AIAlan Irwin

Alan Irwin

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Alan Irwin has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Standardising difference: Multi-level governance and the scaling of autonomous vehicle pilots in China

    by Armin Scheer, Alan Irwin, Wei Zhang

    Autonomous vehicles are developed through pilots and designated test areas that promise to make experimentation generalisable across sites while remaining applicable in specific locations. This paper examines how China’s autonomous vehicle trial regime manages the apparent tension between generalisability and contextual applicability. China is a revealing case since national ministries define baseline requirements, provinces coordinate adaptation across cities, and municipalities translate shared templates into binding local rules. We examine this architecture through a nested case design that tracks policy-making at national (China), provincial (Guangdong) and municipal (Shenzhen) levels. The analysis draws primarily on 39 official policy texts issued between 2019 and 2025. Seven interviews were also conducted.We find that the trial regime does not seek uniform outcomes across jurisdictions. It standardises the procedures through which variation is authorised, evidenced, and overridden. We present this mechanism as ‘standardising difference’. This is visible at three governance junctions. Mutual recognition allows permits and test results to travel while preserving local flexibility. Platform interconnection aligns reporting formats across levels while leaving action thresholds to be contingently configured. Contextual controls render permissions conditional in real time through weather rules, operating boundaries, and situational override. The paper contributes to research on policy mixes, experimental governance, and scaling by revealing how conditional portability is assembled through permits, evidence practices, reporting infrastructures, and override powers.

  • Post-normal science communication? Evidence of third-order thinking among sustainability scientists

    by Marianne Achiam, Alan Irwin

    Mounting socio-environmental crises have prompted calls for post-normal sustainability science, emphasising complexity, uncertainty, and epistemic pluralism, and framing science communication as dialogical and reflexive. However, previous research has identified a gap between these ideals and actual practices, where conventional norms of objectivity and expert authority often prevail. Drawing on Irwin’s (2021) framework of socio-technical orders of thinking, we analyse interviews with 12 leading Danish sustainability scientists. Our thematic analysis shows that scientists pragmatically navigate between first-order (expert-led), second-order (inclusive), and third-order (reflexive and power-aware) modes of thinking. While third-order thinking emerges as integral to sustainability science, traditional assumptions about authority and neutrality continue to shape scientists’ communication practices. These findings invite science communication scholars to view sustainability science as a fertile ground for developing and testing pluralistic, reflexive, and power-aware communication models, while also learning from the situated practices of scientists who already navigate these complexities in context.


  • Open Access

    The Impact and Value of Research in the Arts and Humanities - A Systematic Literature Review

    by Carter Walter Bloch, Alan Irwin, Evanthia Kalpazidou Schmidt, Anna Vigsø Pedersen, Amalie Due Svendsen

    Research and research policy have increasingly directed attention towards issues concerning the impact of research. This focus appears to be driven by a range of factors, including: the wish to demonstrate accountability with regard to public funding, the need to measure and benchmark research quality, and a growing interest in understanding and documenting the connection between research and its societal use (Penfield et al., 2014). Research in the Arts and Humanities (A&H) is no exception from this trend, stimulating considerable debate over the impact of A&H research, as well as on how this impact can be demonstrated (Pedersen et al., 2020; Reale et al., 2018). At the same time, there is a lack of consensus on how valuation and impact in A&H can be understood and measured. Indeed, some scholars question whether the ‘impact’ concept is even appropriate in terms of capturing how A&H research matters for society (Belfiore, 2015; Collini, 2012). In contrast to disciplines within Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM), the societal impact of A&H research may be more difficult to grasp. Hence, a better understanding of the nature of A&H research, as well as how value creation takes place, are central to an appreciation of research impact in A&H and the factors that can promote or hinder it. The Danish Centre for Studies in Research and Research Policy (CFA) at Aarhus University has undertaken a study of existing knowledge about the societal impact of Arts and Humanities research. The goal of this study is to review and synthesise work on the impact of A&H research, including how this impact can be conceptualised and the role of funding and evaluation in promoting this research and its impact. The study was funded by the Augustinus Foundation. This study is based on a systematic literature review as well as insights drawn directly from experts in the field of societal impact, A&H researchers and other key stakeholders.

