NDNicolás Dufey‐Portilla

Nicolás Dufey‐Portilla

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Nicolás Dufey‐Portilla has a total of 57 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Human Consensus Versus Generative Artificial Intelligence When Assessing the Methodological Quality and Overall Confidence in the Results of Systematic Reviews With Meta‐Analysis in Endodontology

    by Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Nicolás Dufey‐Portilla, Sheela B. Abraham, Thilla Sekar Vinothkumar, Giorgos N. Tzanetakis, Jelena Jacimovic, Aleksandar Jakovljevic, Fernando Peña‐Bengoa, Marc Garcia‐Font, Francesc Abella Sans, et al.

    Objective: To evaluate the level of agreement between ChatGPT‐5.5 and human assessments when appraising the methodological quality and overall confidence of the results of systematic reviews (SRs) with meta‐analysis (MA) in endodontology. Methods: SRs with MA related to endodontology and published in English between 2021 and 2024 were included. The methodological quality of the SRs was appraised by three human experts using AMSTAR 2, and a consensus dataset was generated. ChatGPT‐5.5 was applied to generate AMSTAR 2 item‐level ratings and overall confidence classifications for each SR through three newly created accounts. Agreement between consolidated ChatGPT‐5.5 ratings and human consensus was assessed for both overall confidence and each AMSTAR 2 item. Overall‐confidence agreement was evaluated under the primary criterion (Partial Yes = Yes) and an alternative sensitivity criterion (Partial Yes = No). Direct agreement and linearly weighted Cohen's kappa were calculated, and complete 3/3 agreement was used to assess consistency across ChatGPT‐5.5 accounts. Results: One hundred SRs were included. Human consensus and ChatGPT‐5.5 classified 47 and 85 SRs, respectively, as critically low. Under the primary criterion (Partial Yes = Yes), overall confidence matched in 52/100 SRs (52%; weighted κ = 0.182). Under the alternative criterion (Partial Yes = No), agreement increased to 83%, while weighted κ remained similar (κ = 0.173), indicating that direct agreement was sensitive to the handling of Partial Yes. Item‐level agreement varied substantially. Overall confidence was identical across the three ChatGPT‐5.5 accounts in 85 SRs, and global item‐level 3/3 agreement was 86.12%. In the 100 sampled SRs, 15% met the criterion for reporting primary‐study funding and 21% for justifying study designs. Conclusion: Overall‐confidence direct agreement was sensitive to the handling of Partial Yes ratings, whereas chance‐corrected agreement remained similar under both criteria. ChatGPT‐5.5 assigned lower overall confidence classifications more frequently than human consensus, and agreement varied across AMSTAR 2 domains. Although outputs were frequently consistent across the three ChatGPT‐5.5 accounts, between‐account consistency did not ensure concordance with human judgements. The findings do not support the use of ChatGPT‐5.5 as an independent AMSTAR 2 assessor; any exploratory application requires item‐by‐item verification by reviewers with methodological expertise.

  • Undergraduate and Postgraduate Dental Student Knowledge Regarding the Use of Antibiotics in Endodontics: An Online‐Based Survey

    by Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Mohannad Nassar, Venkatesh Alagarsamy, Thilla Sekar Vinothkumar, Anil Kishen, Paul V. Abbott, Juan J. Segura‐Egea, Arindam Dutta, Meric Karapinar Kazandag, Saba Kilimci, et al.

