RBRylee Betchkal

Rylee Betchkal

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Rylee Betchkal has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Reconsidering the Need for Technical Standards: Embracing Competency-Based Education in Nursing

    by Brandy Jackson, Rachel Derr, Elizabeth Davis, Dionne DeMille, Serah Nthenge, Kathleen Tilton, Rylee Betchkal, Lisa Meeks

    The use of technical standards has been common in nursing education for 40 years, originating to clarify nonacademic criteria for admission to and completion of nursing programs. However, these standards have a narrow focus, emphasizing physical and sensory abilities, that serves as a gatekeeper and hinders inclusivity. In recent years, competency-based education (CBE) has emerged as the predominant model for determining student competency in nursing education, prompting a reevaluation of technical standards. This commentary examines the continued use of technical standards in nursing education, questioning both their perceived value and necessity. The authors argue that CBE offers a more precise and less biased means of assessing readiness for practice. By replacing outdated, ableist, technical standards with outcomes-based frameworks nursing education is better positioned to cultivate a diverse workforce.


  • Standardized Language for Clinical Accommodations in U.S. Undergraduate Medical Training: Results From a National Modified Delphi Consensus Study

    by Zainub Dhanani, Suchita Rastogi, Matthew Sullivan, Rylee Ma Betchkal, Peter Poullos, Lisa M. PhD Meeks

    Purpose: Limited guidance on and access to clinical accommodations pose significant barriers to disabled learners’ full participation in medical education. The lack of standardized accommodation language and institutional expertise leads to inconsistent implementation, creating barriers for medical students. This study aimed to establish consensus-based, standardized language for clinical accommodations to improve clarity, consistency, and accessibility for learners with disabilities in U.S. medical schools. Method: A modified Delphi approach was employed to achieve consensus on clinical accommodation language. A committee of 9 disability resource professionals (DRPs) compiled a list of 271 accommodations, which were refined to 89 unique accommodations after eliminating redundancies. These were categorized into 6 domains: adaptive equipment, assistive technology, communication access, location, individualized adjustment/need, and scheduling. Two groups (disability inclusion experts and clinical-phase medical students with lived disability experience) engaged in 4 Delphi rounds between October 2024 and February 2025. Consensus was defined a priori as 80% agreement on accommodation language. Results: In Round 1, none of the accommodations met the 80% consensus threshold. Revisions were made, reducing the list to 75 accommodations for Round 2, where 65 accommodations met the threshold. In Round 3, 9 additional accommodations achieved consensus, leaving 1 accommodation for final revision in Round 4, after which complete consensus was reached. The outcome was a list of 75 vetted clinical accommodations with standardized accommodation language. Conclusions: The study produced a consensus-based list of clinical accommodations to educate and empower students, faculty, and DRPs. By standardizing the language used in accommodations, this work seeks to promote accessibility and advance equity within medical education. Future research should explore the effectiveness and feasibility of implementing these accommodations in clinical settings. Additional efforts should include expanding the guidance to DO-granting institutions, incorporating faculty perspectives, and evaluating the long-term impact of standardized accommodation language on clinical training outcomes.


  • Advancing Disability Equity and Inclusion in Undergraduate Medical Education: Proceedings From the Access in Medicine Summit

    by Maggie Md Salinger, Mytien Nguyen, Allison Kessler, Sarah E. Triano, Rylee Betchkal, Emily C. Cleveland Manchanda, Pilar Md Ortega, Zoie C. Sheets, Nalinda Charnsangavej, Christine Msw Low, et al.

    The Access in Medicine (AIM) Summit, held in April 2024, convened 60 delegates from across the United States to generate practicable solutions for dismantling accessibility barriers in medical education. These proceedings outline the Summit’s objectives and present the resulting insights and actionable recommendations. The Summit featured an innovative design that engaged diverse delegates in collaborative, idea-generating activities that elevated the lived experiences of learners with disabilities. Inspired by guiding principles of social justice and accessibility, delegates recommended a bundle of action-oriented strategies for addressing social and structural barriers to disability equity and inclusion. The proposed action steps identified critical intervention points that span the continuum of undergraduate medical education, from improving support of disabled learners in recruitment and admissions processes through to their residency application and postgraduation transition stages. Though medical education was the AIM Summit focus, delegates emphasized the generalizability of themes to broad training contexts (e.g., residency and other health professions education training), both in the sociostructural challenges they confronted and in the solutions they proposed. These proceedings highlight the vital steps necessary to build more equitable and inclusive learning environments for learners with disabilities.


