Thierry Camelbeeck
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Thierry Camelbeeck has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Koen Van Noten
Seismology-Gravimetry, Royal Observatory of Belgium, Brussels, Belgium
3 shared publications - Kris Vanneste
Royal Observatory of Belgium
3 shared publications - Ben Neefs
Seismology-Gravimetry Department, Royal Observatory of Belgium, Brussels, Belgium
2 shared publications - Thomas Lecocq
Seismology-Gravimetry, Royal Observatory of Belgium, Brussels, Belgium
2 shared publications - David Garcia Moreno
Royal Observatory of Belgium, Av. Circulaire 3, 1180 Uccle, Brussels, Belgium.2 Renard Centre of Marine Geology, Ghent University. Krijgslaan 281 S.8, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium
1 shared publication - Elisabeth Knuts
Royal Observatory of Belgium, Avenue Circulaire 3, 1180 Uccle, Belgium
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Geologica Belgica in Geologica Belgica
- Vol. 28 (1-2) , 1-23
The 1965–1970 seismic episode in the Hainaut coal basin (Belgium): a key period to analyse the triggered nature of a century-long seismic activity
Damaging earthquakes happened in the Hainaut coal basin (Belgium) in the 19th and 20th centuries but stopped after coal mining. We relocated 54 Hainaut earthquakes of the period 1965 and 1985 by using regional and local seismic phase measurements from recordings in and around Belgium. These new results finalise the Hainaut earthquake catalogue, derived from macroseismic data for the 1887–1965 period and instrumental records after 1965. This updated database allows us to discuss the origin of this intriguing seismicity. Computed focal depths show that the strongest earthquakes before 1985 occurred inside the Upper Palaeozoic part of the Brabant Parautochton, probably below the deepest parts of the coal mines. The shallowness of this seismicity, its spatial link with the coal basin, the compressive to strike-slip focal mechanisms of the stronger earthquakes between 1965 and 1985 and the large quantity of coal mass removal all match with worldwide observations of mining-triggered earthquakes. The earthquake mechanisms agree with the local, compressive to transpressive stress regime derived from differences in upper crustal density and topography that make the Hainaut area more sensitive to fault reactivation at shallow depths, as observed in similar tectonic settings elsewhere in the world.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Geologica Belgica in Geologica Belgica
- Vol. 28 (1-2) , 1-23
Open AccessThe 1965–1970 seismic episode in the Hainaut coal basin (Belgium): a key period to analyse the triggered nature of a century-long seismic activity
Damaging earthquakes happened in the Hainaut coal basin (Belgium) in the 19th and 20th centuries but stopped after coal mining. We relocated 54 Hainaut earthquakes of the period 1965 and 1985 by using regional and local seismic phase measurements from recordings in and around Belgium. These new results finalise the Hainaut earthquake catalogue, derived from macroseismic data for the 1887–1965 period and instrumental records after 1965. This updated database allows us to discuss the origin of this intriguing seismicity. Computed focal depths show that the strongest earthquakes before 1985 occurred inside the Upper Palaeozoic part of the Brabant Parautochton, probably below the deepest parts of the coal mines. The shallowness of this seismicity, its spatial link with the coal basin, the compressive to strike-slip focal mechanisms of the stronger earthquakes between 1965 and 1985 and the large quantity of coal mass removal all match with worldwide observations of mining-triggered earthquakes. The earthquake mechanisms agree with the local, compressive to transpressive stress regime derived from differences in upper crustal density and topography that make the Hainaut area more sensitive to fault reactivation at shallow depths, as observed in similar tectonic settings elsewhere in the world.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 29 (5) , 1005-1036
The Belgian traditional macroseismic (BTM) database of the twentieth century
Macroseismic intensity data have been gathered continuously in Belgium since the start of the twentieth century. In this study, we review the applied survey practices used over the previous century: from small-scale ad-hoc improvised surveys to the mass distribution of collective questionnaire versions sent to local authorities. The variety of survey methodologies causes a high degree of heterogeneity within the resulting macroseismic data, increasing the uncertainty in macroseismic applications that rely on homogeneous data. We thoroughly re-evaluated the original source material and intensity scale conversions in order to create the Belgian Traditional Macroseismic (BTM) database, a comprehensive compilation of 20th-century macroseismic data in which all sources are properly referenced. The BTM database currently consists of 23,950 intensity data points (IDPs) on the European Macroseismic Scale for 80 felt earthquakes, ranging from 2.4 to 5.8 on the local magnitude (M L ) scale. Each IDP is provided with a source type and each earthquake is attributed a data quality parameter that indicates the level of uncertainty associated with its IDP source quality. The publication of the BTM database facilitates the use of Belgian macroseismic data for a variety of seismological purposes and allows us to summarize the overall seismic impact on Belgium for the duration of a century. Like in many other parts of the world, traditional procedures have practically been discontinued in Belgium in favour of an online enquiry. However, the potential for high-quality data following a traditional survey methodology is still large and we strongly recommend its continuation.
