Thokozani Zylma Madumuse
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Thokozani Zylma Madumuse has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mubanga Mpundu
University of the Western Cape, South Africa
2 shared publications - Abubaker Qutieshat
Restorative Dentistry, College of Dental Medicine, University of Sharjah, Sharjah, UAE
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 July 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (3) , 1-15
Stakeholder management as a strategic internal capability: An exploration of strategy implementation in Malawian agricultural cooperatives
The study endeavours to explore the significance of stakeholder management as a strategic internal capability towards strategy implementation effectiveness within the novel context of agricultural cooperatives. The objective of the study is to explore how internal capabilities within agricultural cooperatives contribute to strategy implementation effectiveness. The objective of the study was to enquire on the following research questions: How do agricultural cooperatives implement strategies? What are the relevant success factors considered when implementing strategy? What are the possible solutions to challenges that hinder strategy implementation? Merging the Resource-Based View (RBV) theory and Stakeholder theory, the research employed a qualitative research design to attain the objective. It combined social constructionism with an interpretivist approach—a typical approach to qualitative research that made it more flexible and inductive. This approach allowed for the adoption of the circumstances in which the research was being undertaken, consequently influencing the research design. The target population was agriculture cooperatives with a sample size of seven cooperatives, purposively sampled communal groups formed within farming communities. Data was collected through in-depth interviews with the selected cooperatives managers and board members as key informant interviews (KII) and farmer-members as focused group discussions (FGDs). Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data collected. The main finding of the research was that leadership within cooperatives is compromised, as decision-making is a collective effort, which affects the implementation of strategy. Strategy consensus is prevalent within cooperatives, attributed to open communication and organisational structure, which enables transparency and shared values through an internal voting system. However, external stakeholders are not involved in the strategy process and consulted during strategy implementation for financial support, creating a chasm between cooperative objectives and stakeholder objectives, which is an unsustainable development that has led to the failure of cooperative strategies due to lack of resources. The autonomy of cooperative members directs the strategic behaviours of the cooperative as the board and managers are monitored and removed if their behaviours are misaligned with the strategic objectives—often misinterpreted due to the different literacy levels of the members. Internal communication within cooperatives has been established to be open, with no perceived hierarchical barriers creating trust and strategic consensus. The paper concludes that there is a need for clear leadership roles and responsibilities, which would enable and empower management to initiate and implement stakeholder management as a strategic internal capability towards strategy implementation effectiveness. The study therefore recommends a restructuring of the cooperatives from the board level to include external representatives on the board and the empowering of managers through a clear organisational structure.
- 4 July 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (3) , 1-15
Open AccessStakeholder management as a strategic internal capability: An exploration of strategy implementation in Malawian agricultural cooperatives
The study endeavours to explore the significance of stakeholder management as a strategic internal capability towards strategy implementation effectiveness within the novel context of agricultural cooperatives. The objective of the study is to explore how internal capabilities within agricultural cooperatives contribute to strategy implementation effectiveness. The objective of the study was to enquire on the following research questions: How do agricultural cooperatives implement strategies? What are the relevant success factors considered when implementing strategy? What are the possible solutions to challenges that hinder strategy implementation? Merging the Resource-Based View (RBV) theory and Stakeholder theory, the research employed a qualitative research design to attain the objective. It combined social constructionism with an interpretivist approach—a typical approach to qualitative research that made it more flexible and inductive. This approach allowed for the adoption of the circumstances in which the research was being undertaken, consequently influencing the research design. The target population was agriculture cooperatives with a sample size of seven cooperatives, purposively sampled communal groups formed within farming communities. Data was collected through in-depth interviews with the selected cooperatives managers and board members as key informant interviews (KII) and farmer-members as focused group discussions (FGDs). Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data collected. The main finding of the research was that leadership within cooperatives is compromised, as decision-making is a collective effort, which affects the implementation of strategy. Strategy consensus is prevalent within cooperatives, attributed to open communication and organisational structure, which enables transparency and shared values through an internal voting system. However, external stakeholders are not involved in the strategy process and consulted during strategy implementation for financial support, creating a chasm between cooperative objectives and stakeholder objectives, which is an unsustainable development that has led to the failure of cooperative strategies due to lack of resources. The autonomy of cooperative members directs the strategic behaviours of the cooperative as the board and managers are monitored and removed if their behaviours are misaligned with the strategic objectives—often misinterpreted due to the different literacy levels of the members. Internal communication within cooperatives has been established to be open, with no perceived hierarchical barriers creating trust and strategic consensus. The paper concludes that there is a need for clear leadership roles and responsibilities, which would enable and empower management to initiate and implement stakeholder management as a strategic internal capability towards strategy implementation effectiveness. The study therefore recommends a restructuring of the cooperatives from the board level to include external representatives on the board and the empowering of managers through a clear organisational structure.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2025
- Published by University of Oran 2 Mohamed Ben Ahmed in Advanced Research in Economics and Business Strategy Journal
- Vol. 6 (1) , 181-199
Obstacles to effective strategy implementation: Insights from Agricultural Cooperatives in Malawi
The strategy implementation literature remains fragmented, thus requiring further empirical studies to explain SI challenges in different types of organizations. This has influenced the nature of this study, which aims to identify barriers in SI in the novel organizational context of agriculture cooperatives. This research is a qualitative, multi-firm investigation of the barriers to strategy execution in Malawian agricultural cooperatives. Seven agricultural cooperatives with diverse characteristics that have been in business for at least ten years were purposefully chosen for the study. Managers, chairpersons, and organization members provided information through in-depth interviews facilitated by a semi-structured questionnaire. Findings include that strategy implementation ineffectiveness results from the lack of understanding of strategy, financial resources, inadequate infrastructure, governance, organizational structure, and low literacy levels. The reasons for the strategy implementation failure originated from the formulation stage, with the lack of understanding of strategy, resource allocation, and strategic direction affecting the type of strategy. It is recommended that agricultural cooperatives, in an effort to transform into competitive businesses, be remodeled into a structure that can influence effective strategy implementation and give them a competitive advantage. A limited number of in-depth interviews were conducted as access to the other cooperatives was a challenge. However, the number of cooperatives interviewed is a representative sample of the agriculture cooperatives across the country providing deep insights into the topic relevant to the organizational type and industry. This paper explains why strategy implementation fails in underexplored non-investor firms like cooperatives within the agriculture industry.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by University of Oran 2 Mohamed Ben Ahmed in Advanced Research in Economics and Business Strategy Journal
- Vol. 6 (1) , 181-199
Open AccessObstacles to effective strategy implementation: Insights from Agricultural Cooperatives in Malawi
The strategy implementation literature remains fragmented, thus requiring further empirical studies to explain SI challenges in different types of organizations. This has influenced the nature of this study, which aims to identify barriers in SI in the novel organizational context of agriculture cooperatives. This research is a qualitative, multi-firm investigation of the barriers to strategy execution in Malawian agricultural cooperatives. Seven agricultural cooperatives with diverse characteristics that have been in business for at least ten years were purposefully chosen for the study. Managers, chairpersons, and organization members provided information through in-depth interviews facilitated by a semi-structured questionnaire. Findings include that strategy implementation ineffectiveness results from the lack of understanding of strategy, financial resources, inadequate infrastructure, governance, organizational structure, and low literacy levels. The reasons for the strategy implementation failure originated from the formulation stage, with the lack of understanding of strategy, resource allocation, and strategic direction affecting the type of strategy. It is recommended that agricultural cooperatives, in an effort to transform into competitive businesses, be remodeled into a structure that can influence effective strategy implementation and give them a competitive advantage. A limited number of in-depth interviews were conducted as access to the other cooperatives was a challenge. However, the number of cooperatives interviewed is a representative sample of the agriculture cooperatives across the country providing deep insights into the topic relevant to the organizational type and industry. This paper explains why strategy implementation fails in underexplored non-investor firms like cooperatives within the agriculture industry.
