TPTiina Paananen

Tiina Paananen

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Tiina Paananen has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Enhancing Customer Immersion in Online Shopping

    by Tiina Paananen, Tiina Kemppainen, Jenni Ström, Lauri Frank


  • Open Access

    The Drivers of Showrooming Behavior: A Meta-Analysis

    by Matilda Holkkola, Olli Tyrväinen, Markus Makkonen, Heikki Karjaluoto, Tiina Kemppainen, Tiina Paananen, Lauri Frank

    Showrooming behavior refers to consumer behavior where consumers first physically evaluate products in offline channels and then compare the potential purchases in online channels. Although the drivers of showrooming behavior have gained interest from many quantitative researchers and resulted in multiple conflicting results, there is no established framework for these drivers. Therefore, we made a meta-analysis of the drivers of showrooming behavior. To analyze prior results, we conducted a systematic literature review resulting in 24 independent study samples that fit our criteria. Of these samples, 18 drivers were meta-analytically analyzed, resulting in 13 drivers being found to have a statistically significant association and five drivers being found to have no statistically significant association with showrooming behavior. As a theoretical contribution, we provide an established framework and solve prior conflicting findings. As a managerial contribution, we provide advice to decrease customers’ competitive showrooming behavior according to the identified main drivers.


  • Open Access

    Towards Techno-Psychological Immersion: A Narrative Literature Review of Immersion and Its Related Concepts

    by Tiina Paananen, Tiina Kemppainen, Markus Makkonen, Matilda Holkkola, Olli Tyrväinen, Lauri Frank

    Immersion is re-trending interdisciplinary topic in academic research due to new digital innovations, such as augmented reality smart glasses. Immersion is, however, still criticized as being a vague concept which should be clarified. For instance, immersion can be analyzed from both psychological and technological perspectives, yet many studies solely focus on one aspect while neglecting the other. Moreover, technological immersion and immersive technologies can be incorrectly used as synonyms. Thus, in this study, we conducted a narrative literature review of selected articles on immersion. As a result, we present our summary, which includes four sense stimulators (visual, auditory, haptic, and olfactory) of technological immersion and three dimensions (spatial, narrative, and strategic) of psychological immersion. Also, we suggest that immersive technologies should be separated from technological immersion. Lastly, we propose a new perspective to immersion: techno-psychological immersion, which combines technological and psychological viewpoints of immersion.


  • Open Access

    The Use of Neutralisation Techniques in the Context of Responsible Online Shopping: A Latent Profile Analysis

    by Markus Makkonen, Lauri Frank, Matilda Holkkola, Tiina Paananen

    Although many consumers use various neutralisation techniques to eliminate the anticipated guilt that results from not engaging in responsible consumption, the use of such techniques in the context of responsible online shopping has attracted little attention in prior research. In this study, we aim to address this gap by examining (1) whether it is possible to segment consumers in terms of their use of neutralisation techniques to eliminate the anticipated guilt that results from not engaging in responsible online shopping and (2) how these segments potentially differ from each other in terms of demographics (e.g., gender, age, and income), online shopping frequency, and anticipated guilt. The examination is based on 478 responses from Finnish consumers that were collected in spring 2023 and are analysed with latent profile analysis. Our findings suggest the existence of four distinct consumer segments with several differences between them in terms of demographics and anticipated guilt.

  • Open Access

    Dualities of digital services: everyday digital services as positive and negative contributors to customer well-being

