Meg Kiseleva
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Meg Kiseleva has a total of 44 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Alison Cooper
Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, Cardiff University
6 shared publications- Judit Csontos
Cardiff University
6 shared publications Adrian Edwards
Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, Cardiff University
5 shared publicationsElizabeth Gillen
5 shared publications- Mala Mann
Cardiff University
5 shared publications Ruth Lewis
Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, Bangor University, United Kingdom
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Learnings from Healthcare Systems with Large Reductions in Cancer Mortality: A Rapid Evidence Summary
In Wales, cancer is responsible for more than one in four deaths. The incidence of cancer is on the rise and it is projected that by 2035, there will be approximately 24,000 new cancer cases each year in Wales compared to approximately 20,000 in 2019. A new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales will be announced in February 2027. This document was produced to gather learnings from other countries that have achieved improved cancer outcomes in recent years, to support the development of the strategy.The aim of this rapid evidence summary was to identify and describe structures and processes implemented at a national or regional level in countries that have significantly improved cancer outcomes in recent years.This rapid evidence summary consists of two parts. The first part summarised published evidence that directly linked cancer outcomes to country-level factors. Systematic searches of multiple academic and grey literature databases as well as supplementary searches were used to identify such evidence. The second part of this document reported learnings from countries with large reductions in mortality. Targeted searches for country-specific evidence were performed. Findings were summarised narratively.This rapid evidence summary identified only two studies linking relevant country-level factors, including healthcare system characteristics and characteristics of countries’ cancer plans and strategies, to cancer outcomes. To support the development of the new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales, learnings from countries that have seen large improvements in cancer mortality over the recent years have been identified and summarised. While it is difficult to directly link improvements in cancer outcomes in a country to national cancer plans, we hope that examples of cancer-related activities in a wide range of countries that have successfully reduced mortality will provide useful learnings. Due to the high variation in the country contexts, considerations about the applicability to Wales need to be made. In the report, we also discuss the policy and practice implications of the findings, and the research implications and evidence gaps.
- 19 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessLearnings from Healthcare Systems with Large Reductions in Cancer Mortality: A Rapid Evidence Summary
In Wales, cancer is responsible for more than one in four deaths. The incidence of cancer is on the rise and it is projected that by 2035, there will be approximately 24,000 new cancer cases each year in Wales compared to approximately 20,000 in 2019. A new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales will be announced in February 2027. This document was produced to gather learnings from other countries that have achieved improved cancer outcomes in recent years, to support the development of the strategy.The aim of this rapid evidence summary was to identify and describe structures and processes implemented at a national or regional level in countries that have significantly improved cancer outcomes in recent years.This rapid evidence summary consists of two parts. The first part summarised published evidence that directly linked cancer outcomes to country-level factors. Systematic searches of multiple academic and grey literature databases as well as supplementary searches were used to identify such evidence. The second part of this document reported learnings from countries with large reductions in mortality. Targeted searches for country-specific evidence were performed. Findings were summarised narratively.This rapid evidence summary identified only two studies linking relevant country-level factors, including healthcare system characteristics and characteristics of countries’ cancer plans and strategies, to cancer outcomes. To support the development of the new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales, learnings from countries that have seen large improvements in cancer mortality over the recent years have been identified and summarised. While it is difficult to directly link improvements in cancer outcomes in a country to national cancer plans, we hope that examples of cancer-related activities in a wide range of countries that have successfully reduced mortality will provide useful learnings. Due to the high variation in the country contexts, considerations about the applicability to Wales need to be made. In the report, we also discuss the policy and practice implications of the findings, and the research implications and evidence gaps.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
A rapid review of multi-agency working to support transition out of children’s social care
Transition from children’s social care is a complex and often challenging process, and coordination between different agencies, such as health, education, and social care, is important to ensure effective communication, engagement, and continuity of care. This review focuses on young people’s experiences with multi-agency approaches to support transition from children’s social care to adults’ social care or support, their perceptions of success of such approaches, and barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency approaches to transition and to young people engaging with them. This review included 22 UK studies published between 2014 and 2025. Seven of the studies focused on care leavers, six on young people with learning disabilities (LD) or special educational needs or disabilities (SEND), five on young people in the justice system, and four on other groups of young people. Many of the multi-agency initiatives primarily focused on housing support. For young people in the justice system, the initiatives mainly focused on resettlement in community. There were also studies about broader planning for support needs when the young person transitioned to adulthood.The experiences and perceived success of multi-agency working: Care leavers’ experiences of transitions varied, with some young people experiencing anxiety and distress. Perceptions of the benefits of initiatives often related to the quality of their relationship with their transition worker. Some young people said their confidence, general skills, social relationships, and mental health improved during their involvement in multi-agency initiatives. Little evidence was identified about experiences of young people with LD/SEND. For young people in the justice system, mixed experiences were described. Little information was identified about success of multi-agency work as perceived by young people. Some positive experiences with multi-agency working were also described.Barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency work: Barriers included insufficient resources, structural issues and policy and strategy limitations. Shared practices, priorities, and vision as well as information sharing between agencies were important. A significant practitioner-related factor was staff expertise. Barriers and facilitators of young people engaging with multi-agency work: Awareness of the services and flexibility in how young people could engage with them were important factors. More support with engagement for young people could act as a facilitator. Personal factors that might act as barriers to engagement for young people were identified. Good relationships with staff and positive staff attitudes were important facilitators.The review identified evidence gaps and a need for further robust research.
