ZBZoe Bertenshaw

Zoe Bertenshaw

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Zoe Bertenshaw has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Non-Pharmacological Treatment Approaches for People with Concurrent Chronic Pain and Opioid Use Disorder: A Scoping Review

    by Jie Yang, Nazifa Rahman, Thi Nguyen, Monica Jung, Dereje Assefa, Rhiannon Dowla, Lisa J Fyfield, Zoe Bertenshaw, Suzanne Nielsen, Louisa Picco

    Background: Almost half (44%) of people receiving pharmacotherapy for opioid use disorder (OUD) have comorbid chronic non-cancer pain (CNCP). Non-pharmacological treatments for pain management are recommended alongside pharmacotherapy, yet evidence regarding their effectiveness, feasibility, acceptability, and affordability remains limited, warranting an updated review of current evidence. Methods: A scoping review was conducted following JBI methodology and PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Four databases were searched in November 2025, while a grey literature search was conducted in Google Scholar in December 2025 for publications on non-pharmacological interventions for adults with concurrent CNCP and OUD. Eligible publications were screened independently, data were extracted using a standardised form, and findings were synthesised narratively. Results: 35 publications were included, representing 15 publications from 13 primary studies and 20 protocols. Findings from the 13 primary studies primarily examined psychosocial, physical activity, and multimodal interventions, with psychosocial interventions being the most frequently studied. Overall, non-pharmacological interventions showed potential benefits in reducing pain, opioid craving, and substance use. Feasibility varied across intervention modalities, while acceptability was generally favourable among the 7 primary studies that assessed it. Conclusion: This scoping review mapped the available evidence on psychosocial, physical, and multimodal approaches for managing co-occurring CNCP and OUD. However, current evidence remains limited and insufficient to determine comparative effectiveness. The growing number of recently completed and ongoing trials indicates an expanding evidence base that will support more robust future evaluation and inform clinical practice.

  • Open Access

    Polarizing trajectories of colonial ideologies: A latent class growth analysis of historical negation and symbolic exclusion

    by Zoe Bertenshaw, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    The impassioned advocacy both for and against Indigenous rights in recent years suggests a polarization of public opinion. Accordingly, we theorize increasingly divided endorsement of two ideologies that challenge Indigenous rights to material and symbolic equality—historical negation and symbolic exclusion, respectively (the ‘Dark Duo’). Using latent class growth analysis, we test for distinct classes of change in the Dark Duo over 16 years (2009–2025) among a national probability sample of New Zealand adults ( N = 43,020). As expected, results reveal a subgroup of Progressives (76.84%) with lower levels of historical negation and symbolic exclusion that decreased over time and a smaller subgroup of Reactionaries (23.16%) with higher levels of these ideologies that increased over the same period. Demographic and socio‐political variables predicted class membership, and support for political parties varied across classes. Thus, the current study illustrates the presence and implications of ideological polarization towards Indigenous rights.

  • Patriotism Longitudinally Predicts Symbolic Projection of Indigenous Culture Yet Undermines Recognition of Historical Injustices

    by Zoe Bertenshaw, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    Although Indigenous culture can help settler colonies positively distinguish themselves from other nations, unjust colonial histories can undermine national esteem. Patriotism among settler colonisers should therefore discourage marginalising Indigenous culture (low symbolic exclusion) yet encourage denying the contemporary relevance of colonial injustices (high historical negation). Using a random intercepts cross‐lagged panel model (RI‐CLPM), we test the within‐person effects of both patriotism and nationalism on symbolic exclusion and historical negation over 9 years among a nationwide sample of New Zealand Europeans ( N  = 22,547). As hypothesised, patriotism (but not nationalism) uniquely predicted within‐person decreases in symbolic exclusion and increases in historical negation over time. Results replicated when (a) excluding nationalism and (b) examining patriotism's impact on symbolic‐ and resource‐based policy opposition. Thus, patriotism among settler colonisers simultaneously motivates the symbolic projection of Indigenous culture and the denial of the enduring impact of colonial injustices. These insights help explain why some settler colonisers display tokenistic (anti‐)bicultural beliefs.


