Karlygash Kamali
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Karlygash Kamali has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Zhaxat Kenzhin
Kazakh National University of Sports
2 shared publications - A. A. Apysheva
Sarsen Amanzholov East Kazakhstan University
1 shared publication - Aigul Shadiyeva
Central Asian Innovation University
1 shared publication - Aizhamal Aidaraliyeva
Zhangir Khan University
1 shared publication - Altynshash Zamanbekova
Kazakh Ablai Khan University of International Relations and World Languages
1 shared publication - Amit Dutta
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 February 2026
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 1 (13 (139)) , 24-32
Identification of the impact of open banking digital infrastructure on financial inclusion in EU countries in the context of macroeconomic and digital development
The object of the study is the financial inclusion in EU countries in the context of macroeconomic and digital development. The problem of quantitatively assessing this relationship in a broad cross-country context has been solved. The following results were obtained: – a significant cross-country divergence was identified in the level of digitalization of the financial sector, the development of ICT (information and communication technologies) infrastructure, and financial inclusion, which forms fundamentally different starting conditions for the implementation of open banking; – a strong positive correlation was established between the level of banking digitalization and the composite financial inclusion index (Pearson’s coefficient +0.894); – an increase in the banking digitalization index by one point leads to an average increase in the composite financial inclusion index by 0.498 points (p < 0.001); – for “leader” countries, the average banking digitalization index was 82.4; for countries with “medium potential” – 61.8; for countries with “basic challenges” – 48.1. The obtained results are explained by the fact that technological development of the financial sector creates prerequisites for reducing transaction costs and the emergence of innovative, non-territorially bound services. The specific features of the results lie in proving the differentiated potential of open banking: for “leader” countries, for countries with “medium potential”, for countries with “basic challenges”. The practical significance of the study lies in providing regulators and financial institutions with quantitatively grounded conclusions for developing differentiated strategies that take into account the level of readiness of the national ecosystem
- 27 February 2026
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 1 (13 (139)) , 24-32
Open AccessIdentification of the impact of open banking digital infrastructure on financial inclusion in EU countries in the context of macroeconomic and digital development
The object of the study is the financial inclusion in EU countries in the context of macroeconomic and digital development. The problem of quantitatively assessing this relationship in a broad cross-country context has been solved. The following results were obtained: – a significant cross-country divergence was identified in the level of digitalization of the financial sector, the development of ICT (information and communication technologies) infrastructure, and financial inclusion, which forms fundamentally different starting conditions for the implementation of open banking; – a strong positive correlation was established between the level of banking digitalization and the composite financial inclusion index (Pearson’s coefficient +0.894); – an increase in the banking digitalization index by one point leads to an average increase in the composite financial inclusion index by 0.498 points (p < 0.001); – for “leader” countries, the average banking digitalization index was 82.4; for countries with “medium potential” – 61.8; for countries with “basic challenges” – 48.1. The obtained results are explained by the fact that technological development of the financial sector creates prerequisites for reducing transaction costs and the emergence of innovative, non-territorially bound services. The specific features of the results lie in proving the differentiated potential of open banking: for “leader” countries, for countries with “medium potential”, for countries with “basic challenges”. The practical significance of the study lies in providing regulators and financial institutions with quantitatively grounded conclusions for developing differentiated strategies that take into account the level of readiness of the national ecosystem
- Open Access
- 6 October 2025
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 20 (3) , 53-67
Digitalisation Impact on E-Commerce in Kazakhstan: Macroeconomic Effects and Forecast
Today, digital transformation has a significant impact on the structure of trade, consumer behaviour and macroeconomic indicators, especially in developing countries. This study aims to assess the impact of digitalisation on the development of electronic commerce in Kazakhstan and its relationship with macroeconomic indicators, as well as to predict the dynamics of e-commerce using regression and time analysis. The official statistical data of the Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the National Bank, as well as international organisations (the World Bank, ITU) were used as source data. The research methodology includes descriptive statistics, correlation and multiple regression analysis in SPSS, as well as forecasting the volume of electronic commerce using the ARIMA. The results showed a high correlation between the volume of e-commerce and the level of Internet penetration (r = 0.83), the number of users (r = 0.85), as well as the volume of cross-border trade (r = 0.95). Multiple regression showed that e-commerce in the service sector (β = 0.707, p < 0.001) and the share of e-commerce in the retail structure (β = 0.347, p = 0.003) had the most significant impact. The results of the study emphasise the need to review the marketing strategies of enterprises, develop digital infrastructure and improve government policy in the field of cross-border electronic commerce. In future work, it is advisable to use microdata to include behavioural factors, as well as expand time series and apply nonlinear models, including structural shifts, to analyse the impact of digitalisation on trade more accurately.
