Ernest Kurniawan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Ernest Kurniawan has a total of 35 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sumei Sun
Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*STAR)
5 shared publications - A. S. Madhukumar
College of Computing and Data Science, Nanyang Technological University, Jurong West, Singapore
3 shared publications - Amnart Boonkajay
Institute of Infocomm Research, Agency for Science, Technology and Research, Fusionopolis, Singapore
3 shared publications - Jie Cao
School of Information Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, Shenzhen, China
3 shared publications Sumei Sun
Institute of Infocomm Research, Agency for Science, Technology and Research, Fusionopolis, Singapore
3 shared publications- Yonghong Zeng
Institute for Infocomm Research, Agency for Science, Technology and Research, Singapore
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 23 June 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Dependable and Secure Computing
- Vol. 22 (6) , 6230-6247
5Ghoul: Unleashing Chaos on 5G Edge Devices via Stateful Multi-Layer Fuzzing
In this paper, we present 5Ghoul, a framework to systematically discover and replicate security vulnerabilities on arbitrary 5 G edge devices (UE). At the core of 5Ghoul is a stateful fuzzing strategy that provides full control to arbitrarily manipulate any packet down to the data link layer. Moreover, 5Ghoul automatically constructs the protocol state machines to guide the fuzzing process and employs novel strategies to reliably exploit vulnerabilities on commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) UEs over-the-air. The design choices in 5Ghoul were carefully taken to allow packet manipulation in real-time, which, in turn allowed us to fuzz down to data link layer. As of today, we have evaluated 5Ghoul with seven COTS 5 G UEs (smartphones and USB modems) and one open source framework (OpenAirInterface). 5Ghoul has uncovered 12 unknown security vulnerabilities (14 in total) out of which ten exist in COTS UEs (ten CVEs assigned) from major vendors (e.g., Qualcomm and MediaTek). Moreover, of these COTS UE vulnerabilities have been confirmed to have high severity. We also won a bug bounty of over 20 K USD from Qualcomm and MediaTek for discovering these vulnerabilities. We envision 5Ghoul to open the door for 5G security testing at scale.
- 23 June 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Dependable and Secure Computing
- Vol. 22 (6) , 6230-6247
5Ghoul: Unleashing Chaos on 5G Edge Devices via Stateful Multi-Layer Fuzzing
In this paper, we present 5Ghoul, a framework to systematically discover and replicate security vulnerabilities on arbitrary 5 G edge devices (UE). At the core of 5Ghoul is a stateful fuzzing strategy that provides full control to arbitrarily manipulate any packet down to the data link layer. Moreover, 5Ghoul automatically constructs the protocol state machines to guide the fuzzing process and employs novel strategies to reliably exploit vulnerabilities on commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) UEs over-the-air. The design choices in 5Ghoul were carefully taken to allow packet manipulation in real-time, which, in turn allowed us to fuzz down to data link layer. As of today, we have evaluated 5Ghoul with seven COTS 5 G UEs (smartphones and USB modems) and one open source framework (OpenAirInterface). 5Ghoul has uncovered 12 unknown security vulnerabilities (14 in total) out of which ten exist in COTS UEs (ten CVEs assigned) from major vendors (e.g., Qualcomm and MediaTek). Moreover, of these COTS UE vulnerabilities have been confirmed to have high severity. We also won a bug bounty of over 20 K USD from Qualcomm and MediaTek for discovering these vulnerabilities. We envision 5Ghoul to open the door for 5G security testing at scale.