  • Open Access

    Rise of the alt‐White? Examining the prevalence of perceived racial and gender discrimination among White men from 2014 to 2023

    by Kieren J. Lilly, Chantelle Kimberley, Zoe Bertenshaw, Joaquín Bahamondes, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    The alt‐right increasingly claims that White men are becoming targets of discrimination, yet few studies examine how, and for whom, perceived (reverse) discrimination manifests among White men. We address this oversight by examining rates of change in perceptions of ethnic and gender discrimination across 10 annual waves of a nationwide sample of White men (2014 to 2023; N = 20,486). Latent class growth analysis revealed that most White men (82.75% of participants) reported low and stable perceptions of discrimination over time, alleviating concerns of widespread discontent. However, we identified a Disenfranchised class (8.49%) that perceived moderate discrimination and a Radicalized class (8.76%) whose initially low levels of perceived discrimination increased markedly over time. These classes differed across socio‐demographic variables, socio‐political attitudes and well‐being measures. We thus identify how, and for whom, perceptions of discrimination change over time among White men and how these changes undermine health and progressive social change.


  • Open Access

    The gradual decline of colonial ideologies (2009–2018): A latent growth curve analysis of historical negation and symbolic exclusion among settler colonizers

    by Zoe Bertenshaw, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    In nations laden with colonial inequities, settler colonizers protect their structural advantages through ideologies that (a) distance the injustices of colonization from contemporary society (historical negation) and (b) exclude Indigenous culture from the mainstream national identity (symbolic exclusion). Here, we track settler colonizers' endorsement of these two ideologies between 2009 and 2018 among a nationwide random sample of Pākehā/New Zealand Europeans ( N = 22,986). Consistent with global trends toward equality over this period, both historical negation and symbolic exclusion exhibited a gradual, though slightly accelerating, decline. Subsequent analyses indicate that mean levels of both ideologies were higher among men (vs. women), correlated positively with age, conservatism, social dominance orientation, and right‐wing authoritarianism, and correlated negatively with warmth toward Māori. Additionally, the decline in historical negation was attenuated among men and by age, conservatism, and social dominance orientation, whereas the decline in symbolic exclusion was attenuated by age and warmth toward Māori, but accelerated by social dominance orientation. Results thus illustrate a progressive trajectory of ideological change among settler colonizers during the 2009–2018 period and identify factors that impede one's willingness to renounce ideologies that uphold colonial inequities.


  • Open Access

    Identifying Profiles of Colonial Ideologies: A Test of the Moral Credentialer Hypothesis

    by Zoe Bertenshaw, Carla Houkamau, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    Research warns of a tokenistic combination of two colonial ideologies that recognises Indigenous culture as part of the nation's identity (low symbolic exclusion) yet denies the relevance of colonisation to contemporary inequities (high historical negation). Because symbolic exclusion and historical negation respectively reinforce symbolic and material inequalities, this Moral Credentialer profile may mask intolerance with superficial support for equality. Using latent profile analysis, we investigate the presence of this asymmetric response pattern among a nationwide random sample of Pākehā (New Zealand Europeans; N = 13,877) and Māori ( N = 2004). As expected, we identify heterogeneity among both ethnic groups, yet find a Moral Credentialer profile (high historical negation and low symbolic exclusion) among only Pākehā. Sociopolitical attitudes predicted profile membership, which, in turn, predicted bicultural political attitudes. Results thus corroborate a tokenistic subgroup of settler colonisers who endorse less costly forms of symbolic equality whilst upholding material inequities.


  • Open Access

    Barriers to Biculturalism: Historical Negation and Symbolic Exclusion Predict Longitudinal Increases in Bicultural Policy Opposition

    by Zoe Bertenshaw, Chris G. Sibley, Danny Osborne

    The colonial ideologies of historical negation and symbolic exclusion (i.e., the “Dark Duo”) promote inequality between settler colonizers and Indigenous peoples by denying the contemporary relevance of past injustices and excluding Indigenous culture from the nation’s identity, respectively. Although their correlates are established, the temporal ordering of the relationship between the Dark Duo and bicultural policy opposition is unclear. We address this oversight by utilizing nine annual waves of panel data from a nationwide random sample of New Zealand adults ( N = 31,104) to estimate two multigroup RI-CLPMs using the Dark Duo to predict symbolic and resource-based policy opposition (and vice versa). Results revealed that within-person increases in historical negation and symbolic exclusion predicted subsequent increases in symbolic and resource-based bicultural policy opposition for both majority and minority ethnic groups. These relationships were, however, bidirectional, demonstrating a self-perpetuating cycle, whereby the Dark Duo undermines biculturalism and antibiculturalism strengthens the Dark Duo.