Bernhard Lüttgenau
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Bernhard Lüttgenau has a total of 46 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Oleg Kostko
Center for X-ray Optics, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, United States
3 shared publications - Sascha Brose
RWTH Aachen University, Chair for Technology of Optical Systems, Aachen, Germany
3 shared publications - Carlo Holly
Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology ILT 1 , Aachen 52070
2 shared publications - Cheng Wang
Advanced Light Source, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, USA
2 shared publications Honggu Im
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, United States
2 shared publications- Jochen Stollenwerk
RWTH Aachen Univ. (Germany)
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 9 October 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
Monolithic lithium niobate bimorph x-ray mirrors: design, modeling, and experimental validation
Recent studies have introduced monolithic piezoelectric mirrors made of lithium niobate for X-ray beam control. We present prototypes of monolithic bimorph mirrors constructed from a single wafer of lithium niobate featuring symmetric, longitudinally continuous, shaped electrodes designed to modulate local curvature upon voltage application. This paper details their design, fabrication, and testing. Experimental results demonstrate a highly deterministic and linear central curvature response to the applied voltage (R² ≥ 0.9988, p < 0.05), yielding actuation sensitivities of 1.1 × 10−⁵ m−¹/V and 1.3 × 10−⁵ m−¹/V for third- and fourth-order target profiles, respectively. Furthermore, we highlight critical fabrication challenges regarding domain inversion depth control and process-induced wafer deformation, providing key insights for future monolithic adaptive optics designs.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
Monolithic lithium niobate bimorph x-ray mirrors: design, modeling, and experimental validation
Recent studies have introduced monolithic piezoelectric mirrors made of lithium niobate for X-ray beam control. We present prototypes of monolithic bimorph mirrors constructed from a single wafer of lithium niobate featuring symmetric, longitudinally continuous, shaped electrodes designed to modulate local curvature upon voltage application. This paper details their design, fabrication, and testing. Experimental results demonstrate a highly deterministic and linear central curvature response to the applied voltage (R² ≥ 0.9988, p < 0.05), yielding actuation sensitivities of 1.1 × 10−⁵ m−¹/V and 1.3 × 10−⁵ m−¹/V for third- and fourth-order target profiles, respectively. Furthermore, we highlight critical fabrication challenges regarding domain inversion depth control and process-induced wafer deformation, providing key insights for future monolithic adaptive optics designs.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 25 (03) , 1-8
Unveiling chemical heterogeneity in underlayer materials via resonant soft X-ray reflectivity
BackgroundUnderlayers (ULs) play a critical role in the performance of photoresist systems used in extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography. Positioned between the resist and substrate, they influence adhesion, reflectivity, interfacial stability, and overall pattern fidelity. As EUV lithography progresses toward sub-10 nm patterning, the design and optimization of ULs have become increasingly important for mitigating stochastic effects. However, a comprehensive understanding of UL functionality is still lacking.AimOur goal is to develop a nondestructive methodology to characterize the chemical profile of underlayer materials, which is essential for understanding their functional role in EUV lithography.ApproachWe employ resonant soft X-ray reflectivity (RSoXR) near the carbon K-edge to quantitatively probe depth-dependent compositional variations in representative UL films. By tuning the X-ray energy across element-specific absorption edges, RSoXR with enhanced chemical contrast, enables direct observation of chemical heterogeneity within the underlayer.ResultsWe performed RSoXR measurements on spin-on glass (SOG) samples prepared under different curing conditions. A matrix-method algorithm was used to model the X-ray reflectivity and extract the corresponding optical constants and depth profiles. The simulated profiles indicate that the two curing methods result in different levels of curing uniformity, with light-cured SOGs exhibiting clear chemical heterogeneity.ConclusionsOur results highlight the capability of RSoXR to resolve subtle chemical variations in depth profile. This nondestructive metrology can be further extended to investigate EUV resists and UL-resist interfacial behavior, offering a comprehensive understanding of materials evolution throughout EUV lithography processes.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 25 (03) , 1-8
Unveiling chemical heterogeneity in underlayer materials via resonant soft X-ray reflectivity
