PHPhilipp Heinz

Philipp Heinz

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Philipp Heinz has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Patient Benefits in the Context of Sepsis-Related AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems: Scoping Review

    by Pascal Raszke, Godwin Denk Giebel, Jürgen Wasem, Michael Adamzik, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Philipp Heinz, Nina Timmesfeld, Marianne Tokic, Frank Martin Brunkhorst, et al.

    Background: Global digitalization continues to advance, extending its influence into medicine and health care systems worldwide. In recent years, substantial advancements have been made in the research and development of artificial intelligence (AI), raising questions about its potential in medicine. The integration and application of AI in intensive care medicine, particularly in sepsis treatment, presents significant potential for advancing patient outcomes and enhancing patient-relevant benefits. However, a comprehensive and systematic overview of the full spectrum of patient-relevant benefits associated with AI-based clinical decision support systems (CDSS) remains lacking. Objective: This scoping review aimed to identify and categorize evidence on patient-relevant benefits of AI-based CDSS in sepsis care. Methods: Systematic research was conducted in 4 electronic databases: MEDLINE via PubMed, Embase, the ACM Digital Library, and IEEE Xplore. In addition, a comprehensive search on the websites of relevant international organizations, along with a citation search of the included articles, was conducted. Articles were included if they (1) focused on sepsis and (2) described patient-relevant benefits of AI-based CDSS. Articles published between January 1, 2008, and March 2, 2023, were considered for inclusion. Study selection was performed independently by 2 reviewers. The manuscript was drafted in accordance with the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist. The analysis of the included articles was conducted using the program MAXQDA (VERBI Software GmbH), with systemization finalized in a consensus workshop. Results: A total of 3368 records were identified across the 4 databases, of which 24 met the inclusion criteria and were included in the scoping review. The additional search on international websites and in reference lists identified 6 more relevant articles, resulting in 30 included studies. Of these, 20 were quantitative, comprising 7 prospective and 13 retrospective designs. In addition, 1 qualitative study, 1 mixed methods study, 6 review articles, and 2 articles from institutional websites were included. Patient-relevant benefits were systematized in six main categories: (1) prediction, (2) earlier treatment and prioritization of high-risk patients, (3) individualized therapy, (4) improved patient outcomes (including improved Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score, reduced length of stay, and reduced mortality), (5) general improvements in care, and (6) reduced readmission rate. Conclusions: This scoping review underscores the potential of AI-based CDSS to positively impact patient-relevant benefits, particularly in sepsis care, where they demonstrate considerable promise for improving intensive care. However, the majority of the identified studies rely on retrospective database analyses. Future research should focus on validating these findings through prospective studies.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Improving AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems and Their Integration Into Care From the Perspective of Experts: Interview Study Among Different Stakeholders

    by Godwin Denk Giebel, Pascal Raszke, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Michael Adamzik, Philipp Heinz, Marianne Tokic, Nina Timmesfeld, Frank Martin Brunkhorst, Jürgen Wasem, et al.

    Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)–based systems are receiving increasing attention in the health care sector. While the use of AI is well advanced in some medical applications, such as image recognition, it is still in its infancy in others, such as clinical decision support systems (CDSS). Examples of AI-based CDSS can be found in the context of sepsis prediction or antibiotic prescription. Scientific literature indicates that such systems can support physicians in their daily work and lead to improved patient outcomes. Nevertheless, there are various problems and barriers in this context that should be considered. Objective: This study aimed to identify opportunities to optimize AI-based CDSS and their integration into care from the perspective of experts. Methods: Semistructured web-based expert interviews were conducted. Experts representing the perspectives of patients; physicians; caregivers; developers; health insurance representatives; researchers (especially in law and IT); and experts in regulation, market admission and quality management or assurance, and ethics were included. The conversations were recorded and transcribed. Subsequently, a qualitative content analysis was performed. The different approaches to improvement were categorized into groups (“technology,” “data,” “users,” “studies,” “law,” and “general”). These also served as deductive codes. Inductive codes were determined within an internal project workshop. Results: In total, 13 individual and 2 double interviews were conducted with 17 experts. A total of 227 expert statements were included in the analysis. Suggestions were heterogeneous and concerned improvements: (1) in the systems themselves (eg, implementing comprehensive system training involving [future] users; using a comprehensive and high-quality database; considering usability, transparency, and customizability; preventing automation bias through control mechanisms or intelligent design; conducting studies to demonstrate the benefit of the system), (2) on the user side (eg, training [future] physicians could contribute to a more positive attitude and to greater awareness and questioning decision supports suggested by the system and ensuring that the use of the system does not lead to additional work), and (3) in the environment in which the systems are used (eg, increasing the digitalization of the health care system, especially in hospitals; providing transparent public communication about the benefits and risks of AI; providing research funding; clarifying open legal issues, eg, those related to liability; and standardizing and consolidating various approval processes). Conclusions: This study offers several possible strategies for improving AI-based CDSS and their integration into health care. These were found in the areas of “technology,” “data,” “users,” “studies,” “law,” and “general.” Systems, users, and the environment should be taken into account to ensure that the systems are used safely, effectively, and sustainably. Further studies should investigate both the effectiveness of strategies to improve AI-based CDSS and their integration into health care and the accuracy of their match to specific problems. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.2196/62704


