Miguel Hernando Guamanga
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Miguel Hernando Guamanga has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Carlos Saiz
Department of Basic Psychology, Psychobiology and Methodology of Behavioral Sciences, University of Salamanca, 37005 Salamanca, Spain
4 shared publications - Silvia Fernandez Rivas
Department of Basic Psychology, Psychobiology and Methodology of Behavioral Sciences, University of Salamanca, 37005 Salamanca, Spain
3 shared publications Carlos Saiz
1 shared publication- Cristiano Mauro Assis Gomes
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
1 shared publication - Fabián A. González
Faculty of Science and Education, Politécnico Colombiano Jaime Isaza Cadavid, Medellín 050021, Colombia
1 shared publication Fabián A. González-López
Faculty of Science and Education, Politécnico Colombiano Jaime Isaza Cadavid
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 October 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 11, 1906030
Critical reading and the structure of institutional academic performance: evidence from Colombia's Saber 11 examination
Large-scale assessments provide important evidence on educational performance, but institution-level results may provide an incomplete picture when academic domains are interpreted as independent indicators or simple ordinal comparisons. In a secondary analysis of the 2024 Icfes institutional classification file, this study examined the structure of the five Saber 11 institutional classification indices in Colombia, with particular attention to the position of Critical Reading. Analyses included 10,043 educational establishments and used confirmatory factor analysis, symmetric one-domain-out structural parameterizations, and multigroup measurement-invariance models across official and non-official sectors. The five indices were extremely highly correlated, and the first dimension accounted for 96.45% of the total standardized variance. A five-domain common-factor model yielded standardized loadings from .952 to .991, although global fit was mixed, indicating strong commonality without strict unidimensionality. Critical Reading was strongly associated with the latent dimension defined by the remaining four domains ( β = .988), but analogous one-domain-out specifications for Mathematics, Natural Sciences, Social Sciences and Citizenship, and English reproduced essentially the same covariance structure. Thus, the large Critical Reading coefficient did not identify a uniquely privileged directional role. Full metric invariance across institutional sectors was not supported; a limited partial metric solution was obtained after allowing Mathematics and English loadings to vary. dMACS effect sizes indicated non-negligible practical noninvariance for Mathematics (0.283, 95% bootstrap CI [0.266, 0.299]) and especially English (0.609, 95% bootstrap CI [0.584, 0.635]). Standardized Critical Reading associations remained very similar across sectors, although exact equality of the unstandardized coefficient was rejected. These findings indicate that Saber 11 institutional performance is characterized by a dominant but not perfectly unidimensional common structure. Critical Reading is a substantively meaningful marker of this multidomain organization, but its cross-domain relevance should not be interpreted as statistical primacy or causal influence.
- 28 October 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 11, 1906030
Open AccessCritical reading and the structure of institutional academic performance: evidence from Colombia's Saber 11 examination
Large-scale assessments provide important evidence on educational performance, but institution-level results may provide an incomplete picture when academic domains are interpreted as independent indicators or simple ordinal comparisons. In a secondary analysis of the 2024 Icfes institutional classification file, this study examined the structure of the five Saber 11 institutional classification indices in Colombia, with particular attention to the position of Critical Reading. Analyses included 10,043 educational establishments and used confirmatory factor analysis, symmetric one-domain-out structural parameterizations, and multigroup measurement-invariance models across official and non-official sectors. The five indices were extremely highly correlated, and the first dimension accounted for 96.45% of the total standardized variance. A five-domain common-factor model yielded standardized loadings from .952 to .991, although global fit was mixed, indicating strong commonality without strict unidimensionality. Critical Reading was strongly associated with the latent dimension defined by the remaining four domains ( β = .988), but analogous one-domain-out specifications for Mathematics, Natural Sciences, Social Sciences and Citizenship, and English reproduced essentially the same covariance structure. Thus, the large Critical Reading coefficient did not identify a uniquely privileged directional role. Full metric invariance across institutional sectors was not supported; a limited partial metric solution was obtained after allowing Mathematics and English loadings to vary. dMACS effect sizes indicated non-negligible practical noninvariance for Mathematics (0.283, 95% bootstrap CI [0.266, 0.299]) and especially English (0.609, 95% bootstrap CI [0.584, 0.635]). Standardized Critical Reading associations remained very similar across sectors, although exact equality of the unstandardized coefficient was rejected. These findings indicate that Saber 11 institutional performance is characterized by a dominant but not perfectly unidimensional common structure. Critical Reading is a substantively meaningful marker of this multidomain organization, but its cross-domain relevance should not be interpreted as statistical primacy or causal influence.