Haichao Li
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Haichao Li has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heleen Deroo
Department of Environment, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
5 shared publications - Orly Mendoza
Department of Environment, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
5 shared publications Stefaan De Neve
Department of Environment, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
5 shared publicationsSteven Sleutel
Department of Environment, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
5 shared publications- Astrid Françoys
Department of Environment, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
4 shared publications Cecilia Sundberg
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU)
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Radiocarbon
- Vol. 68 (5) , 1146-1154
Bomb 14 C for tracing biochar mineralization in soil
Improving our understanding of biochar carbon (C) stability in soil is crucial given its potential for soil C sequestration. However, challenges with isotopic labeling of biochar restrict our ability to determine its fate in soil. Atmospheric nuclear bomb tests in the 1960s resulted in a 14 C spike in tree rings, providing an opportunity to address this challenge. Here, we present a method that utilizes the elevated levels of 14 C in wood from tree rings formed between 1964 and 1967 as a tracer to determine the proportion of biochar C in mineralized soil. Biochar was produced using wood from the 14 C enriched tree rings as feedstock and thereafter used in a mineralization experiment capturing the emitted CO 2 . We demonstrate that the bomb 14 C-enrichment in the biochar is high enough to differentiate between CO 2 originating from either biochar or soil organic matter mineralization. The method can be used to address questions on biochar persistence, its interactions with soil organic matter and research that is needed to explore the potential to use biochar for C sequestration in soils.
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Radiocarbon
- Vol. 68 (5) , 1146-1154
Open AccessBomb 14 C for tracing biochar mineralization in soil
Improving our understanding of biochar carbon (C) stability in soil is crucial given its potential for soil C sequestration. However, challenges with isotopic labeling of biochar restrict our ability to determine its fate in soil. Atmospheric nuclear bomb tests in the 1960s resulted in a 14 C spike in tree rings, providing an opportunity to address this challenge. Here, we present a method that utilizes the elevated levels of 14 C in wood from tree rings formed between 1964 and 1967 as a tracer to determine the proportion of biochar C in mineralized soil. Biochar was produced using wood from the 14 C enriched tree rings as feedstock and thereafter used in a mineralization experiment capturing the emitted CO 2 . We demonstrate that the bomb 14 C-enrichment in the biochar is high enough to differentiate between CO 2 originating from either biochar or soil organic matter mineralization. The method can be used to address questions on biochar persistence, its interactions with soil organic matter and research that is needed to explore the potential to use biochar for C sequestration in soils.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Soil Science
- Vol. 6, 1809945
Extraction method influences dissolved organic matter from invasive Japanese knotweed-derived biochar and environmental implications
Valorization of invasive plant biomass through pyrolysis into biochar offers opportunities for waste management and resource recovery. However, the release of biochar-derived dissolved organic matter (BDOM), which influences carbon dynamics and pollutant mobility, remains poorly understood. This study investigated BDOM from Japanese knotweed biochar (500 °C) using seven extraction methods, covering mild aqueous conditions (water and CaCl 2 ), salt effects (NaCl), standardized acidic leaching tests (the synthetic precipitation leaching procedure, SPLP, and the toxicity characteristic leaching procedure, TCLP), and strong chemical extraction conditions (HCl and NaOH). NaOH and HCl maximized dissolved organic carbon (DOC) release (75–183 mg L - ¹) while the resulting BDOM exhibited low aromaticity (SUVA 254 : 0.02–0.05 L mg C −1 m −1 ) and relatively lower molecular weight (E 2 /E 3 > 0.5). In contrast, mild extraction (water and CaCl 2 ) released less DOC (5–15 mg L - ¹) but preserved high-aromaticity components with larger molecular weights. Fluorescence analysis identified four distinct BDOM components: (1) a terrestrial humic-like substance (C4) preferentially extracted by water, (2) a fulvic-like component (C2) dominant in NaCl and SPLP extracts, (3) a protein-like component (C1) most abundant in NaCl extract, and (4) a transitional component (C3) that decreased under acidic conditions. The results demonstrate that extraction method influences BDOM quantity, optical characteristics, and compositional features, providing a useful framework for understanding BDOM behavior and informing the environmental management of invasive plant.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Soil Science
- Vol. 6, 1809945
Open AccessExtraction method influences dissolved organic matter from invasive Japanese knotweed-derived biochar and environmental implications
Valorization of invasive plant biomass through pyrolysis into biochar offers opportunities for waste management and resource recovery. However, the release of biochar-derived dissolved organic matter (BDOM), which influences carbon dynamics and pollutant mobility, remains poorly understood. This study investigated BDOM from Japanese knotweed biochar (500 °C) using seven extraction methods, covering mild aqueous conditions (water and CaCl 2 ), salt effects (NaCl), standardized acidic leaching tests (the synthetic precipitation leaching procedure, SPLP, and the toxicity characteristic leaching procedure, TCLP), and strong chemical extraction conditions (HCl and NaOH). NaOH and HCl maximized dissolved organic carbon (DOC) release (75–183 mg L - ¹) while the resulting BDOM exhibited low aromaticity (SUVA 254 : 0.02–0.05 L mg C −1 m −1 ) and relatively lower molecular weight (E 2 /E 3 > 0.5). In contrast, mild extraction (water and CaCl 2 ) released less DOC (5–15 mg L - ¹) but preserved high-aromaticity components with larger molecular weights. Fluorescence analysis identified four distinct BDOM components: (1) a terrestrial humic-like substance (C4) preferentially extracted by water, (2) a fulvic-like component (C2) dominant in NaCl and SPLP extracts, (3) a protein-like component (C1) most abundant in NaCl extract, and (4) a transitional component (C3) that decreased under acidic conditions. The results demonstrate that extraction method influences BDOM quantity, optical characteristics, and compositional features, providing a useful framework for understanding BDOM behavior and informing the environmental management of invasive plant.
