hosts a robust, subterranean ecosystem based on microbial lithoautotrophy. Curiously, acidic biofilms forming above degassing sulfidic cave streams, and the invertebrates that feed on them, are extremely depleted in nitrogen-15 (δ 15 N values less than -20‰). In this study, we tested the hypothesis that these low δ 15 N values result from the volatilization, trapping, and uptake of ammonia degassed from the circumneutral streams. We found that dissolved ammonium in the streams had δ 15 N values near +3‰, whereas NH 3 ( g ) in the cave atmosphere above streams exhibited δ 15 N values as low as -27‰, consistent with fractionation by NH 3 volatilization. Extremely acidic condensation droplets on cave walls efficiently trapped airborne NH 3 , accumulating up to 4 mM NH 4 + with δ 15 N values as low as -29‰, thereby confirming volatilized and trapped ammonia as the primary N source to cave wall biofilms and the extensive subsurface ecosystem they support. Airborne ammonia trapping represents a novel mechanism for biological N acquisition and provides abundant N for growth in an extreme subsurface environment that otherwise receives very limited nutrient input. Significance: Nitrogen is one of the most abundant elements in organic molecules, and is a key limiting nutrient in many ecosystems. We showed that acidic microbial biofilms in sulfidic caves scavenge trace amounts of airborne ammonia, enabling microbial primary production and supporting associated food webs, including animals, in an environment where nitrogen is otherwise extremely scarce. This process represents a novel mechanism of biological nutrient acquisition and results in biomass and organic matter more depleted in the heavy isotope of nitrogen ( 15 N) than almost all other biological materials on Earth. Extreme 15 N isotope depletion is therefore a potential signature of acidic underground ecosystems on Earth and other planetary bodies.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2025
- Published by American Society for Microbiology in Applied and Environmental Microbiology
- Vol. 91 (10) , e0139725
Microbial ecology of acidic, biogenic gypsum: community structure and distribution of extremophiles on freshly formed and relict sulfate deposits in a hydrogen sulfide-rich cave
Sulfate minerals are abundant on the Martian surface, and many of these evaporite deposits are thought to have precipitated from acidic fluids. On Earth, gypsum (CaSO 4 •2H 2 O) and other sulfates sometimes form under acidic conditions, so exploring the extremophilic life that occurs in these mineral environments can help evaluate the astrobiological potential of acid sulfate depositional settings. Here, we characterized the microbial communities associated with acidic gypsum deposits in a sulfuric acid cave, where sulfate precipitation is driven by sulfide-oxidizing bacteria and archaea. We used 16S rRNA gene sequencing and cell counts to characterize gypsum-associated microorganisms in freshly formed and relict deposits throughout the cave, to test how microbial community composition and abundance would vary with distance from the sulfidic water table and with the concentration of H 2 S( g ) and other gases in the cave atmosphere. We found that actively forming gypsum in the lower cave levels was colonized by low-diversity communities that have few cells compared to other environments in the cave. The most abundant taxa were Acidithiobacillus, Metallibacterium, Mycobacteria , and three different Thermoplasmatales -group archaea, which occupied distinct niches based on proximity to sulfidic streams and the concentration of gases in the cave air. By contrast, deposits in older cave levels had more diverse communities that were distinct from those associated with freshly formed gypsum and likely represent a community reliant on different energy resources. These findings show that acidic sulfate deposits serve as habitats for extremophilic microorganisms and broaden our knowledge of the life associated with terrestrial sulfates. IMPORTANCE: Gypsum and other sulfate salts are common on Mars, and many of these deposits are thought to have formed from acidic fluids early in the planet’s history. Understanding the life that survives and thrives in similar environments on Earth is therefore crucial for evaluating whether these Martian sulfates are or ever were habitable. One such environment where acidic gypsum occurs is in sulfuric acid caves, where extremophilic microorganisms drive the precipitation of sulfate minerals by oxidizing hydrogen sulfide gas from the cave atmosphere. Here, we characterized the communities of microorganisms on freshly formed and ancient gypsum in the Frasassi Caves and found that the gypsum deposits hosted microbial communities that changed based on chemical energy availability and the age of the gypsum. Our findings underscore the importance of chemical and microbiological interactions in shaping habitable niches and provide context for searching for past or present life in acidic Martian sulfates.