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessA rapid review of multi-agency working to support transition out of children’s social care
Transition from children’s social care is a complex and often challenging process, and coordination between different agencies, such as health, education, and social care, is important to ensure effective communication, engagement, and continuity of care. This review focuses on young people’s experiences with multi-agency approaches to support transition from children’s social care to adults’ social care or support, their perceptions of success of such approaches, and barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency approaches to transition and to young people engaging with them. This review included 22 UK studies published between 2014 and 2025. Seven of the studies focused on care leavers, six on young people with learning disabilities (LD) or special educational needs or disabilities (SEND), five on young people in the justice system, and four on other groups of young people. Many of the multi-agency initiatives primarily focused on housing support. For young people in the justice system, the initiatives mainly focused on resettlement in community. There were also studies about broader planning for support needs when the young person transitioned to adulthood.The experiences and perceived success of multi-agency working: Care leavers’ experiences of transitions varied, with some young people experiencing anxiety and distress. Perceptions of the benefits of initiatives often related to the quality of their relationship with their transition worker. Some young people said their confidence, general skills, social relationships, and mental health improved during their involvement in multi-agency initiatives. Little evidence was identified about experiences of young people with LD/SEND. For young people in the justice system, mixed experiences were described. Little information was identified about success of multi-agency work as perceived by young people. Some positive experiences with multi-agency working were also described.Barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency work: Barriers included insufficient resources, structural issues and policy and strategy limitations. Shared practices, priorities, and vision as well as information sharing between agencies were important. A significant practitioner-related factor was staff expertise. Barriers and facilitators of young people engaging with multi-agency work: Awareness of the services and flexibility in how young people could engage with them were important factors. More support with engagement for young people could act as a facilitator. Personal factors that might act as barriers to engagement for young people were identified. Good relationships with staff and positive staff attitudes were important facilitators.The review identified evidence gaps and a need for further robust research.
- Open Access
Homelessness, type of homelessness, and risk of cause-specific mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 116 studies comprising 2,563,633 homeless people and 129,292,553 population controls
Background: Homelessness might increase the risk of premature mortality, but evidence is scarce, imprecise, and is mostly limited to rough sleepers as opposed to more common types of homelessness. Methods: Published studies were retrieved through a systematic search of MEDLINE, Embase PsycINFO and Scopus from inception to December 2024. Unpublished data were identified from open-access data archives. We used random-effects meta-analysis to combine effect estimates from published and unpublished data. This review is registered at PROSPERO (CRD42023430984). Findings: We included 116 studies from Europe, the USA, South America, Africa, Asia, and Australia. The meta-analysis of all-cause mortality comprised 110,892,271 people (1,618,049 exposed to homelessness). The risk of all-cause mortality was significantly increased in people exposed to homelessness (Relative risk [RR] 2·12 [95% CI 1·91-2·57], p2 =99·7%), with risks similar in men (3·88, 2·69-5·06) and women (3·46, 2·17-4·70). This risk was most elevated in people who had slept rough (7·63, 3·29-11·97), followed by those who used low-cost hotels (5·18, 1·14-9·23), then hostels (3·44, 2·10-4·77). In analyses of cause-specific mortality (26,291,900 people, 1,202,205 homeless), summary RR estimates were elevated for 33 of the 36 (92%) causes of death and highest for deaths due to psychoactive substance use disorder (21·36, 14·44-31·67), accidental injuries (13·15, 5·46-31·69), drug-overdose (10·80, 6·37-18·31), and those that are alcohol-related (5·93, 1·10-22·04). No evidence of publication bias was detected. Interpretation: Homeless people experience an increased risk of premature mortality across an array of health outcomes. That the most extreme inequities have an interrelated aetiology suggests a cross-sectoral medical, housing, and social care response is required. Funding: The Centre for Homelessness Impact, Health and Care Research Wales, UK Medical Research Council (MR/P023444/1) and the US National Institute on Aging. Research in context: Evidence before this study: While existing systematic reviews have found that homelessness is associated with an increased risk of all-cause mortality, there remains substantial gaps in knowledge. Currently there is no meta-analysis of the risk of death from all-causes and specific disorders, comparison of mortality risk across the spectrum of homelessness experience (e.g., rough sleeping, hostels, single-occupancy low-cost hotels), whether differences exist in the impact on men and women, or in high, or low and middle income countries (LMICs). Accordingly, we searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO and Scopus from inception to December 2024 for studies reporting mortality outcomes among people with a history of homelessness. Additionally, we searched the grey literature and obtained unpublished individual-participant data for two cohort studies from open-access data archives. Added value of this study: Our systematic review and meta-analysis provides the first comprehensive examination to date of mortality among people who have experienced homelessness. Drawing on 116 studies, there was, in aggregate, a doubling in risk of all-cause mortality in the 1,618,049 people who had experienced homelessness relative to the 109,274,222 population controls (relative risk [RR] 2·12, [95% CI 1·91-2·57], p20 for psychoactive substance use disorder, 10-19 for drug-overdose, accidents, and accidental injuries, and 5-10 for alcohol-related causes - none of which have been previously summarised. No evidence of publication bias was found. Implications of all the available evidence: Homelessness is associated with an increased risk of all-cause mortality. Our analysis suggests these a large proportion of these excess deaths are caused by substance use, drug-overdose, accidents and harmful alcohol consumption. The extreme inequalities in mortality we identified points to the need a cross-sectoral response to improve both health and housing conditions for people who have experienced homelessness.
Open AccessHomelessness, type of homelessness, and risk of cause-specific mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 116 studies comprising 2,563,633 homeless people and 129,292,553 population controls
Background: Homelessness might increase the risk of premature mortality, but evidence is scarce, imprecise, and is mostly limited to rough sleepers as opposed to more common types of homelessness. Methods: Published studies were retrieved through a systematic search of MEDLINE, Embase PsycINFO and Scopus from inception to December 2024. Unpublished data were identified from open-access data archives. We used random-effects meta-analysis to combine effect estimates from published and unpublished data. This review is registered at PROSPERO (CRD42023430984). Findings: We included 116 studies from Europe, the USA, South America, Africa, Asia, and Australia. The meta-analysis of all-cause mortality comprised 110,892,271 people (1,618,049 exposed to homelessness). The risk of all-cause mortality was significantly increased in people exposed to homelessness (Relative risk [RR] 2·12 [95% CI 1·91-2·57], p2 =99·7%), with risks similar in men (3·88, 2·69-5·06) and women (3·46, 2·17-4·70). This risk was most elevated in people who had slept rough (7·63, 3·29-11·97), followed by those who used low-cost hotels (5·18, 1·14-9·23), then hostels (3·44, 2·10-4·77). In analyses of cause-specific mortality (26,291,900 people, 1,202,205 homeless), summary RR estimates were elevated for 33 of the 36 (92%) causes of death and highest for deaths due to psychoactive substance use disorder (21·36, 14·44-31·67), accidental injuries (13·15, 5·46-31·69), drug-overdose (10·80, 6·37-18·31), and those that are alcohol-related (5·93, 1·10-22·04). No evidence of publication bias was detected. Interpretation: Homeless people experience an increased risk of premature mortality across an array of health outcomes. That the most extreme inequities have an interrelated aetiology suggests a cross-sectoral medical, housing, and social care response is required. Funding: The Centre for Homelessness Impact, Health and Care Research Wales, UK Medical Research Council (MR/P023444/1) and the US National Institute on Aging. Research in context: Evidence before this study: While existing systematic reviews have found that homelessness is associated with an increased risk of all-cause mortality, there remains substantial gaps in knowledge. Currently there is no meta-analysis of the risk of death from all-causes and specific disorders, comparison of mortality risk across the spectrum of homelessness experience (e.g., rough sleeping, hostels, single-occupancy low-cost hotels), whether differences exist in the impact on men and women, or in high, or low and middle income countries (LMICs). Accordingly, we searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO and Scopus from inception to December 2024 for studies reporting mortality outcomes among people with a history of homelessness. Additionally, we searched the grey literature and obtained unpublished individual-participant data for two cohort studies from open-access data archives. Added value of this study: Our systematic review and meta-analysis provides the first comprehensive examination to date of mortality among people who have experienced homelessness. Drawing on 116 studies, there was, in aggregate, a doubling in risk of all-cause mortality in the 1,618,049 people who had experienced homelessness relative to the 109,274,222 population controls (relative risk [RR] 2·12, [95% CI 1·91-2·57], p20 for psychoactive substance use disorder, 10-19 for drug-overdose, accidents, and accidental injuries, and 5-10 for alcohol-related causes - none of which have been previously summarised. No evidence of publication bias was found. Implications of all the available evidence: Homelessness is associated with an increased risk of all-cause mortality. Our analysis suggests these a large proportion of these excess deaths are caused by substance use, drug-overdose, accidents and harmful alcohol consumption. The extreme inequalities in mortality we identified points to the need a cross-sectoral response to improve both health and housing conditions for people who have experienced homelessness.