- 23 January 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
- Vol. PP (15249050) , 1-18
Tightly-Coupled 6DoF Localization in Complex Environments With GNSS Raw Data
In large-scale urban environments, precise six-degree-of-freedom (6DOF) pose estimation is essential for vehicles and robots to perform autonomous driving and exploration, as well as to achieve high intelligence and full autonomy of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV). Achieving 6DOF pose estimation in Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS)-denied environments is challenging. The performance of relative 6DOF localization systems based on Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR), vision, and inertial data is easily affected by environmental conditions, leading to error accumulation and a significant decrease in estimation accuracy in complex environments. To address this issue, we propose a tightly coupled framework based on nonlinear optimization for vision, LiDAR, inertial, and GNSS raw data. In the experimental section, we validate the effectiveness of the proposed optimization factor model for GNSS data, LiDAR data, and visual data in improving position and orientation estimation accuracy through simulations. Additionally, we use real datasets to compare the proposed algorithm with several existing open-source programs in terms of computational efficiency, pose estimation accuracy, worst-case scenarios, and reliability. The experimental results show that, although the total processing time increases, the position estimation accuracy and orientation estimation accuracy of the proposed fusion algorithm improve by at least 58.0%. Overall, the proposed tightly-coupled algorithm outperforms the existing methods.
- 23 January 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
- Vol. PP (15249050) , 1-18
Tightly-Coupled 6DoF Localization in Complex Environments With GNSS Raw Data
In large-scale urban environments, precise six-degree-of-freedom (6DOF) pose estimation is essential for vehicles and robots to perform autonomous driving and exploration, as well as to achieve high intelligence and full autonomy of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV). Achieving 6DOF pose estimation in Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS)-denied environments is challenging. The performance of relative 6DOF localization systems based on Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR), vision, and inertial data is easily affected by environmental conditions, leading to error accumulation and a significant decrease in estimation accuracy in complex environments. To address this issue, we propose a tightly coupled framework based on nonlinear optimization for vision, LiDAR, inertial, and GNSS raw data. In the experimental section, we validate the effectiveness of the proposed optimization factor model for GNSS data, LiDAR data, and visual data in improving position and orientation estimation accuracy through simulations. Additionally, we use real datasets to compare the proposed algorithm with several existing open-source programs in terms of computational efficiency, pose estimation accuracy, worst-case scenarios, and reliability. The experimental results show that, although the total processing time increases, the position estimation accuracy and orientation estimation accuracy of the proposed fusion algorithm improve by at least 58.0%. Overall, the proposed tightly-coupled algorithm outperforms the existing methods.
- 23 October 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 73 (5) , 3031-3045
Goal-Oriented Communication, Estimation, and Control Over Bidirectional Wireless Links
We consider a wireless networked control system (WNCS) with imperfect bidirectional links for real-time applications such as smart grids. To maintain the stability of WNCS, captured by the probability that plant state violates preset values, at minimal cost, heterogeneous physical processes are monitored by multiple sensors. This status information, such as dynamic plant state and Markov Process-based context information, is then received/estimated by the controller for remote control. However, scheduling multiple sensors and designing the controller with limited resources is challenging due to their coupling, delay, and transmission loss. We formulate a Constrained Markov Decision Problem (CMDP) to minimize violation probability with cost constraints. We reveal the relationship between the goal and different updating actions by analyzing the significance of information that incorporates goal-related usefulness and contextual importance. Subsequently, a goal-oriented deterministic scheduling policy is proposed. Two sensing-assisted control strategies and a control-aware estimation policy are proposed to improve the violation probability-cost tradeoff, integrated with the scheduling policy to form a goal-oriented co-design framework. Additionally, we explore retransmission in downlink transmission and qualitatively analyze its preference scenario. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed goal-oriented co-design policy outperforms previous work in simultaneously reducing violation probability and cost.