- Open Access
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa e Pos-Graduacao em Direito - CONPEDI in International Journal of Professional Business Review
- Vol. 9 (5) , e04699
MAPPING THE TERRAIN OF STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: A SCOPE REVIEW OF EMPIRICAL STUDIES FROM 2014 TO 2024
Objective: This comprehensive scope review critically examines the landscape of empirical research on strategy implementation (SI) over the past decade, from 2014 to 2024. Despite its critical role in determining organizational success or failure, strategy implementation remains an underexplored area within the vast domain of strategic management literature. Method: The article is a comprehensive scope review which analyses 50 peer-reviewed articles, this review not only uncovers the depth and breadth of empirical research conducted in diverse industries and countries but also identifies prevailing obstacles, leadership roles, and the strategic levels at which implementation is discussed. Results and Discussion: The landscape of empirical research on Strategy Implementation (SI) over the decade spanning 2014 to 2024 has been marked by a remarkable diversity, with studies branching out across various facets of SI from multiple disciplinary perspectives Noteworthy within this broad array of research is the significant attention given to empirical studies conducted within the African continent, particularly in countries like Kenya, Zambia, and Nigeria. Research Implications: This paper seeks to map out the evolving nature of strategy implementation research, pinpointing areas ripe for future exploration and also offers a foundation for developing robust theoretical frameworks and practical models to guide effective strategy execution in organizations worldwide. Originality/Value: This study provides a systematic overview of empirical studies focusing on strategy implementation, highlighting key trends, methodologies, and thematic concentrations within the SI field. Abstracto Objetivo: Este examen amplio del alcance examina críticamente el paisaje de la investigación empírica sobre la aplicación de la estrategia (SI) durante la última década, de 2014 a 2024. A pesar de su papel crítico en determinar el éxito o el fracaso de la organización, la aplicación de la estrategia sigue siendo una esfera poco explorada dentro del amplio ámbito de la literatura de gestión estratégica. Método: El artículo es una revisión amplia del alcance que analiza 50 artículos revisados por pares, esta revisión no sólo revela la profundidad y amplitud de la investigación empírica realizada en diversas industrias y países, sino que también identifica los obstáculos predominantes, los roles de liderazgo y los niveles estratégicos en los que se discute la aplicación. Resultados y discusión: El paisaje de la investigación empírica sobre implementación de estrategias (SI) durante el decenio que abarca 2014 a 2024 ha sido marcado por una diversidad notable, con estudios que se ramifican a través de diversas facetas del SI desde múltiples perspectivas disciplinarias Es notable dentro de esta amplia gama de investigaciones la importante atención que se presta a los estudios empíricos llevados a cabo en el continente africano, en particular en países como Kenya, Zambia y Nigeria. Implicaciones de la investigación: Este documento busca mapear la naturaleza evolutiva de las investigaciones de aplicación de estrategias, identificar áreas maduras para la exploración futura y también ofrece una base para el desarrollo de marcos teóricos robustos y modelos prácticos para orientar la ejecución eficaz de la estrategia en las organizaciones de todo el mundo. Originalidad/Valor: Este estudio proporciona una visión general sistemática de los estudios empíricos centrados en la aplicación de la estrategia, destacando las principales tendencias, metodologías y concentraciones temáticas dentro del campo del SI. Palabras clave: Implementación de estrategias, Investigación empírica, Gestión estratégica, éxito organizacional, Revisión de la literatura Abstrato Objectivo: Esta revisão abrangente de âmbito examina criticamente a paisagem da pesquisa empírica sobre a implementação da estratégia (SI) durante a última década, de 2014 a 2024. Apesar de seu papel crítico na determinação de sucesso ou fracasso organizacional, a implementação da estratégia continua a ser uma área pouco explorada no vasto domínio da literatura de gestão estratégica. Método: O artigo é uma revisão de âmbito abrangente que analisa 50 artigos revisados por pares, esta revisão não só descobre a profundidade e a amplitude da pesquisa empírica realizada em diversas indústrias e países, mas também identifica os obstáculos prevalecentes, os papéis de liderança e os níveis estratégicos em que a implementação é discutida. Resultados e Discussão: A paisagem da pesquisa empírica sobre implementação de estratégias (SI) durante a década de 2014 a 2024 foi marcada por uma diversidade notável, com estudos que se ramificam em várias facetas do SI a partir de múltiplas perspectivas disciplinares Notavel dentro desta ampla gama de pesquisas é a atenção significativa dada a estudos empíricos conduzidos dentro do continente africano, particularmente em países como Quênia, Zâmbia, e Nigéria. Implicações da Pesquisa: Este artigo procura mapear a evolução da natureza da pesquisa de implementação de estratégias, identificando áreas maduras para exploração futura e também oferece uma base para o desenvolvimento de quadros teóricos robustos e modelos práticos para orientar a execução eficaz de estratégia em organizações em todo o mundo. Originalidade/Valor: Este...