- Open Access
A rapid review of interventions to reduce suicide ideation, attempts, and deaths at public locations
Suicide deaths are tragic events and those that occur in public places have an impact not only on the deceased person and their family and friends, but also on members of the public. Having up-to-date information about the effectiveness of interventions allows policymakers and organisations managing locations of concern to choose the most appropriate evidence-based suicide prevention strategies for specific locations. This rapid review was conducted to help inform the development of Welsh national guidance. The review included literature published since 2014. 24 studies were identified, and these were conducted in the UK, Australia, South Korea, Canada, USA, Denmark and Japan. The studies covered railway or underground stations, bridges, cliffs or other natural heights, tall buildings, and other types of locations. Surveillance technologies as a means of increasing opportunity for third-party intervention showed the most promise, although the evidence of their effectiveness was limited. In one study, having more closed-circuit television (CCTV) units was associated with fewer suicides at railway stations. Another study that tested a set of interventions including CCTV, infrared security fences, and a suicidal behaviour recognition and alert system, provided some promising initial descriptive data that showed an increase in the number of prevented suicides. Three other studies showed that there was no change in outcomes following the installation of interventions including surveillance technologies. Based on the assessment of the overall body of the evidence, there is a low level of confidence in the findings related to surveillance technologies because of the quality and designs of the studies. Promotion of suicide helplines as an intervention aimed at increasing opportunities for help seeking was examined in seven studies. Two studies reported that the number of suicides increased after the introduction of the intervention. Three studies, of which two examined a set of interventions including helplines, observed no change. In two studies the effect could not be determined. There is a low level of confidence in the evidence for this outcome. Other interventions evaluated included staff training; deployment of specialist staff; campaigns encouraging bystanders to intervene; a crisis café; blue lights at railway stations; suicide prevention messages, memorials, or notes other than official crisis line signage; spinning rollers at the top of fences that prevent gripping; and others. The effect of these interventions could not be determined with certainty but some of them appeared promising and warrant further research. More robust evaluations are needed before any of the interventions reviewed here can be recommended for implementation. To create a better evidence base, high-quality evaluations should be supported and encouraged. Future research should examine which interventions work for who and in what circumstances.
