Sophie Charlotte Bauditz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Sophie Charlotte Bauditz has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Ursula Hess
Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
5 shared publicationsMatthias Ziegler
4 shared publications- Aidan G. C. Wright
Department of Psychology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA
3 shared publications - Matthias Ziegler
Department of Psychology, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Berlin, Germany
3 shared publications - Fabian Gander
University of Basel
2 shared publications Aidan Gc Wright
Department of Psychology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Psychological Test Adaptation and Development
- Vol. 7, 228-238
The Reliability-First Myth in Item Selection – Why Item Difficulty Matters
Psychological tests are commonly evaluated using internal consistency, indexed by Cronbach's α. This emphasis fosters the assumption that maximizing α is sufficient for building useful scales – a position we call the reliability-first myth. The present study illustrates a known but practically important implication of classical test theory: reliability does not uniquely determine how well observed scores support individual-level interpretation. Using a Monte Carlo simulation within a tau-congeneric framework, we varied item-difficulty composition, test length, number of response categories, and mean factor loading. Differentiation was operationalized using the Critical Difference (CD). Response-category count, item-difficulty composition, and test length explained substantial variation in CD, whereas achieved α contributed little unique value. Extreme-difficulty sets yielded the smallest CDs but only by compressing observed-score variance. Mixed-difficulty sets cover the trait more broadly without losing precision. Reliability is therefore necessary but not sufficient for individual-level interpretation.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Psychological Test Adaptation and Development
- Vol. 7, 228-238
Open AccessThe Reliability-First Myth in Item Selection – Why Item Difficulty Matters
Psychological tests are commonly evaluated using internal consistency, indexed by Cronbach's α. This emphasis fosters the assumption that maximizing α is sufficient for building useful scales – a position we call the reliability-first myth. The present study illustrates a known but practically important implication of classical test theory: reliability does not uniquely determine how well observed scores support individual-level interpretation. Using a Monte Carlo simulation within a tau-congeneric framework, we varied item-difficulty composition, test length, number of response categories, and mean factor loading. Differentiation was operationalized using the Critical Difference (CD). Response-category count, item-difficulty composition, and test length explained substantial variation in CD, whereas achieved α contributed little unique value. Extreme-difficulty sets yielded the smallest CDs but only by compressing observed-score variance. Mixed-difficulty sets cover the trait more broadly without losing precision. Reliability is therefore necessary but not sufficient for individual-level interpretation.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1309-1332
Construal and Contact in Person–Situation Relations: Evidence from Controlled and Naturalistic Designs
Personality is increasingly viewed as a dynamic system arising from the interaction between individuals and their situations. Yet, in naturalistic data, within-person links between personality states and situation perceptions often conflate two distinct mechanisms: situation contact—what people objectively encounter—and situation construal—how they interpret these encounters. To disentangle these components, we combined two longitudinal approaches: a standardized laboratory study (N = 189) in which situation contact was held largely constant, and a naturalistic experience-sampling study (N = 1,596) capturing the diversity of everyday contexts. Multilevel models revealed meaningful within-person covariation between Big Five states and situation perceptions in both designs, with effect sizes that were small to medium in magnitude and theoretically coherent across both settings. However, in the naturalistic study, person–situation associations varied systematically across situation cues—social partner, location, and activity—with some associations shifting in magnitude or reversing direction depending on the context. Together, these findings suggest that construal is a primary driver of person–situation associations, but that situation contact shapes which associations emerge, to what degree, and across which situation perception dimensions. Accounting for situation contact may therefore help to more accurately capture personality as a context-sensitive, dynamic system.
- 22 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1309-1332
Open AccessConstrual and Contact in Person–Situation Relations: Evidence from Controlled and Naturalistic Designs
Personality is increasingly viewed as a dynamic system arising from the interaction between individuals and their situations. Yet, in naturalistic data, within-person links between personality states and situation perceptions often conflate two distinct mechanisms: situation contact—what people objectively encounter—and situation construal—how they interpret these encounters. To disentangle these components, we combined two longitudinal approaches: a standardized laboratory study (N = 189) in which situation contact was held largely constant, and a naturalistic experience-sampling study (N = 1,596) capturing the diversity of everyday contexts. Multilevel models revealed meaningful within-person covariation between Big Five states and situation perceptions in both designs, with effect sizes that were small to medium in magnitude and theoretically coherent across both settings. However, in the naturalistic study, person–situation associations varied systematically across situation cues—social partner, location, and activity—with some associations shifting in magnitude or reversing direction depending on the context. Together, these findings suggest that construal is a primary driver of person–situation associations, but that situation contact shapes which associations emerge, to what degree, and across which situation perception dimensions. Accounting for situation contact may therefore help to more accurately capture personality as a context-sensitive, dynamic system.
