Oriol Pomarol Moya
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Oriol Pomarol Moya has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Derek Karssenberg
Department of Physical Geography, Faculty of Geosciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
11 shared publications - Madlene Nussbaum
Utrecht University, Faculty of Geosciences, Physical Geography, 3584CB Utrecht, The Netherlands
11 shared publications Siamak Mehrkanoon
11 shared publications- Walter Willem Immerzeel
Department of Physical Geography, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands
9 shared publications - Philip D. A. Kraaijenbrink
Department of Physical Geography, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands
8 shared publications - Isabelle Gouttevin
Université Grenoble Alpes, Université de Toulouse, Météo-France, CNRS, CNRM, Centre d’Études de la Neige, Grenoble, France
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Adaptive Resampling for Physics-Informed Neural Networks Using a Spring-Based Node-Moving Method
Partial differential equations (PDEs) are central to modelling physical systems, but their numerical solution can be computationally expensive. Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) are a mesh-free method that embed the governing PDEs into the training loss, yet their accuracy depends strongly on the placement of collocation points. We introduce a spring-based node-moving PINN (sn-PINN) that adaptively redistributes a fixed set of collocation points during training, thereby avoiding the increased computational costs compared to other adaptive refinement strategies. At selected intervals, PDE residuals define local spring stiffnesses in a virtual spring system, whose equilibrium relocates points toward regions where the PDE is harder to satisfy. The method is evaluated on one- and two-dimensional steady-state benchmark PDEs and compared with static and random-resampling PINNs. For problems with steep gradients, sn-PINN consistently improves accuracy, reducing the relative L2 error by up to approximately one order of magnitude compared with the baselines. These results show that residual-driven node movement is an effective fixed-budget adaptive strategy for PINNs, especially for one-dimensional problems with steep gradient, which could be extended to higher-dimensional cases with complex steep-gradient patterns.
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessAdaptive Resampling for Physics-Informed Neural Networks Using a Spring-Based Node-Moving Method
Partial differential equations (PDEs) are central to modelling physical systems, but their numerical solution can be computationally expensive. Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) are a mesh-free method that embed the governing PDEs into the training loss, yet their accuracy depends strongly on the placement of collocation points. We introduce a spring-based node-moving PINN (sn-PINN) that adaptively redistributes a fixed set of collocation points during training, thereby avoiding the increased computational costs compared to other adaptive refinement strategies. At selected intervals, PDE residuals define local spring stiffnesses in a virtual spring system, whose equilibrium relocates points toward regions where the PDE is harder to satisfy. The method is evaluated on one- and two-dimensional steady-state benchmark PDEs and compared with static and random-resampling PINNs. For problems with steep gradients, sn-PINN consistently improves accuracy, reducing the relative L2 error by up to approximately one order of magnitude compared with the baselines. These results show that residual-driven node movement is an effective fixed-budget adaptive strategy for PINNs, especially for one-dimensional problems with steep gradient, which could be extended to higher-dimensional cases with complex steep-gradient patterns.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Creating a high-resolution Northern Hemisphere daily SWE dataset (1980-2020) using Machine Learning
Snow water equivalent (SWE) is an important component of the global hydrological cycle, acting as a primary reservoir for seasonal water storage. Despite its relevance, only few datasets are available that provide long-term daily SWE estimates at global scale. Even amongst the best gridded SWE products, the spatial resolution does not go beyond 10km, a significant limitation considering the large spatial variability of snow. Furthermore, assimilation of snow observations in such products remains another key challenge. Machine learning (ML) models and their combination with process-based simulations, what is known as Hybrid Modelling, offer a promising alternative for producing detailed SWE predictions at large scales, given their high inference speed and adaptability to their training data. Hybrid ML models have already been used for SWE prediction over a small number of sites, improving both pure ML approaches and advanced process-based snow models such as Crocus, but their applicability for long-term spatiotemporal modelling of snow at larger scales remains to be tested.In this project, we trained an LSTM model using in-situ snow data from roughly 10000 sites throughout the Northern Hemisphere with the aim of creating a 40-year gridded dataset of daily SWE at 1 km resolution. The model incorporates temperature, precipitation, and shortwave radiation as meteorological predictors, alongside a small set of topographic variables and land cover classification. Preliminary results show a good fit to stations excluded from the training set, with an RMSE of 44 mm, where unequal distribution of observation locations was accounted for by a weighting scheme. These findings suggest the suitability of this approach for extending coverage to ungauged regions across the Northern Hemisphere. The use of the ERA5-Land SWE product as a hybrid support promises further improvements in model performance.Ultimately, this project aims to provide a finer-scale alternative to existing daily SWE products. By improving the spatial resolution to 1km and incorporating available snow measurements, it contributes to a more refined view of seasonal snow storage across the Northern Hemisphere.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessCreating a high-resolution Northern Hemisphere daily SWE dataset (1980-2020) using Machine Learning
