YNYa. S. Naumova

Ya. S. Naumova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Ya. S. Naumova has a total of 73 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Staffing of primary healthcare facilities: results of the MOTIV-2025 study in the Commonwealth of Independent States

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. Sh. Senenko, E. D. Savchenko, N. N. Brimkulov, M. M. Sachek, A. V. Korotkova, G. K. Azhimambetova, A. K. Asanova, E. I. Botbayeva, et al.

       Aim. To analyze staffing parameters for primary health care (PHC) in countries participating in the international research project "Implementation of Measures to Motivate and Incentive Employees of Healthcare Organizations Providing Primary Healthcare in the Commonwealth of Independent States (MOTIV-CIS)".    Material and Methods. This article is a continuation of the results of a study conducted in 4 Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) member states in 2025, titled MOTIV-CIS. This article presents an analysis of the staffing levels of pilot health facilities in the participating countries. Statistical (descriptive statistics) methods were used .    Results. In the pilot health facilities of the participating countries, staffing levels for physicians were most frequently < 90 %. Regarding nursing staff, in the Republic of Belarus and the Kyrgyz Republic, this figure was 49% and 56% of all pilot health facilities, respectively. An exception is the Russian Federation, where the share of pilot MOs with nursing staff levels < 89 % is 69 %. Regarding the "record keepers" category, the distribution of results differs as follows: in the Republic of Belarus and the Russian Federation, high staffing levels are more common, accounting for 72 % and 68 %, respectively. Only in the Kyrgyz Republic did this figure reach 42 %. Against the background of a significant spread in modified employee turnover rates (ETR), particular attention was drawn to the most "favorable" groups of pilot health facilities — those with high staffing levels and positive or stable changes. Spearman's rank correlation analysis revealed no correlation between staffing levels and ETR values for any personnel category.    Conclusion. Differences were identified in the staffing levels for various personnel categories and in ETRs across the pilot health facilities of the participating countries. The results indicate the advisability of taking into account differences in staffing planning across personnel groups in organizations providing primary health care. This, along with previously established differences in staff motivation, will allow for more targeted work with each personnel category to achieve better health outcomes for the population. The use of the ETR is promising for forecasting the human resource situation in specific health facilities.

  • Staff motivation from medical organizations providing primary health care in the Commonwealth of Independent States. Part 2: results of a survey of employees with secondary medical education

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. Sh. Senenko, E. D. Savchenko, N. N. Brimculov, M. M. Sachek, A. V. Korotkova, G. K. Azhymambetova, A. K. Asanova, Zh. S. Botagarina, et al.


  • A review of the development of various primary health care aspects in the context of national health systems of the Commonwealth of Independent States: human resources

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. V. Korotkova, Ya. S. Naumova, I. E. Tytskiy, E. D. Savchenko, A. Sh. Senenko, G. O. Akhverdiev, A. A. Shcharbinsky, M. M. Sachek, et al.

    This review analyzes the human resources of primary health care (PHC). It is part of a series of reviews on various PHC aspects (organizational, management, resources, financing, digitalization, and outcomes. It was compiled to assess the potential for using international experience and evidence-based recommendations to ensure that PHC is provided with trained and efficiently organized human resources in the member states of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS). To compile the review, publications (with an emphasis on evidence-based reviews and methodological documents), regulatory documents, and online resources were selected using selected keywords and concepts related to the human resources aspect of PHC and its characteristics, as well as considering the criterion of potential impact on the outcomes of PHC provision. The article presents the results of a review of primary health care personnel in the context of the health system, including the implementation of recommendations for improving human resources with proven effectiveness, selected during the review process, in CIS member states.    Particular attention to the potential of primary health care personal to implement the principle of permanence (continuity, succession, consistency) of health care allowed us to systematize the approaches used in the selected CIS countries for its implementation. All the review articles in this series address the transition from a "radar" principle associated with the concept of a "completed case of care" to continuous and ongoing permanent management by a local team of specialists to assist patients in managing their health throughout their lives. This approach allowed to conclude that the permanent provision of primary health care, based on patient cooperation and the use of evidence- based self-care and digital technologies, including telemedicine, helps to address the problem of PHC personnel shortage.