    Aim: The use of antibiotics in clinical practice is shaped by the adequate knowledge acquired during professional education. The survey aimed to evaluate the knowledge of final‐year undergraduate and postgraduate endodontic students regarding the use of antibiotics in endodontic management. Methodology: The survey was distributed to final year undergraduates and postgraduate endodontic students across 10 dental schools in different countries. The questionnaire included demographic data and assessed the respondents' knowledge of current guidelines and antibiotic use in endodontic scenarios. The survey instrument was validated and piloted prior to distribution. Responses were summarised using frequencies and percentages. Undergraduate and postgraduate students were compared using Pearson's chi‐squared or Fisher's exact tests. An institution‐equalised sensitivity analysis assessed the influence of institutional participation, and a multivariable logistic generalised estimating equation (GEE) model evaluated factors associated with guideline‐concordant responses across clinical scenarios. Results: The overall response rate for undergraduate students was 37.3%, and for postgraduate students was 87.9%. Most respondents recognised that systemic antibiotics were generally not indicated for localised endodontic infections without systemic involvement but were indicated for acute apical abscess with systemic involvement and after replantation of an avulsed permanent tooth. Awareness of the European Society of Endodontology ( ESE ) guidelines was 49.1% among undergraduate and 82.6% among postgraduate respondents, whereas awareness of the American Association of Endodontists ( AAE ) guidelines was 70.4% and 91.7%, respectively ( p < 0.001 for both comparisons). Awareness of ESE guidelines was independently associated with greater odds of a guideline‐concordant response (adjusted OR = 1.39, 95% CI 1.03–1.88; p = 0.029), whereas postgraduate status was not (adjusted OR = 1.36, 95% CI 0.97–1.91; p = 0.070). Institution‐equalised estimates supported the qualitative interpretation of most outcomes, although the undergraduate estimate recommending prophylaxis before non‐surgical root canal treatment in patients with prosthetic joint replacement within the previous 3 months decreased from 52.5% to 37.2%. Conclusions: Among respondents from the participating dental schools, knowledge of appropriate antibiotic use was identified across clinical scenarios, with variability particularly in antibiotic selection for patients with true penicillin allergy, use of loading doses and prophylactic antibiotic recommendations. Continued integration of antimicrobial stewardship principles into dental education curricula is warranted.

  • Prevalence and Anatomical Characteristics of C‐Shaped Canals in Mandibular Molars in Chile: A Nationwide Multicentre Cross‐Sectional Study

    by Fernando Peña‐Bengoa, Pablo Betancourt, Jaime Abarca, Carolina Cáceres, Patricio Meléndez, Claudia Valenzuela, Karin Steinfort, Nicolás Dufey‐Portilla, Jorge N. R. Martins

    This retrospective multicentre cross‐sectional study aimed to determine the prevalence and characteristics of C‐shaped canals in Chilean mandibular molars using cone‐beam computed tomography (CBCT) and to assess associations with demographic and geographic variables. A total of 5660 mandibular molars from CBCT scans obtained from imaging centres across different regions of Chile were analysed. External root morphology was categorized according to root fusion, and C‐shaped canals were classified using Fan's classification at five axial levels. The prevalence of C‐shaped canals was 9.88%, with most cases occurring in mandibular second molars (93.92%) and bilateral occurrence observed in 53.87% of affected individuals. Their distribution differed significantly across geographic regions ( p = 0.002). Regression analysis accounting for within‐patient clustering showed that female sex was significantly associated with their presence (OR = 1.74), whereas age showed no significant association. All C‐shaped canals showed root fusion. These findings provide population‐specific data for improving diagnostic accuracy and endodontic treatment planning.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Evaluating Guideline Adherence in Gemini‐Powered Dental Trauma Workflows: Standalone Gemini Chat vs. Document‐Grounded NotebookLM

    by Nicolás Dufey‐Portilla, Francesc Abella Sans, Fernando Duran‐Sindreu, Maria Teresa Salagaray, Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Paul V. Abbott, Liran Levin, Marc Garcia‐Font

