Iain Mackie
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Iain Mackie has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jeffrey Dalton
The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
7 shared publications - Shubham Chatterjee
Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, MO, USA
5 shared publications - Carlos Gemmell
University of Glasgow University of Glasgow
2 shared publications - Paul Owoicho
University of Glasgow Glasgow Scotland UK
2 shared publications - Sean MacAvaney
University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom
2 shared publications - Sophie Fischer
University of Glasgow Glasgow Scotland UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 20 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 210-229
DREQ: Document Re-ranking Using Entity-Based Query Understanding
- 20 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 210-229
DREQ: Document Re-ranking Using Entity-Based Query Understanding
- Open Access
DREQ: Document Re-Ranking Using Entity-based Query Understanding
While entity-oriented neural IR models have advanced significantly, they often overlook a key nuance: the varying degrees of influence individual entities within a document have on its overall relevance. Addressing this gap, we present DREQ, an entity-oriented dense document re-ranking model. Uniquely, we emphasize the query-relevant entities within a document's representation while simultaneously attenuating the less relevant ones, thus obtaining a query-specific entity-centric document representation. We then combine this entity-centric document representation with the text-centric representation of the document to obtain a "hybrid" representation of the document. We learn a relevance score for the document using this hybrid representation. Using four large-scale benchmarks, we show that DREQ outperforms state-of-the-art neural and non-neural re-ranking methods, highlighting the effectiveness of our entity-oriented representation approach.
Open AccessDREQ: Document Re-Ranking Using Entity-based Query Understanding
While entity-oriented neural IR models have advanced significantly, they often overlook a key nuance: the varying degrees of influence individual entities within a document have on its overall relevance. Addressing this gap, we present DREQ, an entity-oriented dense document re-ranking model. Uniquely, we emphasize the query-relevant entities within a document's representation while simultaneously attenuating the less relevant ones, thus obtaining a query-specific entity-centric document representation. We then combine this entity-centric document representation with the text-centric representation of the document to obtain a "hybrid" representation of the document. We learn a relevance score for the document using this hybrid representation. Using four large-scale benchmarks, we show that DREQ outperforms state-of-the-art neural and non-neural re-ranking methods, highlighting the effectiveness of our entity-oriented representation approach.
- Open Access
Adaptive Latent Entity Expansion for Document Retrieval
Despite considerable progress in neural relevance ranking techniques, search engines still struggle to process complex queries effectively - both in terms of precision and recall. Sparse and dense Pseudo-Relevance Feedback (PRF) approaches have the potential to overcome limitations in recall, but are only effective with high precision in the top ranks. In this work, we tackle the problem of search over complex queries using three complementary techniques. First, we demonstrate that applying a strong neural re-ranker before sparse or dense PRF can improve the retrieval effectiveness by 5-8%. This improvement in PRF effectiveness can be attributed directly to improving the precision of the feedback set. Second, we propose an enhanced expansion model, Latent Entity Expansion (LEE), which applies fine-grained word and entity-based relevance modelling incorporating localized features. Specifically, we find that by including both words and entities for expansion achieve a further 2-8% improvement in NDCG. Our analysis also demonstrated that LEE is largely robust to its parameters across datasets and performs well on entity-centric queries. And third, we include an 'adaptive' component in the retrieval process, which iteratively refines the re-ranking pool during scoring using the expansion model and avoids re-ranking additional documents. We find that this combination of techniques achieves the best NDCG, MAP and R@1000 results on the TREC Robust 2004 and CODEC document datasets, demonstrating a significant advancement in expansion effectiveness.
Open AccessAdaptive Latent Entity Expansion for Document Retrieval
Despite considerable progress in neural relevance ranking techniques, search engines still struggle to process complex queries effectively - both in terms of precision and recall. Sparse and dense Pseudo-Relevance Feedback (PRF) approaches have the potential to overcome limitations in recall, but are only effective with high precision in the top ranks. In this work, we tackle the problem of search over complex queries using three complementary techniques. First, we demonstrate that applying a strong neural re-ranker before sparse or dense PRF can improve the retrieval effectiveness by 5-8%. This improvement in PRF effectiveness can be attributed directly to improving the precision of the feedback set. Second, we propose an enhanced expansion model, Latent Entity Expansion (LEE), which applies fine-grained word and entity-based relevance modelling incorporating localized features. Specifically, we find that by including both words and entities for expansion achieve a further 2-8% improvement in NDCG. Our analysis also demonstrated that LEE is largely robust to its parameters across datasets and performs well on entity-centric queries. And third, we include an 'adaptive' component in the retrieval process, which iteratively refines the re-ranking pool during scoring using the expansion model and avoids re-ranking additional documents. We find that this combination of techniques achieves the best NDCG, MAP and R@1000 results on the TREC Robust 2004 and CODEC document datasets, demonstrating a significant advancement in expansion effectiveness.
