Morgane Audrey Gelly
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Morgane Audrey Gelly has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Annie Pullen Sansfaçon
School of Social Work, University of Montreal
9 shared publications Sidonie Atgé-Delbays
School of Social Work, University of Montreal, Montreal, Canada
2 shared publicationsAnnie Pullen Sansfaçon
School of Social Work, University of Montreal, Montreal, Canada
1 shared publication- Denise Medico
Professeure, Département de sexologie, Université du Québec à Montréal
1 shared publication Edward Ou Jin Lee
Professeur agrégé, École de travail social, Université de Montréal
1 shared publicationElio Gravel
Canada Research Chair on Partnership Research and Empowerment of Vulnerable youth, University of Montreal, Canada
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Valparaiso in Psicoperspectivas
- Vol. 25 (2)
When participation meets protection: The generative failure of a photovoice with trans youth in care
This article examines the “generative failure” of a “Photovoice” project conducted with transgender youth in Quebec’s child protection system—the first study of its kind in this context. Although initially designed as a six-phase participatory action research model, the project had to be reoriented toward individual qualitative interviews and photo elicitation due to significant institutional, technical, and ethical barriers. Drawing on trans-affirmative and anti-oppressive frameworks, the study analyzes four key challenges: i) structural barriers to recruitment and access caused by institutional control; ii) tensions related to the use of mobile devices in controlled, highly surveilled spaces; iii) the impact of digital exclusion and isolation on participants’ autonomy; and iv) emerging ethical dilemmas regarding the use of smartphones as compensation versus coercive incentives. The findings highlight a fundamental conflict between the emancipatory goals of Photovoice and the coercive and protective logic of child welfare institutions. The study concludes with practical recommendations for researchers and professionals.
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Valparaiso in Psicoperspectivas
- Vol. 25 (2)
Open AccessWhen participation meets protection: The generative failure of a photovoice with trans youth in care
This article examines the “generative failure” of a “Photovoice” project conducted with transgender youth in Quebec’s child protection system—the first study of its kind in this context. Although initially designed as a six-phase participatory action research model, the project had to be reoriented toward individual qualitative interviews and photo elicitation due to significant institutional, technical, and ethical barriers. Drawing on trans-affirmative and anti-oppressive frameworks, the study analyzes four key challenges: i) structural barriers to recruitment and access caused by institutional control; ii) tensions related to the use of mobile devices in controlled, highly surveilled spaces; iii) the impact of digital exclusion and isolation on participants’ autonomy; and iv) emerging ethical dilemmas regarding the use of smartphones as compensation versus coercive incentives. The findings highlight a fundamental conflict between the emancipatory goals of Photovoice and the coercive and protective logic of child welfare institutions. The study concludes with practical recommendations for researchers and professionals.
- Top Cited Papers
- 21 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Sexuality Research and Social Policy
- Vol. 22 (4) , 1748-1764
“They’re Unable to See my Decision to Detransition for What it is”: How Detrans Youth Perceive and Receive Discourses on Detransition
- 21 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Sexuality Research and Social Policy
- Vol. 22 (4) , 1748-1764
Top Cited Papers“They’re Unable to See my Decision to Detransition for What it is”: How Detrans Youth Perceive and Receive Discourses on Detransition
- 25 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Transgender Health
- Vol. 26 (1) , 180-197
Exploring the practice principles and beliefs of trans-care providers working with trans and detrans youth: A survey-based analysis
While research on detransition in young people has helped to develop a data-driven understanding of this new phenomenon, it only became available late 2020. This small-scale exploratory project aims to examine the attitudes and beliefs on the topic of detransition held by trans-care providers working with trans and non-binary youth at a moment when research evidence was limited. An online survey was circulated between September 1, 2020, and January 31, 2021. A total of 147 professionals participated, of whom 61 completed more than 60% of the online survey. The survey examined how attitudes and beliefs of these 61 participants compare between providers who have or may have followed youth who detransitioned (YDT) (n = 29) and those who have not (n = 22). Descriptive and Mann-Withney U tests using SPSS V 28 were performed. Qualitative data were analised through thematic analysis and used to illustrate quantitative data. The analysis uncovered slight but significant differences between these two groups of care providers. The results indicate that those who have interacted with YDT are less likely to have adhered to the empirical evidence available at the time of the survey compared to those who have not. While the reasons for these differences are not entirely clear, the article suggests that media content may have captured the attention of providers who have followed YDT, potentially leading to confirmation bias. The latest peer-reviewed evidence has to be more readily accessible to all providers, and providers must critically appraise evidence to ensure that their practices are more data-driven and insure best intervention for all gender-diverse youth.