- 23 October 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Communications
- Vol. 73 (5) , 3031-3045
Goal-Oriented Communication, Estimation, and Control Over Bidirectional Wireless Links
We consider a wireless networked control system (WNCS) with imperfect bidirectional links for real-time applications such as smart grids. To maintain the stability of WNCS, captured by the probability that plant state violates preset values, at minimal cost, heterogeneous physical processes are monitored by multiple sensors. This status information, such as dynamic plant state and Markov Process-based context information, is then received/estimated by the controller for remote control. However, scheduling multiple sensors and designing the controller with limited resources is challenging due to their coupling, delay, and transmission loss. We formulate a Constrained Markov Decision Problem (CMDP) to minimize violation probability with cost constraints. We reveal the relationship between the goal and different updating actions by analyzing the significance of information that incorporates goal-related usefulness and contextual importance. Subsequently, a goal-oriented deterministic scheduling policy is proposed. Two sensing-assisted control strategies and a control-aware estimation policy are proposed to improve the violation probability-cost tradeoff, integrated with the scheduling policy to form a goal-oriented co-design framework. Additionally, we explore retransmission in downlink transmission and qualitatively analyze its preference scenario. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed goal-oriented co-design policy outperforms previous work in simultaneously reducing violation probability and cost.
- 14 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Network
- Vol. 38 (6) , 13-20
Goal-Oriented Integration of Sensing, Communication, Computing, and Control for Mission-Critical Internet-of-Things
Driven by the development goal of network paradigm and demand for various functions in the sixth-generation (6G) mission-critical Internet-of-Things (MC-IoT), we foresee a goal-oriented integration of sensing, communication, computing, and control (GIS3C) in this paper. We first provide an overview of the tasks, requirements, and challenges of MC-IoT. Then we introduce an end-to-end GIS3C architecture, in which goal-oriented communication is leveraged to bridge and empower sensing, communication, control, and computing functionalities. By revealing the interplay among multiple subsystems in terms of key performance indicators and parameters, this paper introduces unified metrics, i.e ., task completion effectiveness and cost, to facilitate S3C co-design in MC-IoT. The preliminary results demonstrate the benefits of GIS3C in improving task completion effectiveness while reducing costs. We also identify and highlight the gaps and challenges in applying GIS3C in the future 6G networks.
- 14 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Network
- Vol. 38 (6) , 13-20
Goal-Oriented Integration of Sensing, Communication, Computing, and Control for Mission-Critical Internet-of-Things
Driven by the development goal of network paradigm and demand for various functions in the sixth-generation (6G) mission-critical Internet-of-Things (MC-IoT), we foresee a goal-oriented integration of sensing, communication, computing, and control (GIS3C) in this paper. We first provide an overview of the tasks, requirements, and challenges of MC-IoT. Then we introduce an end-to-end GIS3C architecture, in which goal-oriented communication is leveraged to bridge and empower sensing, communication, control, and computing functionalities. By revealing the interplay among multiple subsystems in terms of key performance indicators and parameters, this paper introduces unified metrics, i.e ., task completion effectiveness and cost, to facilitate S3C co-design in MC-IoT. The preliminary results demonstrate the benefits of GIS3C in improving task completion effectiveness while reducing costs. We also identify and highlight the gaps and challenges in applying GIS3C in the future 6G networks.
- 13 March 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Internet of Things Journal
- Vol. 11 (12) , 21474-21485
Risk-Aware and Energy-Efficient AoI Optimization for Multiconnectivity WNCS With Short-Packet Transmissions
Age of Information (AoI) has been proposed to quantify the freshness of information for emerging real-time applications, such as remote monitoring and control in wireless networked control systems (WNCSs). Minimization of the average AoI and its outage probability can ensure timely and stable transmission. Energy efficiency (EE) also plays an important role in WNCSs, as many devices are featured by low cost and limited battery. Multiconnectivity over multiple links enables a decrease in AoI, at the cost of energy. We tackle the unresolved problem of selecting the optimal number of connections that is both AoI-optimal and energy-efficient, while avoiding risky states. To address this issue, the average AoI and Peak AoI (PAoI), as well as PAoI violation probability are formulated as functions of the number of connections. Then, the EE-PAoI ratio is introduced to allow a tradeoff between AoI and energy, which is maximized by the proposed risk-aware, AoI-optimal, and energy-efficient connectivity scheme. To obtain this, we analyze the property of the formulated EE-PAoI ratio and prove the monotonicity of PAoI violation probability. Interestingly, we reveal that the multiconnectivity scheme is not always preferable, and the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) threshold that determines the selection of the multiconnectivity scheme is derived as a function of the coding rate. Also, the optimal number of connections is obtained and shown to be a decreasing function of the transmit power. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed scheme enables more than 15 folds of EE-PAoI gain at the low SNR than the single-connectivity scheme.