  • Open Access

    Citizen Science and Public Policy-Making During the COVID-19 Pandemic

    by Sine Zambach, Maja Horst, Alan Irwin

    Drawing upon the COVID-19 crisis in Denmark, this paper investigates the relationship between public policy-making and Citizen Science as conducted by citizens analysing and visualizing COVID data through social media. We consider whether this form of Citizen Data Science (CDS) can help inform public debate and influence policy-making during a crisis. Specifically, the paper explores the CDS community, its contributions and policy interactions. Though it is difficult to demonstrate a direct causal relationship between CDS and specific policy decisions, we conclude that CDS can act as a form of ‘extended peer community’ where new developments are reflected upon, discussed and supplemented by a larger and not professionally involved audience. In this way, CDS represents a potentially-valuable input to policy. However, it also raises new questions and challenges for policy-making, not least in terms of policy makers’ capacity to identify useful inputs and act upon a broader range of expertise.

  • Making the Global Local: The Case of Chinese Research and Innovation Evaluation Systems

    by Julia Kirch Kirkegaard, Alan Irwin, Xuan Li

    Starting with China's increasingly prominent role in the global politics of science, this paper considers the case of Chinese policies for the evaluation of Research & Innovation (R&I) and the recent problematization of the Science Citation Index. Developing the notion of global embedding, we conduct a document study of Chinese R&I policy to explore how China mediates the relations between global standardization of research quality and local concerns for indigenous research development. Showing that China seeks high global rankings while also questioning them, we explore how globally familiar representations of the scientific process are expressed in core Chinese statements even as China pursues its own distinctive path. We discuss how co-production of standardization and difference instantiates a both practical and pragmatic resolution of global embedding—suggesting a flexible resolution of what might otherwise be presented as contradictory pressures. Shedding light on the mediations and translations of global ranking systems in R&I policy, we contribute to science & technology studies on co-production by exploring the relations between policies for science and the influence of broader political culture. At stake is the very notion that R&I policies can serve local as well as international needs.


  • Open Access

    Always Relevant? Finding a Place for the Social Sciences in the Technical University and the Business School

    by Alan Irwin, Maja Horst

    Relevance with regard to the social sciences can be presented as a new imposition from external stakeholders and an obligation imposed upon the individual researcher. As an alternative approach, we place relevance in a larger institutional but also historical perspective. Taking the case of two non-traditional locations for the social sciences, we suggest that ‘relevance’ has been actively constitutive of both institutions from the beginning—even if the definition and practice of relevance have been matters of discussion, change and contestation. In what we describe as a process of multi-layering, relevance has over time accumulated new meanings which can co-exist with older concerns. It follows that, even when universities express a commitment to relevance, the enactment of that commitment will be open to competing interpretations. Our account identifies an element of circularity as old issues return in new form. We also note that both the institutional past and organizational complexity can be overlooked within contemporary discussions. Relevance is not a static concept around which critical debate then circulates. Its contextuality, case-specificity and multi-dimensionality make it difficult to impose from above. Nevertheless, the shifting construction of its meaning and enactment provokes questions about the identity and purpose of both the social sciences and the universities.


  • Open Access

    STS and Innovation: Building and Jumping Fences

    by Alan Irwin

    In this short contribution, I reflect upon the thematic collection as a whole, returning in particular to the three original questions posed in the collection’s introduction. In conclusion, I argue that STS has a substantial heritage in researching and engaging with innovation. However, drawing inspiration from the contributions in this collection, now is the time to take the STS-innovation relationship even further forward.


  • Open Access

    STS and Innovation: Borderlands, Regenerations and Critical Engagements

    by Alan Irwin

    This introduction to a thematic collection on the relationship between STS and innovation poses three main questions. When it comes to engaging with and acting upon socio-technical change, is ‘innovation’ part of the solution or of the problem? How should we view the relationship between STS approaches to innovation and neighbouring fields, especially Innovation Studies (IS)? What new conceptual and empirical resources can STS bring to the study of innovation (including the possible redefinition and reframing of the term itself)?


  • Open Access

    Re-making ‘quality’ within the social sciences: The debate over rigour and relevance in the modern business school

    by Alan Irwin

    Against the background of previous discussions over the state of academic institutions and the specific operation of research evaluation and measurement systems, this article focuses on the relationship between academic quality and larger societal value within social scientific research. Adopting a perspective from Science and Technology Studies (STS), it specifically explores what has become known as the ‘rigour–relevance’ debate within business and management research and considers its larger implications. On the one hand, it is important to consider how terms such as ‘rigour’ and ‘relevance’ are specifically constructed and performed. On the other, this debate should be seen in the context of the modern business school as an ‘overloaded assemblage’ responsible to multiple audiences and for multiple purposes. In conclusion, it is argued that frameworks of ‘rigour’ and ‘relevance’ should be considered in terms not only of what they include but also omit – with notions of responsibility, public value, cognitive justice and public engagement providing alternative, but characteristically neglected, means of (re-)framing quality in this context.