- 25 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Transgender Health
- Vol. 26 (1) , 180-197
Exploring the practice principles and beliefs of trans-care providers working with trans and detrans youth: A survey-based analysis
While research on detransition in young people has helped to develop a data-driven understanding of this new phenomenon, it only became available late 2020. This small-scale exploratory project aims to examine the attitudes and beliefs on the topic of detransition held by trans-care providers working with trans and non-binary youth at a moment when research evidence was limited. An online survey was circulated between September 1, 2020, and January 31, 2021. A total of 147 professionals participated, of whom 61 completed more than 60% of the online survey. The survey examined how attitudes and beliefs of these 61 participants compare between providers who have or may have followed youth who detransitioned (YDT) (n = 29) and those who have not (n = 22). Descriptive and Mann-Withney U tests using SPSS V 28 were performed. Qualitative data were analised through thematic analysis and used to illustrate quantitative data. The analysis uncovered slight but significant differences between these two groups of care providers. The results indicate that those who have interacted with YDT are less likely to have adhered to the empirical evidence available at the time of the survey compared to those who have not. While the reasons for these differences are not entirely clear, the article suggests that media content may have captured the attention of providers who have followed YDT, potentially leading to confirmation bias. The latest peer-reviewed evidence has to be more readily accessible to all providers, and providers must critically appraise evidence to ensure that their practices are more data-driven and insure best intervention for all gender-diverse youth.
- 4 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Homosexuality
- Vol. 72 (6) , 1002-1024
Gender-Related Medical Experiences of Youth Who Have Detranstioned
People whose gender does not align with their sex assigned at birth can undergo a medical transition process, so their body reflects their gender. However, some people interrupt this process temporarily or permanently, which is often referred to as "detransition." Media coverage of detrans experiences tend to attribute this phenomenon to a lack of medical gatekeeping. However, research has shown detransitions are highly unpredictable. The aim of this article is to examine the medical experiences of youth who have detransitioned during various stages of the process from transition to today. Twenty-five interviews with 15-25-year-old youth who detransitioned were conducted. Thematic analysis led to the development of six themes: facing gatekeeping and invalidation during transition, accessing trans care, lacking adequate support during transition, finding support in detransition, lacking support in detransition, leaving the medical system. Our results question the usefulness of gatekeeping to prevent detransition and shows that it tends to erode the trust relationship between youth and practitioners and stifle gender exploration. Validation, support, information giving as well as exploration without constrain, or expectation of outcome seems to be a more helpful way forward to work with gender diverse youth.