    by Tiina Kemppainen, Tiina Elina Paananen

    Purpose: This study examines the dualities of digital services – that is, how customers’ favorite everyday digital services can positively and negatively contribute to their well-being. Thus, the study describes the meanings of favorite digital services as part of customers’ everyday lives and the types of well-being to which such services can contribute.Design/methodology/approach: We used a qualitative research approach through semi-structured interviews conducted in 2021 to collect data from 14 young adults (22–31 years old) who actively used digital services in their daily lives.Findings: Our findings revealed that customers’ favorite everyday digital services can contribute to their mental well-being, social well-being, and intellectual well-being. Within these three dimensions of well-being, we identified nine dualities of digital services that describe their positive and negative contributions: (1) digital escapism versus digital disruption, (2) digital relaxation versus digital stress, (3) digital empowerment versus digital subjugation, (4) digital augmentation versus digital emptiness, (5) digital socialization versus digital isolation, (6) digital togetherness versus digital exclusion, (7) digital self-expression versus digital pressure, (8) digital learning versus digital dependence, and (9) digital inspiration versus digital stagnation.Practical implications: These findings suggest that everyday digital services have the potential to contribute to customer well-being in various aspects – both positively and negatively – accentuating the need for service providers to decipher the impacts of their offerings on well-being. Indeed, understanding the relationship between digital services and customer well-being can help companies tailor their services to customers’ needs. Companies that prioritize customer well-being not only benefit their customers but also create sustainable growth opportunities in the long run. Further, companies can use the derived information in service design to develop marketing strategies that emphasize the positive impacts of their digital services on customer well-being.Originality/value: Although prior transformative service studies have investigated the well-being of multiple stakeholders, such studies have focused on services related to the physical and healthcare domains. Consequently, the role of everyday digital services as contributors to customer well-being is an under-researched topic. In addition, the concept of well-being and its various dimensions has received limited attention in previous service research. By investigating everyday digital services and their multidimensional contribution to customer well-being, this study broadens the perspective on well-being within TSR and aids in refining a more precise conceptualization.


  • Open Access

    The Cross-Channel Effects of In-Store Customer Experience in the Case of Omnichannel Fashion Retailing in Finland

    by Markus Makkonen, Lauri Frank, Tiina Paananen, Matilda Holkkola, Tiina Kemppainen

    Although omnichannel retailing has emerged as a popular research topic in academic research, there are still gaps in our understanding of this phenomenon. One such gap concerns omnichannel customer experience and particularly the cross-channel or spillover effects of how customer experience in one channel may affect customer behaviour not only in that specific channel but also in the other channels of the same retailer. In this study, we aim to address this gap by examining how customer experience in the offline channel affects customer behaviour in both the offline and the online channel, more specifically how in-store customer experience affects both brick-and-mortar store and online store visit intention. The study is conducted by using survey data from the customers of a Finnish fashion retailer on their recent brick-and-mortar store visit. We find that in-store customer experience does indeed positively affect not only brick-and-mortar store but also online store visit intention.


  • Open Access

    How Do QR Codes Enhance Customer Experience? Omnichannel Customer Experiences in a Brick-and-Mortar Fashion Store

    by Matilda Holkkola, Tiina Paananen, Lauri Frank, Tiina Kemppainen, Markus Makkonen

    In this qualitative study, we investigate how customers perceive QR codes enhancing their customer experience (CX) in the brick-and-mortar (B&M) store environment. Introducing QR codes to B&M stores is a part of the larger phenomenon of retailers creating omnichannel CXs by utilizing digital and cyber-physical elements in B&M stores. To collect data from real customers’ CXs, we displayed QR codes in a Finnish fashion brand’s B&M store and interviewed customers who had authentically visited the store. The QR codes displayed in the store were linked to a product information page on the brand’s online store, a brand ambassador’s Instagram posts, and an online survey. The data consist of 15 individual semi-structured thematic interviews of customers aged under 50 years. By conducting qualitative content analysis, we found six main advantages (i.e., interestingness, informativeness, usability, attractiveness, interaction, and innovativeness) and 14 subgroups of QR codes’ advantages in enhancing the CX.


  • Open Access

    Customers’ QR Code Usage Barriers in a Brick-and-Mortar Store: A Qualitative Study

    by Tiina Paananen, Matilda Holkkola, Markus Makkonen, Lauri Frank, Tiina Kemppainen

    The purpose of this study is to explore the factors that hinder customers from utilizing QR codes when they visit brick-and-mortar (B&M) stores. The research was conducted at a Finnish fashion retailer, where three types of QR codes were displayed for customers to use. In order to identify the barriers that customers face, two different sets of data were collected and analyzed: open-ended survey data (n = 101) and interview data (n = 16). The findings showed two main categories of barriers, customer and company related, with seven sub-barriers. The customer-related barriers included lack of interest in QR codes, user-related usage issues, desire for a device-free B&M store, and dislike toward QR codes. The company-related barriers included unnoticeable QR codes in the B&M store, service personnel in the B&M store, and QR code-related technical problems.