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 14 (9) , 193
From Critical Thinking to Well-Being: The Metacognitive Pathway in a Graphical-Causal Model
This study reanalyzes data from a previous investigation on critical thinking, metacognition, empathy, and psychological well-being by incorporating academic performance into a graphical-causal model. The aim was to compare two explanatory structures: a performance-mediated model, in which metacognition relates to psychological well-being through academic performance, and a direct metacognitive model, in which metacognition maintains a direct relation with well-being. The sample included 155 undergraduate psychology students. Critical thinking, metacognition, empathy, academic performance, and psychological well-being were modeled using directed acyclic graphs, conditional independence tests, Gaussian Bayesian networks, and bootstrap-based arc stability analysis. The initial performance-mediated DAG was not supported because the implied independence between metacognition and well-being conditional on performance was violated. The refined model, which included a direct metacognition–well-being path, was more compatible with the data. Metacognition showed the strongest estimated path to psychological well-being, whereas academic performance did not operate as the main mediating mechanism. Bootstrap results supported the stability of the metacognition–well-being adjacency. Overall, the findings suggest that critical thinking relates to psychological well-being mainly through metacognitive processes, under the assumptions of the specified DAG.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 14 (9) , 193
Open AccessFrom Critical Thinking to Well-Being: The Metacognitive Pathway in a Graphical-Causal Model
This study reanalyzes data from a previous investigation on critical thinking, metacognition, empathy, and psychological well-being by incorporating academic performance into a graphical-causal model. The aim was to compare two explanatory structures: a performance-mediated model, in which metacognition relates to psychological well-being through academic performance, and a direct metacognitive model, in which metacognition maintains a direct relation with well-being. The sample included 155 undergraduate psychology students. Critical thinking, metacognition, empathy, academic performance, and psychological well-being were modeled using directed acyclic graphs, conditional independence tests, Gaussian Bayesian networks, and bootstrap-based arc stability analysis. The initial performance-mediated DAG was not supported because the implied independence between metacognition and well-being conditional on performance was violated. The refined model, which included a direct metacognition–well-being path, was more compatible with the data. Metacognition showed the strongest estimated path to psychological well-being, whereas academic performance did not operate as the main mediating mechanism. Bootstrap results supported the stability of the metacognition–well-being adjacency. Overall, the findings suggest that critical thinking relates to psychological well-being mainly through metacognitive processes, under the assumptions of the specified DAG.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 10 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 13 (3) , 34
Critical Thinking and Metacognition: Pathways to Empathy and Psychological Well-Being
This study examines the relationships between critical thinking, metacognition, psychological well-being, and empathy using structural equation modeling. The study sample consists of 155 university students from a higher education institution in Spain, who completed the PENCRISAL, the metacognitive abilities inventory, the Ryff psychological well-being scale, and the empathy quotient, which assess these psychological constructs. The results indicate that critical thinking has a direct positive effect on metacognition, which, in turn, is significantly associated with higher levels of psychological well-being and empathy. These findings reinforce the essential role of critical thinking in fostering cognitive self-regulation and socioemotional competencies. Furthermore, this study provides empirical evidence supporting the integration of critical thinking into educational programs, emphasizing its potential to enhance reflective thinking, emotional awareness, and interpersonal understanding.