- 4 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Homosexuality
- Vol. 72 (6) , 1002-1024
Gender-Related Medical Experiences of Youth Who Have Detranstioned
People whose gender does not align with their sex assigned at birth can undergo a medical transition process, so their body reflects their gender. However, some people interrupt this process temporarily or permanently, which is often referred to as "detransition." Media coverage of detrans experiences tend to attribute this phenomenon to a lack of medical gatekeeping. However, research has shown detransitions are highly unpredictable. The aim of this article is to examine the medical experiences of youth who have detransitioned during various stages of the process from transition to today. Twenty-five interviews with 15-25-year-old youth who detransitioned were conducted. Thematic analysis led to the development of six themes: facing gatekeeping and invalidation during transition, accessing trans care, lacking adequate support during transition, finding support in detransition, lacking support in detransition, leaving the medical system. Our results question the usefulness of gatekeeping to prevent detransition and shows that it tends to erode the trust relationship between youth and practitioners and stifle gender exploration. Validation, support, information giving as well as exploration without constrain, or expectation of outcome seems to be a more helpful way forward to work with gender diverse youth.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 9 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Dealing With Scam in Online Qualitative Research: Strategies and Ethical Considerations
In the wake of COVID-19, numerous research projects moved to online data collection to comply with public health guidelines. Since then, many qualitative projects have continued to use online methods to collect data. While online methods facilitated research continuity, they also introduced new opportunities for deceptive behaviors, particularly misrepresentation and multiple participation. Drawing from a recent project that conducted online interviews with young people who detransition after a gender transition, this article describes how fraudulent interviews were identified and dealt with. We present 12 indicators of potential scams in qualitative interviews, including similarities between participants, the type of information provided, participants’ behaviors, and inconsistencies in the narratives. We discuss our overall experience and, in light of recent literature, present strategies to prevent and deal with scams in qualitative research.
- 9 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessDealing With Scam in Online Qualitative Research: Strategies and Ethical Considerations
In the wake of COVID-19, numerous research projects moved to online data collection to comply with public health guidelines. Since then, many qualitative projects have continued to use online methods to collect data. While online methods facilitated research continuity, they also introduced new opportunities for deceptive behaviors, particularly misrepresentation and multiple participation. Drawing from a recent project that conducted online interviews with young people who detransition after a gender transition, this article describes how fraudulent interviews were identified and dealt with. We present 12 indicators of potential scams in qualitative interviews, including similarities between participants, the type of information provided, participants’ behaviors, and inconsistencies in the narratives. We discuss our overall experience and, in light of recent literature, present strategies to prevent and deal with scams in qualitative research.
- 18 December 2023
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Revue Jeunes Et Société
- Vol. 7 (1) , 92-117
Regards sur les difficultés vécues lors de la transition chez les jeunes ayant détransitionné
Les caractéristiques propres aux parcours des jeunes qui détransitionnent (qui choisissent de discontinuer leur transition de genre) demeurent encore peu connues à ce jour. En outre, dans les dernières années, plusieurs études se sont intéressées aux difficultés vécues par les jeunes durant leur transition (médicale, sociale et/ou légale). Cependant, encore peu de recherches ont cherché à mettre en relief les défis propres aux parcours des jeunes qui détransitionnent. Or, un besoin criant de caractérisation demeure et pourrait permettre de mieux accompagner ces jeunes avec un parcours de genre encore méconnu et en émergence. Cette étude s’appuie sur des données amassées dans le cadre d’une recherche s’intéressant aux discours autour de la détransition chez les jeunes. Cet article a pour but d’examiner les difficultés vécues lors de la transition chez les jeunes ayant détransitionné. Il s’appuie sur 20 entrevues semi-dirigées avec des jeunes âgé·e·s de 16 à 25 ans, provenant de sept pays différents et ayant détransitionné. L’analyse permet de dégager des difficultés intrinsèques et extrinsèques en incluant plusieurs qui sont également vécues par les jeunes trans et non binaires. Une réflexion sur l’accompagnement des jeunes de la diversité des genres conclut l’article.
- 18 December 2023
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Revue Jeunes Et Société
- Vol. 7 (1) , 92-117
Regards sur les difficultés vécues lors de la transition chez les jeunes ayant détransitionné
Les caractéristiques propres aux parcours des jeunes qui détransitionnent (qui choisissent de discontinuer leur transition de genre) demeurent encore peu connues à ce jour. En outre, dans les dernières années, plusieurs études se sont intéressées aux difficultés vécues par les jeunes durant leur transition (médicale, sociale et/ou légale). Cependant, encore peu de recherches ont cherché à mettre en relief les défis propres aux parcours des jeunes qui détransitionnent. Or, un besoin criant de caractérisation demeure et pourrait permettre de mieux accompagner ces jeunes avec un parcours de genre encore méconnu et en émergence. Cette étude s’appuie sur des données amassées dans le cadre d’une recherche s’intéressant aux discours autour de la détransition chez les jeunes. Cet article a pour but d’examiner les difficultés vécues lors de la transition chez les jeunes ayant détransitionné. Il s’appuie sur 20 entrevues semi-dirigées avec des jeunes âgé·e·s de 16 à 25 ans, provenant de sept pays différents et ayant détransitionné. L’analyse permet de dégager des difficultés intrinsèques et extrinsèques en incluant plusieurs qui sont également vécues par les jeunes trans et non binaires. Une réflexion sur l’accompagnement des jeunes de la diversité des genres conclut l’article.