- 6 October 2025
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 20 (3) , 53-67
Open AccessDigitalisation Impact on E-Commerce in Kazakhstan: Macroeconomic Effects and Forecast
Today, digital transformation has a significant impact on the structure of trade, consumer behaviour and macroeconomic indicators, especially in developing countries. This study aims to assess the impact of digitalisation on the development of electronic commerce in Kazakhstan and its relationship with macroeconomic indicators, as well as to predict the dynamics of e-commerce using regression and time analysis. The official statistical data of the Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the National Bank, as well as international organisations (the World Bank, ITU) were used as source data. The research methodology includes descriptive statistics, correlation and multiple regression analysis in SPSS, as well as forecasting the volume of electronic commerce using the ARIMA. The results showed a high correlation between the volume of e-commerce and the level of Internet penetration (r = 0.83), the number of users (r = 0.85), as well as the volume of cross-border trade (r = 0.95). Multiple regression showed that e-commerce in the service sector (β = 0.707, p < 0.001) and the share of e-commerce in the retail structure (β = 0.347, p = 0.003) had the most significant impact. The results of the study emphasise the need to review the marketing strategies of enterprises, develop digital infrastructure and improve government policy in the field of cross-border electronic commerce. In future work, it is advisable to use microdata to include behavioural factors, as well as expand time series and apply nonlinear models, including structural shifts, to analyse the impact of digitalisation on trade more accurately.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2025
- Published by Innovative Research Publishing in International Journal of Innovative Research and Scientific Studies
- Vol. 8 (3) , 4700-4709
Multilateral trade agreements as a basis for foreign economic cooperation by the example of EU countries
This study investigates the impact of multilateral trade agreements on the gross domestic product (GDP) of EU countries in the context of foreign economic cooperation. The objective is to assess whether the number of such agreements correlates with GDP levels while considering related factors. The analysis applies the Pareto principle to classify EU countries into two groups based on GDP volume. It reveals that both groups display similar levels of economic freedom (69–72%), while countries with higher GDP and lower tax revenues report a greater number of trademark applications from foreign companies. Correlation analysis identifies a strong dependence of GDP on exports, imports, and economic freedom, with correlation coefficients exceeding 90%. These factors are thus considered key drivers of GDP growth. A regression model (R² = 0.862) confirms a significant positive relationship between the number of multilateral trade agreements and changes in export volumes. The findings suggest that such agreements are instrumental in shaping economic policies and fostering integration within the EU. The study underscores the practical relevance of these results for policymaking, particularly in designing strategies aimed at enhancing national competitiveness and promoting sustainable economic growth across the region.
- 16 March 2025
- Published by Innovative Research Publishing in International Journal of Innovative Research and Scientific Studies
- Vol. 8 (3) , 4700-4709
Open AccessMultilateral trade agreements as a basis for foreign economic cooperation by the example of EU countries
This study investigates the impact of multilateral trade agreements on the gross domestic product (GDP) of EU countries in the context of foreign economic cooperation. The objective is to assess whether the number of such agreements correlates with GDP levels while considering related factors. The analysis applies the Pareto principle to classify EU countries into two groups based on GDP volume. It reveals that both groups display similar levels of economic freedom (69–72%), while countries with higher GDP and lower tax revenues report a greater number of trademark applications from foreign companies. Correlation analysis identifies a strong dependence of GDP on exports, imports, and economic freedom, with correlation coefficients exceeding 90%. These factors are thus considered key drivers of GDP growth. A regression model (R² = 0.862) confirms a significant positive relationship between the number of multilateral trade agreements and changes in export volumes. The findings suggest that such agreements are instrumental in shaping economic policies and fostering integration within the EU. The study underscores the practical relevance of these results for policymaking, particularly in designing strategies aimed at enhancing national competitiveness and promoting sustainable economic growth across the region.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 6 (13 (132)) , 30-37
Development of a methodology for assessing innovation activities for management purposes for oil and gas companies
The study focuses on the innovation activity of oil and gas companies, solving the problem of evaluating this activity and presenting the results: – the author's methodology for assessing the innovation activity of oil and gas companies has been developed, the results of which allow to fix the development point in the range of [0–0.5) – “Inert”), [0.5–0.7) – “Developing” and more than 0.7 – “Active”. For each range, management strategies for the future are recommended; – the 5 oil and gas companies were evaluated according to three criteria. In the group of indicators “Investments” the best result is Total (0.95), in the group of indicators “Human resources” all companies showed a high result, on patent activity the European companies have a high result (0.81–0.83). Kazakhstan organizations, having more than sufficient human resources in the R&D sector, are not financed at a competitive level, which leads to a low level of patent activity of companies; – according to the result of the innovation activity assessment, the companies were distributed as follows: “Inert” – TCO (0.43) and KPO (0.32), “Developing” – Shell and ENI (0.68), “Active” – Total (0.81). The results suggest that the calculated method for determining indicators can be used to assess the innovation activity of oil and gas companies, considering the production factor. The results highlight the development of a methodology for assessing the innovation activity of oil and gas companies based on three main criteria, aimed at improving management. The methodology can be used by oil and gas companies and government agencies interested in industry development