- Open Access
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Construal and Contact in Person–Situation Relations: Evidence from Controlled and Naturalistic Designs
Personality is increasingly viewed as a dynamic system arising from the interaction between individuals and their situations. Yet, in naturalistic data, within-person links between personality states and situation perceptions often conflate two distinct mechanisms: situation contact—what people objectively encounter—and situation construal—how they interpret these encounters. To disentangle these components, we combined two longitudinal approaches: a standardized laboratory study (N = 189) in which situation contact was held largely constant, and a naturalistic experience-sampling study (N = 1,596) capturing the diversity of everyday contexts. Multilevel models revealed meaningful within-person covariation between Big Five states and situation perceptions in both designs. Cross-study comparison of standardized effect sizes confirmed broad replication, yet revealed dimension-specific divergence: Duty and Mating showed pronounced differences across designs, whereas dimensions such as Positivity and Negativity replicated closely. In the naturalistic study, person–situation associations varied systematically across situation cues — social partner, location, and activity — with some associations reversing direction depending on the situation contact. Together, these findings demonstrate that situation contact shapes which person–situation associations emerge and to what degree, and that its influence differs meaningfully across psychological situation dimensions. Incorporating situational context into experience-sampling research is therefore essential for accurately capturing personality as a context-sensitive, dynamic system.
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessConstrual and Contact in Person–Situation Relations: Evidence from Controlled and Naturalistic Designs
Personality is increasingly viewed as a dynamic system arising from the interaction between individuals and their situations. Yet, in naturalistic data, within-person links between personality states and situation perceptions often conflate two distinct mechanisms: situation contact—what people objectively encounter—and situation construal—how they interpret these encounters. To disentangle these components, we combined two longitudinal approaches: a standardized laboratory study (N = 189) in which situation contact was held largely constant, and a naturalistic experience-sampling study (N = 1,596) capturing the diversity of everyday contexts. Multilevel models revealed meaningful within-person covariation between Big Five states and situation perceptions in both designs. Cross-study comparison of standardized effect sizes confirmed broad replication, yet revealed dimension-specific divergence: Duty and Mating showed pronounced differences across designs, whereas dimensions such as Positivity and Negativity replicated closely. In the naturalistic study, person–situation associations varied systematically across situation cues — social partner, location, and activity — with some associations reversing direction depending on the situation contact. Together, these findings demonstrate that situation contact shapes which person–situation associations emerge and to what degree, and that its influence differs meaningfully across psychological situation dimensions. Incorporating situational context into experience-sampling research is therefore essential for accurately capturing personality as a context-sensitive, dynamic system.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality Science
- Vol. 6
Personality Concepts in Early 20th-Century American Literature: Examining the Novels of F. Scott Fitzgerald
There is an emerging interest in psychology in examining personality in history, yet the implicit personality models of past historical periods have received little attention. Drawing upon the lexical hypothesis, this study examined the personality concepts and implicit model of personality in early 20th-century American literature, focusing on the novels by F. Scott Fitzgerald. A list of 1710 personality-descriptive adjectives and 100 marker terms of the Big Five model were used to code the descriptions of the novels’ characters (N = 169). Exploratory factor analysis identified a seven-factor structure that could be interpreted with reference to the cultural-historical context of the novels, encompassing themes of dynamism, agility, expressivity, self-regulation and social-relational functioning. Direct comparisons with structures obtained using the same list of words in contemporary self-ratings and in similar text-based analyses of 19th-century English novels from earlier research indicated overall low congruence. Still, some correspondence with the Big Five was observed at the level of marker scales of individual factors, and there was some qualitative similarity of some factors with those of the earlier authors’ models. The findings are discussed with reference to the potential of the presented approach to advance the study of personality structure in history.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality Science
- Vol. 6
Open AccessPersonality Concepts in Early 20th-Century American Literature: Examining the Novels of F. Scott Fitzgerald
There is an emerging interest in psychology in examining personality in history, yet the implicit personality models of past historical periods have received little attention. Drawing upon the lexical hypothesis, this study examined the personality concepts and implicit model of personality in early 20th-century American literature, focusing on the novels by F. Scott Fitzgerald. A list of 1710 personality-descriptive adjectives and 100 marker terms of the Big Five model were used to code the descriptions of the novels’ characters (N = 169). Exploratory factor analysis identified a seven-factor structure that could be interpreted with reference to the cultural-historical context of the novels, encompassing themes of dynamism, agility, expressivity, self-regulation and social-relational functioning. Direct comparisons with structures obtained using the same list of words in contemporary self-ratings and in similar text-based analyses of 19th-century English novels from earlier research indicated overall low congruence. Still, some correspondence with the Big Five was observed at the level of marker scales of individual factors, and there was some qualitative similarity of some factors with those of the earlier authors’ models. The findings are discussed with reference to the potential of the presented approach to advance the study of personality structure in history.
