Dinara Rustembekova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Dinara Rustembekova has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Aigul Nukusheva
Karaganda Buketov University
2 shared publications - R.B. Zhagalov
Buketov Karaganda National Research University Karaganda Kazakhstan
2 shared publications AL-FARABI KAZAKH NATIONAL UNIVERSITY
1 shared publication- Abzal Serikbayev
Karaganda Buketov University
1 shared publication - Alua S. Ibrayeva
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
1 shared publication - Axunkar Birmanova
Karaganda Buketov University Karaganda Kazakhstan
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 8 (4) , 78
Non-normative acts of executive bodies as an instrument for implementing administrative discretion under the legislation of Kazakhstan and foreign countries
This study aims to identify contemporary issues in the formalisation, preparation, and application of the non-normative act (NNA) as an instrument for implementing administrative discretion from a comparative perspective. To achieve the set objectives, a comparative legal approach was employed to analyse the experience of four civil law countries: Kazakhstan, Romania, Ukraine, and Poland. The study draws on three complementary methods: comparative legal analysis, formal legal analysis, and doctrinal interpretation. The four countries were selected based on their shared continental legal tradition and post-socialist heritage, making comparison with Kazakhstan particularly instructive. The analysis centres on four parameters: the legislative definition of the NNA, the limits of administrative discretion, procedural guarantees for the addressee, and mechanisms of judicial review. The findings suggest that in these European countries, the NNA lacks a single, clear legal definition in laws and subordinate legislation. Issues persist regarding blurred boundaries of administrative discretion, the influence of internal instructions, and insufficient procedural guarantees in the adoption of NNAs. Conversely, Kazakhstan’s legislation defines this term, providing a typology that divides NNAs into subtypes. An analysis of the administrative procedure legislation of the three European countries reveals significant gaps.
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 8 (4) , 78
Open AccessNon-normative acts of executive bodies as an instrument for implementing administrative discretion under the legislation of Kazakhstan and foreign countries
This study aims to identify contemporary issues in the formalisation, preparation, and application of the non-normative act (NNA) as an instrument for implementing administrative discretion from a comparative perspective. To achieve the set objectives, a comparative legal approach was employed to analyse the experience of four civil law countries: Kazakhstan, Romania, Ukraine, and Poland. The study draws on three complementary methods: comparative legal analysis, formal legal analysis, and doctrinal interpretation. The four countries were selected based on their shared continental legal tradition and post-socialist heritage, making comparison with Kazakhstan particularly instructive. The analysis centres on four parameters: the legislative definition of the NNA, the limits of administrative discretion, procedural guarantees for the addressee, and mechanisms of judicial review. The findings suggest that in these European countries, the NNA lacks a single, clear legal definition in laws and subordinate legislation. Issues persist regarding blurred boundaries of administrative discretion, the influence of internal instructions, and insufficient procedural guarantees in the adoption of NNAs. Conversely, Kazakhstan’s legislation defines this term, providing a typology that divides NNAs into subtypes. An analysis of the administrative procedure legislation of the three European countries reveals significant gaps.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda University. “Law Series”
- Vol. 31 (2)
The current state of legal regulation of artificial intelligence in the Republic of Kazakhstan
This study addresses the development of a cross-sectoral model for the legal regulation of artificial intelligence (AI) and highlights the transitional nature of the AI legal regime, situated between strategic innovation management and a fully developed system of legal accountability. The purpose of the study is to analyze the current state of AI regulation in the Republic of Kazakhstan, particularly in the context of civil liability for harm caused by AI systems. The methodological framework includes general and specialized scientific methods, such as analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, as well as formal legal and comparative legal approaches. The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of current legislation in Kazakhstan related to AI regulation, identifies existing legal gaps, and proposes scientifically grounded measures to improve civil liability mechanisms in the context of AI technologies. It has been established that Kazakhstan has transitioned from software-oriented digitalization to the formation of a comprehensive legal regime for artificial intelligence. The findings indicate that Kazakhstan is transitioning from software-oriented digitalization to ward the formation of a comprehensive legal regime for AI. The results substantiate the need to improve civil liability for harm caused by AI systems and support the introduction of an additional provision into the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda University. “Law Series”
- Vol. 31 (2)
The current state of legal regulation of artificial intelligence in the Republic of Kazakhstan
This study addresses the development of a cross-sectoral model for the legal regulation of artificial intelligence (AI) and highlights the transitional nature of the AI legal regime, situated between strategic innovation management and a fully developed system of legal accountability. The purpose of the study is to analyze the current state of AI regulation in the Republic of Kazakhstan, particularly in the context of civil liability for harm caused by AI systems. The methodological framework includes general and specialized scientific methods, such as analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, as well as formal legal and comparative legal approaches. The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of current legislation in Kazakhstan related to AI regulation, identifies existing legal gaps, and proposes scientifically grounded measures to improve civil liability mechanisms in the context of AI technologies. It has been established that Kazakhstan has transitioned from software-oriented digitalization to the formation of a comprehensive legal regime for artificial intelligence. The findings indicate that Kazakhstan is transitioning from software-oriented digitalization to ward the formation of a comprehensive legal regime for AI. The results substantiate the need to improve civil liability for harm caused by AI systems and support the introduction of an additional provision into the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda University. “Law Series”
