Ryan Mohamadi

We analyzed the transcriptome data of wildtype and estrogen receptor β knockout (Erβ^KO) rat ovaries during the early postnatal period and detected remarkable changes in epigenetic regulators and transcription factors. Compared with postnatal day (PD) 4.5 ovaries, PD 6.5 wildtype ovaries possessed 581 differentially expressed downstream transcripts (DEDTs), including 17 differentially expressed epigenetic regulators (DEERs) and 23 differentially expressed transcription factors (DETFs). Subsequently, compared with PD 6.5 ovaries, PD 8.5 wildtype ovaries showed 920 DEDTs, including 24 DEERs and 68 DETFs. The DEDTs, DEERs, and DETFs in wildtype ovaries represented the gene expression during primordial follicle activation and the gradual development of primary follicles of first-wave origin because the second-wave follicles remained dormant during this developmental period. When we compared the transcriptome data of age-matched Erβ^KO ovaries, we observed that PD 6.5 Erβ^KO ovaries had 744 DEDTs compared with PD 4.5 ovaries, including 46 DEERs and 55 DETFs. The loss of ERβ rapidly activated the primordial follicles of both first- and second-wave origin on PD 6.5 and showed a remarkable increase in DEDTs (744 vs. 581). However, compared with PD 6.5 ovaries, PD 8.5 Erβ^KO ovaries showed only 191 DEDTs, including 8 DEERs and 10 DETFs. This finding suggests that the PD 8.5 Erβ^KO ovaries did not undergo remarkable ovarian follicle activation greater than that had already occurred in PD 6.5 Erβ^KO ovaries. The results also showed that the numbers of DEERs and DETFs were associated with increased changes in DEDTs; the greater the number of DEERs or DETFs, the larger the number of DEDTs. In addition to the quantitative differences in DEERs and DETFs between the wildtype and Erβ^KO ovaries, the differentially expressed regulators showed distinct patterns. We identified that 17 transcripts were tied to follicle assembly, 6 to follicle activation, and 12 to steroidogenesis. Our observations indicate that a loss of ERβ dysregulates the epigenetic regulators and transcription factors in Erβ^KO ovaries, which disrupts the downstream genes in ovarian follicles and increases follicle activation. Further studies are required to clarify if ERβ directly or indirectly regulates DEDTs, including DEERs and DETFs, during the neonatal development of rat ovarian follicles.

RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) has become a widely adopted technique for studying gene expression. However, conventional RNA-Seq analyses rely on gene expression (GE) values that aggregate all the transcripts produced under a single gene identifier, overlooking the complexity of transcript variants arising from different transcription start sites or alternative splicing. Transcript variants may encode proteins with diverse functional domains, or noncoding RNAs. This study explored the implications of neglecting transcript variants in RNA-Seq analyses. Among the 1334 transcription factor (TF) genes expressed in mouse embryonic stem (ES) or trophoblast stem (TS) cells, 652 were differentially expressed in TS cells based on GE values (365 upregulated and 287 downregulated, ≥absolute 2-fold changes, false discovery rate (FDR) p-value ≤ 0.05). The 365 upregulated genes expressed 883 transcript variants. Further transcript expression (TE) based analyses identified only 174 ( 0.05) between ES and TS cells expressed 2215 transcript variants. These included 477 (>21%) differentially expressed transcripts (276 upregulated and 201 downregulated, ≥absolute 2-fold changes, FDR p-value ≤ 0.05). Hence, GE based RNA-Seq analyses do not represent accurate expression levels due to divergent transcripts expression from the same gene. Our findings show that by including transcript variants in RNA-Seq analyses, we can generate a precise understanding of a gene’s functional and regulatory landscape; ignoring the variants may result in an erroneous interpretation.

