Viktor Biryukov
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Viktor Biryukov has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anatoliy Gozhenko
State Enterprise "Ukrainian Research Institute for Transport Medicine", Ministry of Health of Ukraine, Odesa, Ukraine
5 shared publications - Walery Zukow
Nicolaus Copernicus University, Toruń, Poland
5 shared publications - Oleksandr Vitiukov
International Humanitarian University, Odesa, Ukraine
2 shared publications - D. V. Usenko
Одеський національний медичний університет
1 shared publication Daria Kolomiiets
Odesa National Medical University
1 shared publication- Igor Popovych
Bohomolets’ Institute of Physiology of NAS, Kyїv, Ukraine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 17 September 2026
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Academic Notes. Series: Pedagogical Science
- Vol. 1 (224)
NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDYING THE QUALITY OF ELECTRONIC MEDICAL EDUCATION BASED ON THE «RISK MANAGEMENT» METHOD
This study examines the potential of the international quality standard ISO 9001:2015 and the «risk management» standard ISO 31010:2013 in identifying risks associated with educational processes in medical schools. The objective of the study was to assess the factors that influence the quality of electronic medical education (EME). The research also explores the risks that affect the objectivity of medical school graduate assessments. The purpose of this study is to investigate the features and mechanisms of improving the quality of distance education based on identifying potential risks of the distance education process. The work uses the methods of system and process analysis, as well as the «risk management» method, set out in the international quality standards ISO 9001:2015, ISO 31010:2013 and ISO Guide 73:2013. The study was based on data from an anonymous survey of Odesa National Medical University (ONMedU) graduates, literary sources on the topic of EMH, and the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine’s (MoES) Higher Education Standards for the specialty I2 «Medicine». The literature review demonstrated the irreversibility of the international adoption of EMH in educational technologies, which has greatly intensified competition between higher education institutions in the educational services market. Quality is an important competitive advantage of educational programs and technologies. One mechanism for improving the quality of educational services is the analysis of risks associated with educational processes. The study identified inconsistencies in the structure of the «Standard of Higher Education at the Second (Master’s) Level» for Specialty I2 «Medicine». The standard includes 15 general and 26 specialized competencies that medical graduates must master. Significant variability has been identified in the number of required competencies for passing 29 mandatory program outcomes (MPOs). For example, for MPO 1, graduates must master 15 general and 25 specific competencies. For MPO 26, no specific competencies are required, only two general competencies. This differential weighting of MPOs poses a challenge in objectively assessing the quality of graduates’ knowledge and skills on state examinations. The risks of non-compliance with the MoES Standard’s MPO range from 2.5% to 100% due to incomplete mastery of one of the mandatory competencies. This discrepancy stems from the lack of a process-based approach to the responsibility matrix, which is part of the MoES Standard’s structure. A graphical risk assessment model based on the recommendations of ISO international standards is proposed.
- 17 September 2026
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Academic Notes. Series: Pedagogical Science
- Vol. 1 (224)
NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDYING THE QUALITY OF ELECTRONIC MEDICAL EDUCATION BASED ON THE «RISK MANAGEMENT» METHOD
This study examines the potential of the international quality standard ISO 9001:2015 and the «risk management» standard ISO 31010:2013 in identifying risks associated with educational processes in medical schools. The objective of the study was to assess the factors that influence the quality of electronic medical education (EME). The research also explores the risks that affect the objectivity of medical school graduate assessments. The purpose of this study is to investigate the features and mechanisms of improving the quality of distance education based on identifying potential risks of the distance education process. The work uses the methods of system and process analysis, as well as the «risk management» method, set out in the international quality standards ISO 9001:2015, ISO 31010:2013 and ISO Guide 73:2013. The study was based on data from an anonymous survey of Odesa National Medical University (ONMedU) graduates, literary sources on the topic of EMH, and the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine’s (MoES) Higher Education Standards for the specialty I2 «Medicine». The literature review demonstrated the irreversibility of the international adoption of EMH in educational technologies, which has greatly intensified competition between higher education institutions in the educational services market. Quality is an important competitive advantage of educational programs and technologies. One mechanism for improving the quality of educational services is the analysis of risks associated with educational processes. The study identified inconsistencies in the structure of the «Standard of Higher Education at the Second (Master’s) Level» for Specialty I2 «Medicine». The standard includes 15 general and 26 specialized competencies that medical graduates must master. Significant variability has been identified in the number of required competencies for passing 29 mandatory program outcomes (MPOs). For example, for MPO 1, graduates must master 15 general and 25 specific competencies. For MPO 26, no specific competencies are required, only two general competencies. This differential weighting of MPOs poses a challenge in objectively assessing the quality of graduates’ knowledge and skills on state examinations. The risks of non-compliance with the MoES Standard’s MPO range from 2.5% to 100% due to incomplete mastery of one of the mandatory competencies. This discrepancy stems from the lack of a process-based approach to the responsibility matrix, which is part of the MoES Standard’s structure. A graphical risk assessment model based on the recommendations of ISO international standards is proposed.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Pedagogy and Psychology of Sport
- Vol. 32
Exploring the Viral Paradigm — Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome: A Comparative Pathophysiological Analysis and Rationale for Nosological Differentiation in ICD-11 in Accordance with WHO Classification Reform
