Sultan Büşra Ay Kartbak
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Sultan Büşra Ay Kartbak has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mehmet Birol Özel
Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Kocaeli University, Kocaeli 41190, Türkiye
3 shared publications - Muhammet Çakmak
Faculty of Engineering, Department of Computer Engineering Giresun University Giresun Türkiye
3 shared publications - Duygu Nur Cesur Kocakaya
Private Practice, Gölcük 41650, Türkiye
2 shared publications - Alper Sinanoglu
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Faculty of Dentistry, Kocaeli University, Kocaeli 41190, Türkiye
1 shared publication - Enver Alper Sinanoğlu
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Faculty of Dentistry, Kocaeli University, Kocaeli, Turkey
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 15 (17) , 2240
Classification Performance of Deep Learning Models for the Assessment of Vertical Dimension on Lateral Cephalometric Radiographs
Background/Objectives: Vertical growth pattern significantly influences facial aesthetics and treatment choices. Lateral cephalograms are routinely used for the evaluation of vertical jaw relationships in orthodontic diagnosis. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of deep learning algorithms in classifying cephalometric radiographs according to vertical skeletal growth patterns without the need for anatomical landmark identification. Methods: This study was carried out on lateral cephalometric radiographs of 1050 patients. Cephalometric radiographs were divided into 3 subgroups based on FMA, SN-GoGn, and Cant of Occlusal Plane angles. Six deep learning models (ResNet101, DenseNet 201, EfficientNet B0, EfficientNet V2 B0, ConvNetBase, and a hybrid model) were employed for the classification of the dataset. The performances of the well-known deep learning models and the hybrid model were compared for accuracy, precision, F1-Score, mean absolute error, Cohen’s Kappa, and Grad-CAM metrics. Results: The highest accuracy rates were achieved by the Hybrid Model with 86.67% for FMA groups, 87.29% for SN-GoGn groups, and 82.71% for Cant of Occlusal Plane groups. The lowest accuracy rates were achieved by ConvNet with 79.58% for FMA groups, 65% for SN-GoGn, and 70.21% for Cant of Occlusal Plane groups. Conclusions: The six deep learning algorithms employed demonstrated classification success rates ranging from 65% to 87.29%. The highest classification accuracy was observed in the FMA angle, while the lowest accuracy was recorded for the Cant of the Occlusal Plane angle. The proposed DL algorithms showed potential for direct skeletal orthodontic diagnosis without the need for cephalometric landmark detection steps.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 15 (17) , 2240
Open AccessClassification Performance of Deep Learning Models for the Assessment of Vertical Dimension on Lateral Cephalometric Radiographs
Background/Objectives: Vertical growth pattern significantly influences facial aesthetics and treatment choices. Lateral cephalograms are routinely used for the evaluation of vertical jaw relationships in orthodontic diagnosis. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of deep learning algorithms in classifying cephalometric radiographs according to vertical skeletal growth patterns without the need for anatomical landmark identification. Methods: This study was carried out on lateral cephalometric radiographs of 1050 patients. Cephalometric radiographs were divided into 3 subgroups based on FMA, SN-GoGn, and Cant of Occlusal Plane angles. Six deep learning models (ResNet101, DenseNet 201, EfficientNet B0, EfficientNet V2 B0, ConvNetBase, and a hybrid model) were employed for the classification of the dataset. The performances of the well-known deep learning models and the hybrid model were compared for accuracy, precision, F1-Score, mean absolute error, Cohen’s Kappa, and Grad-CAM metrics. Results: The highest accuracy rates were achieved by the Hybrid Model with 86.67% for FMA groups, 87.29% for SN-GoGn groups, and 82.71% for Cant of Occlusal Plane groups. The lowest accuracy rates were achieved by ConvNet with 79.58% for FMA groups, 65% for SN-GoGn, and 70.21% for Cant of Occlusal Plane groups. Conclusions: The six deep learning algorithms employed demonstrated classification success rates ranging from 65% to 87.29%. The highest classification accuracy was observed in the FMA angle, while the lowest accuracy was recorded for the Cant of the Occlusal Plane angle. The proposed DL algorithms showed potential for direct skeletal orthodontic diagnosis without the need for cephalometric landmark detection steps.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 15 (9) , 1059
Classification of Intraoral Photographs with Deep Learning Algorithms Trained According to Cephalometric Measurements
Background/Objectives: Clinical intraoral photographs are important for orthodontic diagnosis, treatment planning, and documentation. This study aimed to evaluate deep learning algorithms trained utilizing actual cephalometric measurements for the classification of intraoral clinical photographs. Methods: This study was executed on lateral cephalograms and intraoral right-side images of 990 patients. IMPA, interincisal angle, U1–palatal plane angle, and Wits appraisal values were measured utilizing WebCeph. Intraoral photographs were divided into three groups based on cephalometric measurements. A total of 14 deep learning models (DenseNet 121, DenseNet 169, DenseNet 201, EfficientNet B0, EfficientNet V2, Inception V3, MobileNet V2, NasNetMobile, ResNet101, ResNet152, ResNet50, VGG16, VGG19, and Xception) were employed to classify the intraoral photographs. Performance metrics (F1 scores, accuracy, precision, and recall) were calculated and confusion matrices were formed. Results: The highest accuracy rates were 98.33% for IMPA groups, 99.00% for interincisal angle groups, 96.67% for U1–palatal plane angle groups, and 98.33% for Wits measurement groups. Lowest accuracy rates were 59% for IMPA groups, 53% for interincisal angle groups, 33.33% for U1–palatal plane angle groups, and 83.67% for Wits measurement groups. Conclusions: Although accuracy rates varied among classifications and DL algorithms, successful classification could be achieved in the majority of cases. Our results may be promising for case classification and analysis without the need for lateral cephalometric radiographs.
