Hanouf Al Ghanmi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Hanouf Al Ghanmi has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Rami Bahsoon
University of Birmingham
4 shared publications - Sabreen Ahmadjee
Department of Cybersecurity, Umm Al-Qura University, Saudi Arabia
3 shared publications - Hayatullahi Bolaji Adeyemo
School of Computer Science, University of Birmingham
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 May 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
A Systematisation of Transparency, Accountability and Understandability in Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contracts automate agreements, replacing third-party intermediaries with immutable and enforceable algorithms. Despite their potential, the complexity of blockchain often undermines human trust and their wide adoption. To address this challenge, we systematise existing knowledge on three critical human-centric qualities: transparency, accountability and understandability. Although these qualities are frequently invoked as pillars of trust in decentralised systems, they remain ambiguously defined and inconsistently operationalised across the literature and platforms. To establish a clearer and more coherent understanding of these qualities in the context of public blockchains and smart contracts, we introduce a structured model that organises existing knowledge into five levels: output, algorithm, external data, process, and application, acquiring insights from literature. This structured approach provides a comprehensive understanding by revealing gaps and areas of consensus, aiding researchers in identifying areas requiring further investigation. To address unclear or conflicting interpretations, we incorporated insights from experienced blockchain developers. We also conduct a comparative analysis to examine whether the characteristics of public blockchains align with standard definitions of transparency, accountability, and understandability. Our findings show that smart contracts support visibility and traceability at low system levels but lack clarity, answerability, and ease of understanding at higher organisational and user interaction levels. These gaps highlight the need for improved communication practices, clearer governance disclosure, and more human-centred design approaches.
- 4 May 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
Open AccessA Systematisation of Transparency, Accountability and Understandability in Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contracts automate agreements, replacing third-party intermediaries with immutable and enforceable algorithms. Despite their potential, the complexity of blockchain often undermines human trust and their wide adoption. To address this challenge, we systematise existing knowledge on three critical human-centric qualities: transparency, accountability and understandability. Although these qualities are frequently invoked as pillars of trust in decentralised systems, they remain ambiguously defined and inconsistently operationalised across the literature and platforms. To establish a clearer and more coherent understanding of these qualities in the context of public blockchains and smart contracts, we introduce a structured model that organises existing knowledge into five levels: output, algorithm, external data, process, and application, acquiring insights from literature. This structured approach provides a comprehensive understanding by revealing gaps and areas of consensus, aiding researchers in identifying areas requiring further investigation. To address unclear or conflicting interpretations, we incorporated insights from experienced blockchain developers. We also conduct a comparative analysis to examine whether the characteristics of public blockchains align with standard definitions of transparency, accountability, and understandability. Our findings show that smart contracts support visibility and traceability at low system levels but lack clarity, answerability, and ease of understanding at higher organisational and user interaction levels. These gaps highlight the need for improved communication practices, clearer governance disclosure, and more human-centred design approaches.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Computing Surveys
- Vol. 58 (7) , 1-43
Exploring Human-Centric Dimensions in Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contract technology has revolutionised various industries by automating agreements through immutable and self-executing logic, reducing reliance on third-party intermediaries. However, despite its transformative potential, existing research has predominantly focused on technical aspects—particularly security—while largely neglecting human-in-the-loop concerns. Systematic efforts to explore these concerns from a human perspective have been limited which creates a gap in the literature. This study aims to address this gap by offering a comprehensive understanding of smart contracts from a human-centred perspective. To achieve this, we conducted a systematic literature review to examine human-related issues in smart contracts and their existing solutions. We found that concerns are primarily concentrated in two stages: development and interaction. During the development stage, issues arise in relation to programming languages, including complexity, readability and expressiveness, as well as the legality of smart contracts and their ethical and social implications. In the interaction stage, concerns focus on usability, human readability, trust, governance and cost. Additionally, we identified several quality attributes frequently associated with these concerns such as transparency, accountability, understandability, simplicity, learnability, compliance and fairness. We also uncovered new human-centred quality attributes that are overlooked in existing literature, such as explainability and interpretability. This research offers valuable insights for researchers, requirements engineers and designers by examining existing efforts to address human-centric concerns and proposing future directions and opportunities to improve smart contract design.
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Computing Surveys
- Vol. 58 (7) , 1-43
Open AccessExploring Human-Centric Dimensions in Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contract technology has revolutionised various industries by automating agreements through immutable and self-executing logic, reducing reliance on third-party intermediaries. However, despite its transformative potential, existing research has predominantly focused on technical aspects—particularly security—while largely neglecting human-in-the-loop concerns. Systematic efforts to explore these concerns from a human perspective have been limited which creates a gap in the literature. This study aims to address this gap by offering a comprehensive understanding of smart contracts from a human-centred perspective. To achieve this, we conducted a systematic literature review to examine human-related issues in smart contracts and their existing solutions. We found that concerns are primarily concentrated in two stages: development and interaction. During the development stage, issues arise in relation to programming languages, including complexity, readability and expressiveness, as well as the legality of smart contracts and their ethical and social implications. In the interaction stage, concerns focus on usability, human readability, trust, governance and cost. Additionally, we identified several quality attributes frequently associated with these concerns such as transparency, accountability, understandability, simplicity, learnability, compliance and fairness. We also uncovered new human-centred quality attributes that are overlooked in existing literature, such as explainability and interpretability. This research offers valuable insights for researchers, requirements engineers and designers by examining existing efforts to address human-centric concerns and proposing future directions and opportunities to improve smart contract design.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
- Vol. 34 (8) , 1-35
Evaluating the Need for Explanations in Blockchain Smart Contracts to Reconcile Surprises
Smart contracts on the blockchain play an important role in decentralised systems by automating and executing agreements without the need for intermediaries. As these contracts become integral to various domains, ensuring users’ understanding of their functioning is paramount. This article investigates the need for explanations in smart contracts, drawing inspiration from contract law principles and established practices in Explainable AI (XAI). It introduces key purposes—justification, clarification, compliance and consent to design explainability. Additionally, the study proposes a novel assessment framework informed by the Metacognitive Explanation-Based (MEB) theory to systematically evaluate surprise potential in smart contracts lacking explanations. We use surprise as a guiding factor to systematically identify areas requiring improvement in terms of justification, clarification, compliance and consent. To demonstrate the utility of the assessment approach, we evaluate two decentralised lending projects, uncovering potential surprises. One of the key observations is the lack of setting information, especially concerning compliance, consent and decision justification. This absence of information has heightened the potential for surprises. In the process of validating the explanation purposes, we implement techniques to improve the design of the assessed smart contracts. Further, the research explores the tradeoffs involved in integrating explanations, providing nuanced insights into economic implications such as increased deployment and execution costs. This work contributes to the broader comprehension of smart contract explainability requirements and lays out a theoretical foundation for a generic evaluation method. It aims to facilitate the development of more human-centric and comprehensible smart contracts.