- Open Access
School Factors Strongly Impact Transgender and Non-Binary Youths’ Well-Being
Background: School plays an important role in transgender and non-binary (TNB) youths’ life and well-being. The aim of this study was to gain a better understanding of how the lived experiences, gender affirmation and challenges encountered by TNB youths in the school setting affect their well-being. Method: Our study was a qualitative secondary data analysis, based on the interviews of 12 Canadian TNB youths aged 15–17 years old. Results: We found that TNB students’ well-being was closely related to the acknowledgment of gender identity at school. Several factors, including school socio-cultural environment, teachers’ and peers’ attitudes and behaviours, school physical environments and the respect of confidentiality of gender identity were all found to impact TNB students’ well-being. To face adversity related to some of these factors, TNB youths used several contextually driven strategies such as compromising, educating, and sensitizing others about gender diversity and avoiding certain people or situations. Conclusion: Our results highlight the important influence of school climate and culture, as well as teachers’, school personnel’s and peers’ behaviours and attitudes on TNB youths’ well-being. Our findings can guide future interventions to help schools become more inclusive and supportive of gender diversity.
Open AccessSchool Factors Strongly Impact Transgender and Non-Binary Youths’ Well-Being
Background: School plays an important role in transgender and non-binary (TNB) youths’ life and well-being. The aim of this study was to gain a better understanding of how the lived experiences, gender affirmation and challenges encountered by TNB youths in the school setting affect their well-being. Method: Our study was a qualitative secondary data analysis, based on the interviews of 12 Canadian TNB youths aged 15–17 years old. Results: We found that TNB students’ well-being was closely related to the acknowledgment of gender identity at school. Several factors, including school socio-cultural environment, teachers’ and peers’ attitudes and behaviours, school physical environments and the respect of confidentiality of gender identity were all found to impact TNB students’ well-being. To face adversity related to some of these factors, TNB youths used several contextually driven strategies such as compromising, educating, and sensitizing others about gender diversity and avoiding certain people or situations. Conclusion: Our results highlight the important influence of school climate and culture, as well as teachers’, school personnel’s and peers’ behaviours and attitudes on TNB youths’ well-being. Our findings can guide future interventions to help schools become more inclusive and supportive of gender diversity.
- 11 August 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Work Research
- Vol. 45 (3) , 207-219
Affirmation and Safety: An Intersectional Analysis of Trans and Nonbinary Youths in Quebec
This article presents the results of a combined grounded theory and community-based participatory action research project with 54 trans and nonbinary youths (TNBY) residing in the province of Quebec, Canada. The project includes two important sensitizing concepts: intersectionality and recognition. In the research, intersectionality was defined as an approach that explores how people navigate manifold identities (class, race, disability, and so on) in the context of structural oppression. Authors applied an intersectional lens to the recruitment of research participants through an iterative, community-based process, and to the analysis of the oppressive structures that negatively influence the well-being of TNBY and the specific factors that enable TNBY to thrive. Drawing on Honneth’s concept of recognition, authors argue for a contextualized, dynamic, and relational understanding of how well-being is produced. Specifically, they show two presenting needs: one for affirmation and one for safety, access to which springs from resources of privilege that emerge in the environment in which young people are embedded and from which they self-advocate. Understanding the dynamic relationship between these two needs and how they shift according to context is an important component of applying an intersectional approach to supporting TNBY in social work settings.