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Problems and Barriers Related to the Use of AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems: Interview Study

    by Godwin Denk Giebel, Pascal Raszke, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Michael Adamzik, Philipp Heinz, Marianne Tokic, Nina Timmesfeld, Frank Brunkhorst, Jürgen Wasem, et al.

    Background: Digitalization is currently revolutionizing health care worldwide. A promising technology in this context is artificial intelligence (AI). The application of AI can support health care providers in their daily work in various ways. The integration of AI is particularly promising in clinical decision support systems (CDSSs). While the opportunities of this technology are numerous, the problems should not be overlooked. Objective: This study aimed to identify challenges and barriers in the context of AI-based CDSSs from the perspectives of experts across various disciplines. Methods: Semistructured expert interviews were conducted with different stakeholders. These included representatives of patients, physicians and caregivers, developers of AI-based CDSSs, researchers (studying AI in health care and social and health law), quality management and quality assurance representatives, a representative of an ethics committee, a representative of a health insurance fund, and medical product consultants. The interviews took place on the web and were recorded, transcribed, and subsequently subjected to a qualitative content analysis based on the method by Kuckartz. The analysis was conducted using MAXQDA software. Initially, the problems were separated into “general,” “development,” and “clinical use.” Finally, a workshop within the project consortium served to systematize the identified problems. Results: A total of 15 expert interviews were conducted, and 309 expert statements with reference to problems and barriers in the context of AI-based CDSSs were identified. These emerged in 7 problem categories: technology (46/309, 14.9%), data (59/309, 19.1%), user (102/309, 33%), studies (17/309, 5.5%), ethics (20/309, 6.5%), law (33/309, 10.7%), and general (32/309, 10.4%). The problem categories were further divided into problem areas, which in turn comprised the respective problems. Conclusions: A large number of problems and barriers were identified in the context of AI-based CDSSs. These can be systematized according to the point at which they occur (“general,” “development,” and “clinical use”) or according to the problem category (“technology,” “data,” “user,” “studies,” “ethics,” “law,” and “general”). The problems identified in this work should be further investigated. They can be used as a basis for deriving solutions to optimize development, acceptance, and use of AI-based CDSSs. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.2196/preprints.62704


  • Open Access

    User-Oriented Requirements for Artificial Intelligence–Based Clinical Decision Support Systems in Sepsis: Protocol for a Multimethod Research Project

    by Pascal Raszke, Godwin Denk Giebel, Carina Abels, Jürgen Wasem, Michael Adamzik, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Philipp Heinz, Silke Mreyen, Nina Timmesfeld, et al.

    Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)–based clinical decision support systems (CDSS) have been developed for several diseases. However, despite the potential to improve the quality of care and thereby positively impact patient-relevant outcomes, the majority of AI-based CDSS have not been adopted in standard care. Possible reasons for this include barriers in the implementation and a nonuser-oriented development approach, resulting in reduced user acceptance. Objective: This research project has 2 objectives. First, problems and corresponding solutions that hinder or support the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS are identified. Second, the research project aims to increase user acceptance by creating a user-oriented requirement profile, using the example of sepsis. Methods: The research project is based on a multimethod approach combining (1) a scoping review, (2) focus groups with physicians and professional caregivers, and (3) semistructured interviews with relevant stakeholders. The research modules mentioned provide the basis for the development of a (4) survey, including a discrete choice experiment (DCE) with physicians. A minimum of 6667 physicians with expertise in the clinical picture of sepsis are contacted for this purpose. The survey is followed by the development of a requirement profile for AI-based CDSS and the derivation of policy recommendations for action, which are evaluated in a (5) expert roundtable discussion. Results: The multimethod research project started in November 2022. It provides an overview of the barriers and corresponding solutions related to the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS. Using sepsis as an example, a user-oriented requirement profile for AI-based CDSS is developed. The scoping review has been concluded and the qualitative modules have been subjected to analysis. The start of the survey, including the DCE, was at the end of July 2024. Conclusions: The results of the research project represent the first attempt to create a comprehensive user-oriented requirement profile for the development of sepsis-specific AI-based CDSS. In addition, general recommendations are derived, in order to reduce barriers in the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS. The findings of this research project have the potential to facilitate the integration of AI-based CDSS into standard care in the long term. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/62704


  • Open Access

    Improving AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems and Their Integration Into Care From the Perspective of Experts: Interview Study Among Different Stakeholders (Preprint)

    by Godwin Denk Giebel, Pascal Raszke, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Michael Adamzik, Philipp Heinz, Marianne Tokic, Nina Timmesfeld, Frank Martin Brunkhorst, Jürgen Wasem, et al.

    Journal of Medical Internet Research - International Scientific Journal for Medical Research, Information and Communication on the Internet #Preprint #PeerReviewMe: Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint. Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn. Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period. Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author). Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)–based systems are receiving increasing attention in the health care sector. While the use of AI is well advanced in some medical applications, such as image recognition, it is still in its infancy in others, such as clinical decision support systems (CDSS). Examples of AI-based CDSS can be found in the context of sepsis prediction or antibiotic prescription. Scientific literature indicates that such systems can support physicians in their daily work and lead to improved patient outcomes. Nevertheless, there are various problems and barriers in this context that should be considered. Objective: This study aimed to identify opportunities to optimize AI-based CDSS and their integration into care from the perspective of experts. Methods: Semistructured web-based expert interviews were conducted. Experts representing the perspectives of patients; physicians; caregivers; developers; health insurance representatives; researchers (especially in law and IT); and experts in regulation, market admission and quality management or assurance, and ethics were included. The conversations were recorded and transcribed. Subsequently, a qualitative content analysis was performed. The different approaches to improvement were categorized into groups (“technology,” “data,” “users,” “studies,” “law,” and “general”). These also served as deductive codes. Inductive codes were determined within an internal project workshop. Results: In total, 13 individual and 2 double interviews were conducted with 17 experts. A total of 227 expert statements were included in the analysis. Suggestions were heterogeneous and concerned improvements: (1) in the systems themselves (eg, implementing comprehensive system training involving [future] users; using a comprehensive and high-quality database; considering usability, transparency, and customizability; preventing automation bias through control mechanisms or intelligent design; conducting studies to demonstrate the benefit of the system), (2) on the user side (eg, training [future] physicians could contribute to a more positive attitude and to greater awareness and questioning decision supports suggested by the system and ensuring that the use of the system does not lead to additional work), and (3) in the environment in which the systems are used (eg, increasing the digitalization of the health care system, especially in hospitals; providing transparent public communication about the benefits and risks of AI; providing research funding; clarifying open legal issues, eg, those related to liability; and standardizing and consolidating various approval processes). Conclusions: This study offers several possible strategies for improving AI-based CDSS and their integration into health care. These were found in the areas of “technology,” “data,” “users,” “studies,” “law,” and “general.” Systems, users, and the environment should be taken into account to ensure that the systems are used safely, effectively, and sustainably. Further studies should investigate both the effectiveness of strategies to improve AI-based CDSS and their integration into health care and the accuracy of their match to specific problems.

  • Open Access

    Problems and Barriers Related to the Use of AI-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems: Interview Study (Preprint)

    by Godwin Denk Giebel, Pascal Raszke, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Michael Adamzik, Philipp Heinz, Marianne Tokic, Nina Timmesfeld, Frank Brunkhorst, Jürgen Wasem, et al.