- Open Access
- 30 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in SOIL
- Vol. 11 (1) , 105-119
Soil organic carbon mineralization is controlled by the application dose of exogenous organic matter
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of the EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90 d incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg−1 soil). The percentage of mineralized EOM was expected to increase linearly with a higher EOM dose in sandy loam soil and to level off in silt loam soil due to the limited O2 supply in order to maintain aerobic microbial activity. In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with an increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C g−1 EOM). Likewise, the formation of microbial biomass carbon was proportional to EOM dose, suggesting no reduction in microbial growth efficiency at a higher C concentration. In the silt loam soil, a decreasing tendency in the percentage of mineralized EOM was apparent but could not be confirmed statistically. We therefore conclude that, as in the sandy loam, the proportion of EOM mineralization was not affected with an increasing EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C g−1 EOM). Consistently with this lack of response in the proportion of EOM mineralization to EOM dose, soil EH did not decrease with an increasing EOM dose, indicating no O2 limitations. In both soils, an increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which, in turn, stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). The observed stimulation of soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil might have contributed to sustaining the aerobic conditions required for SOC mineralization. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates the mineralization of native SOC. Provisional C balances compared to unamended controls indicated that, at low doses, less C remained than when EOM was added at normal or high doses in sandy loam soil, while no effect was found in silt loam soil. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more added EOM-C, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we can draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- 30 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in SOIL
- Vol. 11 (1) , 105-119
Open AccessSoil organic carbon mineralization is controlled by the application dose of exogenous organic matter
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of the EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90 d incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg−1 soil). The percentage of mineralized EOM was expected to increase linearly with a higher EOM dose in sandy loam soil and to level off in silt loam soil due to the limited O2 supply in order to maintain aerobic microbial activity. In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with an increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C g−1 EOM). Likewise, the formation of microbial biomass carbon was proportional to EOM dose, suggesting no reduction in microbial growth efficiency at a higher C concentration. In the silt loam soil, a decreasing tendency in the percentage of mineralized EOM was apparent but could not be confirmed statistically. We therefore conclude that, as in the sandy loam, the proportion of EOM mineralization was not affected with an increasing EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C g−1 EOM). Consistently with this lack of response in the proportion of EOM mineralization to EOM dose, soil EH did not decrease with an increasing EOM dose, indicating no O2 limitations. In both soils, an increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which, in turn, stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). The observed stimulation of soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil might have contributed to sustaining the aerobic conditions required for SOC mineralization. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates the mineralization of native SOC. Provisional C balances compared to unamended controls indicated that, at low doses, less C remained than when EOM was added at normal or high doses in sandy loam soil, while no effect was found in silt loam soil. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more added EOM-C, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we can draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Elevated CO2 effects on Zn and Fe nutrition in vegetables: A meta-analysis
The atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration has been progressively increasing since the onset of the Industrial Revolution and has already reached at around 420 μmol mol⁻¹ nowadays. It is well recognized that elevated CO2 concentration stimulates the yield for C3 crops, but it also simultaneously changes the essential nutrients. However, compared with the main crops, far less attention has been devoted to the effects of elevated CO2 concentration on vegetable growth and quality. Vegetables are highly recommended in daily diets due to their diverse range of beneficial compounds, such as vitamins, antioxidants, minerals, and dietary fiber. In controlled greenhouse vegetable cultivation, elevated CO2 has been widely adopted as an agricultural practice for enhancing plant growth. Thus, understanding both vegetable growth and nutrient status is crucial to assess the potential impacts of elevated CO2 on future food security in both natural and controlled environments. However, much more attention has been paid to biomass enhancement, and elevated CO2 effects on nutrient quality are less recognized. Among the nutrients, Zinc (Zn) and Iron (Fe) are essential elements in humans. Previous studies have demonstrated a decreasing trend of Zn and Fe in main crops such as wheat and rice with increased CO2, while less is known about whether this alleviation effect on Zn and Fe can apply to vegetables. Therefore, a meta-analysis was conducted in this study to evaluate the influence of elevated CO2 concentration in the atmosphere on vegetable Fe and Zn status, and quantify the potential impact of future climate on nutrition security.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessElevated CO2 effects on Zn and Fe nutrition in vegetables: A meta-analysis
The atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration has been progressively increasing since the onset of the Industrial Revolution and has already reached at around 420 μmol mol⁻¹ nowadays. It is well recognized that elevated CO2 concentration stimulates the yield for C3 crops, but it also simultaneously changes the essential nutrients. However, compared with the main crops, far less attention has been devoted to the effects of elevated CO2 concentration on vegetable growth and quality. Vegetables are highly recommended in daily diets due to their diverse range of beneficial compounds, such as vitamins, antioxidants, minerals, and dietary fiber. In controlled greenhouse vegetable cultivation, elevated CO2 has been widely adopted as an agricultural practice for enhancing plant growth. Thus, understanding both vegetable growth and nutrient status is crucial to assess the potential impacts of elevated CO2 on future food security in both natural and controlled environments. However, much more attention has been paid to biomass enhancement, and elevated CO2 effects on nutrient quality are less recognized. Among the nutrients, Zinc (Zn) and Iron (Fe) are essential elements in humans. Previous studies have demonstrated a decreasing trend of Zn and Fe in main crops such as wheat and rice with increased CO2, while less is known about whether this alleviation effect on Zn and Fe can apply to vegetables. Therefore, a meta-analysis was conducted in this study to evaluate the influence of elevated CO2 concentration in the atmosphere on vegetable Fe and Zn status, and quantify the potential impact of future climate on nutrition security.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Assessing inert pool models for estimating long-term biochar stability in soil
Estimating the long-term stability of biochar in soil often relies on extrapolating mineralization data from short-term laboratory incubations. Various models such as single first-order (SFO), double first-order (DFO), triple first-order (TFO) and the power model have been employed for this purpose, all of which have an inherent assumption that biochar is completely biodegradable. However, recent insights challenge this assumption by highlighting that biochar consist largely of highly condensed aromatic structures, which have been proposed to be essentially inert. If biochar were resistant to microbial degradation it would make sense if this was reflected in the choice of model used. Therefore, our aim was to assess whether the proposed inert pool models (SFO+I and DFO+I) fit the data better compared to existing models (SFO, DFO, TFO and power model) using a recently compiled extensive dataset. We hypothesized that models incorporating an inert pool would fit better (or at least comparably well) to incubation data compared to the existing models and give more reliable long-term predictions. As a way of assessing the model’s predictive ability, we fitted them to progressively shortened incubation times derived from the longest biochar incubation data sets available, and then evaluated how well they extrapolated to the full measured range. Our results indicated that the proposed DFO+I model did indeed fit better than the both DFO and TFO models. Moreover, predictions of BC100 (% of carbon remaining after 100 years) by the inert pool models and by the power model displayed stronger correlations with the biochar stability indicator (H/C ratio) than both SFO and DFO models, which aligns with our initial hypothesis. However, the power model in general outperformed all other models, including the inert pool models, with the highest number of best fits. From our extrapolation exercise, it is clear the DFO model, which has been most widely used to date, substantially underestimated biochar stability in the longer term while the inert pool models tended to overestimate it. This uncertainty appears to be quite severe when fitting inert pool models to incubation data from non-pyrolysed materials. By comparison, the power model appeared to be more robust when estimating biochar persistence in soils. From these results we cannot conclusively confirm nor reject the idea of inert pool models. It is possible that an inert-pool model is the more suitable choice for extrapolating biochar decomposition data. However, it is clear from their tendency to overestimate stability of biodegradable materials. Our current understanding is hampered by the fact that the incubation data set available contains a high proportion of biochars produced at relatively modest temperatures and by a lack of chemical/structural characterization of the incubated biochars. Future research could remedy this by providing better information on the degree of aromatic condensation/proportion of inertinite in incubated biochars samples. For now, we recommend the power model as the most robust option.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAssessing inert pool models for estimating long-term biochar stability in soil