We analyzed the transcriptome of wildtype and estrogen receptor β knockout (Erβ ^KO ) rat ovaries during the early postnatal period and detected remarkable changes in epigenetic regulators and transcription factors. Compared to postnatal day (PD) 4.5 wildtype ovaries, 17 differentially expressed epigenetic regulators (DEERs), and 23 differentially expressed transcription factors (DETFs) were detected in PD6.5 wildtype ovaries. Subsequently, compared to PD 6.5 wildtype ovaries, 24 DEERs and 68 DETFs were detected in PD8.5 ovaries. Changes in DEERs and DEFTs resulted in 581 differentially expressed downstream genes (DEDGs) in PD6.5 and 920 DEDGs in wildtype PD8.5 ovaries. The DEERs, DETFs, and DEDGs in wildtype ovaries represented primordial follicle activation (PFA) and development of the first-wave follicles because the second-wave follicles remain dormant during this period. However, the changes in DEERs, DETFs, and DEDGs during this postnatal period were markedly different in Erβ ^KO rat ovaries, which suffered from increased PFA in both waves. Compared to 17 DEERs and 23 DETFs in wildtype, 46 DEERs and 55 DETFs were identified in PD 6.5 Erβ ^KO ovaries. The differences were more remarkable in PD 8.5 Erβ ^KO ovaries; compared to 24 DEERS and 68 DETFs in wildtype, only 8 DEERs and 10 DETFs were detected in Erβ ^KO ovaries. Such dysregulation resulted in altered DEDGs in PD 6.5 (581 vs. 744) and in PD8.5 (920 vs. 191) Erβ ^KO ovaries. These findings also suggest that the number of DEDGs depends directly on the numbers of DEERS and DETFs. In addition to the quantitative differences in DEERs and DETFs between the wildtype and Erβ ^KO ovaries, we detected distinct differences in the identities of the regulators. Our observations indicate that loss of ERβ dysregulates the epigenetic regulators and transcription factors in Erβ ^KO ovaries, which disrupts the downstream genes in ovarian follicles and increases follicle activation.

RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) has become a widely adopted genome-wide technique for investigating gene expression patterns. However, conventional RNA-Seq analyses typically rely on gene expression (GE) values that aggregate all the transcripts produced by a gene under a single identifier, overlooking the complexity of transcript variants arising from different transcription start sites and alternative splicing events. In this study, we explored the implications of neglecting transcript variants in RNA-Seq analyses. Among the 1334 transcription factor (TF) genes expressed in mouse embryonic stem (ES) or trophoblast stem (TS) cells, 652 were reported to be differentially expressed in TS cells based on GE values (365 upregulated and 287 downregulated, ≥2-fold, FDR p -value ≤0.05). Intriguingly, differential gene expression analysis revealed that of the 365 upregulated genes, 883 transcript variants were expressed, with only 174 (80%) variants were either down-regulated or showed no significant change in expression analysis. Similarly, the 287 genes reported to be downregulated expressed 856 transcript variants, with only 153 (82%) variants that were upregulated or showed no significant changes. Additionally, the 682 TF genes that did not show significant changes between ES and TS cells (GE values < 2-fold changes and/or FDR p-values >0.05) expressed 2215 transcript variants, which included 477 (>21%) that were differentially expressed (276 upregulated and 201 downregulated, ≥2-fold, FDR p-value ≤0.05). Notably, a particular gene does not express just one protein; rather its transcript variants encode multiple proteins with distinct functional domains, including non-coding regulatory RNAs. Our findings underscore the critical necessity of considering transcript variants in RNA-Seq analyses. Doing so may enable a more precise understanding of the intricate functional and regulatory landscape of genes; ignoring the variants may result in an erroneous interpretation. Graphic Differential expression of transcription factors (TFs) between mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells and trophoblast stem (TS) cells. This graphic presentation clearly demonstrates the importance of including transcript variants during RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) analyses. Panel A represents the conventional differential gene expression analysis approach after RNA-Seq, where all transcript reads are taken under a single gene name. Panel B takes differential gene expression analysis one step further by examining all the transcript variants that were previously hidden under the main gene name. Our results indicate that exclusive gene expression (GE) analysis inaccurately defines over 80% of the transcript expression (TE). Without analyses of all the transcript variants’ reads, we fail to uncover the functional importance of the variants and the regulation of their expression. Both GE and TE values are expressed as transcript per million (TPM). Data analyses were performed by using CLC Genomics Workbench.