KTKadi Tulver

Kadi Tulver

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Kadi Tulver has a total of 54 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Creative Cognition: A Collaborative Research Agenda

    by Wendy Ross, Sergio Agnoli, Matthijs Baas, Amory H. Danek, Izabela Lebuda, Rakefet Ackerman, Artur Ammalainen, Mathias Benedek, Honghong Bai, Linden J. Ball, et al.

    Creative cognition research has flourished in recent decades, revealing how extraordinary creative outcomes emerge from ordinary cognitive processes. However, the field faces fragmentation that hinders consensus and integration. This research agenda, developed through a collaborative workshop of 50 European researchers at the Lorentz Centre in Leiden, the Netherlands, identifies four critical challenges for advancing creative cognition research. Challenge 1 addresses theoretical concerns around defining core research terms like divergent thinking, emotions, and metacognition. Challenge 2 focuses on identifying different types and domains of knowledge that influence creative performance. Challenge 3 emphasizes measuring dynamic interactions between cognitive, affective, and metacognitive processes over time. Challenge 4 calls for incorporating environmental and interpersonal contexts, including collaboration, technology, and embodied cognition. These challenges highlight the need for collaborative approaches to develop standardized measures, synthesize existing findings, and foster methodological innovations. By working together as a research community, we can build more comprehensive theories and effective methods for understanding creativity's cognitive foundations while embracing rather than reducing its inherent complexity.


  • Open Access

    Predicting Satisfaction of Counterfactual Explanations from Human Ratings of Explanatory Qualities

    by Marharyta Domnich, Rasmus Moorits Veski, Julius Välja, Kadi Tulver, Raul Vicente

    Counterfactual explanations are a widely used approach in Explainable AI, offering actionable insights into decision-making by illustrating how small changes to input data can lead to different outcomes. Despite their importance, evaluating the quality of counterfactual explanations remains an open problem. Traditional quantitative metrics, such as sparsity or proximity, fail to fully account for human preferences in explanations, while user studies are insightful but not scalable. Moreover, relying only on a single overall satisfaction rating does not lead to a nuanced understanding of why certain explanations are effective or not. To address this, we analyze a dataset of counterfactual explanations that were evaluated by 206 human participants, who rated not only overall satisfaction but also seven explanatory criteria: feasibility, coherence, complexity, understandability, completeness, fairness, and trust. Modeling overall satisfaction as a function of these criteria, we find that feasibility (the actionability of suggested changes) and trust (the belief that the changes would lead to the desired outcome) consistently stand out as the strongest predictors of user satisfaction, though completeness also emerges as a meaningful contributor. Crucially, even excluding feasibility and trust, other metrics explain 58% of the variance, highlighting the importance of additional explanatory qualities. Complexity appears independent, suggesting more detailed explanations do not necessarily reduce satisfaction. Strong metric correlations imply a latent structure in how users judge quality, and demographic background (e.g., medical or ML expertise) significantly affects ranking patterns, highlighting the need for context-specific designs. These insights directly inform the development of improved counterfactual algorithms, highlighting the need to tailor explanatory qualities (completeness, consistency, fairness, complexity) to diverse user expertise and specific domain contexts.


  • Open Access

    The road to Aha: a recipe for mental breakthroughs

    by Kadi Tulver, Karl Kristjan Kaup, Jaan Aru

    We present a novel framework for understanding the diverse spectrum of mental breakthrough events, ranging from problem-solving insights to profound personal transformations. We propose that these events, while varied in expression and impact, share common underlying mechanisms of representational change. We also hypothesise that the differences in phenomenological intensity can be conceptualised along a continuum. Central to our model are three core components – tension, altered salience, and enhanced flexibility – which we identify as essential prerequisites for significant cognitive restructuring. These components interact within an iterative cycle, influencing both the emergence and nature of insight experiences. Drawing on examples from different fields, we explore how a conflict between existing models can trigger this cycle, wherein mechanisms of attention allocation and relaxation of constraints work in tandem to facilitate the emergence of insights. Furthermore, we propose that the intensity of the “aha-moment” and the breadth of its impact are contingent on how central the conflict is within one's conceptual landscape and the extent to which existing mental models are challenged. Thus, the model accounts for both the subtle, momentary insights in problem-solving and the transformative realisations that reshape core beliefs and self-perception. By synthesising insights from various domains, including psychotherapy, contemplative science, and psychedelic research, we present a theoretical account with broad scope, aiming to shed light on the complex processes that can lead to a wide array of mental breakthroughs, thereby contributing to the understanding of insight phenomena across disciplines.

