Benedetta Catanzariti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Benedetta Catanzariti has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Fabio Tollon
University of Edinburgh, Philosophy, Edinburgh, UK
3 shared publications - Sj Bennett
Durham University
2 shared publications - Alessio Giacometti
Padua, Italy
1 shared publication - Amanda M. Horzyk
University of Edinburgh
1 shared publication - Andreas Christou
School of Informatics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, U.K.
1 shared publication Aurora Constantin
Edinburgh Scotland EH8 9AB School of Informatics
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 825-826
Designing Responsible AI: a Pedagogical Blueprint for Interdisciplinary Reflection and Applied Ethics Competencies
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 825-826
Open AccessDesigning Responsible AI: a Pedagogical Blueprint for Interdisciplinary Reflection and Applied Ethics Competencies
- Open Access
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cultural Economy
- p. 1-9
Nuclear clouds: the infrastructural convergence of AI and energy systems
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cultural Economy
- p. 1-9
Open AccessNuclear clouds: the infrastructural convergence of AI and energy systems
- Open Access
- 5 January 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Wellcome Open Research
- Vol. 11
REALIGN Toolkit: Reflexivity, Adaptability, Leadership, and Inclusion as Pillars of Responsible Research and Innovation
While public engagement and interdisciplinary collaborations are now requirements within Responsible Research and Innovation frameworks, a growing body of Science and Technology Studies literature has critiqued how these processes are insufficient on their own and how they often reduce social scientists and humanities scholars’ engagement to tokenistic exercises aimed at legitimising and accelerating technological adoption. With this Open Letter, we address these limitations. Drawing on our collective experience and expertise as social scientists, humanities scholars, and technology developers, we propose a toolkit to reframe responsibility in research and innovation as a collective and sustained effort. We argue that it is necessary to move beyond existing RRI approaches and to actively engage with critical, culturally informed, and interdisciplinary practices that acknowledge the layered complexities of innovation ecosystems, the social construction of technology, and the power asymmetries embedded in participatory processes. To achieve this, we offer a conceptual and reflexive toolkit with recommendations for fostering meaningful, continuous, and early-stage engagement with stakeholders that can advance ethically grounded, socially responsive, and culturally situated research and innovation systems. We call this toolkit REALIGN, as it is centred on four pillars: Re flexivity, A daptability, L eadership, and I nclusion. We offer case studies from our projects, situated in East Asia and Western Europe, the regions with the most rapidly ageing populations. There, assistive robotics has emerged as a promising field for addressing socioeconomic challenges generated by this unprecedented demographic shift. Our critical analysis highlights persistent issues such as late-stage and selective public involvement and the marginalisation of vulnerable user groups. We also include examples of participatory design practices aimed at keeping innovation processes context-sensitive and responsive to real-world needs. We conclude that achieving responsible research and innovation approaches requires robust governance structures, interdisciplinary collaborations, and sustained dialogue among funders, scientists, policymakers, and diverse publics.
- 5 January 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Wellcome Open Research
- Vol. 11
Open AccessREALIGN Toolkit: Reflexivity, Adaptability, Leadership, and Inclusion as Pillars of Responsible Research and Innovation
While public engagement and interdisciplinary collaborations are now requirements within Responsible Research and Innovation frameworks, a growing body of Science and Technology Studies literature has critiqued how these processes are insufficient on their own and how they often reduce social scientists and humanities scholars’ engagement to tokenistic exercises aimed at legitimising and accelerating technological adoption. With this Open Letter, we address these limitations. Drawing on our collective experience and expertise as social scientists, humanities scholars, and technology developers, we propose a toolkit to reframe responsibility in research and innovation as a collective and sustained effort. We argue that it is necessary to move beyond existing RRI approaches and to actively engage with critical, culturally informed, and interdisciplinary practices that acknowledge the layered complexities of innovation ecosystems, the social construction of technology, and the power asymmetries embedded in participatory processes. To achieve this, we offer a conceptual and reflexive toolkit with recommendations for fostering meaningful, continuous, and early-stage engagement with stakeholders that can advance ethically grounded, socially responsive, and culturally situated research and innovation systems. We call this toolkit REALIGN, as it is centred on four pillars: Re flexivity, A daptability, L eadership, and I nclusion. We offer case studies from our projects, situated in East Asia and Western Europe, the regions with the most rapidly ageing populations. There, assistive robotics has emerged as a promising field for addressing socioeconomic challenges generated by this unprecedented demographic shift. Our critical analysis highlights persistent issues such as late-stage and selective public involvement and the marginalisation of vulnerable user groups. We also include examples of participatory design practices aimed at keeping innovation processes context-sensitive and responsive to real-world needs. We conclude that achieving responsible research and innovation approaches requires robust governance structures, interdisciplinary collaborations, and sustained dialogue among funders, scientists, policymakers, and diverse publics.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Society
- Vol. 4 (2) , 1-23
Taming Affect: On the Construction of Objectivity in Data Annotation Practices
Affective computing applications promise to decode human emotional expressions and provide objective insights into users’ affective experience, ranging from frustration and boredom to states of clinical relevance such as depression and anxiety. In this paper, I explore the contexts of development of facial expression recognition systems, machine learning systems designed to recognize changes in facial expressive behaviors and produce some form of meaningful knowledge about such expressions. Drawing on 20 interviews with engineers and annotators involved in developing or working with these models, this paper sheds empirical light on the socio-material practices through which practitioners articulate notions of objectivity, truth, and accuracy to make sense of affective data and validate their systems’ predictions. By exploring two common annotation schemes used to label facial expression recognition training datasets, the Facial Action Coding System (FACS) and the Valence, Arousal, Dominance (VAD) model, I foreground the situated judgments and negotiation practices required to make sense of affective data. Here, I juxtapose annotators’ account of data work – the non-linear interpretative practices that are necessary to ‘fit’ the data into FACS and VAD coding grids – to engineers’ perceptions and expectations around annotation. Here, I show how practitioners mobilize ideal notions of ‘subjectivity’ and ‘intuition’ to manage the uncertainty and ambiguity of affective data.