Estimating the long-term stability of biochar in soil often relies on extrapolating mineralization data from short-term laboratory incubations. Various models such as single first-order (SFO), double first-order (DFO), triple first-order (TFO) and the power model have been employed for this purpose, all of which have an inherent assumption that biochar is completely biodegradable. However, recent insights challenge this assumption by highlighting that biochar consist largely of highly condensed aromatic structures, which have been proposed to be essentially inert. If biochar were resistant to microbial degradation it would make sense if this was reflected in the choice of model used. Therefore, our aim was to assess whether the proposed inert pool models (SFO+I and DFO+I) fit the data better compared to existing models (SFO, DFO, TFO and power model) using a recently compiled extensive dataset. We hypothesized that models incorporating an inert pool would fit better (or at least comparably well) to incubation data compared to the existing models and give more reliable long-term predictions. As a way of assessing the model’s predictive ability, we fitted them to progressively shortened incubation times derived from the longest biochar incubation data sets available, and then evaluated how well they extrapolated to the full measured range. Our results indicated that the proposed DFO+I model did indeed fit better than the both DFO and TFO models. Moreover, predictions of BC100 (% of carbon remaining after 100 years) by the inert pool models and by the power model displayed stronger correlations with the biochar stability indicator (H/C ratio) than both SFO and DFO models, which aligns with our initial hypothesis. However, the power model in general outperformed all other models, including the inert pool models, with the highest number of best fits. From our extrapolation exercise, it is clear the DFO model, which has been most widely used to date, substantially underestimated biochar stability in the longer term while the inert pool models tended to overestimate it. This uncertainty appears to be quite severe when fitting inert pool models to incubation data from non-pyrolysed materials. By comparison, the power model appeared to be more robust when estimating biochar persistence in soils. From these results we cannot conclusively confirm nor reject the idea of inert pool models. It is possible that an inert-pool model is the more suitable choice for extrapolating biochar decomposition data. However, it is clear from their tendency to overestimate stability of biodegradable materials. Our current understanding is hampered by the fact that the incubation data set available contains a high proportion of biochars produced at relatively modest temperatures and by a lack of chemical/structural characterization of the incubated biochars. Future research could remedy this by providing better information on the degree of aromatic condensation/proportion of inertinite in incubated biochars samples. For now, we recommend the power model as the most robust option.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC1
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- 9 June 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC1
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC2
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- 9 June 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC2
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Comment on egusphere-2024-107
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- 13 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-107
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- Open Access
- 30 January 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Soil organic carbon mineralization is controlled by the application dose of exogenous organic matter
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.
- 30 January 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessSoil organic carbon mineralization is controlled by the application dose of exogenous organic matter
Substantial input of exogenous organic matter (EOM) may be required to offset the projected decline in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in croplands caused by global warming. However, information on the effectivity of EOM application dose in preserving SOC stocks is surprisingly limited. Therefore, we set up a 90-day incubation experiment with large soil volumes (sandy loam and silt loam) to compare the mineralization of EOM (13C-labelled ryegrass) and SOC as a function of three EOM application doses (0.5, 1.5, and 5 g dry matter kg-1 soil). In the sandy loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM was not affected by EOM dose, while SOC mineralization increased proportionally with increasing EOM dose (+49.6 mg C per g EOM). In the silt loam soil, the percentage of mineralized EOM decreased somewhat with increasing dose, while SOC mineralization increased at a higher rate than in the sandy loam soil (+117.2 mg C per g EOM). In both textured soils, increasing EOM dose possibly supplied energy for microbial growth and enzyme production, which in turn stimulated mineralization of native SOC (i.e. co-metabolism). Higher soil macroporosity at higher EOM doses in the silt loam soil could have contributed to sustaining aerobic conditions (indicated by soil Eh) and promoting SOC priming as shown by positive relationships between pore neck size classes 43–60, 60–100 and >300 μm and SOC priming, suggesting a new mechanism for understanding SOC priming. In sum, this experiment and our previous research suggest that EOM mineralization is mostly independent of EOM dose, but EOM dose modulates mineralization of native SOC. These findings tentatively indicate that using larger EOM doses could help preserve more of added EOM-C in silt loam soils, but longer-term confirmation in the field will firstly be required before we could draw any conclusion for soil C management.