Snow water equivalent (SWE) is an important component of the global hydrological cycle, acting as a primary reservoir for seasonal water storage. Despite its relevance, only few datasets are available that provide long-term daily SWE estimates at global scale. Even amongst the best gridded SWE products, the spatial resolution does not go beyond 10km, a significant limitation considering the large spatial variability of snow. Furthermore, assimilation of snow observations in such products remains another key challenge. Machine learning (ML) models and their combination with process-based simulations, what is known as Hybrid Modelling, offer a promising alternative for producing detailed SWE predictions at large scales, given their high inference speed and adaptability to their training data. Hybrid ML models have already been used for SWE prediction over a small number of sites, improving both pure ML approaches and advanced process-based snow models such as Crocus, but their applicability for long-term spatiotemporal modelling of snow at larger scales remains to be tested.In this project, we trained an LSTM model using in-situ snow data from roughly 10000 sites throughout the Northern Hemisphere with the aim of creating a 40-year gridded dataset of daily SWE at 1 km resolution. The model incorporates temperature, precipitation, and shortwave radiation as meteorological predictors, alongside a small set of topographic variables and land cover classification. Preliminary results show a good fit to stations excluded from the training set, with an RMSE of 44 mm, where unequal distribution of observation locations was accounted for by a weighting scheme. These findings suggest the suitability of this approach for extending coverage to ungauged regions across the Northern Hemisphere. The use of the ERA5-Land SWE product as a hybrid support promises further improvements in model performance.Ultimately, this project aims to provide a finer-scale alternative to existing daily SWE products. By improving the spatial resolution to 1km and incorporating available snow measurements, it contributes to a more refined view of seasonal snow storage across the Northern Hemisphere.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Inverse Modelling of Shallow Land Subsidence using a Hybrid Differentiable Physics-Machine Learning Approach
Shallow subsidence is a key problem in many coastal plains, such as those of the Mississippi (U.S.A), the Mekong (Vietnam), Po (Italy), and Rhine deltas (Netherlands). Managing it is as important as managing anticipated sea-level rise. Accurate prediction of shallow land subsidence into the coming century, requires robust parameterization of a series of complexly interacting physical and biochemical processes (leading to consolidation, oxidation, shrinkage), that operate across heterogeneous shallow subsurface conditions. Traditional physics-based models depend on parameters that are difficult to constrain spatially, while purely data-driven approaches might give physically inconsistent results and often lack physical interpretability. We present a hybrid modeling framework that balances this tradeoff by combining a fully differentiable version of the process-based subsidence model Atlantis with neural network components for learning spatial parameter heterogeneity, enabling gradient-based parameter optimization directly from observational data.Our approach converts established isotach consolidation model and peat-oxidation calculation methods into a differentiable computational graph, allowing automatic differentiation to propagate observational constraints through the physics model. This enables joint inversion of spatially distributed InSAR-derived observations and vertical extensometer profiles to constrain process parameters at voxel scale. Crucially, we incorporate observation uncertainty (the full variance-covariance structure) of InSAR-derived measurements through a statistically rigorous loss function (Mahalanobis distance), properly accounting for spatial and temporal correlations that traditional calibration approaches neglect. First results confirm that the framework can recover peat oxidation parameters from synthetic subsidence observations; integration of InSAR-derived data with full uncertainty characterization is underway.The differentiable architecture offers several advantages: 1) principled uncertainty quantification by accounting for the error structure of input observations, 2) efficient optimization through gradient descent rather than computationally expensive sampling methods, and 3) flexible integration of heterogeneous data sources within a unified modeling framework. We demonstrate the approach spatially, using various observations for a long-managed mainly agricultural peat meadow polder (Krimpenerwaard, The Netherlands; current average elevation 1.5 m below MSL and sinking). Our methodology bridges geodetic remote sensing with process-based geotechnical modeling, contributing to improved projections of coastal relative sea-level rise by constraining subsurface processes at operationally relevant scales. The approach is computationally efficient and can be scaled to larger areas and longer timeframes, depending on the availability of novel InSAR-derived observations and subsurface data.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessInverse Modelling of Shallow Land Subsidence using a Hybrid Differentiable Physics-Machine Learning Approach