  • Timing of Disability Diagnosis and Accommodations During Medical School by First-Generation Status, Race, Ethnicity, and Gender

    by Mytien Nguyen, Charlene K. PsyD Green, Hyacinth R.C. PhD Mason, Karina PhD Pereira-Lima, Zoie C. Sheets, Samantha L. Schroth, Lydia Smeltz, Christopher J. Moreland, Rylee Ma Betchkal, Christina Growbowski, et al.

    Purpose: Timely diagnosis of disability is essential to student success. This study assesses the association between disability type; first-generation college graduate status; and race, ethnicity, and gender and the timing of disability diagnosis among medical students, and whether the timing of diagnosis is associated with likelihood of receiving accommodations in the preclinical and clinical phases of medical training. Method: The authors conducted a retrospective cohort study between April 2023–April 2024 across 9 U.S. MD-granting programs. Data were obtained from individual student records in collaboration with administrators and designated staff who support students with disability-related concerns and accommodation requests. Modified Poisson regression was utilized to estimate the relative risk of diagnosis timing after matriculation and preclinical and clinical accommodations to account for potential variability across schools. Results: Among the 362 medical students in the study, 167 (46.1%) were diagnosed after medical school matriculation. Compared to continuing-generation students, first-generation college graduates were significantly more likely to have a disability diagnosis after medical school matriculation (59.0% vs 43.2%; aIRR, 1.33; 95% CI, 1.01–1.77). Across all racial and ethnic groups, Black students were significantly more likely to be diagnosed after matriculation compared to their White peers (66.6% vs 41.5%; aIRR, 1.58; 95% CI, 1.21–2.06). Female students were less likely to be diagnosed with a disability after matriculation (aIRR, 0.85; 95% CI, 0.73–0.98). Overall, 232 (64.1%) and 284 (78.4%) participants received preclinical and clinical accommodations, respectively. Students who received a disability diagnosis before medical school matriculation were significantly more likely to receive preclinical accommodations (79.4%) compared to those diagnosed after matriculation (46.1%; aIRR, 0.60; 95% CI, 0.50–0.72). No significant association was found between timing of diagnosis and clinical accommodations. Conclusions: This study highlights the challenges medical students with disabilities face in requesting accommodation, particularly for those who are diagnosed after medical school matriculation.


  • Compounded Challenges: The Impact of Race and Disability on Leave of Absence and Time to Graduation During Undergraduate Medical Education

    by William H. Eidtson, Mytien Nguyen, Tiffany M. Med Hodgens, Karina PhD Pereira-Lima, Tonya L. Fancher, Zoie C. Sheets, Lydia Smeltz, Suchita Rastogi, Raymond H. Curry, Sharad Jain, et al.

    Purpose: Medical students with disabilities (MSWD) from racial and ethnic populations that are underrepresented in medicine (URiM) may experience disparate educational paths compared to their peers, including disruption during training. This study examined whether MSWD who are also URiM experienced disproportionate rates of unintended leaves of absence (LOA) or extended time to graduation (TTG) compared to those who are only URiM, only MSWD, or neither. Method: The authors analyzed data from 372 MSWD and 689 matched nondisabled controls across 9 U.S. MD-granting programs. Students were matched by gender, graduation cohort, and Medical College Admission Test scores. MSWD were categorized into cognitive, physical/sensory, and chronic health disabilities, while race/ethnicity was classified as underrepresented in medicine (e.g., American Indian/Alaska Native, Black/African American, Hispanic/Latino, or Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander), Asian, or White. Likelihood of LOA and extended TTG outcomes were assessed using mixed-effect logistic regression models. Results: MSWD were 2.6 times more likely to take an LOA (25.0% vs 12.6%, P < .001) and 2.6 times more likely to have extended TTG than nondisabled peers (38.6% vs 21.9%, P < .001). URiM students were 1.7 times more likely to take an LOA (22.9% vs 15.3%, P = .01) and 2.1 times more likely to experience extended TTG than White students (36.2% vs 22.5%, P < .001). Adjusted analysis showed URiM MSWD were 5.9 times more likely to take an LOA (40.6% vs 13.4%, P < .001) and 4.9 times more likely to experience extended TTG than nondisabled White peers (56.4% vs 28.7%, P < .001). Conclusions: URiM MSWD faced disproportionately heightened risks for academic disruptions in the form of LOA and extended TTG, underscoring the need for interventions that are more supportive of students with overlapping identities.