- Open Access
GRM: Generative Relevance Modeling Using Relevance-Aware Sample Estimation for Document Retrieval
Recent studies show that Generative Relevance Feedback (GRF), using text generated by Large Language Models (LLMs), can enhance the effectiveness of query expansion. However, LLMs can generate irrelevant information that harms retrieval effectiveness. To address this, we propose Generative Relevance Modeling (GRM) that uses Relevance-Aware Sample Estimation (RASE) for more accurate weighting of expansion terms. Specifically, we identify similar real documents for each generated document and use a neural re-ranker to estimate their relevance. Experiments on three standard document ranking benchmarks show that GRM improves MAP by 6-9% and R@1k by 2-4%, surpassing previous methods.
Open AccessGRM: Generative Relevance Modeling Using Relevance-Aware Sample Estimation for Document Retrieval
Recent studies show that Generative Relevance Feedback (GRF), using text generated by Large Language Models (LLMs), can enhance the effectiveness of query expansion. However, LLMs can generate irrelevant information that harms retrieval effectiveness. To address this, we propose Generative Relevance Modeling (GRM) that uses Relevance-Aware Sample Estimation (RASE) for more accurate weighting of expansion terms. Specifically, we identify similar real documents for each generated document and use a neural re-ranker to estimate their relevance. Experiments on three standard document ranking benchmarks show that GRM improves MAP by 6-9% and R@1k by 2-4%, surpassing previous methods.
- Open Access
Generative and Pseudo-Relevant Feedback for Sparse, Dense and Learned Sparse Retrieval
Pseudo-relevance feedback (PRF) is a classical approach to address lexical mismatch by enriching the query using first-pass retrieval. Moreover, recent work on generative-relevance feedback (GRF) shows that query expansion models using text generated from large language models can improve sparse retrieval without depending on first-pass retrieval effectiveness. This work extends GRF to dense and learned sparse retrieval paradigms with experiments over six standard document ranking benchmarks. We find that GRF improves over comparable PRF techniques by around 10% on both precision and recall-oriented measures. Nonetheless, query analysis shows that GRF and PRF have contrasting benefits, with GRF providing external context not present in first-pass retrieval, whereas PRF grounds the query to the information contained within the target corpus. Thus, we propose combining generative and pseudo-relevance feedback ranking signals to achieve the benefits of both feedback classes, which significantly increases recall over PRF methods on 95% of experiments.
Open AccessGenerative and Pseudo-Relevant Feedback for Sparse, Dense and Learned Sparse Retrieval
Pseudo-relevance feedback (PRF) is a classical approach to address lexical mismatch by enriching the query using first-pass retrieval. Moreover, recent work on generative-relevance feedback (GRF) shows that query expansion models using text generated from large language models can improve sparse retrieval without depending on first-pass retrieval effectiveness. This work extends GRF to dense and learned sparse retrieval paradigms with experiments over six standard document ranking benchmarks. We find that GRF improves over comparable PRF techniques by around 10% on both precision and recall-oriented measures. Nonetheless, query analysis shows that GRF and PRF have contrasting benefits, with GRF providing external context not present in first-pass retrieval, whereas PRF grounds the query to the information contained within the target corpus. Thus, we propose combining generative and pseudo-relevance feedback ranking signals to achieve the benefits of both feedback classes, which significantly increases recall over PRF methods on 95% of experiments.