- 13 March 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Internet of Things Journal
- Vol. 11 (12) , 21474-21485
Risk-Aware and Energy-Efficient AoI Optimization for Multiconnectivity WNCS With Short-Packet Transmissions
Age of Information (AoI) has been proposed to quantify the freshness of information for emerging real-time applications, such as remote monitoring and control in wireless networked control systems (WNCSs). Minimization of the average AoI and its outage probability can ensure timely and stable transmission. Energy efficiency (EE) also plays an important role in WNCSs, as many devices are featured by low cost and limited battery. Multiconnectivity over multiple links enables a decrease in AoI, at the cost of energy. We tackle the unresolved problem of selecting the optimal number of connections that is both AoI-optimal and energy-efficient, while avoiding risky states. To address this issue, the average AoI and Peak AoI (PAoI), as well as PAoI violation probability are formulated as functions of the number of connections. Then, the EE-PAoI ratio is introduced to allow a tradeoff between AoI and energy, which is maximized by the proposed risk-aware, AoI-optimal, and energy-efficient connectivity scheme. To obtain this, we analyze the property of the formulated EE-PAoI ratio and prove the monotonicity of PAoI violation probability. Interestingly, we reveal that the multiconnectivity scheme is not always preferable, and the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) threshold that determines the selection of the multiconnectivity scheme is derived as a function of the coding rate. Also, the optimal number of connections is obtained and shown to be a decreasing function of the transmit power. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed scheme enables more than 15 folds of EE-PAoI gain at the low SNR than the single-connectivity scheme.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
- Vol. 73 (8) , 10884-10898
Robust Loop-Closure Algorithm Based on GNSS Raw Data for Large-Scale and Complex Environments
Trajectory drift is a significant issue in intelligent vehicles that rely on multi-source fusion for achieving autonomous navigation, hindering the accurate positioning of these vehicles. Existing loop-closure algorithms mostly rely on single-sensor data, such as visual or LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data, making their performance susceptible to degradation in challenging environments. This paper proposes a novel loop-closure detection algorithm. It employs ORB (Oriented FAST and Rotated BRIEF) feature points from visual data for loop-closure candidate frame detection, confirms loop-closure frames using depth values mapped from LiDAR data onto images, and finally utilizes GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System) raw data to validate and correct trajectory drift further. The paper concludes by validating the stability and robustness of the proposed loop-closure algorithm through simulations with various publicly available datasets, thereby assessing its performance in large-scale and complex environments. Furthermore, by integrating the proposed loop-closure algorithm into an openly accessible online odometer, the results demonstrate an improvement in position estimation accuracy by 83.45%.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
- Vol. 73 (8) , 10884-10898
Robust Loop-Closure Algorithm Based on GNSS Raw Data for Large-Scale and Complex Environments
Trajectory drift is a significant issue in intelligent vehicles that rely on multi-source fusion for achieving autonomous navigation, hindering the accurate positioning of these vehicles. Existing loop-closure algorithms mostly rely on single-sensor data, such as visual or LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data, making their performance susceptible to degradation in challenging environments. This paper proposes a novel loop-closure detection algorithm. It employs ORB (Oriented FAST and Rotated BRIEF) feature points from visual data for loop-closure candidate frame detection, confirms loop-closure frames using depth values mapped from LiDAR data onto images, and finally utilizes GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System) raw data to validate and correct trajectory drift further. The paper concludes by validating the stability and robustness of the proposed loop-closure algorithm through simulations with various publicly available datasets, thereby assessing its performance in large-scale and complex environments. Furthermore, by integrating the proposed loop-closure algorithm into an openly accessible online odometer, the results demonstrate an improvement in position estimation accuracy by 83.45%.