  • Staff motivation from medical organizations providing primary health care in the Commonwealth of Independent States. Part 1: results of a survey of doctors

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. Sh. Senenko, E. D. Savchenko, G. K. Azhimambetova, N. N. Brimkulov, Zh. S. Botagarina, E. I. Botbayeva, Z. A. Dolonbayeva, A. V. Korotkova, et al.

       Aim.  To analyze the results of a survey of physicians from health facilities in countries participating in the project "Implementation of Measures to Motivate and Incentive Employees of Primary Health Care Organizations in the Member States of the Commonwealth of Independent States" regarding the relevance of financial and non-financial incentives.    Material and methods. The study was based on the results of a survey of physicians from the Republic of Belarus, the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Kyrgyz Republic, and the Russian Federation working in primary health care organizations. The research supervisor developed a special questionnaire.    Results.  The results demonstrated the high importance for physicians of understanding the criteria for evaluating their performance, the importance of creating conditions for achieving these criteria, and maintaining a dialogue with the administration of health facility. Among financial incentives, incentive payments are of primary importance. Among non-material motivational measures, a letter of gratitude from a manager is the most significant. Differences in assessments of motivation and incentive measures across countries for specific items are demonstrated.    Conclusion. The study's results allowed us to identify areas for improving performance evaluation criteria, creating conditions for their implementation, and fostering dialogue with employees. The development of a corporate culture in health facilities providing primary health care appears promising as a means of achieving these goals.


  • Open Access

    Study of general practitioner (family physician) training in the Commonwealth of Independent States

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, O. Yu. Kuznetsova, A. V. Korotkova, N. N. Brimkulov, E. D. Savchenko, G. K. Azhimambetova, F. L. Azizova, H. S. Akhmedov, E. I. Botbaeva, et al.

    Aim . To assess the current status and identify prospects for harmonizing the training of ge­neral practitioners (GP) (family physicians (FP)) in individual members of the Common­wealth of Independent States (CIS) to improve the quality of primary health care (PHC). Material and methods . The study data was collected and analyzed in 2025 by researchers from leading medical universities in the CIS member states as part of the international research project GP-FP using specially developed questionnaires. Research methods inclu­ded statistical, analytical, and contextual comparison. Results . An analysis of regulatory data regarding GP-FP training revealed similar models of ma­naging PHC as the foundation of the entire healthcare system, the systematic GP-FP im­ple­mentation, and the use of the territorial-­district principle, as well as some differences. A comparison of country data on educational and professional standards and residency training programs revealed convergence across most parameters. The country data is sys­tema­tized and presented in tabular format. Conclusion . The significant similarities and some differences in the training and professional activities of GP-FP highlight the potential for harmonizing programs, requirements, and the regulatory framework for training these specialists across the CIS and, accordingly, outlined areas for further research.


  • Open Access

    Results of interviews with chief medical officers: measures of staff motivation in primary health care in the Commonwealth of Independent States

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. Sh. Senenko, E. D. Savchenko, G. K. Azhimambetova, N. N. Brimkulov, E. I. Botbayeva, Z. A. Dolonbayeva, A. V. Korotkova, G. U. Kulkaeva, et al.

    Aim . To analyze the results of interviews with chief medical officers in health facilities in the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) members providing primary health care (PHC) on experience with financial and non- financial incentives for staff. Material and methods . Original interview form was used. The form was available online on a digital platform or on paper. Participation of chief medical officers in the study was strictly voluntary and anonymous. Research methods included sociological, statistical (descriptive statistics), and contextual comparative analysis. Results . The study revealed both common trends and differences in the approaches to motivating the staff of primary healthcare organizations in the project countries. All countries use incentive payments and traditional forms of non-financial recognition, but the range and implementation of additional measures vary significantly. In the Republic of Belarus, social and household support measures and leisure activities are more developed; in the Russian Federation, comprehensive social assistance measures, mentoring, and professional exchanges are more prevalent; and in the Kyrgyz Republic, there is a limited range of social support tools and a low representation of corporate culture elements, while traditional motivation is more prevalent. Differences were also identified in the degree of specificity of performance evaluation criteria, the availability of conditions for their implementation, and the distribution of management practices related to professional development and staff retention. Conclusion . The study identified following areas for developing the management of medical staff motivation: improving the conditions necessary for meeting established performance evaluation criteria, expanding interaction with staff regarding performance assessment, etc.; increasing management's attention to employees' personal professional and career growth, and expanding support measures in various life situations. A promising area is the development of a corporate culture in medical organizations providing primary health care, which primarily requires enhancing related management's knowledge.


