Christina A. Hackmann
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Christina A. Hackmann has a total of 289 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sharath Shyamappa Paligi
Plant Ecology and Ecosystems Research, Albrecht von Haller Institute for Plant Sciences, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany
9 shared publications - Christian Ammer
Silviculture and Forest Ecology of the Temperate Zones University of Göttingen Göttingen Germany
4 shared publications Christian Ammer
3 shared publicationsChristoph Leuschner
Plant Ecology, Albrecht von Haller Institute for Plant Sciences University of Göttingen Göttingen Germany
3 shared publications- Christoph Leuschner
Plant Ecology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany
3 shared publications Martina Mund
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
The PSInet Plant Water Potential Database: advancing new perspectives on plant water status, traits, and hydraulic processes
Water potential gradients drive water flow within and between soils and plants, and the internal plant water potential controls a wide range of physiological processes including photosynthesis, growth, and mortality. Notwithstanding this clear relevance for many critical aspects of ecosystem function, water potential data have historically been relatively inaccessible and unnetworked. The absence of a centralized repository for plant water potential time series limits our ability to integrate a wealth of ecophysiological information from other networks and from remote sensing. Closing this gap is necessary to address unresolved questions about plant responses to drought and heat stress, and to make confident predictions about plant and ecosystem function in a warming world. Here, we introduce the PSInet database -- a global collection of plant water potential time series from 285 datasets representing 523 species. We present the workflow that guided database development and evaluate its key features. Through a series of preliminary analyses, we then highlight the potential of the PSInet database for applications including: a) advancing plant water use strategy frameworks; b) disentangling the impacts of soil versus atmospheric drought stress; c) assessing the long-held assumption of pre-dawn equilibration of ecosystem water potential; d) understanding the risk of drought-driven mortality; and e) benchmarking remote-sensing data products and land-surface models.
Open AccessThe PSInet Plant Water Potential Database: advancing new perspectives on plant water status, traits, and hydraulic processes
Water potential gradients drive water flow within and between soils and plants, and the internal plant water potential controls a wide range of physiological processes including photosynthesis, growth, and mortality. Notwithstanding this clear relevance for many critical aspects of ecosystem function, water potential data have historically been relatively inaccessible and unnetworked. The absence of a centralized repository for plant water potential time series limits our ability to integrate a wealth of ecophysiological information from other networks and from remote sensing. Closing this gap is necessary to address unresolved questions about plant responses to drought and heat stress, and to make confident predictions about plant and ecosystem function in a warming world. Here, we introduce the PSInet database -- a global collection of plant water potential time series from 285 datasets representing 523 species. We present the workflow that guided database development and evaluate its key features. Through a series of preliminary analyses, we then highlight the potential of the PSInet database for applications including: a) advancing plant water use strategy frameworks; b) disentangling the impacts of soil versus atmospheric drought stress; c) assessing the long-held assumption of pre-dawn equilibration of ecosystem water potential; d) understanding the risk of drought-driven mortality; and e) benchmarking remote-sensing data products and land-surface models.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Tree Physiology
- Vol. 46 (7)
From microscopic movements to forest-scale insights: the Nordic Dendrometer Meeting and the emergence of the Global Dendrometer Network
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Tree Physiology
- Vol. 46 (7)
Open AccessFrom microscopic movements to forest-scale insights: the Nordic Dendrometer Meeting and the emergence of the Global Dendrometer Network
- Open Access
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 388
Isohydric Douglas fir shows earlier drought-induced declines in stem water status and growth than anisohydric beech
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 388
Open AccessIsohydric Douglas fir shows earlier drought-induced declines in stem water status and growth than anisohydric beech
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 251 (1) , 569-588
Continuous monitoring of plant water potential: sensor‐based approaches and best practices
Summary: Plant water potential is a central integrator of plant water status, linking hydraulic function with physiological performance and ecosystem water dynamics across species and systems. This review is motivated by the need to capture these dynamics under rapidly changing environmental conditions, which are often missed by discrete measurements. We evaluate the main approaches for continuous monitoring of plant water potential, including direct in situ sensors, indirect methods based on plant water content, and remote‐sensing proxies. We discuss the principles, measurement mechanisms, practical constraints, and environmental sensitivities of each approach. Relative to traditional methods, such as pressure chambers, continuous measurements offer major advantages by resolving rapid variation in water status and strengthening inference on plant–soil–atmosphere interactions. These approaches are especially valuable under dynamic field conditions, where temporal variability in vapor pressure deficit, soil moisture, temperature, and radiation strongly shapes hydraulic behavior. We conclude that continuous monitoring has substantial potential to advance plant and ecosystem science, but wider application will depend on careful interpretation and greater harmonization across comparable methodologies. By synthesizing core principles, methodological challenges and best practices, this review provides a practical framework for researchers and practitioners applying continuous water potential measurements.