- Open Access
Drone Controller Localization Based on RSSI Ratio
We proposed two methods for the localization of drone controllers based on received signal strength indicator (RSSI) ratios: the RSSI ratio fingerprint method and the model-based RSSI ratio algorithm. To evaluate the performance of our proposed algorithms, we conducted both simulations and field trials. The simulation results show that our two proposed RSSI-ratio-based localization methods outperformed the distance mapping algorithm proposed in literature when tested in a WLAN channel. Moreover, increasing the number of sensors improved the localization performance. Averaging a number of RSSI ratio samples also improved the performance in propagation channels that did not exhibit location-dependent fading effects. However, in channels with location-dependent fading effects, averaging a number of RSSI ratio samples did not significantly improve the localization performance. Additionally, reducing the grid size improved the performance in channels with small shadowing factor values, but this only resulted in marginal gains in channels with larger shadowing factors. Our field trial results align with the simulation results in a two-ray ground reflection (TRGR) channel. Our methods provide a robust and effective solution for the localization of drone controllers using RSSI ratios.
Open AccessDrone Controller Localization Based on RSSI Ratio
We proposed two methods for the localization of drone controllers based on received signal strength indicator (RSSI) ratios: the RSSI ratio fingerprint method and the model-based RSSI ratio algorithm. To evaluate the performance of our proposed algorithms, we conducted both simulations and field trials. The simulation results show that our two proposed RSSI-ratio-based localization methods outperformed the distance mapping algorithm proposed in literature when tested in a WLAN channel. Moreover, increasing the number of sensors improved the localization performance. Averaging a number of RSSI ratio samples also improved the performance in propagation channels that did not exhibit location-dependent fading effects. However, in channels with location-dependent fading effects, averaging a number of RSSI ratio samples did not significantly improve the localization performance. Additionally, reducing the grid size improved the performance in channels with small shadowing factor values, but this only resulted in marginal gains in channels with larger shadowing factors. Our field trial results align with the simulation results in a two-ray ground reflection (TRGR) channel. Our methods provide a robust and effective solution for the localization of drone controllers using RSSI ratios.
- 4 December 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 86-92
Towards Automated Fuzzing of 4G/5G Protocol Implementations Over the Air
Recent rise in the mobile network communication vulnerabilities highlights the need for systematic security testing frameworks for communication protocols. In this paper, we propose a real-time framework to fully manipulate the 4G and 5G data-link and network communication to the base station (eNB/gNB). This is for experimenting and testing the security of data-link protocols such as Media Access Control (MAC), Radio Link Control (RLC), Packet Data Convergence Protocol (PDCP) and network protocols such as Radio Resource Control (RRC) and Non-access stratum (NAS). Although we focus on the base station, our framework is equally applicable for manipulating the communication to the user equipment (UE). An appealing feature of our framework is that it automatically constructs the protocol state machine during normal communication. This allows us to validate the response from the base station when it is subjected to unexpected packet sequences. Our framework also exposes an application programming interfaces (APIs) for designers to install custom attack scenarios. We have implemented our framework and used it to generate several (adversarial) scenarios that include injection of malformed and out-of-order packets as well as flooding certain packets. Our evaluation revealed crashes in OpenAirInterface (OAI) UE and gNB, as well as in Open5GS core network. Additionally, we guide our validation via the automatically constructed state machine and have caught most adversarial scenarios during our evaluation. We envision our proposed framework to provide the foundation for automated security testing of 4G/5G data-link protocol implementation.