- 11 August 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Work Research
- Vol. 45 (3) , 207-219
Affirmation and Safety: An Intersectional Analysis of Trans and Nonbinary Youths in Quebec
This article presents the results of a combined grounded theory and community-based participatory action research project with 54 trans and nonbinary youths (TNBY) residing in the province of Quebec, Canada. The project includes two important sensitizing concepts: intersectionality and recognition. In the research, intersectionality was defined as an approach that explores how people navigate manifold identities (class, race, disability, and so on) in the context of structural oppression. Authors applied an intersectional lens to the recruitment of research participants through an iterative, community-based process, and to the analysis of the oppressive structures that negatively influence the well-being of TNBY and the specific factors that enable TNBY to thrive. Drawing on Honneth’s concept of recognition, authors argue for a contextualized, dynamic, and relational understanding of how well-being is produced. Specifically, they show two presenting needs: one for affirmation and one for safety, access to which springs from resources of privilege that emerge in the environment in which young people are embedded and from which they self-advocate. Understanding the dynamic relationship between these two needs and how they shift according to context is an important component of applying an intersectional approach to supporting TNBY in social work settings.
- Open Access
- 15 June 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Enfances, Familles, Générations
- No. 36
Soutien et non soutien parental des jeunes trans : vers une compréhension nuancée des formes de soutien et des attentes des jeunes trans
Cadre de la recherche : Cet article porte sur les différents niveaux de soutien parental dont bénéficient (ou ne bénéficient pas) les jeunes trans. Objectifs : Le présent article vise à définir ce qu’est le soutien parental du point de vue des jeunes trans, et à montrer comment celui-ci affecte leur bien-être. Méthodologie : L’article s’appuie sur une recherche qualitative pour laquelle des entrevues semi-dirigées ont été menées auprès de 54 jeunes trans âgé(e)s entre 15 et 25 ans et résidant au Québec. Le processus de collecte et d’analyse des données a suivi une démarche de théorisation ancrée et a été guidé par deux concepts sensibilisateurs : la reconnaissance (Honneth) et l’intersectionnalité (Crenshaw). Résultats : Notre recherche permet de dégager trois niveaux de soutien : soutien fort, neutralité négative et non-soutien ou rejet. Ces formes de soutien parental peuvent être inconditionnelles ou conditionnelles à ce que la jeune personne se conforme à certaines normes données. Un soutien fort qui encourage l’expression de genre favorise le bien-être des jeunes et fortifie la relation avec leurs parents. Au contraire, le non-soutien ou rejet parental affecte le bien-être des jeunes, peut les exposer à des situations plus précaires ou les conduire à chercher d’autres formes de soutien. Par ailleurs, un soutien partiel ou la neutralité négative semblent aussi affecter négativement le bien-être et l’estime de soi le la jeune personne. Conclusion : Notre article démontre que, pour favoriser le bien-être des jeunes, l’acceptation parentale doit s’accompagner de gestes concrets qui permettent et encouragent clairement l’expression de genre des jeunes trans. Il serait valable, selon nous, d’informer et d’accompagner les parents dans le processus d’acceptation de leur enfant. Contribution : Cet article permet de pallier un manque de données qualitatives sur le soutien parental et ses effets sur les jeunes trans, depuis la perspective des jeunes personnes elles-mêmes. Notre étude permet d’établir avec plus de finesse comment le soutien parental ou son absence s’inscrivent dans des trajectoires de vie et affectent le bien-être des jeunes trans.