- 10 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 13 (3) , 34
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessCritical Thinking and Metacognition: Pathways to Empathy and Psychological Well-Being
This study examines the relationships between critical thinking, metacognition, psychological well-being, and empathy using structural equation modeling. The study sample consists of 155 university students from a higher education institution in Spain, who completed the PENCRISAL, the metacognitive abilities inventory, the Ryff psychological well-being scale, and the empathy quotient, which assess these psychological constructs. The results indicate that critical thinking has a direct positive effect on metacognition, which, in turn, is significantly associated with higher levels of psychological well-being and empathy. These findings reinforce the essential role of critical thinking in fostering cognitive self-regulation and socioemotional competencies. Furthermore, this study provides empirical evidence supporting the integration of critical thinking into educational programs, emphasizing its potential to enhance reflective thinking, emotional awareness, and interpersonal understanding.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 9, 1423441
Analysis of the contribution of critical thinking and psychological well-being to academic performance
This study examines the influence of critical thinking and psychological well-being on the academic performance of first-year college students. It emphasizes the importance of a model of psychological well-being focused on self-acceptance, environmental mastery and purpose in life, along with a critical thinking approach oriented to problem solving and decision making. A total of 128 first-year psychology students from a Spanish public university participated, assessed by means of Ryff’s psychological well-being scale (PWBS) and the PENCRISAL critical thinking test, complemented with grades obtained in a critical thinking course. The results show positive correlations between psychological well-being, critical thinking and academic performance, with a stronger relationship between critical thinking and academic performance. However, psychological well-being also plays a significant role in academic performance. The findings highlight the need for holistic pedagogical approaches that combine cognitive skills and personal development to enhance first-year students’ learning.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 9, 1423441
Open AccessAnalysis of the contribution of critical thinking and psychological well-being to academic performance
This study examines the influence of critical thinking and psychological well-being on the academic performance of first-year college students. It emphasizes the importance of a model of psychological well-being focused on self-acceptance, environmental mastery and purpose in life, along with a critical thinking approach oriented to problem solving and decision making. A total of 128 first-year psychology students from a Spanish public university participated, assessed by means of Ryff’s psychological well-being scale (PWBS) and the PENCRISAL critical thinking test, complemented with grades obtained in a critical thinking course. The results show positive correlations between psychological well-being, critical thinking and academic performance, with a stronger relationship between critical thinking and academic performance. However, psychological well-being also plays a significant role in academic performance. The findings highlight the need for holistic pedagogical approaches that combine cognitive skills and personal development to enhance first-year students’ learning.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 11 (12) , 226
Critical Thinking: The ARDESOS-DIAPROVE Program in Dialogue with the Inference to the Best and Only Explanation
In our daily lives, we are often faced with the need to explain various phenomena, but we do not always select the most accurate explanation. For example, let us consider a “toxic” relationship with physical and psychological abuse, where one of the partners is reluctant to end it. Explanations for this situation can range from emotional or economic dependency to irrational hypotheses such as witchcraft. Surprisingly, some people may turn to the latter explanation and consequently seek ineffective solutions, such as visiting a witch doctor instead of a psychologist. This choice of an inappropriate explanation can lead to actions that are not only ineffective but potentially harmful. This example underscores the importance of inference to the best explanation (IBE) in everyday decision making. IBE involves selecting the hypothesis that would best explain the available body of data or evidence, a process that is crucial to making sound decisions but is also vulnerable to bias and errors of judgment. Within this context, the purpose of our article is to explore how the IBE process and the selection of appropriate explanations impact decision making and problem solving in real life. To this end, we systematically analyze the role of IBE in the ARDESOS-DIAPROVE program, evaluating how this approach can enhance the teaching and practice of critical thinking.
- 16 December 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Intelligence
- Vol. 11 (12) , 226
Open AccessCritical Thinking: The ARDESOS-DIAPROVE Program in Dialogue with the Inference to the Best and Only Explanation
In our daily lives, we are often faced with the need to explain various phenomena, but we do not always select the most accurate explanation. For example, let us consider a “toxic” relationship with physical and psychological abuse, where one of the partners is reluctant to end it. Explanations for this situation can range from emotional or economic dependency to irrational hypotheses such as witchcraft. Surprisingly, some people may turn to the latter explanation and consequently seek ineffective solutions, such as visiting a witch doctor instead of a psychologist. This choice of an inappropriate explanation can lead to actions that are not only ineffective but potentially harmful. This example underscores the importance of inference to the best explanation (IBE) in everyday decision making. IBE involves selecting the hypothesis that would best explain the available body of data or evidence, a process that is crucial to making sound decisions but is also vulnerable to bias and errors of judgment. Within this context, the purpose of our article is to explore how the IBE process and the selection of appropriate explanations impact decision making and problem solving in real life. To this end, we systematically analyze the role of IBE in the ARDESOS-DIAPROVE program, evaluating how this approach can enhance the teaching and practice of critical thinking.