    Aim: The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy and inter‐account consistency of two Google Gemini–powered, user‐facing workflows for dental trauma decision support: standalone Gemini chat and NotebookLM, a document‐grounded workflow that generates responses grounded in uploaded European Society of Endodontology and International Association of Dental Traumatology guideline documents, when answering dichotomous (yes/no) clinical questions on the management of traumatized permanent teeth. Methodology: A cross‐sectional simulation was conducted using 99 dichotomous (yes/no) questions derived from the European Society of Endodontology and International Association of Dental Traumatology guidelines. Three academic endodontists submitted each question to Gemini and NotebookLM using three independent Google accounts, generating 297 responses per workflow. Accuracy was defined as exact agreement with guideline‐based answers, and consistency as the proportion of identical responses across the three trials. Statistical analyses included Wald and Wilson 95% confidence intervals, Fleiss' kappa for inter‐account agreement, and Pearson's chi‐squared tests to compare proportions. Results: Gemini demonstrated an overall accuracy of 83.83% (95% CI: 75.08–90.47) and a consistency of 74.74% (κ = 0.84). NotebookLM showed higher accuracy (92.93%; 95% CI: 85.97–97.11) and perfect consistency (100%; κ = 1.00). While the difference in accuracy did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.076), NotebookLM exhibited significantly greater consistency (p < 0.001). Conclusions: The responses generated from the guidelines were highly consistent with both workflows. Document grounding may enhance repeatability and alignment with guideline‐derived decision points for structured dichotomous inquiries, as evidenced by NotebookLM's ability to achieve complete inter‐account consistency and to quantitatively increase accuracy. These results are the outcome of workflow‐level benchmarking; therefore, clinical utility cannot be inferred solely from them; professional oversight and additional validation remain necessary before any clinical application.


  • Evaluating Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models on External Cervical Resorption: A Comparative Study of Gemini and NotebookLM

    by Marc Garcia-Font, Nicolás Dufey-Portilla, Fernando Durán-Sindreu, José Antonio González Sánchez, Gustavo Rodríguez Millán, Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Paul M.H. Dummer, Francesc Abella Sans


  • Open Access

    Assessing the validity of ChatGPT-4o and Google Gemini Advanced when responding to frequently asked questions in endodontics

    by Nicolás Dufey-Portilla, Ana Billik Frisman, Maximiliano Gallardo Robles, Fernando Peña-Bengoa, Consuelo Cabrera Ávila, Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Paul M. H. Dummer, Marc Garcia-Font, Francesc Abella Sans

    Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming access to dental information via large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and Google Gemini. Both models are increasingly being used in endodontics as a source of information for patients. Therefore, as developers release new versions, the validity of their responses must be continuously compared to professional consultations. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the validity of the responses provided by the most advanced LLMs [Google Gemini Advanced (GGA) and ChatGPT-4o] to frequently asked questions (FAQs) in endodontics. Methodology: A cross-sectional analytical study was conducted in five phases. The top 20 endodontic FAQs submitted by users to chatbots and collected from Google Trends were compiled. In total, nine academically certified endodontic specialists with educational roles scored GGA and ChatGPT-4o responses to the FAQs using a five-point Likert scale. Validity was determined using high (4.5-5) and low (≥4) thresholds. The Fisher's exact test was used for comparative analysis. Results: At the low threshold, both models obtained 95% validity (95% CI: 75.1%- 99.9%; p=.05). At the high threshold, ChatGPT-4o achieved 35% (95% CI: 15.4%- 59.2%) and GGA, 40% (95% CI: 19.1%- 63.9%) validity (p=1). Conclusions: ChatGPT-4o and GGA responses showed high validity under lenient criteria that significantly decreased under stricter thresholds, limiting their reliability as a stand-alone source of information in endodontics. While AI chatbots show promise to improve patient education in endodontics, their validity limitations under rigorous evaluation highlight the need for careful professional monitoring.


  • Accuracy and Consistency of Gemini Responses Regarding the Management of Traumatized Permanent Teeth

    by Nicolas Dufey Portilla, Marc Garcia‐Font, Venkateshbabu Nagendrababu, Paul V. Abbott, Jose Antonio Gonzalez Sanchez, Francesc Abella

    Background: The aim of this cross‐sectional observational analytical study was to assess the accuracy and consistency of responses provided by Google Gemini (GG), a free‐access high‐performance multimodal large language model, to questions related to the European Society of Endodontology position statement on the management of traumatized permanent teeth (MTPT).Materials and Methods: Three academic endodontists developed a set of 99 yes/no questions covering all areas of the MTPT. Nine general dentists and 22 endodontic specialists evaluated these questions for clarity and comprehension through an iterative process. Two academic dental trauma experts categorized the knowledge required to answer each question into three levels. The three academic endodontists submitted the 99 questions to the GG, resulting in 297 responses, which were then assessed for accuracy and consistency. Accuracy was evaluated using the Wald binomial method, while the consistency of GG responses was assessed using the kappa‐Fleiss coefficient with a confidence interval of 95%. A 5% significance level chi‐squared test was used to evaluate the influence of question level of knowledge on accuracy and consistency.Results: The responses generated by Gemini showed an overall moderate accuracy of 80.81%, with no significant differences found between the responses of the academic endodontists. Overall, high consistency (95.96%) was demonstrated, with no significant differences between GG responses across the three accounts. The analysis also revealed no correlation between question level of knowledge and accuracy or consistency, with no significant differences.Conclusions: The results of this study could significantly impact the potential use of Gemini as a free‐access source of information for clinicians in the MTPT.


