Francesco Balzan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Francesco Balzan has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Federica Russo
Freudenthal Institute, Utrecht University
2 shared publicationsLorenzo Angeli
2 shared publications- Lorenzo Angeli
University of Trento, Trento, Italy
2 shared publications - Maurizio Gabbrielli
University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
2 shared publications Ralph Meulenbroeks
Freudenthal Institute, Utrecht University
2 shared publications- Amine Hatun Ataş
Galatasaray University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Artificial Intelligence in Education
- Vol. 2 (1) , 18-32
Tools or crutches? Budgeting human and machine autonomy when introducing GenAI in education
Purpose: Generative AI (GenAI) in education brings renewed attention to learner autonomy – that is, whether learners can think and act independently. GenAI offers the promise of learning efficiency and personalization, while raising questions about its alignment with nurturing autonomous learners. In this paper, we present a theoretical framework to investigate the relationship between GenAI and learner autonomy, to guide the design of educational environments that are safe and autonomy-supporting. Design/methodology/approach: Our paper explores the multifaceted nature of autonomy across the cognitive, philosophical, political and computing fields, connecting theories such as self-determination theory with reflections on machine autonomy. Leveraging Latour's Actor-Network Theory, our framework aims to elucidate how autonomy is distributed between human and non-human actors in educational environments. Findings: Our main contribution is the process of “autonomy budgeting”, viewing autonomy as a resource that is allocated and traded off between an ensemble of actors. Autonomy budgeting works as a guiding conceptual tool for researchers, educators, curriculum designers and policymakers to assess and manage the autonomy trade-offs involved in integrating GenAI into educational environments. Research limitations/implications: By re-centering the learner's agency and capacity for self-regulation, autonomy budgeting provides a way to conceptualize and operationalize autonomy within AI-mediated education, and to navigate the complex interplay between human and machine agency in education. Originality/value: Our framework develops reflections on the socio-technical nature of educational processes, where technologies act as co-participants rather than neutral tools. Autonomy in education, becomes a multifaceted construct that spans (human) cognitive, epistemic and political domains, and must be considered vis-a-vis varying degrees of machine autonomy.
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Artificial Intelligence in Education
- Vol. 2 (1) , 18-32
Open AccessTools or crutches? Budgeting human and machine autonomy when introducing GenAI in education
Purpose: Generative AI (GenAI) in education brings renewed attention to learner autonomy – that is, whether learners can think and act independently. GenAI offers the promise of learning efficiency and personalization, while raising questions about its alignment with nurturing autonomous learners. In this paper, we present a theoretical framework to investigate the relationship between GenAI and learner autonomy, to guide the design of educational environments that are safe and autonomy-supporting. Design/methodology/approach: Our paper explores the multifaceted nature of autonomy across the cognitive, philosophical, political and computing fields, connecting theories such as self-determination theory with reflections on machine autonomy. Leveraging Latour's Actor-Network Theory, our framework aims to elucidate how autonomy is distributed between human and non-human actors in educational environments. Findings: Our main contribution is the process of “autonomy budgeting”, viewing autonomy as a resource that is allocated and traded off between an ensemble of actors. Autonomy budgeting works as a guiding conceptual tool for researchers, educators, curriculum designers and policymakers to assess and manage the autonomy trade-offs involved in integrating GenAI into educational environments. Research limitations/implications: By re-centering the learner's agency and capacity for self-regulation, autonomy budgeting provides a way to conceptualize and operationalize autonomy within AI-mediated education, and to navigate the complex interplay between human and machine agency in education. Originality/value: Our framework develops reflections on the socio-technical nature of educational processes, where technologies act as co-participants rather than neutral tools. Autonomy in education, becomes a multifaceted construct that spans (human) cognitive, epistemic and political domains, and must be considered vis-a-vis varying degrees of machine autonomy.