- 18 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 29 (5) , 1005-1036
Open AccessThe Belgian traditional macroseismic (BTM) database of the twentieth century
Macroseismic intensity data have been gathered continuously in Belgium since the start of the twentieth century. In this study, we review the applied survey practices used over the previous century: from small-scale ad-hoc improvised surveys to the mass distribution of collective questionnaire versions sent to local authorities. The variety of survey methodologies causes a high degree of heterogeneity within the resulting macroseismic data, increasing the uncertainty in macroseismic applications that rely on homogeneous data. We thoroughly re-evaluated the original source material and intensity scale conversions in order to create the Belgian Traditional Macroseismic (BTM) database, a comprehensive compilation of 20th-century macroseismic data in which all sources are properly referenced. The BTM database currently consists of 23,950 intensity data points (IDPs) on the European Macroseismic Scale for 80 felt earthquakes, ranging from 2.4 to 5.8 on the local magnitude (M L ) scale. Each IDP is provided with a source type and each earthquake is attributed a data quality parameter that indicates the level of uncertainty associated with its IDP source quality. The publication of the BTM database facilitates the use of Belgian macroseismic data for a variety of seismological purposes and allows us to summarize the overall seismic impact on Belgium for the duration of a century. Like in many other parts of the world, traditional procedures have practically been discontinued in Belgium in favour of an online enquiry. However, the potential for high-quality data following a traditional survey methodology is still large and we strongly recommend its continuation.
- Open Access
- 12 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering
- Vol. 22 (10) , 1-25
Testing the applicability of ground motion prediction equations for the Hainaut region (Belgium) using intensity data
In regions where strong earthquakes occurred before the deployment of dense seismic and accelerometric networks, intensity datasets can help select appropriate ground motion prediction equations (GMPEs) for seismic hazard studies. This is the case for the Hainaut seismic zone, which was one of the most seismically active zones in and around Belgium during the twentieth century. A recent reassessment of the intensity dataset of the area showed that intensities in this region attenuate much faster with distance than in other parts of northwestern Europe. Unfortunately, this characteristic has not yet been taken into account in current hazard maps for Belgium and northern France. Based on this dataset, we evaluate the goodness of fit of published GMPEs with intensities in Hainaut by means of a ground-motion-to-intensity conversion equation (GMICE) and according to different metrics (Likelihood, Log-likelihood and Euclidean-based Distance Ranking) published in literature. We also introduce a new measure to specifically evaluate the distance trend. Our results show that none of the tested GMPEs convincingly fits the intensity dataset, in particular the fast attenuation with distance. Nevertheless, applying the few GMPEs that show a reasonable fit in seismic hazard computations, we observe a decrease of the influence of the Hainaut seismicity on hazard maps for Belgium and northern France. This result is compatible with the earthquake intensity observations for the last 350 years in this part of Europe.
- 12 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering
- Vol. 22 (10) , 1-25
Open AccessTesting the applicability of ground motion prediction equations for the Hainaut region (Belgium) using intensity data
In regions where strong earthquakes occurred before the deployment of dense seismic and accelerometric networks, intensity datasets can help select appropriate ground motion prediction equations (GMPEs) for seismic hazard studies. This is the case for the Hainaut seismic zone, which was one of the most seismically active zones in and around Belgium during the twentieth century. A recent reassessment of the intensity dataset of the area showed that intensities in this region attenuate much faster with distance than in other parts of northwestern Europe. Unfortunately, this characteristic has not yet been taken into account in current hazard maps for Belgium and northern France. Based on this dataset, we evaluate the goodness of fit of published GMPEs with intensities in Hainaut by means of a ground-motion-to-intensity conversion equation (GMICE) and according to different metrics (Likelihood, Log-likelihood and Euclidean-based Distance Ranking) published in literature. We also introduce a new measure to specifically evaluate the distance trend. Our results show that none of the tested GMPEs convincingly fits the intensity dataset, in particular the fast attenuation with distance. Nevertheless, applying the few GMPEs that show a reasonable fit in seismic hazard computations, we observe a decrease of the influence of the Hainaut seismicity on hazard maps for Belgium and northern France. This result is compatible with the earthquake intensity observations for the last 350 years in this part of Europe.