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 251 (1) , 569-588
Continuous monitoring of plant water potential: sensor‐based approaches and best practices
Summary: Plant water potential is a central integrator of plant water status, linking hydraulic function with physiological performance and ecosystem water dynamics across species and systems. This review is motivated by the need to capture these dynamics under rapidly changing environmental conditions, which are often missed by discrete measurements. We evaluate the main approaches for continuous monitoring of plant water potential, including direct in situ sensors, indirect methods based on plant water content, and remote‐sensing proxies. We discuss the principles, measurement mechanisms, practical constraints, and environmental sensitivities of each approach. Relative to traditional methods, such as pressure chambers, continuous measurements offer major advantages by resolving rapid variation in water status and strengthening inference on plant–soil–atmosphere interactions. These approaches are especially valuable under dynamic field conditions, where temporal variability in vapor pressure deficit, soil moisture, temperature, and radiation strongly shapes hydraulic behavior. We conclude that continuous monitoring has substantial potential to advance plant and ecosystem science, but wider application will depend on careful interpretation and greater harmonization across comparable methodologies. By synthesizing core principles, methodological challenges and best practices, this review provides a practical framework for researchers and practitioners applying continuous water potential measurements.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Assessing forest resilience using multiple indicators: integrating structural, hydrological, ecophysiological, and stakeholder perspectives
Forests play a key role in mitigating climate change, yet their capacity to do so critically depends on their resilience to increasing climatic stressors such as drought and heat extremes. Here we aim to enhance science-based knowledge on forest resilience by applying a multi-scale research framework that integrates structural, hydrological, ecophysiological, and stakeholder perspectives at European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) stands in Central Germany.In a first step, we combine terrestrial, drone-based, and airborne LiDAR technologies to comprehensively characterize three-dimensional forest structure across spatial scales. From these data, we derive indicators of forest resilience related to canopy complexity. A particular focus is placed on evaluating the robustness of LiDAR-derived metrics with respect to phenological variability and spatial resolution, ensuring their applicability for long-term monitoring and cross-site comparisons.To link forest structure with ecosystem functioning, we investigate forest water, carbon and other biogeochemical fluxes along gradients of water availability and stand structure. In 2025 we carried out intensive measurement campaigns including detailed measurements of soil moisture at multiple depths, allowing us to assess how different stand structures influence soil water dynamics. We also measured mercury (Hg) concentration in the forest canopy for assessing Hg cycling of forests as indicator of biogeochemical resilience. We performed tree-level observations of growth and water consumption via dendrometer and sap flux sensors and combined them with ecosystem-scale measurements of CO₂, water, and energy exchange between forests and the atmosphere using the eddy covariance technique for ecophysiological indicators of forest resilience.Complementing these biophysical assessments, we integrate a socio-ecological dimension through qualitative interviews with forest stakeholders. This allows us to evaluate stakeholder assessments of the status quo, their visions for resilient forests, and the specific requirements for a successful transformation toward those goals.By integrating multiple indicators derived from measurements across spatial, temporal, and social scales, we provide a broad assessment of forest resilience. Our results contribute to a mechanistic understanding of how forest structure mediates water and carbon fluxes under climate stress, supporting the development of resilient forest management strategies and improved monitoring approaches for climate change mitigation that are both scientifically robust and stakeholder-informed.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAssessing forest resilience using multiple indicators: integrating structural, hydrological, ecophysiological, and stakeholder perspectives
Forests play a key role in mitigating climate change, yet their capacity to do so critically depends on their resilience to increasing climatic stressors such as drought and heat extremes. Here we aim to enhance science-based knowledge on forest resilience by applying a multi-scale research framework that integrates structural, hydrological, ecophysiological, and stakeholder perspectives at European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) stands in Central Germany.In a first step, we combine terrestrial, drone-based, and airborne LiDAR technologies to comprehensively characterize three-dimensional forest structure across spatial scales. From these data, we derive indicators of forest resilience related to canopy complexity. A particular focus is placed on evaluating the robustness of LiDAR-derived metrics with respect to