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 60-73
Comparing a Human’s and a Multi-Agent System’s Thematic Analysis: Assessing Qualitative Coding Consistency
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 60-73
Comparing a Human’s and a Multi-Agent System’s Thematic Analysis: Assessing Qualitative Coding Consistency
- Open Access
A Computational Model of Inclusive Pedagogy: From Understanding to Application
Human education transcends mere knowledge transfer, it relies on co-adaptation dynamics -- the mutual adjustment of teaching and learning strategies between agents. Despite its centrality, computational models of co-adaptive teacher-student interactions (T-SI) remain underdeveloped. We argue that this gap impedes Educational Science in testing and scaling contextual insights across diverse settings, and limits the potential of Machine Learning systems, which struggle to emulate and adaptively support human learning processes. To address this, we present a computational T-SI model that integrates contextual insights on human education into a testable framework. We use the model to evaluate diverse T-SI strategies in a realistic synthetic classroom setting, simulating student groups with unequal access to sensory information. Results show that strategies incorporating co-adaptation principles (e.g., bidirectional agency) outperform unilateral approaches (i.e., where only the teacher or the student is active), improving the learning outcomes for all learning types. Beyond the testing and scaling of context-dependent educational insights, our model enables hypothesis generation in controlled yet adaptable environments. This work bridges non-computational theories of human education with scalable, inclusive AI in Education systems, providing a foundation for equitable technologies that dynamically adapt to learner needs.
Open AccessA Computational Model of Inclusive Pedagogy: From Understanding to Application
Human education transcends mere knowledge transfer, it relies on co-adaptation dynamics -- the mutual adjustment of teaching and learning strategies between agents. Despite its centrality, computational models of co-adaptive teacher-student interactions (T-SI) remain underdeveloped. We argue that this gap impedes Educational Science in testing and scaling contextual insights across diverse settings, and limits the potential of Machine Learning systems, which struggle to emulate and adaptively support human learning processes. To address this, we present a computational T-SI model that integrates contextual insights on human education into a testable framework. We use the model to evaluate diverse T-SI strategies in a realistic synthetic classroom setting, simulating student groups with unequal access to sensory information. Results show that strategies incorporating co-adaptation principles (e.g., bidirectional agency) outperform unilateral approaches (i.e., where only the teacher or the student is active), improving the learning outcomes for all learning types. Beyond the testing and scaling of context-dependent educational insights, our model enables hypothesis generation in controlled yet adaptable environments. This work bridges non-computational theories of human education with scalable, inclusive AI in Education systems, providing a foundation for equitable technologies that dynamically adapt to learner needs.
- Open Access
- 7 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
Tools or Crutches? Budgeting human and machine autonomy when introducing GenAI in education
Scholars have defined education as an endeavour to foster autonomy — empowering individuals to think and act independently. This positioning of autonomy at the centre of the learning process comes from several educational approaches, from cognitive to philosophical and political. The pivotal role of autonomy has also been emphasised and extensively studied in psychological approaches to learning and education, becoming an integral value in frameworks such as Self-Determination Theory. The prominent introduction of generative AI (GenAI), however, creates an urgency to (re)assess the role of autonomy in the educational process. While GenAI promises to enhance learning efficiency and accessibility, here we ask: do these tools align or conflict with the overarching goal of cultivating autonomous subjects? In this paper, we lay down a theoretical framework aimed at first, answering that question and second, informing the design of safe educational environments and practices. Our proposal is based on two key assumptions: (i) human educational processes should be understood through a distributed, socio-technical approach in which technologies are active participants; (ii) autonomy in education must be understood from a multidisciplinary perspective in which cognitive, epistemic, and political autonomies of humans interact with the different levels of machine autonomy. These assumptions inform our main contribution: the `autonomy budget', which enables teachers, curriculum designers, and institutional decision-makers to analyze the autonomy trade-offs arising from integrating GenAI in education. We conceptualize the autonomy budget as a zero-sum game of resource allocation, providing a theoretical lens to examine the educational impacts of GenAI adoption and to outline key policy elements for its use in specific pedagogical contexts.