  • Open Access

    The Journey Within: Mental Navigation as a Novel Framework for Understanding Psychotherapeutic Transformation

    by Mykyta Kabrel, Kadi Tulver, Jaan Aru

    Background: Despite the demonstrated efficacy of psychotherapy, the precise mechanisms that drive therapeutic transformations have posed a challenge and still remain unresolved. Here, we suggest a potential solution to this problem by introducing a framework based on the concept of mental navigation. It refers to our ability to navigate our cognitive space of thoughts, ideas, concepts, and memories, similar to how we navigate physical space. We start by analyzing the neural, cognitive, and experiential constituents intrinsic to mental navigation. Subsequently, we posit that the metaphoric spatial language we employ to articulate introspective experiences (e.g., “unexplored territory” or “going in circles”) serves as a robust marker of mental navigation.Methods: Using large text corpora, we compared the utilization of spatial language between transcripts of psychotherapy sessions (≈ 12M. words), casual everyday conversations (≈ 12M. words), and fictional dialogues in movies (≈ 14M. words). We also examined 110 psychotherapy transcripts qualitatively to discern patterns and dynamics associated with mental navigation. Results: We found a notable increase in the utilization of spatial metaphors during psychotherapy compared to casual everyday dialogues (U = 192.0, p = .001, d = 0.549) and fictional conversations (U = 211, p < .001, d = 0.792). In turn, analyzing the usage of non-spatial metaphors, we did not find significant differences between the three datasets (H = 0.682, p = 0.710). The qualitative analysis highlighted specific examples of mental navigation at play. Conclusion: Mental navigation might underlie the psychotherapy process and serve as a robust framework for understanding the transformative changes it brings about.

  • Open Access

    Facilitating real-life creative insight through psychedelic virtual reality

    by Timo Siimon, Kadi Tulver, Karl Kristjan Kaup, Madis Vasser, Jaan Aru

    The goal of the present work was to study the potential of facilitating creative insight in a real-life setting. To that end, participants were recruited who were struggling with a creative problem and had reached an impasse. Based on previous research, we hypothesized that solutions might be facilitated through virtual reality that replicates visual content experienced under the influence of psychedelics. Psychedelic visual experiences might support creative insight by relaxing the priors and constraints the person has about their creative problem. To test this idea, we tested a psychedelic virtual reality (VR) and developed a novel VR control environment. We observed that qualitatively psychedelic VR was more useful for eliciting creative insights than the control. We provide a thematic analysis demonstrating that psychedelic VR supported several aspects of creative insight. Taken together, we tested a novel method of psychedelic virtual reality to enhance creativity in real-life settings and observed encouraging results, which need to be investigated in larger studies.


  • Open Access

    Psychedelic replications in virtual reality and their potential as a therapeutic instrument: an open-label feasibility study

    by Karl Kristjan Kaup, Madis Vasser, Kadi Tulver, Juhan Pikamäe, Jaan Aru

    Background: Recent research has shown promising results for the therapeutic benefits of psychedelics. One popular view claims that these benefits are mediated by the subjective experiences induced by these substances. Based on this, we designed a virtual reality experience, Psyrreal, that mimics the phenomenological components of psychedelic experiences. Aims: We aimed to investigate the therapeutic efficacy of Psyrreal and psychedelic VR experiences in treating depressive symptoms as well as explore the effect of Psyrreal on subjective factors which have been suggested to mediate the therapeutic benefits of psychedelics.Methods: In this open-label feasibility study, thirteen participants with mild-to-moderate depression underwent a 2-day therapeutic intervention implementing Psyrreal. Depressive symptoms were evaluated by the Emotional State Questionnaire (EST-Q2) at the start of the intervention and 2 weeks after. A thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews after Psyrreal was also conducted as an additional assessment of the method.Results: A 2-day intervention implementing Psyrreal led to significant decreases in depressive symptoms at the 2-week follow-up (n = 10, p = 0.007, Hedges’ g = 1.046) measured by the Emotional State Questionnaire (EST-Q2). The analysis of semi-structured interviews suggests that Psyrreal could lead to insight and alterations in the sense of self in some people.Conclusion: This work proposes a novel method using virtual reality to augment the treatment of psychological disorders as well as to precisely investigate the mediating subjective factors of the therapeutic effects of psychedelic substances. Our preliminary results suggest that VR experiences combined with psychological support show potential in treating depressive symptoms and further research into similar methods is warranted