- 22 October 2025
- Published by American Society for Microbiology in Applied and Environmental Microbiology
- Vol. 91 (10) , e0139725
Open AccessMicrobial ecology of acidic, biogenic gypsum: community structure and distribution of extremophiles on freshly formed and relict sulfate deposits in a hydrogen sulfide-rich cave
Sulfate minerals are abundant on the Martian surface, and many of these evaporite deposits are thought to have precipitated from acidic fluids. On Earth, gypsum (CaSO 4 •2H 2 O) and other sulfates sometimes form under acidic conditions, so exploring the extremophilic life that occurs in these mineral environments can help evaluate the astrobiological potential of acid sulfate depositional settings. Here, we characterized the microbial communities associated with acidic gypsum deposits in a sulfuric acid cave, where sulfate precipitation is driven by sulfide-oxidizing bacteria and archaea. We used 16S rRNA gene sequencing and cell counts to characterize gypsum-associated microorganisms in freshly formed and relict deposits throughout the cave, to test how microbial community composition and abundance would vary with distance from the sulfidic water table and with the concentration of H 2 S( g ) and other gases in the cave atmosphere. We found that actively forming gypsum in the lower cave levels was colonized by low-diversity communities that have few cells compared to other environments in the cave. The most abundant taxa were Acidithiobacillus, Metallibacterium, Mycobacteria , and three different Thermoplasmatales -group archaea, which occupied distinct niches based on proximity to sulfidic streams and the concentration of gases in the cave air. By contrast, deposits in older cave levels had more diverse communities that were distinct from those associated with freshly formed gypsum and likely represent a community reliant on different energy resources. These findings show that acidic sulfate deposits serve as habitats for extremophilic microorganisms and broaden our knowledge of the life associated with terrestrial sulfates. IMPORTANCE: Gypsum and other sulfate salts are common on Mars, and many of these deposits are thought to have formed from acidic fluids early in the planet’s history. Understanding the life that survives and thrives in similar environments on Earth is therefore crucial for evaluating whether these Martian sulfates are or ever were habitable. One such environment where acidic gypsum occurs is in sulfuric acid caves, where extremophilic microorganisms drive the precipitation of sulfate minerals by oxidizing hydrogen sulfide gas from the cave atmosphere. Here, we characterized the communities of microorganisms on freshly formed and ancient gypsum in the Frasassi Caves and found that the gypsum deposits hosted microbial communities that changed based on chemical energy availability and the age of the gypsum. Our findings underscore the importance of chemical and microbiological interactions in shaping habitable niches and provide context for searching for past or present life in acidic Martian sulfates.
- Open Access
Microbial ecology of acidic, biogenic gypsum: Community structure and distribution of extremophiles on freshly formed and relict sulfate deposits in a hydrogen sulfide-rich cave
Sulfate minerals are abundant on the Martian surface, and many of these evaporite deposits are thought to have precipitated from acidic fluids. On Earth, gypsum (CaSO 4 •2H 2 O) and other sulfates sometimes form under acidic conditions, so exploring the extremophilic life that occurs in these mineral environments can help us evaluate the astrobiological potential of acid sulfate depositional settings. Here, we characterized the microbial communities associated with acidic gypsum deposits in a sulfuric acid cave, where sulfate precipitation is driven by sulfide-oxidizing bacteria and archaea. We used 16S rRNA gene sequencing and cell counts to characterize gypsum-associated microorganisms in freshly formed and relict deposits throughout the cave, in order to test hypotheses about how microbial community composition and abundance would vary with distance from the sulfidic water table and with the concentration of H 2 S( g ) and other gases in the cave atmosphere. We found that actively-forming gypsum in the lower cave levels was colonized by low diversity communities of sulfide-oxidizing chemolithotrophs and other acidophiles that have few cells compared to other environments in the cave. The most abundant taxa were Acidithiobacillus, Metallibacterium, Mycobacteria , and three different Thermoplasmatales -group archaea, which occupied distinct niches based on proximity to sulfidic streams and the concentration of gases in the cave air. In contrast, deposits in older cave levels had more diverse communities that are dominated by chemoorganotrophic and methanotrophic taxa. These findings show that acidic sulfate deposits serve as habitats for extremophilic microorganisms, and broaden our knowledge of the life associated with terrestrial sulfates. Importance: Gypsum and other sulfate salts are common on Mars, and many of these deposits are thought to have formed from acidic fluids early in the planet’s history. Understanding the life that survives and thrives in similar environments on Earth is therefore crucial for evaluating whether these Martian sulfates are or ever were habitable. One such environment where acidic gypsum occurs is in sulfuric acid caves, where extremophilic microorganisms drive the precipitation of sulfate minerals by oxidizing hydrogen sulfide gas from the cave atmosphere. Here, we characterized the communities of microorganisms on freshly formed and ancient gypsum in the Frasassi Caves, and found that the gypsum deposits hosted microbial communities that changed based on chemical energy availability and the age of the gypsum. Our findings underscore the importance of chemical and microbiological interactions in shaping habitable niches, and provide context for searching for past or present life in acidic Martian sulfates.