phenological variability and spatial resolution, ensuring their applicability for long-term monitoring and cross-site comparisons.To link forest structure with ecosystem functioning, we investigate forest water, carbon and other biogeochemical fluxes along gradients of water availability and stand structure. In 2025 we carried out intensive measurement campaigns including detailed measurements of soil moisture at multiple depths, allowing us to assess how different stand structures influence soil water dynamics. We also measured mercury (Hg) concentration in the forest canopy for assessing Hg cycling of forests as indicator of biogeochemical resilience. We performed tree-level observations of growth and water consumption via dendrometer and sap flux sensors and combined them with ecosystem-scale measurements of CO₂, water, and energy exchange between forests and the atmosphere using the eddy covariance technique for ecophysiological indicators of forest resilience.Complementing these biophysical assessments, we integrate a socio-ecological dimension through qualitative interviews with forest stakeholders. This allows us to evaluate stakeholder assessments of the status quo, their visions for resilient forests, and the specific requirements for a successful transformation toward those goals.By integrating multiple indicators derived from measurements across spatial, temporal, and social scales, we provide a broad assessment of forest resilience. Our results contribute to a mechanistic understanding of how forest structure mediates water and carbon fluxes under climate stress, supporting the development of resilient forest management strategies and improved monitoring approaches for climate change mitigation that are both scientifically robust and stakeholder-informed.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Tracing water and nitrogen uptake in mature forests using stable isotopes
Trees are powerful mediators within ecosystem water and nutrient cycles. Through their roots, they take up these essential resources from the soil, distributing them in the system and upward into the canopy to maintain transpiration and photosynthesis.However, understanding and predicting real-world dynamics remains challenging: tree species identity, species mixture, site and soil conditions may shape tree water and nutrient uptake fundamentally, particularly in mature forests. Moreover, in the face of climate change, access to resources in deeper, less drought-prone soil layers is crucial for buffering drought impacts and maintaining forest functioning. Studies targeting tree resource uptake in mature forests are still scarce; but they are emerging, with stable isotopes as a central tool.We investigated root water uptake depth and subsoil water and nitrogen uptake in mature temperate forests of north-western Germany, using 2H, 18O and 15N as tracers. Native European beech, non-native Douglas fir, and native but drought-sensitive Norway spruce were studied, revealing tree species-specific uptake strategies and influences of species mixture. Furthermore, we found consistent site effects: on well-drained, sandy soils, the trees integrated more resources from deeper layers than on loamy soils. Notably, transit times from soil to canopy were slower for nitrogen than for water, highlighting the biotic and abiotic interactions that decouple nitrogen from water.We conclude that species-specific traits in interaction with soil characteristics are crucial for understanding and predicting water and nutrient fluxes in forests. Our findings underscore the importance of belowground processes when assessing forest functioning and resilience.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTracing water and nitrogen uptake in mature forests using stable isotopes
Trees are powerful mediators within ecosystem water and nutrient cycles. Through their roots, they take up these essential resources from the soil, distributing them in the system and upward into the canopy to maintain transpiration and photosynthesis.However, understanding and predicting real-world dynamics remains challenging: tree species identity, species mixture, site and soil conditions may shape tree water and nutrient uptake fundamentally, particularly in mature forests. Moreover, in the face of climate change, access to resources in deeper, less drought-prone soil layers is crucial for buffering drought impacts and maintaining forest functioning. Studies targeting tree resource uptake in mature forests are still scarce; but they are emerging, with stable isotopes as a central tool.We investigated root water uptake depth and subsoil water and nitrogen uptake in mature temperate forests of north-western Germany, using 2H, 18O and 15N as tracers. Native European beech, non-native Douglas fir, and native but drought-sensitive Norway spruce were studied, revealing tree species-specific uptake strategies and influences of species mixture. Furthermore, we found consistent site effects: on well-drained, sandy soils, the trees integrated more resources from deeper layers than on loamy soils. Notably, transit times from soil to canopy were slower for nitrogen than for water, highlighting the biotic and abiotic interactions that decouple nitrogen from water.We conclude that species-specific traits in interaction with soil characteristics are crucial for understanding and predicting water and nutrient fluxes in forests. Our findings underscore the importance of belowground processes when assessing forest functioning and resilience.