BackgroundUnderlayers (ULs) play a critical role in the performance of photoresist systems used in extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography. Positioned between the resist and substrate, they influence adhesion, reflectivity, interfacial stability, and overall pattern fidelity. As EUV lithography progresses toward sub-10 nm patterning, the design and optimization of ULs have become increasingly important for mitigating stochastic effects. However, a comprehensive understanding of UL functionality is still lacking.AimOur goal is to develop a nondestructive methodology to characterize the chemical profile of underlayer materials, which is essential for understanding their functional role in EUV lithography.ApproachWe employ resonant soft X-ray reflectivity (RSoXR) near the carbon K-edge to quantitatively probe depth-dependent compositional variations in representative UL films. By tuning the X-ray energy across element-specific absorption edges, RSoXR with enhanced chemical contrast, enables direct observation of chemical heterogeneity within the underlayer.ResultsWe performed RSoXR measurements on spin-on glass (SOG) samples prepared under different curing conditions. A matrix-method algorithm was used to model the X-ray reflectivity and extract the corresponding optical constants and depth profiles. The simulated profiles indicate that the two curing methods result in different levels of curing uniformity, with light-cured SOGs exhibiting clear chemical heterogeneity.ConclusionsOur results highlight the capability of RSoXR to resolve subtle chemical variations in depth profile. This nondestructive metrology can be further extended to investigate EUV resists and UL-resist interfacial behavior, offering a comprehensive understanding of materials evolution throughout EUV lithography processes.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 25 (02) , 1-16
High-throughput analysis of total electron yield and outgassing under EUV exposure for accelerated photoresist materials discovery
BackgroundAs technology nodes shrink, extreme ultraviolet (EUV) photoresists are essential for high-resolution nanopatterning. Incident photons, as well as electrons generated during EUV exposure can cause both intended and unintended chemical reactions. Understanding these processes is critical for improving resist performance.AimThis study investigates how resist components, particularly photoacid generators (PAGs) and photo decomposable quenchers (PDQ), influence photon- and electron-induced chemistry. It also aims to develop a high-throughput characterization method for efficient screening of novel materials.ApproachA high-throughput system combining total electron yield (TEY) and residual gas analysis (RGA) was developed. TEY measures electron generation and capture, while RGA monitors chemical transformations via outgassing. The method is applied to model resists.ResultsTEY and outgassing analysis revealed that PAGs and PDQs strongly influence electron behavior and outgassing characteristics. The high-throughput system enabled the rapid screening of up to 50 samples, providing detailed insights into resist chemistry and performance.ConclusionsThe developed technique offers a powerful tool for understanding photon and electron interactions with model resists and accelerating the discovery of next-generation EUV photoresists.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 25 (02) , 1-16
High-throughput analysis of total electron yield and outgassing under EUV exposure for accelerated photoresist materials discovery
BackgroundAs technology nodes shrink, extreme ultraviolet (EUV) photoresists are essential for high-resolution nanopatterning. Incident photons, as well as electrons generated during EUV exposure can cause both intended and unintended chemical reactions. Understanding these processes is critical for improving resist performance.AimThis study investigates how resist components, particularly photoacid generators (PAGs) and photo decomposable quenchers (PDQ), influence photon- and electron-induced chemistry. It also aims to develop a high-throughput characterization method for efficient screening of novel materials.ApproachA high-throughput system combining total electron yield (TEY) and residual gas analysis (RGA) was developed. TEY measures electron generation and capture, while RGA monitors chemical transformations via outgassing. The method is applied to model resists.ResultsTEY and outgassing analysis revealed that PAGs and PDQs strongly influence electron behavior and outgassing characteristics. The high-throughput system enabled the rapid screening of up to 50 samples, providing detailed insights into resist chemistry and performance.ConclusionsThe developed technique offers a powerful tool for understanding photon and electron interactions with model resists and accelerating the discovery of next-generation EUV photoresists.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2025
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 24 (03) , 1-11
High-precision monitoring of outgassing species in model extreme ultraviolet photoresists with a cavity ring-down spectrometer