Shallow subsidence is a key problem in many coastal plains, such as those of the Mississippi (U.S.A), the Mekong (Vietnam), Po (Italy), and Rhine deltas (Netherlands). Managing it is as important as managing anticipated sea-level rise. Accurate prediction of shallow land subsidence into the coming century, requires robust parameterization of a series of complexly interacting physical and biochemical processes (leading to consolidation, oxidation, shrinkage), that operate across heterogeneous shallow subsurface conditions. Traditional physics-based models depend on parameters that are difficult to constrain spatially, while purely data-driven approaches might give physically inconsistent results and often lack physical interpretability. We present a hybrid modeling framework that balances this tradeoff by combining a fully differentiable version of the process-based subsidence model Atlantis with neural network components for learning spatial parameter heterogeneity, enabling gradient-based parameter optimization directly from observational data.Our approach converts established isotach consolidation model and peat-oxidation calculation methods into a differentiable computational graph, allowing automatic differentiation to propagate observational constraints through the physics model. This enables joint inversion of spatially distributed InSAR-derived observations and vertical extensometer profiles to constrain process parameters at voxel scale. Crucially, we incorporate observation uncertainty (the full variance-covariance structure) of InSAR-derived measurements through a statistically rigorous loss function (Mahalanobis distance), properly accounting for spatial and temporal correlations that traditional calibration approaches neglect. First results confirm that the framework can recover peat oxidation parameters from synthetic subsidence observations; integration of InSAR-derived data with full uncertainty characterization is underway.The differentiable architecture offers several advantages: 1) principled uncertainty quantification by accounting for the error structure of input observations, 2) efficient optimization through gradient descent rather than computationally expensive sampling methods, and 3) flexible integration of heterogeneous data sources within a unified modeling framework. We demonstrate the approach spatially, using various observations for a long-managed mainly agricultural peat meadow polder (Krimpenerwaard, The Netherlands; current average elevation 1.5 m below MSL and sinking). Our methodology bridges geodetic remote sensing with process-based geotechnical modeling, contributing to improved projections of coastal relative sea-level rise by constraining subsurface processes at operationally relevant scales. The approach is computationally efficient and can be scaled to larger areas and longer timeframes, depending on the availability of novel InSAR-derived observations and subsurface data.
- Open Access
- 3 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 20 (2) , 1427-1444
Improving snow water equivalent modelling: a comparative study of hybrid machine learning techniques
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE simulation, but those still suffer from biases in their predictions, have long run times and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been recent attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE predictions from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluated two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data-augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches were deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and an ML setup using measured data only. The post processing setup outperformed all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performed poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in this setup resulted in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbated the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performed slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10 %. The feature importances of the ML-models were consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which showed some improvement for the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables improved the results, but were only relevant for few variables and up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, suggesting their potential to improve forecasts of SWE at large spatio-temporal scales, where they remain to be tested.
- 3 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 20 (2) , 1427-1444
Open AccessImproving snow water equivalent modelling: a comparative study of hybrid machine learning techniques
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE simulation, but those still suffer from biases in their predictions, have long run times and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been recent attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE predictions from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluated two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data-augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches were deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and an ML setup using measured data only. The post processing setup outperformed all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performed poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in this setup resulted in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbated the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performed slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10 %. The feature importances of the ML-models were consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which showed some improvement for the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables improved the results, but were only relevant for few variables and up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, suggesting their potential to improve forecasts of SWE at large spatio-temporal scales, where they remain to be tested.
