DEDorottya Egres

Dorottya Egres

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Dorottya Egres has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Discourse-Directive Function of Loci in the Argument Model of Topics

    by Dorottya Egres

    In argumentation theory, loci - also referred to as topoi - are commonly viewed as abstract sources of inference that guide the invention of arguments. Within the Argument Model of Topics (AMT), loci are analysed as sources of inference underlying individual arguments. This paper extends said view by arguing that loci perform a discourse-directive function beyond the level of individual arguments. This function is understood in an analytical sense and refers to how loci orient argumentative interaction by indicating the inferential relations along which issues become arguable in particular ways, such as procedural conditions, goals, constrained choices, conceptual boundaries, or source evaluation. Situated at the meso-level of analysis, this function exceeds the micro-level reconstruction of individual arguments while preceding the identification of recurring argumentative patterns at the macro-level. This paper shows how the reappearance of premises in extended debates, when repeatedly connected to conclusions through the same loci , recurrently instantiates the same inferential relations that orient argumentative interaction. These recurrent inferential relations do not themselves constitute argumentative patterns, but repetition makes these relations empirically traceable across argumentative contributions before the stabilization of argumentative patterns. The analytical framework is illustrated by examples from the controversy of nuclear energy production.

  • Open Access

    Impolite, uncivil and underage: a case study about the influence of socio-demographic factors on discursive sanctioning

    by Dorottya Egres

    According to the literature on impoliteness and political incivility, the evaluation of a transgressive communicative act depends on the context of the speech, the characteristics of the speaker and the audience, and many other factors. This paper examines how the socio-demographic background of a high school girl – who gave a profanity-laden public speech aimed at the political leaders of the country – can influence the evaluation as well as the discursive sanctions. Discursive sanctioning is conceptualized as the verbal proposal of retribution, describing the negative consequences the transgressor should endure. This research employs the methodology of frame analysis to investigate comments written by citizens in response to news media articles shared on Facebook, then creates a typology of discursive sanctions ranging from benign and constructive to harsh and destructive. Results show that age is a more prominent factor influencing the evaluation than gender, even though swearing is usually associated with young people. Results also show the overwhelming support of commenters; however, discursive sanctions include severe age- and gender-specific punishments.


  • Open Access

    The Relevance of Moral Emotional Appeals in Environmental Political Debates

    by Dorottya Egres

    This paper examines the relevance of moral emotional appeals in the mixed dialogue type of public debates between politicians about environmentalism, relying on the concepts of goals and emotional appeals from the informal logical tradition. This paper argues that if argumentative moves are evaluated according to the action-producing dialogue type’s collective goal which could be pressing for action on environmentalism, and politicians take on the role of emotional entrepreneurs, then moral emotional appeals by politicians could evoke moral emotions in the audience, thus encouraging them to become more environmentally friendly. The influence of moral emotions on individual sustainable choices is based on empirical research from political and environmental sciences. Résumé: Cet article examine la pertinence des appels émotionnels moraux dans les débats publics de type dialogue mixte entre politiciens sur l'environnementalisme, en s'appuyant sur les concepts d'objectifs et d'appels émotionnels issus de la tradition de la logique non formelle. Cet article soutient que si les démarches argumentatives sont évaluées en fonction de l'objectif collectif du dialogue productif d'action, qui pourrait inciter à agir en faveur de l'environnementalisme, et si les politiciens assument le rôle d'entrepreneurs émotionnels, alors les appels émotionnels moraux des politiciens pourraient susciter des émotions morales chez le public, l'incitant ainsi à devenir plus respectueux de l'environnement. L'influence des émotions morales sur les choix individuels durables est fondée sur des recherches empiriques en sciences politiques et environnementales.

  • Open Access

    Nuclear perceptions from radioactive blue to sustainable green: The EU taxonomy as reflection of a divided public

    by Dorottya Egres, Gábor Sarlós

    Following the Fukushima disaster, several European countries revisited their policies and decided to phase out nuclear energy production. More recently, however, the EU taxonomy proposed a classification system of environmentally sustainable economic activities and consequently reopened the debate regarding nuclear energy. This study analyses public comments about the inclusion or exclusion of nuclear energy as a response to climate change, in the conceptual frameworks of ecological modernization, sustainability and technological neutrality. The study highlights the challenge of shaping energy policies amid dynamic circumstances and diverse viewpoints. Proponents of nuclear energy emphasised its low‐carbon emissions and climate change mitigation potential, while opponents focused on issues of radioactive waste and environmental risks. The study reveals that sustainability emerges as a potential reconciling framework to match arguments to influence the EU's decision‐making, while it reflects the political primacy of this process. Finally, this research recommends improving feedback visibility and enhancing clear communication, and suggests further research directions to understand future EU nuclear energy policies.