  • Open Access

    The Role, Challenges, and Employment Characteristics of Disability Resource Professionals in Medical Education: A National Study

    by Erin Broskowski, Sarah E. Triano, Kara James, Rylee Betchkal, Karyn LaTurner Echols, Suzanne Hawks, Ochanya Ogah, Mytien Nguyen, Lisa M. Meeks

    Background: Disability disclosure and accommodation requests among US medical students have increased significantly, yet gaps in support persist. Disability resource professionals (DRPs) are one essential support in bridging these gaps, but only 9% of medical schools employ a dedicated DRP, leaving institutions potentially underprepared to address the needs of students with disabilities. Objective: This study explored the roles, qualifications, and challenges of DRPs in US medical schools to identify barriers to job performance and inform strategies for strengthening and supporting this role in medical education. Methods: An exploratory, cross-sectional survey was conducted in July to August 2023. A 27-question online survey was distributed through convenience and snowball strategy via social media and listservs. Questions addressed institutional structures, the size of DRP student caseloads, job satisfaction, mentorship, and barriers to managing caseloads. Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and χ 2 tests, qualitative responses were thematically analyzed. The University of Michigan IRB approved this study. Results: Seventy-nine DRPs from 72 US MD and 7 DO programs participated. Most respondents reported excessive workloads, with 30% managing caseloads exceeding 100 students. Less than half of DRPs (45.6%) indicated that their workload was manageable. Inadequate professional development, lack of mentorship, and low salary satisfaction emerged as common challenges. Respondents also reported institutional barriers, including stigma, faculty resistance to accommodations, and the complexity of coordinating disability accommodations across didactic, clinical, and testing environments. Discussion: DRPs are critical to fostering accessible and inclusive medical education, yet systemic barriers undermine their effectiveness and place institutions at risk of increased student attrition, legal liability, and resource strain. Addressing these challenges requires investments in manageable caseloads, professional development for DRPs, faculty training, and institutional prioritization of the DRP role. Conclusions: Systemic investments in staffing, training, and institutional culture are necessary to support DRPs and the growing population of US medical students with disabilities (MSWDs).


  • Informed Inclusion Model: Medical Student Wheelchair User in an Obstetrics and Gynecology Clerkship

    by Diane Brown-Young, Theresa A Papich, Stacie Jhaveri, Craig Nielsen, Marcy Med Pardee, Rylee Betchkal, Eboni Med Porter, Lisa M. PhD Meeks

    Students with physical disabilities are underrepresented in medicine, driven in part by ableist beliefs about the ability of individuals with disabilities to complete procedure-based or surgically oriented clerkships, including obstetrics and gynecology (Ob/Gyn). There is a growing commitment to disability inclusion by medical and specialty training associations. Yet published case studies and accommodation protocols for medical student wheelchair users navigating an Ob/Gyn clerkship are absent in the literature. This article describes successful disability inclusion for an Ob/Gyn clerkship, including accommodations for medical student wheelchair users. The authors share mechanisms to address and combat ableist assumptions and facilitate access for future medical students by working collaboratively with student and key stakeholders to develop an inclusive and accessible training experience. These recommendations are shared through the story of a third-year medical student who rotated through the longitudinal clerkships at the Cleveland Clinic Lerner College of Medicine. The student, an individual with osteogenesis imperfecta who uses a power wheelchair with a seat elevator, completed third-year rotations and thrived in her clinical experiences. The authors describe her journey through a robust 4-week Ob/Gyn clerkship, in which she fulfilled the required clinical core conditions and observation skills with reasonable accommodation. Given the high acuity, surgery, and outpatient demands in Ob/Gyn—and the transferrable skills to other clerkships—the student’s experience is an excellent exemplar for demonstrating disability inclusion and reasonable accommodation. Ob/Gyn clerkship directors and clinical faculty can broadly use the recommended timelines and communication protocols to create accessible training environments. With student input, minor scheduling adjustments, ongoing communication, reasonable accommodations, and an open mind, medical students on the clinical wards who are wheelchair users can successfully navigate the required expectations of medical training.