  • Open Access

    Restructuring insight: An integrative review of insight in problem-solving, meditation, psychotherapy, delusions and psychedelics

    by Kadi Tulver, Karl Kristjan Kaup, Ruben Eero Laukkonen, Jaan Aru

    Occasionally, a solution or idea arrives as a sudden understanding - an insight. Insight has been considered an “extra” ingredient of creative thinking and problem-solving. Here we propose that insight is central in seemingly distinct areas of research. Drawing on literature from a variety of fields, we show that besides being commonly studied in problem-solving literature, insight is also a core component in psychotherapy and meditation, a key process underlying the emergence of delusions in schizophrenia, and a factor in the therapeutic effects of psychedelics. In each case, we discuss the event of insight and its prerequisites and consequences. We review evidence for the commonalities and differences between the fields and discuss their relevance for capturing the essence of the insight phenomenon. The goal of this integrative review is to bridge the gap between the different views and inspire interdisciplinary research efforts for understanding this central process of human cognition.


  • Open Access

    Among the two kinds of metacognitive evaluation, only one is predictive of illusory object perception

    by Sandra Vetik, Kadi Tulver, Diana Lints, Talis Bachmann

    The relationship between expectation-induced hallucination proneness and self-confidence in performance was studied in a visual perception task. Participants were promptedeither to recognize briefly shown faces as male or female or to rate the subjective vividness of a square surrounding the face. Importantly, in a few critical trials the square was absent. Upon completion, participants rated their performance in the face recognition task; they were alsoasked whether they were sure that their estimation was correct. Out of 35 participants, 33 “hallucinated” on at least one trial, rating the square as visible when it was actually absent. Negative correlation between hallucination proneness and self-confidence in performance (metacognitive rating) was found: the more hallucinations a participant experienced, the less confident (s)he was in his/her performance in the face recognition task. Most subjects underestimated their performance; higher ratings were also more accurate. Thus, higher hallucination proneness was associated with more inaccurate ratings of one’s own perception. However, confidence in self-ratings as measured by the second follow-up question was unrelated to both, hallucination proneness and self-confidence in performance, supporting the view thatthere is no unitary mechanism of metacognitive evaluations and extending this view to the domain of visual hallucinatory perception.

  • Open Access

    Individual differences in the effects of priors: a multi-paradigm approach

    by Kadi Tulver, Jaan Aru, Renate Rutiku, Talis Bachmann

    The present study investigated individual differences in how much subjects rely on prior information, such as expectations or knowledge, when faced with perceptual ambiguity. The behavioural performance of forty-four participants was measured on four different visual paradigms (Mooney face recognition, illusory contours, blur detection and representational momentum) in which priors have been shown to affect perception. In addition, questionnaires were used to measure autistic and schizotypal traits in the non-clinical population. We hypothesized that someone who in the face of ambiguous or noisy perceptual input relies heavily on priors, would exhibit this tendency across a variety of tasks. This general pattern would then be reflected in high pairwise correlations between the behavioural measures and an emerging common factor. On the contrary, our results imply that there is no single factor that explains the individual differences present in the aforementioned tasks, as further evidenced by the overall lack of robust correlations between the separate paradigms. Instead, a two-factor structure reflecting differences in the hierarchy of perceptual processing was the best fit for explaining the individual variance in these tasks. This lends support to the notion that mechanisms underlying the effects of priors likely originate from several independent sources and that it is important to consider the role of specific tasks and stimuli more carefully when reporting effects of priors on perception.

  • Open Access

    Aru, Tulver & Bachmann (2018) - It’s all in your head: Expectations create illusory perception in a dual-task setup

    by Jaan Aru, Kadi Tulver, Talis Bachmann

    Predictions about the world can guide our perception and action, but they can also misguide us. We developed novel dual-task setups where the participants are occupied by a primary task and are from time to time queried about the phenomenal contents of the auxiliary task. We show that “hallucinating” the presence of an actually absent stimulus is not an exception, but a common phenomenon (more than 90% of participants experienced illusory objects at least once). Additionally, in experiment 1 we found a negative correlation between the amount of illusory perceptions and the Autism Spectrum Quotient score. People who scored higher on the questionnaire, were less likely to experience illusory objects. Finally, we observed no effect of spatial attention on expectation-based illusory presence of an object. More generally our results demonstrate that expectations misguide perception when attention is diverted to another task.