Open AccessA rapid review of interventions to reduce suicide ideation, attempts, and deaths at public locations
Suicide deaths are tragic events and those that occur in public places have an impact not only on the deceased person and their family and friends, but also on members of the public. Having up-to-date information about the effectiveness of interventions allows policymakers and organisations managing locations of concern to choose the most appropriate evidence-based suicide prevention strategies for specific locations. This rapid review was conducted to help inform the development of Welsh national guidance. The review included literature published since 2014. 24 studies were identified, and these were conducted in the UK, Australia, South Korea, Canada, USA, Denmark and Japan. The studies covered railway or underground stations, bridges, cliffs or other natural heights, tall buildings, and other types of locations. Surveillance technologies as a means of increasing opportunity for third-party intervention showed the most promise, although the evidence of their effectiveness was limited. In one study, having more closed-circuit television (CCTV) units was associated with fewer suicides at railway stations. Another study that tested a set of interventions including CCTV, infrared security fences, and a suicidal behaviour recognition and alert system, provided some promising initial descriptive data that showed an increase in the number of prevented suicides. Three other studies showed that there was no change in outcomes following the installation of interventions including surveillance technologies. Based on the assessment of the overall body of the evidence, there is a low level of confidence in the findings related to surveillance technologies because of the quality and designs of the studies. Promotion of suicide helplines as an intervention aimed at increasing opportunities for help seeking was examined in seven studies. Two studies reported that the number of suicides increased after the introduction of the intervention. Three studies, of which two examined a set of interventions including helplines, observed no change. In two studies the effect could not be determined. There is a low level of confidence in the evidence for this outcome. Other interventions evaluated included staff training; deployment of specialist staff; campaigns encouraging bystanders to intervene; a crisis café; blue lights at railway stations; suicide prevention messages, memorials, or notes other than official crisis line signage; spinning rollers at the top of fences that prevent gripping; and others. The effect of these interventions could not be determined with certainty but some of them appeared promising and warrant further research. More robust evaluations are needed before any of the interventions reviewed here can be recommended for implementation. To create a better evidence base, high-quality evaluations should be supported and encouraged. Future research should examine which interventions work for who and in what circumstances.
- Open Access
Rapid review of the characteristics and outcomes of children involved in private family law proceedings due to parental separation
Private law childrens proceedings typically involve court disputes between parents who have separated and disagree about child arrangements, and are asking the court to make orders that determine where a child should live and with whom they should spend time. Children involved in private law, who potentially represent a vulnerable group, commonly receive less attention in policy than those in public law cases. The aim of this review was to shine a light on the wellbeing and other important characteristics or outcomes of children who are currently, or have been, involved in family law proceedings due to parental separation, to identify the support needs of these children who are often overlooked in policy. This rapid review is intended for policymakers who are responsible for policy concerning children and families as well as for family law professionals and families in private law childrens proceedings. The literature searches were conducted between June and August 2024. The included literature was published between 2001 and 2022. 22 studies reported in 25 documents were identified (8 published in academic journals and 17 in reports produced by organisations). Originated in England and Wales (n=13), Australia (n=7), Canada (n=1), New Zealand (n=1). Most studies aimed to describe the characteristics of children who are or have been involved in private family law proceedings, whilst only one compared the outcomes of such children to those in the general population. Almost all of the studies addressed mental health and emotional wellbeing. Written accounts of children, parents, and professionals described children as having anxiety, depression, anger, post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms, and eating disorders, and experiencing self-harm and suicide attempts. In Wales, children with a history of involvement in private law proceedings had higher incidence of depression and anxiety than children in the general population. From the evidence, it was unclear whether the poor mental health was associated with parental separation, the court proceedings, court orders, or some other factors, but some participants attributed difficulties to unwanted court orders. Other key areas of evidence included engagement with mental health services, behaviour, development, social relationships, learning and education, and physical health. Cardiff Evidence Synthesis Collaborative were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.
Open AccessRapid review of the characteristics and outcomes of children involved in private family law proceedings due to parental separation
Private law childrens proceedings typically involve court disputes between parents who have separated and disagree about child arrangements, and are asking the court to make orders that determine where a child should live and with whom they should spend time. Children involved in private law, who potentially represent a vulnerable group, commonly receive less attention in policy than those in public law cases. The aim of this review was to shine a light on the wellbeing and other important characteristics or outcomes of children who are currently, or have been, involved in family law proceedings due to parental separation, to identify the support needs of these children who are often overlooked in policy. This rapid review is intended for policymakers who are responsible for policy concerning children and families as well as for family law professionals and families in private law childrens proceedings. The literature searches were conducted between June and August 2024. The included literature was published between 2001 and 2022. 22 studies reported in 25 documents were identified (8 published in academic journals and 17 in reports produced by organisations). Originated in England and Wales (n=13), Australia (n=7), Canada (n=1), New Zealand (n=1). Most studies aimed to describe the characteristics of children who are or have been involved in private family law proceedings, whilst only one compared the outcomes of such children to those in the general population. Almost all of the studies addressed mental health and emotional wellbeing. Written accounts of children, parents, and professionals described children as having anxiety, depression, anger, post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms, and eating disorders, and experiencing self-harm and suicide attempts. In Wales, children with a history of involvement in private law proceedings had higher incidence of depression and anxiety than children in the general population. From the evidence, it was unclear whether the poor mental health was associated with parental separation, the court proceedings, court orders, or some other factors, but some participants attributed difficulties to unwanted court orders. Other key areas of evidence included engagement with mental health services, behaviour, development, social relationships, learning and education, and physical health. Cardiff Evidence Synthesis Collaborative were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.