Open AccessMicrobial ecology of acidic, biogenic gypsum: Community structure and distribution of extremophiles on freshly formed and relict sulfate deposits in a hydrogen sulfide-rich cave
Sulfate minerals are abundant on the Martian surface, and many of these evaporite deposits are thought to have precipitated from acidic fluids. On Earth, gypsum (CaSO 4 •2H 2 O) and other sulfates sometimes form under acidic conditions, so exploring the extremophilic life that occurs in these mineral environments can help us evaluate the astrobiological potential of acid sulfate depositional settings. Here, we characterized the microbial communities associated with acidic gypsum deposits in a sulfuric acid cave, where sulfate precipitation is driven by sulfide-oxidizing bacteria and archaea. We used 16S rRNA gene sequencing and cell counts to characterize gypsum-associated microorganisms in freshly formed and relict deposits throughout the cave, in order to test hypotheses about how microbial community composition and abundance would vary with distance from the sulfidic water table and with the concentration of H 2 S( g ) and other gases in the cave atmosphere. We found that actively-forming gypsum in the lower cave levels was colonized by low diversity communities of sulfide-oxidizing chemolithotrophs and other acidophiles that have few cells compared to other environments in the cave. The most abundant taxa were Acidithiobacillus, Metallibacterium, Mycobacteria , and three different Thermoplasmatales -group archaea, which occupied distinct niches based on proximity to sulfidic streams and the concentration of gases in the cave air. In contrast, deposits in older cave levels had more diverse communities that are dominated by chemoorganotrophic and methanotrophic taxa. These findings show that acidic sulfate deposits serve as habitats for extremophilic microorganisms, and broaden our knowledge of the life associated with terrestrial sulfates. Importance: Gypsum and other sulfate salts are common on Mars, and many of these deposits are thought to have formed from acidic fluids early in the planet’s history. Understanding the life that survives and thrives in similar environments on Earth is therefore crucial for evaluating whether these Martian sulfates are or ever were habitable. One such environment where acidic gypsum occurs is in sulfuric acid caves, where extremophilic microorganisms drive the precipitation of sulfate minerals by oxidizing hydrogen sulfide gas from the cave atmosphere. Here, we characterized the communities of microorganisms on freshly formed and ancient gypsum in the Frasassi Caves, and found that the gypsum deposits hosted microbial communities that changed based on chemical energy availability and the age of the gypsum. Our findings underscore the importance of chemical and microbiological interactions in shaping habitable niches, and provide context for searching for past or present life in acidic Martian sulfates.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 9 (2) , 199-210
Abundant ammonia and nitrogen-rich soluble organic matter in samples from asteroid (101955) Bennu
Organic matter in meteorites reveals clues about early Solar System chemistry and the origin of molecules important to life, but terrestrial exposure complicates interpretation. Samples returned from the B-type asteroid Bennu by the Origins, Spectral Interpretation, Resource Identification, and Security–Regolith Explorer mission enabled us to study pristine carbonaceous astromaterial without uncontrolled exposure to Earth’s biosphere. Here we show that Bennu samples are volatile rich, with more carbon, nitrogen and ammonia than samples from asteroid Ryugu and most meteorites. Nitrogen-15 isotopic enrichments indicate that ammonia and other N-containing soluble molecules formed in a cold molecular cloud or the outer protoplanetary disk. We detected amino acids (including 14 of the 20 used in terrestrial biology), amines, formaldehyde, carboxylic acids, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and N-heterocycles (including all five nucleobases found in DNA and RNA), along with ~10,000 N-bearing chemical species. All chiral non-protein amino acids were racemic or nearly so, implying that terrestrial life’s left-handed chirality may not be due to bias in prebiotic molecules delivered by impacts. The relative abundances of amino acids and other soluble organics suggest formation and alteration by low-temperature reactions, possibly in NH 3 -rich fluids. Bennu’s parent asteroid developed in or accreted ices from a reservoir in the outer Solar System where ammonia ice was stable.