BackgroundExtreme ultraviolet (EUV) photoresists play a pivotal role in advancing nanopatterning technologies by balancing image quality and sensitivity. The outgassing behavior of photoresist thin films under EUV and deep ultraviolet (DUV) exposure reveals chemical details relevant to their performance.AimWe focus on utilizing an analytical technique not previously used in photolithography, the tabletop cavity ring-down spectrometer, to investigate outgassing dynamics in EUV photoresists, enabling precise chemical identification and deeper insights into resist processing.ApproachThe spectrometer’s enhanced laser path length (∼20 km) and broadband absorption capabilities in the C–H overtone region allow for sensitive and temporally resolved detection of mixtures of outgassed species. Using a model resist comprising a polymer matrix with a photoacid generator and quencher, we analyzed the influence of time delays between exposure and post-exposure bake (PEB) as well as storage under varying environmental conditions.ResultsSuppression of isobutylene outgassing and thickness loss was observed with extended delays between exposure and PEB, potentially linked to water absorption and acid deactivation. The technique proved highly effective in distinguishing subtle chemical differences between processing stages.ConclusionsDelay times and their environmental conditions, particularly humidity, reduce outgassing and thickness loss of photoresists during PEB, suggesting decreased acid-driven deprotection. This can potentially impact sensitivity, defectivity, and roughness of resist patterns, necessitating precise monitoring and control.
- 1 July 2025
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 24 (03) , 1-11
Open AccessHigh-precision monitoring of outgassing species in model extreme ultraviolet photoresists with a cavity ring-down spectrometer
BackgroundExtreme ultraviolet (EUV) photoresists play a pivotal role in advancing nanopatterning technologies by balancing image quality and sensitivity. The outgassing behavior of photoresist thin films under EUV and deep ultraviolet (DUV) exposure reveals chemical details relevant to their performance.AimWe focus on utilizing an analytical technique not previously used in photolithography, the tabletop cavity ring-down spectrometer, to investigate outgassing dynamics in EUV photoresists, enabling precise chemical identification and deeper insights into resist processing.ApproachThe spectrometer’s enhanced laser path length (∼20 km) and broadband absorption capabilities in the C–H overtone region allow for sensitive and temporally resolved detection of mixtures of outgassed species. Using a model resist comprising a polymer matrix with a photoacid generator and quencher, we analyzed the influence of time delays between exposure and post-exposure bake (PEB) as well as storage under varying environmental conditions.ResultsSuppression of isobutylene outgassing and thickness loss was observed with extended delays between exposure and PEB, potentially linked to water absorption and acid deactivation. The technique proved highly effective in distinguishing subtle chemical differences between processing stages.ConclusionsDelay times and their environmental conditions, particularly humidity, reduce outgassing and thickness loss of photoresists during PEB, suggesting decreased acid-driven deprotection. This can potentially impact sensitivity, defectivity, and roughness of resist patterns, necessitating precise monitoring and control.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2024
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 23 (04) , 043002-11
Achromatic Talbot lithography with partially coherent extreme ultraviolet radiation: mask and illumination parameter optimization
Dense periodic nanostructures with feature sizes below 100 nm are essential for numerous industrial and scientific applications, such as photoresist qualification for achieving high resolution1,2 and the creation of high-resolution structures to produce, e.g., metamaterials, biosensors, quantum dot arrays, and artificial crystals.3 – 5 Fabricating these nanostructures is a complex task, requiring advanced patterning technologies such as electron beam lithography, nanoimprint lithography, or industrial projection lithography for structure definition. Each method has its strengths and limitations. Electron beam lithography offers high resolution but suffers from limited throughput. Nanoimprint lithography provides high throughput but lacks pattern fidelity for large-area nanopatterning. Industrial projection lithography ensures high pattern fidelity and throughput, but its application is mostly limited to major companies in the semiconductor industry due to high investment and operational costs. Qualifying next-generation photoresists for extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography presents even greater challenges as it often demands resolutions beyond the state of the art. Research on photoresists and related processing relies mostly on high-volume manufacturing (HVM) tools6 and synchrotron facilities.7 – 10 To optimize the photoresist development process and ensure quality control, systematic investigations on the achievable sensitivity, contrast, and resolution are necessary. However, using HVM tools for these tasks is often impractical due to their high operational cost and complexity, so operating such tools at the resist supplier’s site is not feasible. Synchrotrons provide spatial and temporal coherent EUV radiation with high intensity and allow for lithographic approaches such as dual-grating interference lithography, leading to the highest demonstrated resolution.9 Despite their advantages, the limited number of synchrotron facilities and the limited availability of beamtime slow down the corresponding research and development, resulting in a long lead time for new products.