- Open Access
Supporting women, girls and people who menstruate to participate in physical activity – Rapid evidence summary
Insufficient physical activity is a leading risk factor for non-communicable diseases and has a negative effect on mental health and quality of life. Women, girls and people who menstruate living in Wales are less likely to engage in regular physical activity than boys and men. The aim of this rapid evidence summary is to identify research focusing on physical activity participation (including exercise and sport) of women, girls and people who menstruate in relation to the menstrual cycle, to inform the Welsh Government Period Proud Action Plan. Results 42 reports were identified, including overviews of reviews, systematic reviews, a scoping review, organisational reports, and primary studies. The secondary research evidence was published between 2008 and 2024 with the most recent searches being conducted in September 2023. The primary studies were published between 2020 and 2022. The organisational reports were published between 2018 and 2024. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps There is a need for interventions that could support physical activity participation (including exercise or sport) of women, girls and people who menstruate in relation to the menstrual cycle. These interventions need to consider and address barriers that women, girls and people who menstruate face in relation to their menstrual cycle, and robust evaluations are required to determine effectiveness. Funding statement The Cardiff Evidence Synthesis Collaborative were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.
Open AccessSupporting women, girls and people who menstruate to participate in physical activity – Rapid evidence summary
Insufficient physical activity is a leading risk factor for non-communicable diseases and has a negative effect on mental health and quality of life. Women, girls and people who menstruate living in Wales are less likely to engage in regular physical activity than boys and men. The aim of this rapid evidence summary is to identify research focusing on physical activity participation (including exercise and sport) of women, girls and people who menstruate in relation to the menstrual cycle, to inform the Welsh Government Period Proud Action Plan. Results 42 reports were identified, including overviews of reviews, systematic reviews, a scoping review, organisational reports, and primary studies. The secondary research evidence was published between 2008 and 2024 with the most recent searches being conducted in September 2023. The primary studies were published between 2020 and 2022. The organisational reports were published between 2018 and 2024. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps There is a need for interventions that could support physical activity participation (including exercise or sport) of women, girls and people who menstruate in relation to the menstrual cycle. These interventions need to consider and address barriers that women, girls and people who menstruate face in relation to their menstrual cycle, and robust evaluations are required to determine effectiveness. Funding statement The Cardiff Evidence Synthesis Collaborative were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.
- Open Access
A rapid review of the effectiveness of interventions to enhance equitable or overall access to mental health services by ethnic minority groups
It is estimated that one in four people will experience poor mental health throughout their lifetime. However, ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers experience more barriers accessing mental health services and have poorer mental health outcomes than those from non-ethnic minority groups. Evidence suggests that interventions that improve access and engagement with mental health services may help reduce disparities affecting ethnic minority groups. This review aims to assess the effectiveness of interventions that enhance equitable or overall access to mental health services by ethnic minority groups. The review included evidence available up until 19th December 2023. Psycho-educational interventions that focused on providing culturally appropriate information, showed mixed results for help seeking behaviour, improvements in depressions stigma. Multi-component interventions within healthcare settings had mixed results. Some studies showed positive outcomes; such as increased help seeking intentions and improved attendance rates, while others did not show significant differences in outcomes. Interventions that included integrating specialist mental health services within primary care resulted in variable outcomes. The findings of interventions incorporating language support into mental health services were also variable. The effectiveness of interventions to enhance the cultural competency of mental health services varied across studies. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps Future research should prioritise rigorous study designs, including randomised controlled trials and longitudinal studies. More research is required to compare outcomes between ethnic minority participants and White participants. Economic considerations Ethnic minority individuals are disproportionately affected by economic determinants of poor mental health including increased likelihood of low income. Future research should investigate the economic benefit from an NHS and societal perspective of improving access to mental health services for ethnic minority individuals.