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 9 (2) , 199-210
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessAbundant ammonia and nitrogen-rich soluble organic matter in samples from asteroid (101955) Bennu
Organic matter in meteorites reveals clues about early Solar System chemistry and the origin of molecules important to life, but terrestrial exposure complicates interpretation. Samples returned from the B-type asteroid Bennu by the Origins, Spectral Interpretation, Resource Identification, and Security–Regolith Explorer mission enabled us to study pristine carbonaceous astromaterial without uncontrolled exposure to Earth’s biosphere. Here we show that Bennu samples are volatile rich, with more carbon, nitrogen and ammonia than samples from asteroid Ryugu and most meteorites. Nitrogen-15 isotopic enrichments indicate that ammonia and other N-containing soluble molecules formed in a cold molecular cloud or the outer protoplanetary disk. We detected amino acids (including 14 of the 20 used in terrestrial biology), amines, formaldehyde, carboxylic acids, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and N-heterocycles (including all five nucleobases found in DNA and RNA), along with ~10,000 N-bearing chemical species. All chiral non-protein amino acids were racemic or nearly so, implying that terrestrial life’s left-handed chirality may not be due to bias in prebiotic molecules delivered by impacts. The relative abundances of amino acids and other soluble organics suggest formation and alteration by low-temperature reactions, possibly in NH 3 -rich fluids. Bennu’s parent asteroid developed in or accreted ices from a reservoir in the outer Solar System where ammonia ice was stable.
- Open Access
- 27 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences
- Vol. 11, 1485483
Operational considerations for approximating molecular assembly by Fourier transform mass spectrometry
Some of the most common life detection techniques for planetary exploration focus on organic molecule characterization, but life on other planets may not chemically resemble that found on Earth. Therefore, an agnostic detection system of signs of life (biosignatures) is essential. Assembly Theory (AT) is a conceptual tool for understanding evolution and object formation that has been useful in developing an approach to quantify molecular complexity via the Molecular Assembly index, which when combined with abundance, allows the total assembly number of a sample to be calculated. Because AT makes no assumptions about the chemistry of life, it is an agnostic tool that identifies molecular structures that are probabilistically more likely to have arisen via selection and therefore biological processes. AT uses graph theory to quantify molecular complexity by finding the shortest sequence of joining operations (e.g., chemical bonds) required to build a compound from a set of starting materials allowing recursive reuse of units or fragments. For molecules, this number of steps is the MA value. We explore the use of Fourier transform (i.e., Orbitrap) mass spectrometry for approximating MA by quantifying how a molecule breaks apart into fragments. We analyze amino acid and nucleoside standards individually and as mixtures, as well as amino acids from naturally occurring biological and meteoritic sources. Aside from sample type, we evaluate the effect of analyte concentration and fragmentation energies on the generated MA value. Additionally, an older Orbitrap model similar to flight prototype instrumentation, was tested. The raw mass spectrometry data was compared with two different MA processing algorithms - one that uses the parent molecule spectrum and molecular weight (recursive) and one that does not (non-recursive). Concentration, fragmentation energy, and sample type all influence the raw mass spectra. However, the recursive algorithm reports MA estimates that are more consistent across sample types, concentrations, and fragmentation energies. We discuss instrument requirements for approximating MA that can be applied to future flight and sample return missions.