- 7 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
Open AccessTools or Crutches? Budgeting human and machine autonomy when introducing GenAI in education
Scholars have defined education as an endeavour to foster autonomy — empowering individuals to think and act independently. This positioning of autonomy at the centre of the learning process comes from several educational approaches, from cognitive to philosophical and political. The pivotal role of autonomy has also been emphasised and extensively studied in psychological approaches to learning and education, becoming an integral value in frameworks such as Self-Determination Theory. The prominent introduction of generative AI (GenAI), however, creates an urgency to (re)assess the role of autonomy in the educational process. While GenAI promises to enhance learning efficiency and accessibility, here we ask: do these tools align or conflict with the overarching goal of cultivating autonomous subjects? In this paper, we lay down a theoretical framework aimed at first, answering that question and second, informing the design of safe educational environments and practices. Our proposal is based on two key assumptions: (i) human educational processes should be understood through a distributed, socio-technical approach in which technologies are active participants; (ii) autonomy in education must be understood from a multidisciplinary perspective in which cognitive, epistemic, and political autonomies of humans interact with the different levels of machine autonomy. These assumptions inform our main contribution: the `autonomy budget', which enables teachers, curriculum designers, and institutional decision-makers to analyze the autonomy trade-offs arising from integrating GenAI in education. We conceptualize the autonomy budget as a zero-sum game of resource allocation, providing a theoretical lens to examine the educational impacts of GenAI adoption and to outline key policy elements for its use in specific pedagogical contexts.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 80-86
A 2-Step Methodology for XAI in Education
- Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Who Pilots the Copilots? Mapping a Generative AI’s Actor-Network to assess its educational impacts
Generative AI (GenAI) is praised as a transformative force for education, with the potential to significantly alter teaching and learn- ing. Despite its promise, debates persist regarding GenAI impacts, with critical voices highlighting the necessity for thorough ethical scrutiny. While traditional ethical evaluations of GenAI tend to focus on the opacity of AI decision-making, we argue that the true challenge for eth- ical evaluation extends beyond the model themselves, and to the socio- technical networks shaping GenAI development and training. To address this limitation, we present an evaluation method, called Ethical Network Evaluation for AI (ENEA), which combines Latour’s Actor-Network The- ory — used to map network dynamics by tracing actors’ interests and values — with Brusseau’s AI Human Impact framework, which identi- fies ethical indicators for evaluating AI systems. By applying ENEA to GenAI “copilots” in education, we show how making Actor-Networks vis- ible lets us unveil a great variety of dilemmas, guiding ethical auditing and stakeholder discussions.
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessWho Pilots the Copilots? Mapping a Generative AI’s Actor-Network to assess its educational impacts
Generative AI (GenAI) is praised as a transformative force for education, with the potential to significantly alter teaching and learn- ing. Despite its promise, debates persist regarding GenAI impacts, with critical voices highlighting the necessity for thorough ethical scrutiny. While traditional ethical evaluations of GenAI tend to focus on the opacity of AI decision-making, we argue that the true challenge for eth- ical evaluation extends beyond the model themselves, and to the socio- technical networks shaping GenAI development and training. To address this limitation, we present an evaluation method, called Ethical Network Evaluation for AI (ENEA), which combines Latour’s Actor-Network The- ory — used to map network dynamics by tracing actors’ interests and values — with Brusseau’s AI Human Impact framework, which identi- fies ethical indicators for evaluating AI systems. By applying ENEA to GenAI “copilots” in education, we show how making Actor-Networks vis- ible lets us unveil a great variety of dilemmas, guiding ethical auditing and stakeholder discussions.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Distributed Science - The Scientific Process as Multi-Scale Active Inference
This paper applies the theory of active inference—a Bayesian theory of cognition—to provide a multi-scale description of science understood as a distributed, evidence-seeking process. This allows us to naturalise the scientific process in terms of dynamics that can be read as inference or Bayesian belief updating, i.e., processes that maximize the evidence for a generative model of the sensed and measured world. Our goal is to ground a computational framework that elucidates how individual cognitive processes contribute to the emergence of the scientific system, and reciprocally, how collective values, practices and technological advancements guide individual scientific cognition. Epistemologically, it also addresses some key questions, e.g., is science a special? And in what ways is scientific pursuit an existential imperative for all beings? Pragmatically, it proposes a way of simulating the practice of science, which may have a foundational role in the next generation of augmented intelligence systems.
- 17 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessDistributed Science - The Scientific Process as Multi-Scale Active Inference
This paper applies the theory of active inference—a Bayesian theory of cognition—to provide a multi-scale description of science understood as a distributed, evidence-seeking process. This allows us to naturalise the scientific process in terms of dynamics that can be read as inference or Bayesian belief updating, i.e., processes that maximize the evidence for a generative model of the sensed and measured world. Our goal is to ground a computational framework that elucidates how individual cognitive processes contribute to the emergence of the scientific system, and reciprocally, how collective values, practices and technological advancements guide individual scientific cognition. Epistemologically, it also addresses some key questions, e.g., is science a special? And in what ways is scientific pursuit an existential imperative for all beings? Pragmatically, it proposes a way of simulating the practice of science, which may have a foundational role in the next generation of augmented intelligence systems.