Open AccessA rapid review of the effectiveness of interventions to enhance equitable or overall access to mental health services by ethnic minority groups
It is estimated that one in four people will experience poor mental health throughout their lifetime. However, ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers experience more barriers accessing mental health services and have poorer mental health outcomes than those from non-ethnic minority groups. Evidence suggests that interventions that improve access and engagement with mental health services may help reduce disparities affecting ethnic minority groups. This review aims to assess the effectiveness of interventions that enhance equitable or overall access to mental health services by ethnic minority groups. The review included evidence available up until 19th December 2023. Psycho-educational interventions that focused on providing culturally appropriate information, showed mixed results for help seeking behaviour, improvements in depressions stigma. Multi-component interventions within healthcare settings had mixed results. Some studies showed positive outcomes; such as increased help seeking intentions and improved attendance rates, while others did not show significant differences in outcomes. Interventions that included integrating specialist mental health services within primary care resulted in variable outcomes. The findings of interventions incorporating language support into mental health services were also variable. The effectiveness of interventions to enhance the cultural competency of mental health services varied across studies. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps Future research should prioritise rigorous study designs, including randomised controlled trials and longitudinal studies. More research is required to compare outcomes between ethnic minority participants and White participants. Economic considerations Ethnic minority individuals are disproportionately affected by economic determinants of poor mental health including increased likelihood of low income. Future research should investigate the economic benefit from an NHS and societal perspective of improving access to mental health services for ethnic minority individuals.
- Open Access
What works to support better access to mental health services (from primary care to inpatients) for minority groups to reduce inequalities? A rapid evidence summary
It is estimated that one in four people will experience poor mental health throughout their lifetimes. However, ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers experience more barriers accessing mental health services and have poorer mental health outcomes than those from non-ethnic minority groups. Evidence suggests that interventions that improve access and engagement with mental health services may help reduce disparities affecting ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers. Thus, the aim of this rapid evidence summary was to explore the literature on what works to support better access to mental health services for ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers to reduce inequalities. The review included interventions that were developed or assessed to improve equity in access, engagement, utilisation, or provision of mental health services. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps There is limited review evidence regarding the effectiveness of interventions to improve access to mental healthcare across ethnic minority groups. Review evidence regarding interventions to support refugees and asylum seekers access to primary healthcare or specialised clinics (for example pregnancy and postpartum) is available, but the findings related to mental health care cannot be extracted.
Open AccessWhat works to support better access to mental health services (from primary care to inpatients) for minority groups to reduce inequalities? A rapid evidence summary
It is estimated that one in four people will experience poor mental health throughout their lifetimes. However, ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers experience more barriers accessing mental health services and have poorer mental health outcomes than those from non-ethnic minority groups. Evidence suggests that interventions that improve access and engagement with mental health services may help reduce disparities affecting ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers. Thus, the aim of this rapid evidence summary was to explore the literature on what works to support better access to mental health services for ethnic minority groups, refugees and asylum seekers to reduce inequalities. The review included interventions that were developed or assessed to improve equity in access, engagement, utilisation, or provision of mental health services. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps There is limited review evidence regarding the effectiveness of interventions to improve access to mental healthcare across ethnic minority groups. Review evidence regarding interventions to support refugees and asylum seekers access to primary healthcare or specialised clinics (for example pregnancy and postpartum) is available, but the findings related to mental health care cannot be extracted.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Neurodiversity
- Vol. 2
A rapid review of supports for neurodivergent students in higher education. Implications for research and practice
Inclusive education has recently increased focused on support for students with neurodivergent conditions including autism or dyslexia. A number of practice guidelines have been published. As neurodivergent students are more likely to drop out of higher education, it is tenable that environments, structures and processes may not address needs. This rapid review assessed robustness of evidence regarding adjustments and support in higher education and to identify priorities for future research and practice. Through a systematic process, we elicited studies summarised in 11 existing reviews. We found the evidence to be United States-centric and sample sizes small. We synthesised evidence for (a) examination adjustments, (b) explicit instruction, (c) strategy instruction, (d) technology-based interventions, (e) psychological supports, (f) mentoring and coaching, (g) comprehensive support programmes, (h) transition into university, and (i) transition into employment. Most studies focused on distinct conditions such as autism rather than taking a comprehensive approach. The evidence is overall modest and more focused on skills and learning, rather than educational outcomes (e.g. increasing successful completion) or life outcomes such as successful transition into work which we identify as a priority for future research alongside institutional neuroinclusion and curriculum design.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Neurodiversity
- Vol. 2
Open AccessA rapid review of supports for neurodivergent students in higher education. Implications for research and practice
Inclusive education has recently increased focused on support for students with neurodivergent conditions including autism or dyslexia. A number of practice guidelines have been published. As neurodivergent students are more likely to drop out of higher education, it is tenable that environments, structures and processes may not address needs. This rapid review assessed robustness of evidence regarding adjustments and support in higher education and to identify priorities for future research and practice. Through a systematic process, we elicited studies summarised in 11 existing reviews. We found the evidence to be United States-centric and sample sizes small. We synthesised evidence for (a) examination adjustments, (b) explicit instruction, (c) strategy instruction, (d) technology-based interventions, (e) psychological supports, (f) mentoring and coaching, (g) comprehensive support programmes, (h) transition into university, and (i) transition into employment. Most studies focused on distinct conditions such as autism rather than taking a comprehensive approach. The evidence is overall modest and more focused on skills and learning, rather than educational outcomes (e.g. increasing successful completion) or life outcomes such as successful transition into work which we identify as a priority for future research alongside institutional neuroinclusion and curriculum design.