  • Analysis of primary caregivers’ knowledge concerning the cariogenic risk associated with the use of pediatric liquid medications

    by Viña del Mar Private Practice, Florencia Cáceres-Riveros, Paula Karin-Navea, Puerto Aysén Private Practice, Nicolás Dufey-Portilla, Facultad de Odontología Departamento de Endodoncia, Cristina Barrera-Gutierréz, Facultad de Odontología Departamento de Odontopediatría, Javiera Brantt-Brantt

    Introduction: Pediatric liquid medications (PLM) are frequently administered to children, yet their usage may contribute to the onset of dental caries. Despite its prevalence, there is a notable scarcity of scientific research regarding caregivers’ knowledge of this potential cariogenic risk. Objective: This study aims to assess the knowledge of the main caregivers of children aged 5 to 12 years concerning the cariogenic potential associated with the use of PLM. Materials and Methods: A cross-sectional analytical obser-vational study involving 152 primary caregivers of children aged 5 to 12 was conducted. Data were collected on caregivers’ perceptions of the cariogenic risk associated with PLMs and their consumption habits. The study also assessed oral hygiene routines and evaluated the level of information provided by healthcare professionals. Results: Research findings indicated a significant lack of awa-reness among primary caregivers regarding the cariogenic risks of PLMs, with 78.95% being unaware of these risks and 47.37% unaware of the sugars present in such medications. Additionally, a high rate of PLM consumption was observed, with 63% of caregivers using them in the last year. The study underscored a notable absence of guidance from healthcare professionals, as 91.45% of the caregivers stated that they had not received instructions on tooth brushing after the administration of the PLM. Conclusions: The study highlights a significant lack of awa-reness among primary caregivers regarding the cariogenic risks associated with the ingestion of pediatric liquid medications. This deficit in information and preventive measures presents a substantial obstacle to children’s oral health. To address this issue, it is crucial for healthcare professionals to offer comprehensive guidance and promote preventive measures.

  • Open Access

    Evaluation of Internal Bleaching with 35% Hydrogen Peroxide in Dentin Conditioned with 37% Phosphoric Acid and 17% EDTA

    by Facultad de Odontología Departamento de Endodoncia, Fernando Peña-Bengoa, Nicolás Dufey, Germán Buchheister

    Introduction: This study aimed to evaluate the effect of dentin surface treatment with 37% phosphoric acid or 17% ethylenedia-minetetraacetic acid (EDTA) before Internal Bleaching with 35% hydrogen peroxide using the walking bleach technique. Material and Methods: This experimental in vitro study used 66 human premolars extracted for orthodontic reasons, which were debrided, endodontically prepared, and pigmented with chromogens derived from blood decomposition. The samples were randomly divided into three groups (n=22). Group A: bleaching agent without dentin conditioning; group B: bleaching agent in dentin conditioned with phosphoric acid 37%; group C: bleaching agent in dentin conditioned with 17% EDTA. 4 applications of bleaching agent were used with a separation of 4 days between each session. The initial color (baseline) and after each application was determined by spectrophotometry, recording the CIE L*a*b* values and the total color variation between the initial parameters and the different evaluation times. Results: Data were statistically analyzed with the Wilcoxon test. This showed statistically significant differences for the total variation of the color between the study groups, with the control group in no case inferior to the rest. Conclusion: The application of 37% phosphoric acid increased the effectiveness of the bleaching agent when compared to 17% EDTA. However, these did not increase the effectiveness compared to the application of the bleaching agent without a previous dentin surface treatment.