Nicholas W. Waterbury
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Nicholas W. Waterbury has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alan James Simmons
University of Illinois Springfield, Springfield, IL, USA
2 shared publications James F. Spriggs Ii
Department of Political Science, Washington University, Saint Louis, MO, USA
1 shared publication- Joshua Boston
Bowling Green State University
1 shared publication - Patrick Rickert
Department of Political Science, Rollins College
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 18 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (1) , 295-308
The Curious Case of the Migrating Seat: Understanding the Role of Senate Norms in Confirming Judges on the U.S. Courts of Appeals
The confirmation of lower federal court judges heavily depends on senatorial courtesy and the blue slip. Prior work largely ignores state representation—a norm whereby each judgeship on the U.S. Courts of Appeals is assigned to a particular state in the Circuit. Given this norm, senators expect that the president will nominate someone from the same state as the departing circuit judge. However, presidents fail to follow this norm nearly a quarter of the time. This research analyzes how ignoring state representation increases the level of conflict over a nominee. Our results reveal that (a) the probability of a nominee’s rejection by the Senate and (b) the amount of time for the Senate to take final action both increase as the ideological distance between the previous home state senators and the president grows. Additionally, if the new home state senators reveal public opposition to a nomination, the likelihood of rejection and time to final action increase.
- 18 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (1) , 295-308
The Curious Case of the Migrating Seat: Understanding the Role of Senate Norms in Confirming Judges on the U.S. Courts of Appeals
The confirmation of lower federal court judges heavily depends on senatorial courtesy and the blue slip. Prior work largely ignores state representation—a norm whereby each judgeship on the U.S. Courts of Appeals is assigned to a particular state in the Circuit. Given this norm, senators expect that the president will nominate someone from the same state as the departing circuit judge. However, presidents fail to follow this norm nearly a quarter of the time. This research analyzes how ignoring state representation increases the level of conflict over a nominee. Our results reveal that (a) the probability of a nominee’s rejection by the Senate and (b) the amount of time for the Senate to take final action both increase as the ideological distance between the previous home state senators and the president grows. Additionally, if the new home state senators reveal public opposition to a nomination, the likelihood of rejection and time to final action increase.
- 28 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Politics Research
- Vol. 53 (2) , 209-221
The Impact of Judicial Selection Method on State Supreme Court Justice Ideology
Among political institutions in the United States, state courts are surprisingly susceptible to ideological extremism because of the non-uniform ways judges are selected. In this paper we examine the effect of selection methods on the ideological composition of state supreme courts. We theorize that methods involving partisan politics lead to more ideological justices and that, among that subset, Republican affiliated justices will be the most extreme. We test our expectations using a dataset of over 600 state supreme court selections between 1961–2011. Using a contemporary matching algorithm designed to maximize causal identification, we find support for our hypotheses. Our results speak to the consequences of federalism in court composition and offer an insight into how polarization manifests in the judiciary.
- 28 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Politics Research
- Vol. 53 (2) , 209-221
The Impact of Judicial Selection Method on State Supreme Court Justice Ideology
Among political institutions in the United States, state courts are surprisingly susceptible to ideological extremism because of the non-uniform ways judges are selected. In this paper we examine the effect of selection methods on the ideological composition of state supreme courts. We theorize that methods involving partisan politics lead to more ideological justices and that, among that subset, Republican affiliated justices will be the most extreme. We test our expectations using a dataset of over 600 state supreme court selections between 1961–2011. Using a contemporary matching algorithm designed to maximize causal identification, we find support for our hypotheses. Our results speak to the consequences of federalism in court composition and offer an insight into how polarization manifests in the judiciary.
- 20 March 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Politics Research
- Vol. 52 (4) , 367-380
Sincere, Strategic, or Something Else? The Impact of Ranked-Choice Voting on Voter Decision Making Processes
The academic debate on how voters decide which candidates to support often centers on whether they prioritize their personal preferences or consider who can beat the opposing candidate. American research on voting behavior has largely focused on first-past-the-post (FPTP) elections. However, considering jurisdictions are adopting new electoral systems such as ranked-choice voting (RCV) this leads to several questions about the impact of system adoption on voter decision-making. Particularly, does the voter decision-making process differ depending on the system used? To investigate the impact of RCV on voter decision-making across electoral systems we conducted a survey experiment in a federal senate election. Our findings indicate that in comparison to FPTP elections, RCV elections may lead to decreases in both sincere and strategic voting. Instead, RCV appears to increase voter uncertainty around how to decide which candidates to support and leads to voters who appear to be neither sincere nor strategic.
- 20 March 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Politics Research
- Vol. 52 (4) , 367-380
Sincere, Strategic, or Something Else? The Impact of Ranked-Choice Voting on Voter Decision Making Processes
The academic debate on how voters decide which candidates to support often centers on whether they prioritize their personal preferences or consider who can beat the opposing candidate. American research on voting behavior has largely focused on first-past-the-post (FPTP) elections. However, considering jurisdictions are adopting new electoral systems such as ranked-choice voting (RCV) this leads to several questions about the impact of system adoption on voter decision-making. Particularly, does the voter decision-making process differ depending on the system used? To investigate the impact of RCV on voter decision-making across electoral systems we conducted a survey experiment in a federal senate election. Our findings indicate that in comparison to FPTP elections, RCV elections may lead to decreases in both sincere and strategic voting. Instead, RCV appears to increase voter uncertainty around how to decide which candidates to support and leads to voters who appear to be neither sincere nor strategic.
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- Vol. 12 (2) , 413-434
Justice Isn’t Blind: Attorney Attractiveness and Success in US Federal Court
Many court observers have argued that judges are capable of avoiding the use of extraneous factors in decision-making. This study examines the influence of seemingly irrelevant heuristics on real-world courtroom proceedings. Drawing on theories from neighboring disciplines, I hypothesize that physically attractive attorneys have greater success in US federal court. Using a generalizable causal inference strategy and a dataset of over 1,000 cases and 3,000 votes, I find support for my expectations using multiple measures of attractiveness. These findings raise serious normative concerns about equality and underscore the need to adjust traditional models of judicial behavior to account for inherent biases.
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- Vol. 12 (2) , 413-434
Justice Isn’t Blind: Attorney Attractiveness and Success in US Federal Court
Many court observers have argued that judges are capable of avoiding the use of extraneous factors in decision-making. This study examines the influence of seemingly irrelevant heuristics on real-world courtroom proceedings. Drawing on theories from neighboring disciplines, I hypothesize that physically attractive attorneys have greater success in US federal court. Using a generalizable causal inference strategy and a dataset of over 1,000 cases and 3,000 votes, I find support for my expectations using multiple measures of attractiveness. These findings raise serious normative concerns about equality and underscore the need to adjust traditional models of judicial behavior to account for inherent biases.