    BACKGROUND Digitalization is currently revolutionizing health care worldwide. A promising technology in this context is artificial intelligence (AI). The application of AI can support health care providers in their daily work in various ways. The integration of AI is particularly promising in clinical decision support systems (CDSSs). While the opportunities of this technology are numerous, the problems should not be overlooked. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to identify challenges and barriers in the context of AI-based CDSSs from the perspectives of experts across various disciplines. METHODS Semistructured expert interviews were conducted with different stakeholders. These included representatives of patients, physicians and caregivers, developers of AI-based CDSSs, researchers (studying AI in health care and social and health law), quality management and quality assurance representatives, a representative of an ethics committee, a representative of a health insurance fund, and medical product consultants. The interviews took place on the web and were recorded, transcribed, and subsequently subjected to a qualitative content analysis based on the method by Kuckartz. The analysis was conducted using MAXQDA software. Initially, the problems were separated into “general,” “development,” and “clinical use.” Finally, a workshop within the project consortium served to systematize the identified problems. RESULTS A total of 15 expert interviews were conducted, and 309 expert statements with reference to problems and barriers in the context of AI-based CDSSs were identified. These emerged in 7 problem categories: technology (46/309, 14.9%), data (59/309, 19.1%), user (102/309, 33%), studies (17/309, 5.5%), ethics (20/309, 6.5%), law (33/309, 10.7%), and general (32/309, 10.4%). The problem categories were further divided into problem areas, which in turn comprised the respective problems. CONCLUSIONS A large number of problems and barriers were identified in the context of AI-based CDSSs. These can be systematized according to the point at which they occur (“general,” “development,” and “clinical use”) or according to the problem category (“technology,” “data,” “user,” “studies,” “ethics,” “law,” and “general”). The problems identified in this work should be further investigated. They can be used as a basis for deriving solutions to optimize development, acceptance, and use of AI-based CDSSs. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT RR2-10.2196/preprints.62704

  • Open Access

    User-Oriented Requirements for Artificial Intelligence–Based Clinical Decision Support Systems in Sepsis: Protocol for a Multimethod Research Project (Preprint)

    by Pascal Raszke, Godwin Denk Giebel, Carina Abels, Jürgen Wasem, Michael Adamzik, Hartmuth Nowak, Lars Palmowski, Philipp Heinz, Silke Mreyen, Nina Timmesfeld, et al.

    BACKGROUND Artificial intelligence (AI)–based clinical decision support systems (CDSS) have been developed for several diseases. However, despite the potential to improve the quality of care and thereby positively impact patient-relevant outcomes, the majority of AI-based CDSS have not been adopted in standard care. Possible reasons for this include barriers in the implementation and a nonuser-oriented development approach, resulting in reduced user acceptance. OBJECTIVE This research project has 2 objectives. First, problems and corresponding solutions that hinder or support the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS are identified. Second, the research project aims to increase user acceptance by creating a user-oriented requirement profile, using the example of sepsis. METHODS The research project is based on a multimethod approach combining (1) a scoping review, (2) focus groups with physicians and professional caregivers, and (3) semistructured interviews with relevant stakeholders. The research modules mentioned provide the basis for the development of a (4) survey, including a discrete choice experiment (DCE) with physicians. A minimum of 6667 physicians with expertise in the clinical picture of sepsis are contacted for this purpose. The survey is followed by the development of a requirement profile for AI-based CDSS and the derivation of policy recommendations for action, which are evaluated in a (5) expert roundtable discussion. RESULTS The multimethod research project started in November 2022. It provides an overview of the barriers and corresponding solutions related to the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS. Using sepsis as an example, a user-oriented requirement profile for AI-based CDSS is developed. The scoping review has been concluded and the qualitative modules have been subjected to analysis. The start of the survey, including the DCE, was at the end of July 2024. CONCLUSIONS The results of the research project represent the first attempt to create a comprehensive user-oriented requirement profile for the development of sepsis-specific AI-based CDSS. In addition, general recommendations are derived, in order to reduce barriers in the development and implementation of AI-based CDSS. The findings of this research project have the potential to facilitate the integration of AI-based CDSS into standard care in the long term. CLINICALTRIAL INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT DERR1-10.2196/62704