- Open Access
- 11 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Hydrological Processes
- Vol. 40 (2)
Branch Orientation: A Potential Indicator of Stem Rehydration and Water Stress
Spring rehydration in snow‐covered temperate forests marks a key ecohydrological transition, influencing forest productivity and water balance. Tree water deficit is a key ecohydrological indicator about above ground water status and response to subsurface water availability. But simple measures of rehydration and water deficit are few and the relationship between stem rehydration and simple indicators like structural movement linked to branch orientation remains poorly understood. We investigated the coordination between stem rehydration, tree water deficit and branch movement in Abies balsamea using high‐resolution dendrometer data and time‐lapse imagery from early March to mid‐May in Ontario, Canada. In this video and data, we showed that upward branch movement consistently aligned with stem radius expansion during snowmelt and after rainfall events, while downward branch posture corresponded with dry periods and increased tree water deficit. Freeze–thaw events caused abrupt stem shrinkage but had limited influence on branch position. These findings suggest that branch posture reflects stem water status, potentially offering a visual and qualitative indicator of subsurface water availability to trees. While this is not a substitute for physiological measurements, branch movement could support field‐based monitoring of rehydration dynamics and further new opportunities to tree water relation studies. As climate change alters snowmelt timing and moisture regimes, integrating structural and physiological indicators may enhance our understanding of plant–water interactions in cold‐region ecosystems.
- 11 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Hydrological Processes
- Vol. 40 (2)
Open AccessBranch Orientation: A Potential Indicator of Stem Rehydration and Water Stress
Spring rehydration in snow‐covered temperate forests marks a key ecohydrological transition, influencing forest productivity and water balance. Tree water deficit is a key ecohydrological indicator about above ground water status and response to subsurface water availability. But simple measures of rehydration and water deficit are few and the relationship between stem rehydration and simple indicators like structural movement linked to branch orientation remains poorly understood. We investigated the coordination between stem rehydration, tree water deficit and branch movement in Abies balsamea using high‐resolution dendrometer data and time‐lapse imagery from early March to mid‐May in Ontario, Canada. In this video and data, we showed that upward branch movement consistently aligned with stem radius expansion during snowmelt and after rainfall events, while downward branch posture corresponded with dry periods and increased tree water deficit. Freeze–thaw events caused abrupt stem shrinkage but had limited influence on branch position. These findings suggest that branch posture reflects stem water status, potentially offering a visual and qualitative indicator of subsurface water availability to trees. While this is not a substitute for physiological measurements, branch movement could support field‐based monitoring of rehydration dynamics and further new opportunities to tree water relation studies. As climate change alters snowmelt timing and moisture regimes, integrating structural and physiological indicators may enhance our understanding of plant–water interactions in cold‐region ecosystems.