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 6 (13 (132)) , 30-37
Open AccessDevelopment of a methodology for assessing innovation activities for management purposes for oil and gas companies
The study focuses on the innovation activity of oil and gas companies, solving the problem of evaluating this activity and presenting the results: – the author's methodology for assessing the innovation activity of oil and gas companies has been developed, the results of which allow to fix the development point in the range of [0–0.5) – “Inert”), [0.5–0.7) – “Developing” and more than 0.7 – “Active”. For each range, management strategies for the future are recommended; – the 5 oil and gas companies were evaluated according to three criteria. In the group of indicators “Investments” the best result is Total (0.95), in the group of indicators “Human resources” all companies showed a high result, on patent activity the European companies have a high result (0.81–0.83). Kazakhstan organizations, having more than sufficient human resources in the R&D sector, are not financed at a competitive level, which leads to a low level of patent activity of companies; – according to the result of the innovation activity assessment, the companies were distributed as follows: “Inert” – TCO (0.43) and KPO (0.32), “Developing” – Shell and ENI (0.68), “Active” – Total (0.81). The results suggest that the calculated method for determining indicators can be used to assess the innovation activity of oil and gas companies, considering the production factor. The results highlight the development of a methodology for assessing the innovation activity of oil and gas companies based on three main criteria, aimed at improving management. The methodology can be used by oil and gas companies and government agencies interested in industry development
- Open Access
- 31 October 2024
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 5 (13 (131)) , 14-21
Identifying the characteristics of public-private partnership projects on green energy in developing countries with different incomes
The object of the study is public-private partnership projects in green energy in developing countries. The problematics of the study is based on the intersection of the current problems of improving energy efficiency and environmental friendliness of energy innovations. The problem of analyzing such projects was solved with the following results: The findings of the study indicate the importance of country income as a factor influencing investment in public-private partnership projects in green energy. The analysis indicates the importance of the country's income as a factor influencing the established technological structure of public-private partnership projects in the green energy sector. It is proved that energy efficiency significantly depends on the technological structure of public-private partnership projects in green energy. The obtained results are explained by assuming the dependence of public-private partnership projects in green energy on the income level of the economy, based on Wallis one-way analysis of variance and cross-tabulation. Mann-Whitney U test was used to explain the dependence of energy efficiency on the technological structure of such projects. The particularity of this study is the analysis of the technological structure of public-private partnership projects in green energy, taking into account the specifics of developing countries and the application of their clustering. This research is of practical significance in the possibility of applying the results obtained by the authorities for the creation and implementation of public-private partnership projects in the field of green energy, as well as by energy companies implementing new technologies using water, wind and solar energy.
- 31 October 2024
- Published by Private Company Technology Center in Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies
- Vol. 5 (13 (131)) , 14-21
Open AccessIdentifying the characteristics of public-private partnership projects on green energy in developing countries with different incomes
The object of the study is public-private partnership projects in green energy in developing countries. The problematics of the study is based on the intersection of the current problems of improving energy efficiency and environmental friendliness of energy innovations. The problem of analyzing such projects was solved with the following results: The findings of the study indicate the importance of country income as a factor influencing investment in public-private partnership projects in green energy. The analysis indicates the importance of the country's income as a factor influencing the established technological structure of public-private partnership projects in the green energy sector. It is proved that energy efficiency significantly depends on the technological structure of public-private partnership projects in green energy. The obtained results are explained by assuming the dependence of public-private partnership projects in green energy on the income level of the economy, based on Wallis one-way analysis of variance and cross-tabulation. Mann-Whitney U test was used to explain the dependence of energy efficiency on the technological structure of such projects. The particularity of this study is the analysis of the technological structure of public-private partnership projects in green energy, taking into account the specifics of developing countries and the application of their clustering. This research is of practical significance in the possibility of applying the results obtained by the authorities for the creation and implementation of public-private partnership projects in the field of green energy, as well as by energy companies implementing new technologies using water, wind and solar energy.