- 1 October 2024
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 23 (04) , 043002-11
Open AccessAchromatic Talbot lithography with partially coherent extreme ultraviolet radiation: mask and illumination parameter optimization
Dense periodic nanostructures with feature sizes below 100 nm are essential for numerous industrial and scientific applications, such as photoresist qualification for achieving high resolution1,2 and the creation of high-resolution structures to produce, e.g., metamaterials, biosensors, quantum dot arrays, and artificial crystals.3 – 5 Fabricating these nanostructures is a complex task, requiring advanced patterning technologies such as electron beam lithography, nanoimprint lithography, or industrial projection lithography for structure definition. Each method has its strengths and limitations. Electron beam lithography offers high resolution but suffers from limited throughput. Nanoimprint lithography provides high throughput but lacks pattern fidelity for large-area nanopatterning. Industrial projection lithography ensures high pattern fidelity and throughput, but its application is mostly limited to major companies in the semiconductor industry due to high investment and operational costs. Qualifying next-generation photoresists for extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography presents even greater challenges as it often demands resolutions beyond the state of the art. Research on photoresists and related processing relies mostly on high-volume manufacturing (HVM) tools6 and synchrotron facilities.7 – 10 To optimize the photoresist development process and ensure quality control, systematic investigations on the achievable sensitivity, contrast, and resolution are necessary. However, using HVM tools for these tasks is often impractical due to their high operational cost and complexity, so operating such tools at the resist supplier’s site is not feasible. Synchrotrons provide spatial and temporal coherent EUV radiation with high intensity and allow for lithographic approaches such as dual-grating interference lithography, leading to the highest demonstrated resolution.9 Despite their advantages, the limited number of synchrotron facilities and the limited availability of beamtime slow down the corresponding research and development, resulting in a long lead time for new products.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (02) , 021208-12
Latent image characterization by spectroscopic reflectometry in the extreme ultraviolet
Background: In the extreme ultaviolet (EUV) lithography process the performance of the photoresist is a crucial factor regarding the quality and critical dimensions of the fabricated structures. Aim: The characterization of the latent image structures in photoresists during the process steps before the development of the resist is key to understand the relation between the material of the resists, the selection of process parameters, and the resulting quality of fabricated structures. Approach: Spectroscopic EUV reflectometry is a nondestructive metrology technique that measures the broadband reflectance of samples in the EUV spectral range and under grazing incidence angles. The technique offers a combination of high sensitivity to nanoscale structural parameters of periodic structures as well as a high sensitivity to the material composition samples, enabling the characterization of latent images of periodic structures. Results: Measurements of the reflectance of an EUV-exposed and unexposed photoresist reveal the contrast in optical constants after the resists are treated with a post-exposure bake as well as shrinkage of the resist layer thickness. Based on this data, simulative studies on latent images of periodic grating structures are conducted showing the possibility to extract information on the structure parameters including the latent image profile and surface topography. Conclusion: Spectroscopic EUV reflectometry shows to be sensitive to the contrast of exposed and unexposed photoresist which commends the technique to be adequate for the characterization of latent images in photoresists.