- Open Access
A rapid review of physical health risks associated with special procedures (tattooing, body piercing, acupuncture, electrolysis)
Special procedures, such as tattooing (including semi-permanent make-up), body piercing, acupuncture and electrolysis involve piercing the skin and carry a potential risk of infection and other complications. This review provides an up-to-date evidence base on the main physical health risks associated with these special procedures. Searches were conducted for research published between 2015 and 2023. Where possible, existing reviews were used. For tattooing, one systematic review including 55 studies was identified. For semi-permanent make-up, 37 cases presented in 31 case reports were identified. For body piercing, four systematic reviews were identified, which covered 174 studies. For acupuncture, one evidence map of 535 systematic reviews without age limits and one overview of 24 systematic reviews focused on children were included. For electrolysis, one case report was identified. Complications and adverse events resulting from special procedures include fungal infections, bacterial infections, viral infections, blood-borne infections, allergic reactions, malignant growths, benign growths, sarcoidosis-related reactions, and a range of other skin and eye-related adverse reactions and dental issues. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps Most of the primary evidence for the physical health risks associated with the special procedures came from case reports and case series, which do not allow causal inferences or provide information on the prevalence of adverse events. Future primary research should employ more robust designs to gather evidence about the causal links between special procedures and adverse physical health events as well as about the prevalence of such events in people receiving special procedures. More evidence is needed to identify physical health risks associated with electrolysis. Policy and Practice Implications The evidence contained in this review will be used to inform the training of local authority enforcement officers and special procedures practitioners and to educate members of the public who seek to use these services. Due to the nature of the special procedures which involves piercing the skin and poses the risk of introducing infections to the body, high standards of hygiene may reduce the rate of infection. Funding statement The Wales Centre for Evidence Based Care, and the Specialist Unit for Review Evidence, were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.
Open AccessA rapid review of physical health risks associated with special procedures (tattooing, body piercing, acupuncture, electrolysis)
Special procedures, such as tattooing (including semi-permanent make-up), body piercing, acupuncture and electrolysis involve piercing the skin and carry a potential risk of infection and other complications. This review provides an up-to-date evidence base on the main physical health risks associated with these special procedures. Searches were conducted for research published between 2015 and 2023. Where possible, existing reviews were used. For tattooing, one systematic review including 55 studies was identified. For semi-permanent make-up, 37 cases presented in 31 case reports were identified. For body piercing, four systematic reviews were identified, which covered 174 studies. For acupuncture, one evidence map of 535 systematic reviews without age limits and one overview of 24 systematic reviews focused on children were included. For electrolysis, one case report was identified. Complications and adverse events resulting from special procedures include fungal infections, bacterial infections, viral infections, blood-borne infections, allergic reactions, malignant growths, benign growths, sarcoidosis-related reactions, and a range of other skin and eye-related adverse reactions and dental issues. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps Most of the primary evidence for the physical health risks associated with the special procedures came from case reports and case series, which do not allow causal inferences or provide information on the prevalence of adverse events. Future primary research should employ more robust designs to gather evidence about the causal links between special procedures and adverse physical health events as well as about the prevalence of such events in people receiving special procedures. More evidence is needed to identify physical health risks associated with electrolysis. Policy and Practice Implications The evidence contained in this review will be used to inform the training of local authority enforcement officers and special procedures practitioners and to educate members of the public who seek to use these services. Due to the nature of the special procedures which involves piercing the skin and poses the risk of introducing infections to the body, high standards of hygiene may reduce the rate of infection. Funding statement The Wales Centre for Evidence Based Care, and the Specialist Unit for Review Evidence, were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.