- Open Access
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
The Many Faces of Narcissism: A Question of Situation Perception?
This study investigated the correlations and transactions between narcissistic states—narcissistic agency, antagonism, and vulnerability—and situation perceptions using the DIAMONDS framework. Participants (N = 183) engaged in weekly online group discussions over six weeks, simulating a natural acquaintance process. Results showed significant correlations: Situation perceptions of Positivity related to heightened narcissistic agency, while Duty and Negativity perceptions were linked to narcissistic antagonism and vulnerability. A Random-Intercept Cross-Lagged Panel Model revealed person-situation transactions, with situation perceptions often preceding changes in narcissistic states. For example, perceptions of Intellect and Positivity increased narcissistic agency, while Intellect, Duty, and Negativity triggered higher-than-usual narcissistic antagonism. Findings highlight the role of situation perceptions in shaping narcissistic state variability.
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessThe Many Faces of Narcissism: A Question of Situation Perception?
This study investigated the correlations and transactions between narcissistic states—narcissistic agency, antagonism, and vulnerability—and situation perceptions using the DIAMONDS framework. Participants (N = 183) engaged in weekly online group discussions over six weeks, simulating a natural acquaintance process. Results showed significant correlations: Situation perceptions of Positivity related to heightened narcissistic agency, while Duty and Negativity perceptions were linked to narcissistic antagonism and vulnerability. A Random-Intercept Cross-Lagged Panel Model revealed person-situation transactions, with situation perceptions often preceding changes in narcissistic states. For example, perceptions of Intellect and Positivity increased narcissistic agency, while Intellect, Duty, and Negativity triggered higher-than-usual narcissistic antagonism. Findings highlight the role of situation perceptions in shaping narcissistic state variability.
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 39 (5) , 792-813
Relations among the trifurcated narcissism domains at trait and state level: Two of a kind?
This study explored narcissistic states using a hierarchical, trifurcated structure, examining state variability and trait-state associations of agentic extraversion, self-centered antagonism, and narcissistic neuroticism. The primary objective was to investigate whether the structural composition of narcissism, well-established in trait data, could be replicated in state data. We examined this structure at both between- and within-person levels in state data, including situation-specific structures of narcissism. The study used data from an experimental study where participants ( N = 189) met in groups of up to four people weekly over six weeks. Multilevel confirmatory factor analyses revealed that the narcissism structure was largely the same at both levels. However, within-person compositions of narcissism differed across affiliative versus controversial situations. In affiliative contexts, grandiosity manifested exclusively through agentic extraversion, with no expression through self-centered antagonism. In controversial settings, agentic extraversion and narcissistic neuroticism exhibited a slight negative association, contrasting the positive association observed across all group meetings. Our results show that narcissistic states exhibited less variability compared to the Big Five and rarely varied above their corresponding trait levels. This research contributes to a refined understanding of narcissism, highlighting the interplay between trait tendencies and situational factors in shaping narcissistic state expressions.
- 8 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 39 (5) , 792-813
Open AccessRelations among the trifurcated narcissism domains at trait and state level: Two of a kind?