- 27 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences
- Vol. 11, 1485483
Open AccessOperational considerations for approximating molecular assembly by Fourier transform mass spectrometry
Some of the most common life detection techniques for planetary exploration focus on organic molecule characterization, but life on other planets may not chemically resemble that found on Earth. Therefore, an agnostic detection system of signs of life (biosignatures) is essential. Assembly Theory (AT) is a conceptual tool for understanding evolution and object formation that has been useful in developing an approach to quantify molecular complexity via the Molecular Assembly index, which when combined with abundance, allows the total assembly number of a sample to be calculated. Because AT makes no assumptions about the chemistry of life, it is an agnostic tool that identifies molecular structures that are probabilistically more likely to have arisen via selection and therefore biological processes. AT uses graph theory to quantify molecular complexity by finding the shortest sequence of joining operations (e.g., chemical bonds) required to build a compound from a set of starting materials allowing recursive reuse of units or fragments. For molecules, this number of steps is the MA value. We explore the use of Fourier transform (i.e., Orbitrap) mass spectrometry for approximating MA by quantifying how a molecule breaks apart into fragments. We analyze amino acid and nucleoside standards individually and as mixtures, as well as amino acids from naturally occurring biological and meteoritic sources. Aside from sample type, we evaluate the effect of analyte concentration and fragmentation energies on the generated MA value. Additionally, an older Orbitrap model similar to flight prototype instrumentation, was tested. The raw mass spectrometry data was compared with two different MA processing algorithms - one that uses the parent molecule spectrum and molecular weight (recursive) and one that does not (non-recursive). Concentration, fragmentation energy, and sample type all influence the raw mass spectra. However, the recursive algorithm reports MA estimates that are more consistent across sample types, concentrations, and fragmentation energies. We discuss instrument requirements for approximating MA that can be applied to future flight and sample return missions.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society
- Vol. 56 (1)
Moon: Handle With Care
The exploration of the Moon involves multiple and complex competing interests, including those of nation states and commercial entities. This article identifies important science questions whose answers may be obscured by human activities on the Moon. We aim to encourage follow-on work to produce environmental impact assessments for various lunar activities in order to understand the degree of contamination generated by different processes. We also encourage the preservation of scientifically important regions, as proposed by others (e.g., ; ; ). In the following sections, we discuss what measurements are necessary to determine how and where science investigations and exploration (commercial or otherwise) can be carried out concurrently. We advocate a strategy of concurrent exploration and science where possible, and for a science-first approach in cases where exploration may obscure scientific evidence that is uniquely preserved on the Moon.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society
- Vol. 56 (1)
Open AccessMoon: Handle With Care
The exploration of the Moon involves multiple and complex competing interests, including those of nation states and commercial entities. This article identifies important science questions whose answers may be obscured by human activities on the Moon. We aim to encourage follow-on work to produce environmental impact assessments for various lunar activities in order to understand the degree of contamination generated by different processes. We also encourage the preservation of scientifically important regions, as proposed by others (e.g., ; ; ). In the following sections, we discuss what measurements are necessary to determine how and where science investigations and exploration (commercial or otherwise) can be carried out concurrently. We advocate a strategy of concurrent exploration and science where possible, and for a science-first approach in cases where exploration may obscure scientific evidence that is uniquely preserved on the Moon.
- 22 December 2023
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 382 (6677) , 1411-1416
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in samples of Ryugu formed in the interstellar medium
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contain ≲20% of the carbon in the interstellar medium. They are potentially produced in circumstellar environments (at temperatures ≳1000 kelvin), by (~10 kelvin) interstellar clouds, or by processing of carbon-rich dust grains. We report isotopic properties of PAHs extracted from samples of the asteroid Ryugu and the meteorite Murchison. The doubly- 13 C substituted compositions (Δ2× 13 C values) of the PAHs naphthalene, fluoranthene, and pyrene are 9 to 51‰ higher than values expected for a stochastic distribution of isotopes. The Δ2× 13 C values are higher than expected if the PAHs formed in a circumstellar environment, but consistent with formation in the interstellar medium. By contrast, the PAHs phenanthrene and anthracene in Ryugu samples have Δ2× 13 C values consistent with formation by higher-temperature reactions.
- 22 December 2023
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 382 (6677) , 1411-1416
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in samples of Ryugu formed in the interstellar medium
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contain ≲20% of the carbon in the interstellar medium. They are potentially produced in circumstellar environments (at temperatures ≳1000 kelvin), by (~10 kelvin) interstellar clouds, or by processing of carbon-rich dust grains. We report isotopic properties of PAHs extracted from samples of the asteroid Ryugu and the meteorite Murchison. The doubly- 13 C substituted compositions (Δ2× 13 C values) of the PAHs naphthalene, fluoranthene, and pyrene are 9 to 51‰ higher than values expected for a stochastic distribution of isotopes. The Δ2× 13 C values are higher than expected if the PAHs formed in a circumstellar environment, but consistent with formation in the interstellar medium. By contrast, the PAHs phenanthrene and anthracene in Ryugu samples have Δ2× 13 C values consistent with formation by higher-temperature reactions.