- Open Access
DocuT5: Seq2seq SQL Generation with Table Documentation
Current SQL generators based on pre-trained language models struggle to answer complex questions requiring domain context or understanding fine-grained table structure. Humans would deal with these unknowns by reasoning over the documentation of the tables. Based on this hypothesis, we propose DocuT5, which uses off-the-shelf language model architecture and injects knowledge from external `documentation' to improve domain generalization. We perform experiments on the Spider family of datasets that contain complex questions that are cross-domain and multi-table. Specifically, we develop a new text-to-SQL failure taxonomy and find that 19.6% of errors are due to foreign key mistakes, and 49.2% are due to a lack of domain knowledge. We proposed DocuT5, a method that captures knowledge from (1) table structure context of foreign keys and (2) domain knowledge through contextualizing tables and columns. Both types of knowledge improve over state-of-the-art T5 with constrained decoding on Spider, and domain knowledge produces state-of-the-art comparable effectiveness on Spider-DK and Spider-SYN datasets.
Open AccessDocuT5: Seq2seq SQL Generation with Table Documentation
Current SQL generators based on pre-trained language models struggle to answer complex questions requiring domain context or understanding fine-grained table structure. Humans would deal with these unknowns by reasoning over the documentation of the tables. Based on this hypothesis, we propose DocuT5, which uses off-the-shelf language model architecture and injects knowledge from external `documentation' to improve domain generalization. We perform experiments on the Spider family of datasets that contain complex questions that are cross-domain and multi-table. Specifically, we develop a new text-to-SQL failure taxonomy and find that 19.6% of errors are due to foreign key mistakes, and 49.2% are due to a lack of domain knowledge. We proposed DocuT5, a method that captures knowledge from (1) table structure context of foreign keys and (2) domain knowledge through contextualizing tables and columns. Both types of knowledge improve over state-of-the-art T5 with constrained decoding on Spider, and domain knowledge produces state-of-the-art comparable effectiveness on Spider-DK and Spider-SYN datasets.
- Open Access
CODEC: Complex Document and Entity Collection
CODEC is a document and entity ranking benchmark that focuses on complex research topics. We target essay-style information needs of social science researchers, i.e. "How has the UK's Open Banking Regulation benefited Challenger Banks?". CODEC includes 42 topics developed by researchers and a new focused web corpus with semantic annotations including entity links. This resource includes expert judgments on 17,509 documents and entities (416.9 per topic) from diverse automatic and interactive manual runs. The manual runs include 387 query reformulations, providing data for query performance prediction and automatic rewriting evaluation. CODEC includes analysis of state-of-the-art systems, including dense retrieval and neural re-ranking. The results show the topics are challenging with headroom for document and entity ranking improvement. Query expansion with entity information shows significant gains in document ranking, demonstrating the resource's value for evaluating and improving entity-oriented search. We also show that the manual query reformulations significantly improve document ranking and entity ranking performance. Overall, CODEC provides challenging research topics to support the development and evaluation of entity-centric search methods.
Open AccessCODEC: Complex Document and Entity Collection
CODEC is a document and entity ranking benchmark that focuses on complex research topics. We target essay-style information needs of social science researchers, i.e. "How has the UK's Open Banking Regulation benefited Challenger Banks?". CODEC includes 42 topics developed by researchers and a new focused web corpus with semantic annotations including entity links. This resource includes expert judgments on 17,509 documents and entities (416.9 per topic) from diverse automatic and interactive manual runs. The manual runs include 387 query reformulations, providing data for query performance prediction and automatic rewriting evaluation. CODEC includes analysis of state-of-the-art systems, including dense retrieval and neural re-ranking. The results show the topics are challenging with headroom for document and entity ranking improvement. Query expansion with entity information shows significant gains in document ranking, demonstrating the resource's value for evaluating and improving entity-oriented search. We also show that the manual query reformulations significantly improve document ranking and entity ranking performance. Overall, CODEC provides challenging research topics to support the development and evaluation of entity-centric search methods.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL)
- p. 654-658
GRILLBot: A multi-modal conversational agent for complex real-world tasks
Carlos Gemmell, Federico Rossetto, Iain Mackie, Paul Owoicho, Sophie Fischer, Jeff Dalton. Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Meeting of the Special Interest Group on Discourse and Dialogue. 2022.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL)
- p. 654-658
Open AccessGRILLBot: A multi-modal conversational agent for complex real-world tasks
Carlos Gemmell, Federico Rossetto, Iain Mackie, Paul Owoicho, Sophie Fischer, Jeff Dalton. Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Meeting of the Special Interest Group on Discourse and Dialogue. 2022.