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
- Vol. 34 (8) , 1-35
Open AccessEvaluating the Need for Explanations in Blockchain Smart Contracts to Reconcile Surprises
Smart contracts on the blockchain play an important role in decentralised systems by automating and executing agreements without the need for intermediaries. As these contracts become integral to various domains, ensuring users’ understanding of their functioning is paramount. This article investigates the need for explanations in smart contracts, drawing inspiration from contract law principles and established practices in Explainable AI (XAI). It introduces key purposes—justification, clarification, compliance and consent to design explainability. Additionally, the study proposes a novel assessment framework informed by the Metacognitive Explanation-Based (MEB) theory to systematically evaluate surprise potential in smart contracts lacking explanations. We use surprise as a guiding factor to systematically identify areas requiring improvement in terms of justification, clarification, compliance and consent. To demonstrate the utility of the assessment approach, we evaluate two decentralised lending projects, uncovering potential surprises. One of the key observations is the lack of setting information, especially concerning compliance, consent and decision justification. This absence of information has heightened the potential for surprises. In the process of validating the explanation purposes, we implement techniques to improve the design of the assessed smart contracts. Further, the research explores the tradeoffs involved in integrating explanations, providing nuanced insights into economic implications such as increased deployment and execution costs. This work contributes to the broader comprehension of smart contract explainability requirements and lays out a theoretical foundation for a generic evaluation method. It aims to facilitate the development of more human-centric and comprehensible smart contracts.
- 3 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1984-2004
ExplanaSC: A Framework for Determining Information Requirements for Explainable Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contracts (SCs) have emerged as a transformative technology, enabling the automation and execution of contractual agreements without the need for intermediaries. However, as SCs evolve to become more complex in their decentralised decision-making abilities, there are notable difficulties in comprehending the underlying reasoning process and ensuring users’ understanding. The existing literature primarily focuses on the technical aspects of SC, overlooking the exploration of the decision-making process within these systems and the involvement of humans. In this paper, we propose a framework that integrates human-centered design principles by applying Situation Awareness (SA) and goal directed task analysis (GDTA) concepts to determine information requirements necessary to design eXplainable smart contracts (XSC). The framework provides a structured approach for requirements engineers to identify information that can keep users well-informed throughout the decision-making process. The framework considers factors such as the business logic model, data model, and roles and responsibilities model to define specific information requirements that shape SC behaviour and necessitate explanations. To guide the determination of information requirements, the framework categorises SC decision mechanisms into autonomy, governance, processing, and behaviour. The ExplanaSC framework promotes the generation of XSC explanations through three levels aligned with SA: XSC explanation for perception, XSC explanation for comprehension, and XSC explanation for projection. Overall, this framework contributes to the development of XSC systems and lays the foundation for more transparent, and trustworthy decentralized applications. The XSC explanations aims to facilitate user awareness of complex decision-making processes. The evaluation of the framework uses a case to exemplify the working of our framework, its added value and limitations, and consults experts in the field for feedback and refinements.
- 3 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1984-2004
ExplanaSC: A Framework for Determining Information Requirements for Explainable Blockchain Smart Contracts
Blockchain smart contracts (SCs) have emerged as a transformative technology, enabling the automation and execution of contractual agreements without the need for intermediaries. However, as SCs evolve to become more complex in their decentralised decision-making abilities, there are notable difficulties in comprehending the underlying reasoning process and ensuring users’ understanding. The existing literature primarily focuses on the technical aspects of SC, overlooking the exploration of the decision-making process within these systems and the involvement of humans. In this paper, we propose a framework that integrates human-centered design principles by applying Situation Awareness (SA) and goal directed task analysis (GDTA) concepts to determine information requirements necessary to design eXplainable smart contracts (XSC). The framework provides a structured approach for requirements engineers to identify information that can keep users well-informed throughout the decision-making process. The framework considers factors such as the business logic model, data model, and roles and responsibilities model to define specific information requirements that shape SC behaviour and necessitate explanations. To guide the determination of information requirements, the framework categorises SC decision mechanisms into autonomy, governance, processing, and behaviour. The ExplanaSC framework promotes the generation of XSC explanations through three levels aligned with SA: XSC explanation for perception, XSC explanation for comprehension, and XSC explanation for projection. Overall, this framework contributes to the development of XSC systems and lays the foundation for more transparent, and trustworthy decentralized applications. The XSC explanations aims to facilitate user awareness of complex decision-making processes. The evaluation of the framework uses a case to exemplify the working of our framework, its added value and limitations, and consults experts in the field for feedback and refinements.