- Open Access
- 12 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Reply on RC2
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- 12 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Open AccessReply on RC2
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Comment on egusphere-2025-1845
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- 4 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-1845
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Reply on RC1
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- 21 July 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Open AccessReply on RC1
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- Open Access
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Comment on egusphere-2025-1845
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-1845
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- Open Access
- 5 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Improving forecasts of snow water equivalent with hybrid machine learning
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- 5 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-23
Open AccessImproving forecasts of snow water equivalent with hybrid machine learning
Accurate characterization of snow water equivalent (SWE) is important for water resource management in large parts of the Northern Hemisphere, but its large spatio-temporal variability and limited observational data make it difficult to quantify. Complex physically-based models have been developed that allow long-term SWE prediction, including scenarios without snowpack observations or in future events. However, those still suffer from large errors in their simulations, have long run times at large scales and provide challenges for integrating observational data. There have been attempts at using machine learning (ML) to improve SWE forecasting from meteorological data with promising results, but the data scarcity issue and concerns about the ability to extrapolate in time and space remain. In this study, we evaluate two hybrid setups that integrate physically-based simulations and ML. The first setup, referred to as post-processing, follows a common approach in which the simulated outputs from a numerical snow model, Crocus, are used as predictors to the ML component in addition to the meteorological data. The second setup, named data augmentation, involves an ML model trained not only on measured SWE but also on Crocus-simulated SWE at additional locations. These approaches are deployed using in-situ meteorological and SWE measurements available at ten stations throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and compared to Crocus and a ML setup using measured data only. The results show that the post processing setup outperforms all other approaches when predicting on left-out years in the training stations, but performs poorly when extrapolating to other locations compared to Crocus. The addition of a large set of Crocus-simulated variables besides SWE in the post-processing setup results in similar performance for left-out years but exacerbates the spatial extrapolation issue. On the other hand, the data-augmentation setup performs slightly worse on the left-out years, but showed much better transferability to new locations, improving the other ML-based setups greatly and reducing the RMSE in Crocus by more than 10%. The feature importances of the ML-models are consistent with physical knowledge, despite having unusual deviations at extreme values, which could be further improved with the data-augmentation setup. Lastly, the addition of lagged variables results in improved results, but they are only relevant for up to a week. These results prove the usefulness of hybrid models and particularly the data-augmentation setup for SWE prediction even in data-scarce domains, which has the potential to improve forecasts of SWE at unprecedented spatio-temporal scales.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Bridging machine learning and physics-based models for improving snow water equivalent predictions in the northern hemisphere
Snow water equivalent (SWE) is an important component of the hydrological cycle but still faces large uncertainties in its quantification due to its high temporal and spatial variability. While machine learning (ML) has been applied to multiple domains in hydrology, its use for SWE prediction has been hindered by limited observational training data beyond the local scale. Hybrid models that integrate simulated data from physics-based models with a ML setup may overcome this lack of observations, outperforming both physics-based models and conventional ML approaches in data-scarce regions.In this project, we tested two different hybrid ML setups that predict the daily change in SWE using Crocus snow model simulations together with data from ten meteorological and snow observation stations throughout the northern hemisphere containing 7-20 years of data. The first setup follows a common post-processor approach where the outputs and state variables from Crocus are fed as additional predictors to the ML model at each time step. The second setup follows the concept of data augmentation, where Crocus is used to simulate SWE for stations for which no observations are available. These simulations are then fed as additional data points to the ML model, but are weighted in the loss function to control their influence during training.The obtained results show that the post-processor approach is best suited for predicting SWE in years excluded during training. However, when predicting SWE in untrained stations the data augmentation setup achieves the largest increase in performance, reducing the root mean squared error by 22% compared to Crocus and by 42% compared to the measurement-based ML model. A feature importance analysis reveals that the hybrid model predictions are influenced the most by the current SWE status, incoming radiation, snowfall and air temperature. These results showcase the potential of hybrid models for predicting variables that suffer from data scarcity such as SWE.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessBridging machine learning and physics-based models for improving snow water equivalent predictions in the northern hemisphere
Snow water equivalent (SWE) is an important component of the hydrological cycle but still faces large uncertainties in its quantification due to its high temporal and spatial variability. While machine learning (ML) has been applied to multiple domains in hydrology, its use for SWE prediction has been hindered by limited observational training data beyond the local scale. Hybrid models that integrate simulated data from physics-based models with a ML setup may overcome this lack of observations, outperforming both physics-based models and conventional ML approaches in data-scarce regions.In this project, we tested two different hybrid ML setups that predict the daily change in SWE using Crocus snow model simulations together with data from ten meteorological and snow observation stations throughout the northern hemisphere containing 7-20 years of data. The first setup follows a common post-processor approach where the outputs and state variables from Crocus are fed as additional predictors to the ML model at each time step. The second setup follows the concept of data augmentation, where Crocus is used to simulate SWE for stations for which no observations are available. These simulations are then fed as additional data points to the ML model, but are weighted in the loss function to control their influence during training.The obtained results show that the post-processor approach is best suited for predicting SWE in years excluded during training. However, when predicting SWE in untrained stations the data augmentation setup achieves the largest increase in performance, reducing the root mean squared error by 22% compared to Crocus and by 42% compared to the measurement-based ML model. A feature importance analysis reveals that the hybrid model predictions are influenced the most by the current SWE status, incoming radiation, snowfall and air temperature. These results showcase the potential of hybrid models for predicting variables that suffer from data scarcity such as SWE.