- 15 June 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Enfances, Familles, Générations
- No. 36
Open AccessSoutien et non soutien parental des jeunes trans : vers une compréhension nuancée des formes de soutien et des attentes des jeunes trans
Cadre de la recherche : Cet article porte sur les différents niveaux de soutien parental dont bénéficient (ou ne bénéficient pas) les jeunes trans. Objectifs : Le présent article vise à définir ce qu’est le soutien parental du point de vue des jeunes trans, et à montrer comment celui-ci affecte leur bien-être. Méthodologie : L’article s’appuie sur une recherche qualitative pour laquelle des entrevues semi-dirigées ont été menées auprès de 54 jeunes trans âgé(e)s entre 15 et 25 ans et résidant au Québec. Le processus de collecte et d’analyse des données a suivi une démarche de théorisation ancrée et a été guidé par deux concepts sensibilisateurs : la reconnaissance (Honneth) et l’intersectionnalité (Crenshaw). Résultats : Notre recherche permet de dégager trois niveaux de soutien : soutien fort, neutralité négative et non-soutien ou rejet. Ces formes de soutien parental peuvent être inconditionnelles ou conditionnelles à ce que la jeune personne se conforme à certaines normes données. Un soutien fort qui encourage l’expression de genre favorise le bien-être des jeunes et fortifie la relation avec leurs parents. Au contraire, le non-soutien ou rejet parental affecte le bien-être des jeunes, peut les exposer à des situations plus précaires ou les conduire à chercher d’autres formes de soutien. Par ailleurs, un soutien partiel ou la neutralité négative semblent aussi affecter négativement le bien-être et l’estime de soi le la jeune personne. Conclusion : Notre article démontre que, pour favoriser le bien-être des jeunes, l’acceptation parentale doit s’accompagner de gestes concrets qui permettent et encouragent clairement l’expression de genre des jeunes trans. Il serait valable, selon nous, d’informer et d’accompagner les parents dans le processus d’acceptation de leur enfant. Contribution : Cet article permet de pallier un manque de données qualitatives sur le soutien parental et ses effets sur les jeunes trans, depuis la perspective des jeunes personnes elles-mêmes. Notre étude permet d’établir avec plus de finesse comment le soutien parental ou son absence s’inscrivent dans des trajectoires de vie et affectent le bien-être des jeunes trans.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Revue Jeunes Et Société
- Vol. 6 (1) , 104-127
Regards croisés de jeunes trans et de leurs parents sur la transition médicale au Canada : quel impact sur l’épanouissement des jeunes?
The past decade has witnessed significant change in medical care for trans youth. A well-established pathologizing approach focused on asserting a young person’s assigned gender has been challenged by a growing number of experts who favour a model that supports gender exploration (e.g., by providing access to hormonal treatments and puberty blockers). Based on interviews with 36 parent-youth dyads (72 interviews in total), this article explores the expectations and impacts associated with medical transition. On the one hand, the interview data show that young people and their parents agree that access to trans-affirmative medical care has a positive impact on youth development. Specifically, it is seen to reduce suffering associated with gender dysphoria, while promoting both self-recognition and intersubjectivity. On the other hand, the interview data highlight the extent to which available health care pathways (often based on a binary approach) have failed to keep pace with the expectations and concerns of youth and their parents. Our article therefore emphasizes the importance of offering transaffirmative care adapted to the needs of youth seeking to transition.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Revue Jeunes Et Société
- Vol. 6 (1) , 104-127
Open AccessRegards croisés de jeunes trans et de leurs parents sur la transition médicale au Canada : quel impact sur l’épanouissement des jeunes?
The past decade has witnessed significant change in medical care for trans youth. A well-established pathologizing approach focused on asserting a young person’s assigned gender has been challenged by a growing number of experts who favour a model that supports gender exploration (e.g., by providing access to hormonal treatments and puberty blockers). Based on interviews with 36 parent-youth dyads (72 interviews in total), this article explores the expectations and impacts associated with medical transition. On the one hand, the interview data show that young people and their parents agree that access to trans-affirmative medical care has a positive impact on youth development. Specifically, it is seen to reduce suffering associated with gender dysphoria, while promoting both self-recognition and intersubjectivity. On the other hand, the interview data highlight the extent to which available health care pathways (often based on a binary approach) have failed to keep pace with the expectations and concerns of youth and their parents. Our article therefore emphasizes the importance of offering transaffirmative care adapted to the needs of youth seeking to transition.