  • Open Access

    Review of the development of various aspects of primary health care in the context of national health systems of the Commonwealth of Independent States: the digitalization aspect

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. V. Korotkova, Y. S. Naumova, I. E. Tytsky, G. O. Hagverdiyev, A. A. Shcherbinsky, М. М. Sachek, G. U. Kulkaeva, T. A. Akmatov, et al.

    Обзор развития различных аспектов первичной медико-санитарной помощи в контексте национальных систем здравоохранения государств — участников Содружества Независимых Государств: аспект цифровизации


  • Open Access

    Development of various aspects of primary health care in the context of national health systems of the Commonwealth of Independent States. Part 2: management of primary health care subsystems, structural elements, processes

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. V. Korotkova, Yu. S. Naumova, G. O. Hagverdiyev, A. A. Shcherbinsky, M. M. Sachek, G. U. Kulkaeva, N. N. Brimkulov, G. M. Muhsinzoda, et al.

    Based on an analytical review of information sources on the status and development of various aspects of primary health care (PHC) in the world and in selected countries, as well as international evidence-based recommendations in a series of reviews, to assess international experience and guidelines for the development of PHC in selected members of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), in particular, with respect to the management aspect. To prepare the review, a database of publications, regulatory legal documents and Internet resources was used based on selected keywords and concepts related to the management of PHC and its characteristics. Priority was given to last decade materials concerning the CIS member states. The characteristics of national PHC management were identified, systematized and arranged in following sections: principles of PHC subsystems, structural elements, processes. The second part presents the analysis of the development of PHC management and its characteristics, including the implementation of recommendations with proven effectiveness in the CIS member states. The analysis of sources on the experience of the CIS member states in the medical examination and follow-up of patients with chronic diseases gave grounds to propose a more precise name for continuous health care in managing health throughout life — the principle of permanence.


  • Open Access

    Review of the development of various primary health care aspects in the context of national health systems of the member states of the Commonwealth of Independent States. Part 1: Organizational aspect

    by O. M. Drapkina, R. N. Shepel, A. V. Korotkova, Yu. S. Naumova, G. O. Hagverdiyev, A. A. Shcherbinsky, M. M. Sachek, G. U. Kulkaeva, N. N. Brimkulov, G. M. Muhsinzoda, et al.

    The article based on an analytical review of information sources on the status and development of various aspects of primary health care (PHC) in the world and in selected countries, as well as international evidencebased recommendations, to assess the prospects of using international experience and recommendations for the development of PHC in the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) member states with regard to the organizational aspect, which is considered in this article.A database of scientific publications, regulatory legal documents, and Internet resources was used with an emphasis on evidence-based reviews and methodological documents that were included on the basis of selected keywords and concepts related to organization aspect of health systems and PHC and characteristics, as well as by the criteria of potential impact on the results of PHC provision. Priority in the search was given to materials from the last decade and to the countries with similar models of health systems.The characteristics of the main aspects of national PHC subsystems — organizational, management, resources, financing, digitalization and results — were identified, systematized and ordered in the structure of the PHC characteristics matrices in the selected countries.This two-part article presents results of an analysis of the development of the organizational aspect of PHC and its characteristics, including the implementation of recommendations selected in the review process with proven effectiveness in the CIS member states.Analysis of the development since 2002 of the WHO idea of the transition of the PHC subsystem organization from the "radar" principle associated with the concept of "completed case of medical care" to the continuous and permanent management of patients with chronic diseases by a team of specialists, as well as the experience of the CIS member states in the medical examination of the attached population and dispensary supervision (implementation of management programs) for patients with chronic diseases gave reason to propose an updated name for the principle of constant medical care in managing people health throughout their lives — the principle of "permanence". And also suggest using it not only in the management of chronic conditions,