- 22 April 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 15 (9) , 1059
Open AccessClassification of Intraoral Photographs with Deep Learning Algorithms Trained According to Cephalometric Measurements
Background/Objectives: Clinical intraoral photographs are important for orthodontic diagnosis, treatment planning, and documentation. This study aimed to evaluate deep learning algorithms trained utilizing actual cephalometric measurements for the classification of intraoral clinical photographs. Methods: This study was executed on lateral cephalograms and intraoral right-side images of 990 patients. IMPA, interincisal angle, U1–palatal plane angle, and Wits appraisal values were measured utilizing WebCeph. Intraoral photographs were divided into three groups based on cephalometric measurements. A total of 14 deep learning models (DenseNet 121, DenseNet 169, DenseNet 201, EfficientNet B0, EfficientNet V2, Inception V3, MobileNet V2, NasNetMobile, ResNet101, ResNet152, ResNet50, VGG16, VGG19, and Xception) were employed to classify the intraoral photographs. Performance metrics (F1 scores, accuracy, precision, and recall) were calculated and confusion matrices were formed. Results: The highest accuracy rates were 98.33% for IMPA groups, 99.00% for interincisal angle groups, 96.67% for U1–palatal plane angle groups, and 98.33% for Wits measurement groups. Lowest accuracy rates were 59% for IMPA groups, 53% for interincisal angle groups, 33.33% for U1–palatal plane angle groups, and 83.67% for Wits measurement groups. Conclusions: Although accuracy rates varied among classifications and DL algorithms, successful classification could be achieved in the majority of cases. Our results may be promising for case classification and analysis without the need for lateral cephalometric radiographs.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 14 (17) , 1916
Profile Photograph Classification Performance of Deep Learning Algorithms Trained Using Cephalometric Measurements: A Preliminary Study
Extraoral profile photographs are crucial for orthodontic diagnosis, documentation, and treatment planning. The purpose of this study was to evaluate classifications made on extraoral patient photographs by deep learning algorithms trained using grouped patient pictures based on cephalometric measurements. Cephalometric radiographs and profile photographs of 990 patients from the archives of Kocaeli University Faculty of Dentistry Department of Orthodontics were used for the study. FH-NA, FH-NPog, FMA and N-A-Pog measurements on patient cephalometric radiographs were carried out utilizing Webceph. 3 groups for every parameter were formed according to cephalometric values. Deep learning algorithms were trained using extraoral photographs of the patients which were grouped according to respective cephalometric measurements. 14 deep learning models were trained and tested for accuracy of prediction in classifying patient images. Accuracy rates of up to 96.67% for FH-NA groups, 97.33% for FH-NPog groups, 97.67% for FMA groups and 97.00% for N-A-Pog groups were obtained. This is a pioneering study where an attempt was made to classify clinical photographs using artificial intelligence architectures that were trained according to actual cephalometric values, thus eliminating or reducing the need for cephalometric X-rays in future applications for orthodontic diagnosis.
- 30 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Diagnostics
- Vol. 14 (17) , 1916
Open AccessProfile Photograph Classification Performance of Deep Learning Algorithms Trained Using Cephalometric Measurements: A Preliminary Study
Extraoral profile photographs are crucial for orthodontic diagnosis, documentation, and treatment planning. The purpose of this study was to evaluate classifications made on extraoral patient photographs by deep learning algorithms trained using grouped patient pictures based on cephalometric measurements. Cephalometric radiographs and profile photographs of 990 patients from the archives of Kocaeli University Faculty of Dentistry Department of Orthodontics were used for the study. FH-NA, FH-NPog, FMA and N-A-Pog measurements on patient cephalometric radiographs were carried out utilizing Webceph. 3 groups for every parameter were formed according to cephalometric values. Deep learning algorithms were trained using extraoral photographs of the patients which were grouped according to respective cephalometric measurements. 14 deep learning models were trained and tested for accuracy of prediction in classifying patient images. Accuracy rates of up to 96.67% for FH-NA groups, 97.33% for FH-NPog groups, 97.67% for FMA groups and 97.00% for N-A-Pog groups were obtained. This is a pioneering study where an attempt was made to classify clinical photographs using artificial intelligence architectures that were trained according to actual cephalometric values, thus eliminating or reducing the need for cephalometric X-rays in future applications for orthodontic diagnosis.