- 4 December 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 86-92
Towards Automated Fuzzing of 4G/5G Protocol Implementations Over the Air
Recent rise in the mobile network communication vulnerabilities highlights the need for systematic security testing frameworks for communication protocols. In this paper, we propose a real-time framework to fully manipulate the 4G and 5G data-link and network communication to the base station (eNB/gNB). This is for experimenting and testing the security of data-link protocols such as Media Access Control (MAC), Radio Link Control (RLC), Packet Data Convergence Protocol (PDCP) and network protocols such as Radio Resource Control (RRC) and Non-access stratum (NAS). Although we focus on the base station, our framework is equally applicable for manipulating the communication to the user equipment (UE). An appealing feature of our framework is that it automatically constructs the protocol state machine during normal communication. This allows us to validate the response from the base station when it is subjected to unexpected packet sequences. Our framework also exposes an application programming interfaces (APIs) for designers to install custom attack scenarios. We have implemented our framework and used it to generate several (adversarial) scenarios that include injection of malformed and out-of-order packets as well as flooding certain packets. Our evaluation revealed crashes in OpenAirInterface (OAI) UE and gNB, as well as in Open5GS core network. Additionally, we guide our validation via the automatically constructed state machine and have caught most adversarial scenarios during our evaluation. We envision our proposed framework to provide the foundation for automated security testing of 4G/5G data-link protocol implementation.
- 4 April 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 337-376
Blockchain for Secure and Transparent Track-and-Trace in Manufacturing
- 4 April 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 337-376
Blockchain for Secure and Transparent Track-and-Trace in Manufacturing
- 20 February 2014
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications
- Vol. 32 (11) , 2075-2089
Energy Efficient Cooperative Strategies for Relay-Assisted Downlink Cellular Systems
The impact of cognitive radio techniques on the energy efficiency of a downlink cellular system in which multiple relays assist the transmission of the base station toward multiple receivers is studied. In particular, the fundamental tradeoff between the power consumption at the base station and the level of cooperation at the relay nodes is investigated. By increasing its transmit power, the base station can distribute the same message to multiple relays. In turn, the common knowledge at the relays enables cooperation, which results in a reduction in the power consumption due to interference management and coherent combining gains. This implies that the overall power efficiency can potentially be improved by an increase in the power consumption at the base station. We employ an information-theoretical analysis of the attainable power efficiency based on the chain graph representation of achievable schemes. This novel theoretical tool uses a graphical Markov model to represent coding operations and allows for the automatic derivation of achievable rate regions for general networks. This approach provides an effective tool to analyze the relationship between the energy consumption at the base station and power savings provided by relay cooperation through the use of transmission strategies such as superposition coding, interference decoding and rate-splitting. We present numerical evaluations for the scenario in which two relay nodes aid the communication between the base station and three receivers. These evaluations show that cooperative strategies at the relays provide clear advantages as compared to the non-cooperative scenario for varying channel conditions and target rates.
- 20 February 2014
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications
- Vol. 32 (11) , 2075-2089
Energy Efficient Cooperative Strategies for Relay-Assisted Downlink Cellular Systems
The impact of cognitive radio techniques on the energy efficiency of a downlink cellular system in which multiple relays assist the transmission of the base station toward multiple receivers is studied. In particular, the fundamental tradeoff between the power consumption at the base station and the level of cooperation at the relay nodes is investigated. By increasing its transmit power, the base station can distribute the same message to multiple relays. In turn, the common knowledge at the relays enables cooperation, which results in a reduction in the power consumption due to interference management and coherent combining gains. This implies that the overall power efficiency can potentially be improved by an increase in the power consumption at the base station. We employ an information-theoretical analysis of the attainable power efficiency based on the chain graph representation of achievable schemes. This novel theoretical tool uses a graphical Markov model to represent coding operations and allows for the automatic derivation of achievable rate regions for general networks. This approach provides an effective tool to analyze the relationship between the energy consumption at the base station and power savings provided by relay cooperation through the use of transmission strategies such as superposition coding, interference decoding and rate-splitting. We present numerical evaluations for the scenario in which two relay nodes aid the communication between the base station and three receivers. These evaluations show that cooperative strategies at the relays provide clear advantages as compared to the non-cooperative scenario for varying channel conditions and target rates.