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa e Pos-Graduacao em Direito - CONPEDI in International Journal of Professional Business Review
- Vol. 9 (5) , e04699
Open AccessMAPPING THE TERRAIN OF STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: A SCOPE REVIEW OF EMPIRICAL STUDIES FROM 2014 TO 2024
Objective: This comprehensive scope review critically examines the landscape of empirical research on strategy implementation (SI) over the past decade, from 2014 to 2024. Despite its critical role in determining organizational success or failure, strategy implementation remains an underexplored area within the vast domain of strategic management literature. Method: The article is a comprehensive scope review which analyses 50 peer-reviewed articles, this review not only uncovers the depth and breadth of empirical research conducted in diverse industries and countries but also identifies prevailing obstacles, leadership roles, and the strategic levels at which implementation is discussed. Results and Discussion: The landscape of empirical research on Strategy Implementation (SI) over the decade spanning 2014 to 2024 has been marked by a remarkable diversity, with studies branching out across various facets of SI from multiple disciplinary perspectives Noteworthy within this broad array of research is the significant attention given to empirical studies conducted within the African continent, particularly in countries like Kenya, Zambia, and Nigeria. Research Implications: This paper seeks to map out the evolving nature of strategy implementation research, pinpointing areas ripe for future exploration and also offers a foundation for developing robust theoretical frameworks and practical models to guide effective strategy execution in organizations worldwide. Originality/Value: This study provides a systematic overview of empirical studies focusing on strategy implementation, highlighting key trends, methodologies, and thematic concentrations within the SI field. Abstracto Objetivo: Este examen amplio del alcance examina críticamente el paisaje de la investigación empírica sobre la aplicación de la estrategia (SI) durante la última década, de 2014 a 2024. A pesar de su papel crítico en determinar el éxito o el fracaso de la organización, la aplicación de la estrategia sigue siendo una esfera poco explorada dentro del amplio ámbito de la literatura de gestión estratégica. Método: El artículo es una revisión amplia del alcance que analiza 50 artículos revisados por pares, esta revisión no sólo revela la profundidad y amplitud de la investigación empírica realizada en diversas industrias y países, sino que también identifica los obstáculos predominantes, los roles de liderazgo y los niveles estratégicos en los que se discute la aplicación. Resultados y discusión: El paisaje de la investigación empírica sobre implementación de estrategias (SI) durante el decenio que abarca 2014 a 2024 ha sido marcado por una diversidad notable, con estudios que se ramifican a través de diversas facetas del SI desde múltiples perspectivas disciplinarias Es notable dentro de esta amplia gama de investigaciones la importante atención que se presta a los estudios empíricos llevados a cabo en el continente africano, en particular en países como Kenya, Zambia y Nigeria. Implicaciones de la investigación: Este documento busca mapear la naturaleza evolutiva de las investigaciones de aplicación de estrategias, identificar áreas maduras para la exploración futura y también ofrece una base para el desarrollo de marcos teóricos robustos y modelos prácticos para orientar la ejecución eficaz de la estrategia en las organizaciones de todo el mundo. Originalidad/Valor: Este estudio proporciona una visión general sistemática de los estudios empíricos centrados en la aplicación de la estrategia, destacando las principales tendencias, metodologías y concentraciones temáticas dentro del campo del SI. Palabras clave: Implementación de estrategias, Investigación empírica, Gestión estratégica, éxito organizacional, Revisión de la literatura Abstrato Objectivo: Esta revisão abrangente de âmbito examina criticamente a paisagem da pesquisa empírica sobre a implementação da estratégia (SI) durante a última década, de 2014 a 2024. Apesar de seu papel crítico na determinação de sucesso ou fracasso organizacional, a implementação da estratégia continua a ser uma área pouco explorada no vasto domínio da literatura de gestão estratégica. Método: O artigo é uma revisão de âmbito abrangente que analisa 50 artigos revisados por pares, esta revisão não só descobre a profundidade e a amplitude da pesquisa empírica realizada em diversas indústrias e países, mas também identifica os obstáculos prevalecentes, os papéis de liderança e os níveis estratégicos em que a implementação é discutida. Resultados e Discussão: A paisagem da pesquisa empírica sobre implementação de estratégias (SI) durante a década de 2014 a 2024 foi marcada por uma diversidade notável, com estudos que se ramificam em várias facetas do SI a partir de múltiplas perspectivas disciplinares Notavel dentro desta ampla gama de pesquisas é a atenção significativa dada a estudos empíricos conduzidos dentro do continente africano, particularmente em países como Quênia, Zâmbia, e Nigéria. Implicações da Pesquisa: Este artigo procura mapear a evolução da natureza da pesquisa de implementação de estratégias, identificando áreas maduras para exploração futura e também oferece uma base para o desenvolvimento de quadros teóricos robustos e modelos práticos para orientar a execução eficaz de estratégia em organizações em todo o mundo. Originalidade/Valor: Este...