- Open Access
- 23 November 2021
- Published by University of Liege in Bulletin de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège
- p. 11-21
The importance of human-induced earthquakes in the seismicity of stable continental regions
Des études récentes suggèrent que la sismicité dans les régions continentales stables (RCS) et les grands tremblements de terre qui y sont associés peuvent être expliqués par l’action de perturbations transitoires des contraintes locales dans la croûte terrestre ou de la résistance des failles au glissement. Dans cet article, nous expliquons pourquoi ces contraintes transitoires joueraient un rôle beaucoup plus fondamental dans l’initiation des grands tremblements de terre en RCS qu’en limite de plaques. Ces modifications de contraintes dans la croûte peuvent être reliées à des phénomènes environnementaux naturels, mais aussi à certains types d’activité humaine. Nous discutons la contribution induite par l’Homme à la sismicité en RCS et défendons l’idée qu’elle est probablement beaucoup plus répandue qu’il n’est généralement admis. Cette hypothèse pose la question de la validité des méthodes d’évaluation de l’aléa sismique en RCS et montre l’importance de mieux comprendre la contribution des séismes induits par l’activité humaine dans la sismicité observée.
- 23 November 2021
- Published by University of Liege in Bulletin de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège
- p. 11-21
Open AccessThe importance of human-induced earthquakes in the seismicity of stable continental regions
Des études récentes suggèrent que la sismicité dans les régions continentales stables (RCS) et les grands tremblements de terre qui y sont associés peuvent être expliqués par l’action de perturbations transitoires des contraintes locales dans la croûte terrestre ou de la résistance des failles au glissement. Dans cet article, nous expliquons pourquoi ces contraintes transitoires joueraient un rôle beaucoup plus fondamental dans l’initiation des grands tremblements de terre en RCS qu’en limite de plaques. Ces modifications de contraintes dans la croûte peuvent être reliées à des phénomènes environnementaux naturels, mais aussi à certains types d’activité humaine. Nous discutons la contribution induite par l’Homme à la sismicité en RCS et défendons l’idée qu’elle est probablement beaucoup plus répandue qu’il n’est généralement admis. Cette hypothèse pose la question de la validité des méthodes d’évaluation de l’aléa sismique en RCS et montre l’importance de mieux comprendre la contribution des séismes induits par l’activité humaine dans la sismicité observée.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-40
Reply on RC3
Shallow, light to moderate magnitude earthquakes in stable continental regions can have a damaging impact on vulnerable surface constructions. In the coal area of the Hainaut province in Belgium, a century of shallow seismic activity occurred from the end of the 19th century until the late 20th century. This seismicity is the second largest source of seismic hazard in northwestern Europe, after the Lower Rhine Embayment. The present study synthesises the impact and damage caused by this unique shallow seismicity. Reviewing intensity data provided in official macroseismic surveys held by the Royal Observatory of Belgium, press reports, and contemporary scientific studies resulted in a complete macroseismic intensity dataset. The strong shaking of five seismic events with moment magnitudes Mw around 4.0, which occurred on 3 June 1911, 3 April 1949, 15 December 1965, 16 January 1966, and 28 March 1967, locally caused widespread moderate damage to buildings corresponding to maximum intensity VII in the EMS-98 scale. For 28 earthquakes, detailed macroseismic maps were created. Our study highlights the capability of shallow, small-magnitude earthquakes to generate damage. Subsequently, using the Hainaut intensity dataset, we modelled a new Hainaut intensity attenuation law and created relationships linking magnitude, epicentral intensity and focal depth. Using these relationships, we estimated the location and magnitude of pre-1985 earthquakes that occurred prior to deployment of the modern digital Belgian seismic network. Estimated focal depths allowed discriminating between two different types of earthquakes. Some events were very shallow, only a few hundred metres deep, suggesting a close link to mining activities. Other earthquakes, including the largest and most damaging events, occurred at depths greater than 2 km but no deeper than 6 km, which would exclude a direct relationship with mining, but yet still might imply a triggering causality. This work results in a new updated earthquake catalogue including 123 seismic events. Our attenuation modelling moreover suggests that current hazard maps overestimated ground motion levels in the Hainaut area due to the use of inadequate ground motion prediction equations. Our Hainaut attenuation model is hence useful to evaluate the potential impact of current and future, e.g. geothermal energy, projects in the Hainaut area and other regions with a similar geological configuration.