- 7 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Society
- Vol. 4 (2) , 1-23
Open AccessTaming Affect: On the Construction of Objectivity in Data Annotation Practices
Affective computing applications promise to decode human emotional expressions and provide objective insights into users’ affective experience, ranging from frustration and boredom to states of clinical relevance such as depression and anxiety. In this paper, I explore the contexts of development of facial expression recognition systems, machine learning systems designed to recognize changes in facial expressive behaviors and produce some form of meaningful knowledge about such expressions. Drawing on 20 interviews with engineers and annotators involved in developing or working with these models, this paper sheds empirical light on the socio-material practices through which practitioners articulate notions of objectivity, truth, and accuracy to make sense of affective data and validate their systems’ predictions. By exploring two common annotation schemes used to label facial expression recognition training datasets, the Facial Action Coding System (FACS) and the Valence, Arousal, Dominance (VAD) model, I foreground the situated judgments and negotiation practices required to make sense of affective data. Here, I juxtapose annotators’ account of data work – the non-linear interpretative practices that are necessary to ‘fit’ the data into FACS and VAD coding grids – to engineers’ perceptions and expectations around annotation. Here, I show how practitioners mobilize ideal notions of ‘subjectivity’ and ‘intuition’ to manage the uncertainty and ambiguity of affective data.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 40 (6) , 5101
Correction: “Everybody knows what a pothole is”: representations of work and intelligence in AI practice and governance
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 40 (6) , 5101
Open AccessCorrection: “Everybody knows what a pothole is”: representations of work and intelligence in AI practice and governance
- Open Access
- 27 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 40 (5) , 3283-3294
“Everybody knows what a pothole is”: representations of work and intelligence in AI practice and governance
In this paper, we empirically and conceptually examine how distributed human–machine networks of labour comprise a form of underlying intelligence within Artificial Intelligence (AI), considering the implications of this for Responsible Artificial Intelligence (R-AI) innovation. R-AI aims to guide AI research, development and deployment in line with certain normative principles, for example fairness, privacy, and explainability; notions implicitly shaped by comparisons of AI with individualised notions of human intelligence. However, as critical scholarship on AI demonstrates, this is a limited framing of the nature of intelligence, both of humans and AI. Furthermore, it dismisses the skills and labour central to developing AI systems, involving a distributed network of human-directed practices and reasoning. We argue that inequities in the agency and recognition of different types of practitioners across these networks of AI development have implications beyond RAI, with narrow framings concealing considerations which are important within broader discussions of AI intelligence. Drawing from interactive workshops conducted with AI practitioners, we explore practices of data acquisition, cleaning, and annotation, as the point where practitioners interface with domain experts and data annotators. Despite forming a crucial part of AI design and development, this type of data work is frequently framed as a tedious, unskilled, and low-value process. In exploring these practices, we examine the political role of the epistemic framings that underpin AI development and how these framings can shape understandings of distributed intelligence, labour practices, and annotators’ agency within data structures. Finally, we reflect on the implications of our findings for developing more participatory and equitable approaches to machine learning applications in the service of R-AI.
- 27 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 40 (5) , 3283-3294
Open Access“Everybody knows what a pothole is”: representations of work and intelligence in AI practice and governance
In this paper, we empirically and conceptually examine how distributed human–machine networks of labour comprise a form of underlying intelligence within Artificial Intelligence (AI), considering the implications of this for Responsible Artificial Intelligence (R-AI) innovation. R-AI aims to guide AI research, development and deployment in line with certain normative principles, for example fairness, privacy, and explainability; notions implicitly shaped by comparisons of AI with individualised notions of human intelligence. However, as critical scholarship on AI demonstrates, this is a limited framing of the nature of intelligence, both of humans and AI. Furthermore, it dismisses the skills and labour central to developing AI systems, involving a distributed network of human-directed practices and reasoning. We argue that inequities in the agency and recognition of different types of practitioners across these networks of AI development have implications beyond RAI, with narrow framings concealing considerations which are important within broader discussions of AI intelligence. Drawing from interactive workshops conducted with AI practitioners, we explore practices of data acquisition, cleaning, and annotation, as the point where practitioners interface with domain experts and data annotators. Despite forming a crucial part of AI design and development, this type of data work is frequently framed as a tedious, unskilled, and low-value process. In exploring these practices, we examine the political role of the epistemic framings that underpin AI development and how these framings can shape understandings of distributed intelligence, labour practices, and annotators’ agency within data structures. Finally, we reflect on the implications of our findings for developing more participatory and equitable approaches to machine learning applications in the service of R-AI.