- 1 April 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (02) , 021208-12
Open AccessLatent image characterization by spectroscopic reflectometry in the extreme ultraviolet
Background: In the extreme ultaviolet (EUV) lithography process the performance of the photoresist is a crucial factor regarding the quality and critical dimensions of the fabricated structures. Aim: The characterization of the latent image structures in photoresists during the process steps before the development of the resist is key to understand the relation between the material of the resists, the selection of process parameters, and the resulting quality of fabricated structures. Approach: Spectroscopic EUV reflectometry is a nondestructive metrology technique that measures the broadband reflectance of samples in the EUV spectral range and under grazing incidence angles. The technique offers a combination of high sensitivity to nanoscale structural parameters of periodic structures as well as a high sensitivity to the material composition samples, enabling the characterization of latent images of periodic structures. Results: Measurements of the reflectance of an EUV-exposed and unexposed photoresist reveal the contrast in optical constants after the resists are treated with a post-exposure bake as well as shrinkage of the resist layer thickness. Based on this data, simulative studies on latent images of periodic grating structures are conducted showing the possibility to extract information on the structure parameters including the latent image profile and surface topography. Conclusion: Spectroscopic EUV reflectometry shows to be sensitive to the contrast of exposed and unexposed photoresist which commends the technique to be adequate for the characterization of latent images in photoresists.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 20 (02) , 021007-11
EUV scattering from carbon nanotube pellicles: measurement and control
Background: EUV lithography has been introduced for semiconductor fabrication, which makes maximizing yield and throughput increasingly important. One key component is the use of a high-transmission pellicle to keep particles out of the focal plane and thereby minimize their impact on imaging. Imec initiated the development of a promising pellicle approach based on a network of carbon nanotubes (CNT), which has the advantage of many tunable structural parameters to form a pellicle membrane. A balance between membrane robustness and particle nonpermeability on one side and low EUV absorption and membrane scattering on the other must be found. The membrane scatter is important for EUV flare effects during wafer printing. Aim: The experimental measurement of the flare must be determined as a function of the tunable CNT structural parameters. However, this measurement can be very challenging for the low-flare requirements involved. Approach: The EUV scatter measurements on CNT-based pellicle membranes have been performed and optimized in a stand-alone irradiation setup at RWTH Aachen University. The measurement results were compared to flare simulations using a CNT cylinder model, which is used to improve the experimental measurements. Results: With this approach, the flare of pellicles with different CNT structures and network parameters are investigated, as well as CNT pellicles that incorporate protective coatings. Conclusion: The proposed flare measurement procedure can be used to test for acceptable scattering levels for EUV imaging applications.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 20 (02) , 021007-11
EUV scattering from carbon nanotube pellicles: measurement and control
Background: EUV lithography has been introduced for semiconductor fabrication, which makes maximizing yield and throughput increasingly important. One key component is the use of a high-transmission pellicle to keep particles out of the focal plane and thereby minimize their impact on imaging. Imec initiated the development of a promising pellicle approach based on a network of carbon nanotubes (CNT), which has the advantage of many tunable structural parameters to form a pellicle membrane. A balance between membrane robustness and particle nonpermeability on one side and low EUV absorption and membrane scattering on the other must be found. The membrane scatter is important for EUV flare effects during wafer printing. Aim: The experimental measurement of the flare must be determined as a function of the tunable CNT structural parameters. However, this measurement can be very challenging for the low-flare requirements involved. Approach: The EUV scatter measurements on CNT-based pellicle membranes have been performed and optimized in a stand-alone irradiation setup at RWTH Aachen University. The measurement results were compared to flare simulations using a CNT cylinder model, which is used to improve the experimental measurements. Results: With this approach, the flare of pellicles with different CNT structures and network parameters are investigated, as well as CNT pellicles that incorporate protective coatings. Conclusion: The proposed flare measurement procedure can be used to test for acceptable scattering levels for EUV imaging applications.