- Open Access
- 15 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plant, Cell & Environment
- Vol. 49 (10) , 7676-7691
De‐Coupled Water and Nitrogen Translocation From Subsoil to Canopy of Temperate Forest Trees
Water and nitrogen (N) transport from soil to canopy play a central role in tree functioning, yet direct evidence for their timing and coupling in mature forests remains scarce. We report results from a paired dual‐isotope ( 2 H, 15 N) tracer experiment in a temperate forest, comparing water and nitrate uptake patterns across tree species (Douglas fir, European beech), soil textures (loamy, sandy) and rooting depths (surface, subsoil). Using simultaneous double tracer injections into the lower rooting zone, followed by canopy xylem sap and foliage sampling over 2 months, we quantified the appearance of water and nitrate in xylem sap and foliage, supported by sap flow measurements to estimate transit times. Water reached the canopy faster than nitrogen, revealing a marked asynchrony in resource translocation for both species and sites—the first such field observation. Douglas fir showed greater subsoil water and nitrate uptake on sandy than on loamy soil, and higher subsoil uptake compared to beech under identical conditions. Tree species, soil texture and soil depth jointly govern water and nitrate uptake dynamics, as well as their temporal decoupling. These findings provide novel field‐based evidence of asynchronous water and nitrate transport, advancing our understanding of tree ecophysiology and nutrient cycling under field conditions.
- 15 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plant, Cell & Environment
- Vol. 49 (10) , 7676-7691
Open AccessDe‐Coupled Water and Nitrogen Translocation From Subsoil to Canopy of Temperate Forest Trees
Water and nitrogen (N) transport from soil to canopy play a central role in tree functioning, yet direct evidence for their timing and coupling in mature forests remains scarce. We report results from a paired dual‐isotope ( 2 H, 15 N) tracer experiment in a temperate forest, comparing water and nitrate uptake patterns across tree species (Douglas fir, European beech), soil textures (loamy, sandy) and rooting depths (surface, subsoil). Using simultaneous double tracer injections into the lower rooting zone, followed by canopy xylem sap and foliage sampling over 2 months, we quantified the appearance of water and nitrate in xylem sap and foliage, supported by sap flow measurements to estimate transit times. Water reached the canopy faster than nitrogen, revealing a marked asynchrony in resource translocation for both species and sites—the first such field observation. Douglas fir showed greater subsoil water and nitrate uptake on sandy than on loamy soil, and higher subsoil uptake compared to beech under identical conditions. Tree species, soil texture and soil depth jointly govern water and nitrate uptake dynamics, as well as their temporal decoupling. These findings provide novel field‐based evidence of asynchronous water and nitrate transport, advancing our understanding of tree ecophysiology and nutrient cycling under field conditions.
- Open Access
Isohydric species show earlier drought-induced declines in stem water content, rehydration, sap flow, and growth than anisohydric species
Isohydric species reduce water potential fluctuations through more stringent stomatal regulation. It is unclear whether isohydric behavior leads to smaller reversible diurnal stem shrinkage (i.e. greater nocturnal stem rehydration) during drought and a lower drought sensitivity of radial growth compared to anisohydric behavior. With synchronous high-resolution sap flow and dendrometer measurements in mature anisohydric European beech and isohydric Douglas fir trees in pure and mixed stands, we quantified declines in stem water content (SWC), stem rehydration, sap flow and radial growth during soil dry-down and determined the critical soil moisture levels (expressed as Relative Extractable Water, REW) and elapsed desiccation time until 30-90% reductions in these traits. Sap flow and growth started to decline in both species at REW ~0.6, preceding declines in stem rehydration. Water-spending Douglas fir approached 50% drops in SWC, sap flow, stem rehydration and growth during soil dry-down faster than beech, indicating higher drought sensitivity. In mixture, both species reached these reduction levels later than in monoculture, suggesting positive mixing effects on the species drought resistance. Our findings demonstrate that SWC, sap flow and radial growth decrease earlier than nocturnal stem rehydration, with isohydric and anisohydric species exhibiting different timelines of physiological downregulation during soil dry-down.
