PMPolly Evans McGinn

Polly Evans McGinn

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Polly Evans McGinn has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Identified child maltreatment and domestic abuse in child welfare service investigations

    by Rakel Aasheim Greve, Birgitta Persdotter, Polly Faith Evans Mcginn, Karl Ove Hufthammer

    BackgroundChild maltreatment and domestic abuse pose major risks to children’s health and development. Child welfare services (CWS) are central to identifying such violence, yet little is known about what is actually documented in investigations.ObjectiveTo examine which types of violence and perpetrators are identified in Norwegian child welfare investigations and how identification is associated with case characteristics.Participants and SettingAll investigations initiated based on suspected child maltreatment or domestic abuse, from 18 CWS between September 2024 and February 2025.MethodsCaseworkers completed a web-based questionnaire. Descriptive statistics are reported. Multiple logistic regression was used to investigate the association with case characteristics.ResultsA total of 725 investigations was included (children aged 0–17 years; mean 8.4 years; 55% boys). Violence was identified in 55% of the investigations. Overall, domestic abuse was identified in 35%, physical violence in 27%, emotional abuse in 16%, abusive caregiving in 4%, negative social control in 2% and sexual violence in 1%. When sexual violence was suspected in the referral, only 11% of investigations resulted in identification of this type of violence, compared to 55% for domestic abuse and 48% for physical violence. Parents were perpetrators in 92% of the cases with violence – fathers alone in 44%, mothers alone in 19%. Child maltreatment was more frequently identified in cases with older children (≥ 7 years). Domestic abuse was less frequently identified when the child had a disability (OR 0.41, 95% CI 0.18–0.84, P = 0.01).ConclusionsAbout half of violence-related referrals resulted in identification of violence, most often domestic abuse or physical child maltreatment, while sexual violence was rarely substantiated, indicating potential under-identification.

  • Open Access

    Children’s voices in child welfare assessment. An exploratory quantitative study of children’s participation in Norwegian child welfare expert reports

    by Polly Evans McGinn, Dag Øystein Nordanger, Magne Olav Mæhle, Øivin Christiansen, Hanne Cecilie Braarud

  • Open Access

    Conceptions of participation in child protection care assessments—A discourse analysis of independent experts accounts

    by Tone Jørgensen, Rakel Aasheim Greve, Polly Evans McGinn, Øivin Christiansen

    Although there is a growing knowledge base on children’s participation in child welfare, little research has examined the child’s position as a participant in child protection assessments undertaken by independent experts. Independent experts are commonly used in child protection care proceedings to assess families and contribute to a sound basis for care order decisions. Their reports are highly influential in the child welfare decision-making process. Based on twelve qualitative interviews with independent experts, we explore accounts of their practices of involving children in their investigation. Using a discursive approach, we analyse how the experts use various interpretative repertoires about children’s participation to reason about the position of themselves and the child as participants in the care assessment. Our analysis demonstrates four distinct positions in their discursive constructions of children’s participation. These are the protector position, the investigator position, the facilitator position, and the non-therapist position, each with a distinct interpretation repertoire. The article discusses these in relation to the specific practice context that independent expert care assessments are a part of. Further, we argue for an increased awareness of how conceptualizations of participation simultaneously contribute to what positions become available for children as participants in an independent expert care assessment.


  • Open Access

    Utilisation of a cultural perspective in child welfare expert assessments in Norway

    by Polly Evans McGinn, Dag Øystein Nordanger, Magne Olav Mæhle, Øivin Christiansen, Hanne Cecilie Braarud

    In Norway, legislation requires consideration of a child’s culture in all phases of child welfare work. Through a quantitative content analysis of 285 child welfare expert assessment reports, we explored experts’ utilisation of a cultural perspective, comparing reports concerning immigrant and non-immigrant background children. We found that experts were rarely instructed to employ a cultural perspective but do so more frequently in reports concerning immigrant than non-immigrant background children. We found little evidence of critical reflection and interpreters were used rarely. The article discusses the possible explanations for and implications of a limited cultural perspective in child welfare expert assessments.


  • Open Access

    Expert reports: an empirical study of the use of attachment theory in expert assessments in Norwegian child protection cases

    by Hanne Cecilie Braarud, Polly Faith Evans Mcginn, Dag Øystein Nordanger, Øivin Christiansen, Magne Olav Mæhle

    Acknowledged researchers have highlighted the potential pitfalls of using attachment theory to guide decision-making in child protection (CP) cases. This study explores how attachment theory is applied in expert assessments in Norwegian CP decision-making processes, analyzing 285 independent expert reports. Independent experts were mandated to assess the child's attachment quality to the caregiver in one third of the reports. In almost two thirds of the reports, experts weighted the child's attachment quality to the caregiver in their concluding evaluation. Few expert assessments included the employment of attachment measures. When descriptively comparing older and newer reports, there were more newer reports that mandated the experts to assess the child's attachment quality, but fewer newer reports where the experts weighted the child's attachment quality in the concluding evaluation. Our results illustrate that the criticism of an overconfindent use of attachment theory is also relevant for independet expert assessment in CP cases.