- Vol. 12131 (1)
The use of blockchain technology in the public procurement system: international legal experience
The subject of the research is the analysis of international experience in the application of blockchain technology in public procurement systems, with particular reference to China, United Kingdom, Japan, Mexico, and South Korea. The purpose of the scientific work is to examine the theoretical and international legal aspects of the use of blockchain technology in public procurement systems. The methodological basis of the research includes a set of general scientific and private scientific methods, such as systemic, structuralfunctional, historical, and analysis synthesis, comparative law. The principles of transparency, fair competition, equal access for participants, and legality are outlined in regulatory legal acts regulating the field of public procurement, which in turn forms the legal basis for organizing the procurement process. To fully implement these principles, the introduction of distributed ledger technologies, such as blockchain, is considered a harmonious direction. Blockchain technology ensures data immutability and allows you to obtain an accurate digital footprint of each transaction, thereby strengthening control over decisions made and executed contracts as well as increasing the transparency of these procedures. The authors propose to introduce blockchain technology into the public procurement system and determine the legal status of a smart contract to optimize the level of data security protection of the public procurement procedure and increase their transparency and accessibility.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda University. “Law Series”
- Vol. 12131 (1)
The use of blockchain technology in the public procurement system: international legal experience
The subject of the research is the analysis of international experience in the application of blockchain technology in public procurement systems, with particular reference to China, United Kingdom, Japan, Mexico, and South Korea. The purpose of the scientific work is to examine the theoretical and international legal aspects of the use of blockchain technology in public procurement systems. The methodological basis of the research includes a set of general scientific and private scientific methods, such as systemic, structuralfunctional, historical, and analysis synthesis, comparative law. The principles of transparency, fair competition, equal access for participants, and legality are outlined in regulatory legal acts regulating the field of public procurement, which in turn forms the legal basis for organizing the procurement process. To fully implement these principles, the introduction of distributed ledger technologies, such as blockchain, is considered a harmonious direction. Blockchain technology ensures data immutability and allows you to obtain an accurate digital footprint of each transaction, thereby strengthening control over decisions made and executed contracts as well as increasing the transparency of these procedures. The authors propose to introduce blockchain technology into the public procurement system and determine the legal status of a smart contract to optimize the level of data security protection of the public procurement procedure and increase their transparency and accessibility.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in BULLETIN of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University Law Series
- Vol. 151 (2) , 159-184
Waste recycling incentives: legal and economic mechanisms
In the context of increasing waste volumes and the need for sustainable development, an effective waste recycling system has become a priority. This study aims to analyze the legal and economic mechanisms that encourage waste recycling to determine the most effective approaches. The research utilizes literature review methods, comparative analysis, statistical data analysis, and case studies. The results of the study indicate that key legal mechanisms include Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), separate waste collection, recycling quotas, and penalties. An analysis of three EPR models (individual, collective, and mixed) revealed their advantages and disadvantages depending on the specific context. Economic tools, such as subsidies, tax incentives, and environmental fees, provide financial motivation for recycling but require a balanced approach to prevent dependency on government resources and the shifting of costs onto consumers. A comprehensive approach that combines economic and legal mechanisms has proven most effective, as evidenced by the successful experiences of countries with advanced recycling systems. The practical significance of this study lies in its potential application for developing and improving recycling incentive programs across various countries.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in BULLETIN of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University Law Series
- Vol. 151 (2) , 159-184
Open AccessWaste recycling incentives: legal and economic mechanisms
In the context of increasing waste volumes and the need for sustainable development, an effective waste recycling system has become a priority. This study aims to analyze the legal and economic mechanisms that encourage waste recycling to determine the most effective approaches. The research utilizes literature review methods, comparative analysis, statistical data analysis, and case studies. The results of the study indicate that key legal mechanisms include Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), separate waste collection, recycling quotas, and penalties. An analysis of three EPR models (individual, collective, and mixed) revealed their advantages and disadvantages depending on the specific context. Economic tools, such as subsidies, tax incentives, and environmental fees, provide financial motivation for recycling but require a balanced approach to prevent dependency on government resources and the shifting of costs onto consumers. A comprehensive approach that combines economic and legal mechanisms has proven most effective, as evidenced by the successful experiences of countries with advanced recycling systems. The practical significance of this study lies in its potential application for developing and improving recycling incentive programs across various countries.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 112 (4) , 25-36
CULTURAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND GLOBALIZATION
Modern processes of globalization cause the transformation of the substantive aspect of human rights, which requires their scientific substantiation. The article will introduce the theoretical and methodological study of the cultural rights of the individual, as well as the issues of their implementation in the modern world under the influence of socio-economic, political and spiritual transformations. As a result of the analysis, the axiological concept of the realization of cultural rights by a person is shown, as well as the relationship with other, important, human rights is demonstrated; objective and subjective indicators that contradict the protection and implementation of cultural human rights are determined. The comparative legal analysis of the norms of Constitutions, national laws and international legal acts in the field of recognition and realization of cultural rights has revealed reformational trends in the field of their legal regulation in democratic states of the world. Based on the lack of a unified doctrinal theory of cognition of cultural rights, the adoption of a universal strategic international legal document designed to support the implementation of individual cultural rights in modern society - the "International Action Program for the development of an effective mechanism for the implementation of individual cultural rights in the field of integration" is recommended in the international arena. The purpose of this scientific article is to provide a comprehensive description of the problems of the realization of cultural rights and the formation of a holistic view of their further development in the conditions of modern globalization processes. While paying tribute to the theoretical and practical significance of this scientific heritage, it should be recognized that the realization of cultural rights in the context of globalization processes remains little explored. There are no generalizing, synthesizing works on the indicated problems. The article examines some aspects of the development of individual rights in an integrating world by the example of human rights in the field of culture. In this direction, the essence of the word "globalization" and the meaning of cultural rights are revealed. The article analyzes the version of cultural rights in various international legal instruments and in the general comments adopted by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. And also, the article establishes the place of cultural human and civil rights in the general structure of individual rights. The paper shows the specific features of the cultural rights of the individual. Based on the conducted research, it is concluded that the state is the subject of setting priorities in policy in the field of cultural issues, which also follow from its main tasks in this area. The results of the study can be used in goal-setting in the field of education and the design of normative legal acts in the field of education and human rights.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 112 (4) , 25-36
Open AccessCULTURAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND GLOBALIZATION
Modern processes of globalization cause the transformation of the substantive aspect of human rights, which requires their scientific substantiation. The article will introduce the theoretical and methodological study of the cultural rights of the individual, as well as the issues of their implementation in the modern world under the influence of socio-economic, political and spiritual transformations. As a result of the analysis, the axiological concept of the realization of cultural rights by a person is shown, as well as the relationship with other, important, human rights is demonstrated; objective and subjective indicators that contradict the protection and implementation of cultural human rights are determined. The comparative legal analysis of the norms of Constitutions, national laws and international legal acts in the field of recognition and realization of cultural rights has revealed reformational trends in the field of their legal regulation in democratic states of the world. Based on the lack of a unified doctrinal theory of cognition of cultural rights, the adoption of a universal strategic international legal document designed to support the implementation of individual cultural rights in modern society - the "International Action Program for the development of an effective mechanism for the implementation of individual cultural rights in the field of integration" is recommended in the international arena. The purpose of this scientific article is to provide a comprehensive description of the problems of the realization of cultural rights and the formation of a holistic view of their further development in the conditions of modern globalization processes. While paying tribute to the theoretical and practical significance of this scientific heritage, it should be recognized that the realization of cultural rights in the context of globalization processes remains little explored. There are no generalizing, synthesizing works on the indicated problems. The article examines some aspects of the development of individual rights in an integrating world by the example of human rights in the field of culture. In this direction, the essence of the word "globalization" and the meaning of cultural rights are revealed. The article analyzes the version of cultural rights in various international legal instruments and in the general comments adopted by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. And also, the article establishes the place of cultural human and civil rights in the general structure of individual rights. The paper shows the specific features of the cultural rights of the individual. Based on the conducted research, it is concluded that the state is the subject of setting priorities in policy in the field of cultural issues, which also follow from its main tasks in this area. The results of the study can be used in goal-setting in the field of education and the design of normative legal acts in the field of education and human rights.