Mykola Kolotylo
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 December 2024
- Published by National University of Kyiv - Mohyla Academy in Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal
- No. 10,p. 83-98
Ukraine’s Accession Process to the EU: Judicial Reform in the Focus
This article scrutinizes the bilateral relations between the EU and Ukraine in the light of granting the candidate status and commencing the accession process. Firstly, it analyses the main legal frameworks existing prior to Ukraine’s application for membership. Further, it explores the main reflections on Ukraine’s application and the possible scenarios for the accession process. The reform of the judiciary is considered closely as a main condition within the accession process. It is argued that the fulfillment of the conditions prescribed in the European Commission’s opinion in 2022 and assessment report in 2023 relating to the judiciary have to be considered as a first step of successful negotiations process. Hence, the complex reform of the judiciary serves as a cornerstone in the accession process.
- 30 December 2024
- Published by National University of Kyiv - Mohyla Academy in Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal
- No. 10,p. 83-98
Open AccessUkraine’s Accession Process to the EU: Judicial Reform in the Focus
This article scrutinizes the bilateral relations between the EU and Ukraine in the light of granting the candidate status and commencing the accession process. Firstly, it analyses the main legal frameworks existing prior to Ukraine’s application for membership. Further, it explores the main reflections on Ukraine’s application and the possible scenarios for the accession process. The reform of the judiciary is considered closely as a main condition within the accession process. It is argued that the fulfillment of the conditions prescribed in the European Commission’s opinion in 2022 and assessment report in 2023 relating to the judiciary have to be considered as a first step of successful negotiations process. Hence, the complex reform of the judiciary serves as a cornerstone in the accession process.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2024
- Published by National University of Kyiv - Mohyla Academy in NaUKMA Research Papers. Law
- Vol. 13, 83-89
Judicial System Reform in Albania in the Context of Accession Process to the European Union
This article examines the reform of the justice system in Albania since 2016 through the lens of the accession procedure to the European Union and the practice of the European Court of Human Rights in individual cases against Albania. The first part is devoted to the analysis of the general context in which the reform of the justice system in 2016 was implemented in Albania and examines its main elements. The relevant reports of the European Commission regarding Albania are considered in this part with a focus on recommendations concerning the judiciary.The second part analyses the key judgements of the European Court of Human Rights regarding the process of reforming the justice system in Albania since 2016 based on individual applications of judges and prosecutors who were dismissed from their positions as a result of the re-evaluation procedure. These judgements include the following cases: Besnik Cani v. Albania, Gashi and Gina v. Albania, Nikëhasani v. Albania, Sevdari v. Albania, and Xhoxhaj v. Albania. In particular, the following aspects were considered: the status of bodies created to reassess judges and prosecutors, their independence and impartiality; as well as the proportionality of the interference in the private life of the applicants.Finally, the article aims to assess the impact of judgements in specific cases of the European Court of Human Rights on the accession procedure of Albania and other candidate states to the European Union. The article scrutinizes the reports of the European Commission regarding other candidate states in terms of the recommendations provided related to the judiciary and the rule of law. The article demonstrates the interrelation between the accession process to the European Union and the relevant judgements of the European Court of Human Rights analysing the judgements and key reports concerning other candidate countries. In particular, the reports of the European Commission concerning Georgia, Moldova, and Ukraine are considered. It is argued that the conclusions obtained in individual cases regarding the reform of the justice system in Albania should be interpreted in a much broader context of the procedure of accession tothe European Union of other candidate states.
- 22 October 2024
- Published by National University of Kyiv - Mohyla Academy in NaUKMA Research Papers. Law
- Vol. 13, 83-89
Open AccessJudicial System Reform in Albania in the Context of Accession Process to the European Union
This article examines the reform of the justice system in Albania since 2016 through the lens of the accession procedure to the European Union and the practice of the European Court of Human Rights in individual cases against Albania. The first part is devoted to the analysis of the general context in which the reform of the justice system in 2016 was implemented in Albania and examines its main elements. The relevant reports of the European Commission regarding Albania are considered in this part with a focus on recommendations concerning the judiciary.The second part analyses the key judgements of the European Court of Human Rights regarding the process of reforming the justice system in Albania since 2016 based on individual applications of judges and prosecutors who were dismissed from their positions as a result of the re-evaluation procedure. These judgements include the following cases: Besnik Cani v. Albania, Gashi and Gina v. Albania, Nikëhasani v. Albania, Sevdari v. Albania, and Xhoxhaj v. Albania. In particular, the following aspects were considered: the status of bodies created to reassess judges and prosecutors, their independence and impartiality; as well as the proportionality of the interference in the private life of the applicants.Finally, the article aims to assess the impact of judgements in specific cases of the European Court of Human Rights on the accession procedure of Albania and other candidate states to the European Union. The article scrutinizes the reports of the European Commission regarding other candidate states in terms of the recommendations provided related to the judiciary and the rule of law. The article demonstrates the interrelation between the accession process to the European Union and the relevant judgements of the European Court of Human Rights analysing the judgements and key reports concerning other candidate countries. In particular, the reports of the European Commission concerning Georgia, Moldova, and Ukraine are considered. It is argued that the conclusions obtained in individual cases regarding the reform of the justice system in Albania should be interpreted in a much broader context of the procedure of accession tothe European Union of other candidate states.