- 11 October 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-40
Open AccessReply on RC3
Shallow, light to moderate magnitude earthquakes in stable continental regions can have a damaging impact on vulnerable surface constructions. In the coal area of the Hainaut province in Belgium, a century of shallow seismic activity occurred from the end of the 19th century until the late 20th century. This seismicity is the second largest source of seismic hazard in northwestern Europe, after the Lower Rhine Embayment. The present study synthesises the impact and damage caused by this unique shallow seismicity. Reviewing intensity data provided in official macroseismic surveys held by the Royal Observatory of Belgium, press reports, and contemporary scientific studies resulted in a complete macroseismic intensity dataset. The strong shaking of five seismic events with moment magnitudes Mw around 4.0, which occurred on 3 June 1911, 3 April 1949, 15 December 1965, 16 January 1966, and 28 March 1967, locally caused widespread moderate damage to buildings corresponding to maximum intensity VII in the EMS-98 scale. For 28 earthquakes, detailed macroseismic maps were created. Our study highlights the capability of shallow, small-magnitude earthquakes to generate damage. Subsequently, using the Hainaut intensity dataset, we modelled a new Hainaut intensity attenuation law and created relationships linking magnitude, epicentral intensity and focal depth. Using these relationships, we estimated the location and magnitude of pre-1985 earthquakes that occurred prior to deployment of the modern digital Belgian seismic network. Estimated focal depths allowed discriminating between two different types of earthquakes. Some events were very shallow, only a few hundred metres deep, suggesting a close link to mining activities. Other earthquakes, including the largest and most damaging events, occurred at depths greater than 2 km but no deeper than 6 km, which would exclude a direct relationship with mining, but yet still might imply a triggering causality. This work results in a new updated earthquake catalogue including 123 seismic events. Our attenuation modelling moreover suggests that current hazard maps overestimated ground motion levels in the Hainaut area due to the use of inadequate ground motion prediction equations. Our Hainaut attenuation model is hence useful to evaluate the potential impact of current and future, e.g. geothermal energy, projects in the Hainaut area and other regions with a similar geological configuration.
- 6 December 2017
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 89 (1) , 191-201
A Nineteenth‐Century National Prussian Macroseismic Questionnaire
We recently discovered in the regional record office of North Rhine‐Westphalia (Landesarchiv Nordrhein Westfalen) in Duisburg (Germany) numerous original documents organized and distributed during the nineteenth century by the Prussian authority. These documents constitute a series of completed surveys very similar to present‐day macroseismic questionnaires that were ostensibly used to gather information about felt earthquakes in the Kingdom of Prussia. This article presents an overview of these documents and discusses their importance for broadening the knowledge base of nineteenth‐century earthquakes in this part of Europe. Indeed, for some earthquakes, answers to the questionnaires furnish original historical sources that were never scientifically exploited; for other earthquakes, the surveys formed the basic source of information, utilized but not referenced in two nineteenth‐century scientific studies. Detailed examination of a small sample from these historical documents definitively demonstrates the necessity for a reevaluation of the nineteenth‐century earthquakes.
- 6 December 2017
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 89 (1) , 191-201
A Nineteenth‐Century National Prussian Macroseismic Questionnaire
We recently discovered in the regional record office of North Rhine‐Westphalia (Landesarchiv Nordrhein Westfalen) in Duisburg (Germany) numerous original documents organized and distributed during the nineteenth century by the Prussian authority. These documents constitute a series of completed surveys very similar to present‐day macroseismic questionnaires that were ostensibly used to gather information about felt earthquakes in the Kingdom of Prussia. This article presents an overview of these documents and discusses their importance for broadening the knowledge base of nineteenth‐century earthquakes in this part of Europe. Indeed, for some earthquakes, answers to the questionnaires furnish original historical sources that were never scientifically exploited; for other earthquakes, the surveys formed the basic source of information, utilized but not referenced in two nineteenth‐century scientific studies. Detailed examination of a small sample from these historical documents definitively demonstrates the necessity for a reevaluation of the nineteenth‐century earthquakes.