Open AccessIsohydric species show earlier drought-induced declines in stem water content, rehydration, sap flow, and growth than anisohydric species
Isohydric species reduce water potential fluctuations through more stringent stomatal regulation. It is unclear whether isohydric behavior leads to smaller reversible diurnal stem shrinkage (i.e. greater nocturnal stem rehydration) during drought and a lower drought sensitivity of radial growth compared to anisohydric behavior. With synchronous high-resolution sap flow and dendrometer measurements in mature anisohydric European beech and isohydric Douglas fir trees in pure and mixed stands, we quantified declines in stem water content (SWC), stem rehydration, sap flow and radial growth during soil dry-down and determined the critical soil moisture levels (expressed as Relative Extractable Water, REW) and elapsed desiccation time until 30-90% reductions in these traits. Sap flow and growth started to decline in both species at REW ~0.6, preceding declines in stem rehydration. Water-spending Douglas fir approached 50% drops in SWC, sap flow, stem rehydration and growth during soil dry-down faster than beech, indicating higher drought sensitivity. In mixture, both species reached these reduction levels later than in monoculture, suggesting positive mixing effects on the species drought resistance. Our findings demonstrate that SWC, sap flow and radial growth decrease earlier than nocturnal stem rehydration, with isohydric and anisohydric species exhibiting different timelines of physiological downregulation during soil dry-down.
- Open Access
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plant Biology
- Vol. 28 (3) , 872-887
Root water uptake depth in temperate forest trees: species‐specific patterns shaped by neighbourhood and environment
Root water uptake regulates plant transpiration and internal water supply. Forests in Central Europe increasingly face water limitations, highlighting the need to understand tree water sources and consumption. However, knowledge about water uptake depth and how it varies with tree species identity, neighbourhood, site, and environmental conditions remains scarce. We used stable water isotopes to study water uptake depth in pure and mixed stands of European beech ( Fagus sylvatica ), Douglas fir ( Pseudotsuga menziesii ), and Norway spruce ( Picea abies ). Investigations included natural abundance sampling at four sites, and a weekly subsoil tracer experiment (1 m mineral soil depth) at one of these sites. European beech and Douglas fir accessed relatively deeper water than Norway spruce. Beech used deeper water in mixtures with both conifers, while spruce shifted to shallower layers in mixture with beech. Douglas fir showed no significant difference between pure and mixed stand. Deepest uptake occurred on well‐drained, sandy soil, while shallowest uptake was on an occasionally stagnic soil. The tracer experiment revealed a relatively low contribution from subsoil water (>1 m, ca. 9%); the organic layer contributed similar magnitudes, but varied more dynamically with tree water consumption. Our results emphasize the importance of species‐specific traits and mixture effects in forest water cycles, and how they are mediated by site and environmental conditions. Douglas fir appears more drought resistant than Norway spruce, by accessing deeper water sources. We conclude that beech and Douglas fir may equally coexist, while beech presence exacerbates the drought exposure of spruce.
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plant Biology
- Vol. 28 (3) , 872-887
Open AccessRoot water uptake depth in temperate forest trees: species‐specific patterns shaped by neighbourhood and environment
Root water uptake regulates plant transpiration and internal water supply. Forests in Central Europe increasingly face water limitations, highlighting the need to understand tree water sources and consumption. However, knowledge about water uptake depth and how it varies with tree species identity, neighbourhood, site, and environmental conditions remains scarce. We used stable water isotopes to study water uptake depth in pure and mixed stands of European beech ( Fagus sylvatica ), Douglas fir ( Pseudotsuga menziesii ), and Norway spruce ( Picea abies ). Investigations included natural abundance sampling at four sites, and a weekly subsoil tracer experiment (1 m mineral soil depth) at one of these sites. European beech and Douglas fir accessed relatively deeper water than Norway spruce. Beech used deeper water in mixtures with both conifers, while spruce shifted to shallower layers in mixture with beech. Douglas fir showed no significant difference between pure and mixed stand. Deepest uptake occurred on well‐drained, sandy soil, while shallowest uptake was on an occasionally stagnic soil. The tracer experiment revealed a relatively low contribution from subsoil water (>1 m, ca. 9%); the organic layer contributed similar magnitudes, but varied more dynamically with tree water consumption. Our results emphasize the importance of species‐specific traits and mixture effects in forest water cycles, and how they are mediated by site and environmental conditions. Douglas fir appears more drought resistant than Norway spruce, by accessing deeper water sources. We conclude that beech and Douglas fir may equally coexist, while beech presence exacerbates the drought exposure of spruce.