This study explored narcissistic states using a hierarchical, trifurcated structure, examining state variability and trait-state associations of agentic extraversion, self-centered antagonism, and narcissistic neuroticism. The primary objective was to investigate whether the structural composition of narcissism, well-established in trait data, could be replicated in state data. We examined this structure at both between- and within-person levels in state data, including situation-specific structures of narcissism. The study used data from an experimental study where participants ( N = 189) met in groups of up to four people weekly over six weeks. Multilevel confirmatory factor analyses revealed that the narcissism structure was largely the same at both levels. However, within-person compositions of narcissism differed across affiliative versus controversial situations. In affiliative contexts, grandiosity manifested exclusively through agentic extraversion, with no expression through self-centered antagonism. In controversial settings, agentic extraversion and narcissistic neuroticism exhibited a slight negative association, contrasting the positive association observed across all group meetings. Our results show that narcissistic states exhibited less variability compared to the Big Five and rarely varied above their corresponding trait levels. This research contributes to a refined understanding of narcissism, highlighting the interplay between trait tendencies and situational factors in shaping narcissistic state expressions.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
The Many Faces of Narcissism: Unpacking Situational Triggers and State Interactions
This study investigated the correlations and transactions between narcissistic states (narcissistic agency, antagonism, and vulnerability) and situation perceptions using the DIAMONDS framework. Participants (N = 183) engaged in weekly online group discussions over six weeks, simulating a natural acquaintance process. Results showed significant correlations: Positive situation perceptions related to heightened narcissistic agency, while Duty and Negativity perceptions were linked to narcissistic antagonism and vulnerability. A Random-Intercept Cross-Lagged Panel Model revealed person-situation transactions, with situation perceptions often preceding changes in narcissistic states. For example, perceptions of Intellect and Positivity increased narcissistic agency, while Intellect, Duty, and Negativity triggered higher-than-usual narcissistic antagonism. Findings highlight the role of situation perceptions in shaping narcissistic state variability.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessThe Many Faces of Narcissism: Unpacking Situational Triggers and State Interactions
This study investigated the correlations and transactions between narcissistic states (narcissistic agency, antagonism, and vulnerability) and situation perceptions using the DIAMONDS framework. Participants (N = 183) engaged in weekly online group discussions over six weeks, simulating a natural acquaintance process. Results showed significant correlations: Positive situation perceptions related to heightened narcissistic agency, while Duty and Negativity perceptions were linked to narcissistic antagonism and vulnerability. A Random-Intercept Cross-Lagged Panel Model revealed person-situation transactions, with situation perceptions often preceding changes in narcissistic states. For example, perceptions of Intellect and Positivity increased narcissistic agency, while Intellect, Duty, and Negativity triggered higher-than-usual narcissistic antagonism. Findings highlight the role of situation perceptions in shaping narcissistic state variability.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Relations among the Trifurcated Narcissistic Domains at Trait and State Level: Two of a Kind?
This study explored narcissistic states using a hierarchical, trifurcated structure, examining state variability and trait-state associations of agentic extraversion, self-centered antagonism, and narcissistic neuroticism. The primary objective was to investigate whether the structural composition of narcissism, well-established in trait data, could be replicated in state data. We examined this structure at both between- and within-person levels in state data, including situation-specific compositions of narcissism. The study used data from an experimental study where participants (N = 189) met in groups of up to four people weekly over six weeks. Multilevel confirmatory factor analyses revealed that the narcissism structure was largely the same at both levels. However, within-person compositions of narcissism differed across affiliative versus controversial situations. In affiliative contexts, grandiosity manifested exclusively through agentic extraversion, with no expression through self-centered antagonism. In controversial settings, agentic extraversion and narcissistic neuroticism exhibited a slight negative association, contrasting the positive association observed across all group meetings. Our results show that narcissistic states exhibited less variability compared to the Big Five and rarely varied above their corresponding trait levels. This research contributes to a refined understanding of narcissism, highlighting the interplay between trait tendencies and situational factors in shaping narcissistic state expressions.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessRelations among the Trifurcated Narcissistic Domains at Trait and State Level: Two of a Kind?
This study explored narcissistic states using a hierarchical, trifurcated structure, examining state variability and trait-state associations of agentic extraversion, self-centered antagonism, and narcissistic neuroticism. The primary objective was to investigate whether the structural composition of narcissism, well-established in trait data, could be replicated in state data. We examined this structure at both between- and within-person levels in state data, including situation-specific compositions of narcissism. The study used data from an experimental study where participants (N = 189) met in groups of up to four people weekly over six weeks. Multilevel confirmatory factor analyses revealed that the narcissism structure was largely the same at both levels. However, within-person compositions of narcissism differed across affiliative versus controversial situations. In affiliative contexts, grandiosity manifested exclusively through agentic extraversion, with no expression through self-centered antagonism. In controversial settings, agentic extraversion and narcissistic neuroticism exhibited a slight negative association, contrasting the positive association observed across all group meetings. Our results show that narcissistic states exhibited less variability compared to the Big Five and rarely varied above their corresponding trait levels. This research contributes to a refined understanding of narcissism, highlighting the interplay between trait tendencies and situational factors in shaping narcissistic state expressions.