- Open Access
- 7 August 2013
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 13 (8) , 1983-1997
Comparison of ground motions estimated from prediction equations and from observed damage during the M = 4.6 1983 Liège earthquake (Belgium)
On 8 November 1983 an earthquake of magnitude 4.6 damaged more than 16 000 buildings in the region of Liège (Belgium). The extraordinary damage produced by this earthquake, considering its moderate magnitude, is extremely well documented, giving the opportunity to compare the consequences of a recent moderate earthquake in a typical old city of Western Europe with scenarios obtained by combining strong ground motions and vulnerability modelling. The present study compares 0.3 s spectral accelerations estimated from ground motion prediction equations typically used in Western Europe with those obtained locally by applying the statistical distribution of damaged masonry buildings to two fragility curves, one derived from the HAZUS programme of FEMA (FEMA, 1999) and another developed for high-vulnerability buildings by Lang and Bachmann (2004), and to a method proposed by Faccioli et al. (1999) relating the seismic vulnerability of buildings to the damage and ground motions. The results of this comparison reveal good agreement between maxima spectral accelerations calculated from these vulnerability and fragility curves and those predicted from attenuation law equations, suggesting peak ground accelerations for the epicentral area of the 1983 earthquake of 0.13–0.20 g (g: gravitational acceleration).
- 7 August 2013
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 13 (8) , 1983-1997
Open AccessComparison of ground motions estimated from prediction equations and from observed damage during the M = 4.6 1983 Liège earthquake (Belgium)
On 8 November 1983 an earthquake of magnitude 4.6 damaged more than 16 000 buildings in the region of Liège (Belgium). The extraordinary damage produced by this earthquake, considering its moderate magnitude, is extremely well documented, giving the opportunity to compare the consequences of a recent moderate earthquake in a typical old city of Western Europe with scenarios obtained by combining strong ground motions and vulnerability modelling. The present study compares 0.3 s spectral accelerations estimated from ground motion prediction equations typically used in Western Europe with those obtained locally by applying the statistical distribution of damaged masonry buildings to two fragility curves, one derived from the HAZUS programme of FEMA (FEMA, 1999) and another developed for high-vulnerability buildings by Lang and Bachmann (2004), and to a method proposed by Faccioli et al. (1999) relating the seismic vulnerability of buildings to the damage and ground motions. The results of this comparison reveal good agreement between maxima spectral accelerations calculated from these vulnerability and fragility curves and those predicted from attenuation law equations, suggesting peak ground accelerations for the epicentral area of the 1983 earthquake of 0.13–0.20 g (g: gravitational acceleration).
- Open Access
- 1 December 2001
- Published by Netherlands Journal of Geosciences Foundation in Netherlands Journal of Geosciences
- Vol. 80 (3-4) , 171-185
The Deposition History of the Coversands along the Bree Fault Escarpment, NE Belgium
The coversands along the Bree fault escarpment, NE Belgium, were investigated by a combined dating approach including infrared optically stimulated luminescence (IRSL), thermoluminescence (TL) and radiocarbon methods. Four trenches were excavated cutting the fault scarp near the village of Bree in northeast Belgium. Altogether 17 luminescence samples and seven radiocarbon samples were investigated in order to set up a more reliable and precise chronological frame for the local coversand stratigraphy and the timing of Late Quaternary earthquake events. The chronological results indicate at least five accumulation periods for the coversand units in the area of interest. The oldest coversands were deposited during Saalian or Early Weichselian followed by coversands deposited during the Early and/or Middle Weichselian. At least three coversand units can be distinguished for the time span of the Late Weichselian to Holocene. Significant TL age underestimation of more than 20% compared to IRSL was found for samples from Trench 4. Most of the IRSL age estimates are in agreement with radiocarbon dates from the same section.
- 1 December 2001
- Published by Netherlands Journal of Geosciences Foundation in Netherlands Journal of Geosciences
- Vol. 80 (3-4) , 171-185
Open AccessThe Deposition History of the Coversands along the Bree Fault Escarpment, NE Belgium
The coversands along the Bree fault escarpment, NE Belgium, were investigated by a combined dating approach including infrared optically stimulated luminescence (IRSL), thermoluminescence (TL) and radiocarbon methods. Four trenches were excavated cutting the fault scarp near the village of Bree in northeast Belgium. Altogether 17 luminescence samples and seven radiocarbon samples were investigated in order to set up a more reliable and precise chronological frame for the local coversand stratigraphy and the timing of Late Quaternary earthquake events. The chronological results indicate at least five accumulation periods for the coversand units in the area of interest. The oldest coversands were deposited during Saalian or Early Weichselian followed by coversands deposited during the Early and/or Middle Weichselian. At least three coversand units can be distinguished for the time span of the Late Weichselian to Holocene. Significant TL age underestimation of more than 20% compared to IRSL was found for samples from Trench 4. Most of the IRSL age estimates are in agreement with radiocarbon dates from the same section.