- 19 August 2021
- Published by Universidad del Norte in Eidos
- Vol. 36, 171-193
Husserl: ¿Phenomenology of Mathematic?
La fenomenología de Husserl está inmersa en un entramado de regresiones y revisiones conceptuales que dificultan la identificación de una estructura sistémica. Los conceptos característicos de la fenomenología carecen de univocidad y no son propios de algunas obras de Husserl. Philosophie der Arithmetik ilustra el problema referido. ¿Puede inscribirse esta obra dentro de la categoría de texto fenomenológico? ¿Es posible hablar de una fenomenología de la matemática en Husserl? y ¿qué sentido tendría esto? Los objetivos del presente ensayo son: primero, analizar la dificultad que tiene Philosophie der Arithmetik para responder a las inquietudes de la filosofía de las matemáticas, y segundo, proponer la posibilidad de una fenomenología de la matemática condicionada a la clarificación conceptual y al estudio crítico de la influencia de la tradición analítica sobre la filosofía de las matemáticas.
- 19 August 2021
- Published by Universidad del Norte in Eidos
- Vol. 36, 171-193
Husserl: ¿Phenomenology of Mathematic?
La fenomenología de Husserl está inmersa en un entramado de regresiones y revisiones conceptuales que dificultan la identificación de una estructura sistémica. Los conceptos característicos de la fenomenología carecen de univocidad y no son propios de algunas obras de Husserl. Philosophie der Arithmetik ilustra el problema referido. ¿Puede inscribirse esta obra dentro de la categoría de texto fenomenológico? ¿Es posible hablar de una fenomenología de la matemática en Husserl? y ¿qué sentido tendría esto? Los objetivos del presente ensayo son: primero, analizar la dificultad que tiene Philosophie der Arithmetik para responder a las inquietudes de la filosofía de las matemáticas, y segundo, proponer la posibilidad de una fenomenología de la matemática condicionada a la clarificación conceptual y al estudio crítico de la influencia de la tradición analítica sobre la filosofía de las matemáticas.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2020
- Published by Corporacion Minuto de Dios University - UNIMINUTO in Polisemia
- Vol. 16 (30) , 117-132
La lógica formal, el pensamiento crítico y la cognición situada
En este ensayo se plantea que la enseñanza de la lógica formal, en función del desarrollo de las habilidades esenciales de pensamiento crítico, debe enmarcarse en la enseñanza situacional (o cognición situada) a través del análisis y la evaluación de los argumentos auténticos que pululan en la realidad inmediata, para dar cuenta de los límites y alcances que tiene la misma lógica formal. La consecuencia pedagógica de esto es mostrar una lógica que trasciende así misma con el fin de validarse como una herramienta útil para el análisis y evaluación de argumentos; y que luego, en su inmanencia, se retrae para reconocerse falible y en continua revisión, para así poder o no ser inscrita en relación con el desarrollo de las habilidades del pensamiento crítico.
- 15 October 2020
- Published by Corporacion Minuto de Dios University - UNIMINUTO in Polisemia
- Vol. 16 (30) , 117-132
Open AccessLa lógica formal, el pensamiento crítico y la cognición situada
En este ensayo se plantea que la enseñanza de la lógica formal, en función del desarrollo de las habilidades esenciales de pensamiento crítico, debe enmarcarse en la enseñanza situacional (o cognición situada) a través del análisis y la evaluación de los argumentos auténticos que pululan en la realidad inmediata, para dar cuenta de los límites y alcances que tiene la misma lógica formal. La consecuencia pedagógica de esto es mostrar una lógica que trasciende así misma con el fin de validarse como una herramienta útil para el análisis y evaluación de argumentos; y que luego, en su inmanencia, se retrae para reconocerse falible y en continua revisión, para así poder o no ser inscrita en relación con el desarrollo de las habilidades del pensamiento crítico.
- 1 August 2008
Karl Popper: demarcación y objetividad