Background. Acute respiratory illnesses, collectively referred to as the "common cold," represent one of the most prevalent conditions worldwide, affecting billions of individuals annually and imposing an enormous socioeconomic burden estimated at over $40 billion per year in the United States alone. Despite their ubiquity, the etiopathogenesis of these conditions remains insufficiently understood and scientifically contested. Contemporary medicine attributes all common cold episodes exclusively to viral infections — predominantly rhinoviruses (30–50%), coronaviruses (10–15%), and other respiratory viruses. However, this monocausal viral paradigm fails to explain several well-documented clinical and epidemiological inconsistencies: the onset of symptoms within minutes of cold exposure (far preceding any possible viral incubation period), the reversibility of symptoms upon rewarming, the absence of fever in a substantial proportion of cases, and the paradoxical age-related pattern of incidence in which elderly individuals — despite progressive immunosenescence — suffer fewer episodes than children or young adults. These unresolved contradictions call for a fundamental reassessment of the pathogenesis of cold-associated respiratory disease. The present review builds upon and extends the pathophysiological framework systematically introduced by Gozhenko et al. (2025, 2026), who first proposed a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model of the common cold, and who first described the five interconnected pathophysiological mechanisms forming a self-sufficient symptom cascade independent of any viral agent. Objective. This narrative review critically examines the role of cold exposure and cold stress in the pathogenesis of acute upper respiratory tract disorders and proposes a novel conceptual framework distinguishing two fundamentally different clinical entities: Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome (ACRS) and Acute Viral Respiratory Syndrome (AVRS). The review introduces a three-phase model of ACRS in which cold-induced vascular dysfunction opens a "gateway" for endogenous microbiome activation, followed by neutrophilic inflammation as a second phase — a mechanism analogous to the ancient folk tradition of steam inhalation therapy (potato steam, warm dry air inhalation documented by British researchers approximately 20 years ago). The review further presents evidence supporting a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model, as proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025, 2026), and provides formal justification for WHO ICD-11 nosological reform. Methods. A comprehensive narrative literature review was conducted across PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases, covering publications from 1946 to 2026 in English, Ukrainian, and Polish. Search terms included: cold stress, thermoregulation, upper respiratory tract, mucosal immunity, vasoconstriction, common cold pathophysiology, mucociliary clearance, cold air inhalation, HPA axis immune suppression, TRPM8, TRPA1, nasal mucosa cold, respiratory microbiome, neutrophilic inflammation, warm air inhalation therapy, geomagnetic disturbances immune, aromatherapy nasal. Artificial intelligence tools (large language models) were used exclusively for auxiliary tasks — initial literature sorting, grammatical proofreading, and reference formatting — with all scientific content, analyses, and conclusions being the sole intellectual product of the authors. Original thermodynamic calculations of metabolic energy expenditure during cold air breathing were performed and are presented in full within the manuscript. Results. Convergent evidence from physiology, immunology, neuroscience, thermodynamics, and microbiology reveals a three-phase pathophysiological model of ACRS fundamentally distinct from AVRS. Phase I (Initiation, 0–30 min): Cold air activates TRPM8 (threshold <25–28°C) and TRPA1 (threshold <17°C) thermosensory receptors, triggering rapid sympathetically mediated vasoconstriction within seconds to minutes, followed by reactive vasodilation with ischemia–reperfusion injury, release of histamine, bradykinin, prostaglandins (PGE₂, PGD₂), leukotrienes (LTC₄, LTD₄), and substance P — producing the clinical triad of rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, and sneezing independently of any viral agent. Phase II (Microbiome Activation and Bacterial Phase, 2–24 h): Cold-induced vascular dysfunction, mucociliary paralysis, and local immunosuppression open a "gateway" for the resident upper respiratory tract microbiome. The shift from protective commensals (Lactobacillus spp., Dolosigranulum pigrum) toward opportunistic pathogens (Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pneumoniae) triggers neutrophilic recruitment and the classical inflammatory response — explaining why "pure" ACRS, if untreated, progresses to purulent rhinitis and sinusitis without any external viral agent. Phase III (Resolution or Viral Superinfection, 6 h – 3 days): Upon rewarming, pure ACRS resolves spontaneously. However, cold-induced mucociliary dysfunction, reduced sIgA, and suppressed interferon signaling create a "window of vulnerability" (2–4 h) that maximally favors viral invasion — explaining the clinical phenomenon of "severe cold after chilling." The comparative analysis of ACRS versus AVRS (Gozhenko et al., 2025, 2026) demonstrates that these two entities differ fundamentally in trigger (cold stress vs. external viral agent), incubation period (absent vs. obligatory 12–72 h), pathogenetic mechanism (thermoregulatory vasospasm → microbiome activation → neutrophilic inflammation vs. viral cytopathic effect → interferon response → adaptive immunity), seasonality (strictly temperature-dependent vs. year-round, as demonstrated by the COVID-19 pandemic), and...
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Pedagogy and Psychology of Sport
- Vol. 32
Open AccessExploring the Viral Paradigm — Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome: A Comparative Pathophysiological Analysis and Rationale for Nosological Differentiation in ICD-11 in Accordance with WHO Classification Reform
Background. Acute respiratory illnesses, collectively referred to as the "common cold," represent one of the most prevalent conditions worldwide, affecting billions of individuals annually and imposing an enormous socioeconomic burden estimated at over $40 billion per year in the United States alone. Despite their ubiquity, the etiopathogenesis of these conditions remains insufficiently understood and scientifically contested. Contemporary medicine attributes all common cold episodes exclusively to viral infections — predominantly rhinoviruses (30–50%), coronaviruses (10–15%), and other respiratory viruses. However, this monocausal viral paradigm fails to explain several well-documented clinical and epidemiological inconsistencies: the onset of symptoms within minutes of cold exposure (far preceding any possible viral incubation period), the reversibility of symptoms upon rewarming, the absence of fever in a substantial proportion of cases, and the paradoxical age-related pattern of incidence in which elderly individuals — despite progressive immunosenescence — suffer fewer episodes than children or young adults. These unresolved contradictions call for a fundamental reassessment of the pathogenesis of cold-associated respiratory disease. The present review builds upon and extends the pathophysiological framework systematically introduced by Gozhenko et al. (2025, 2026), who first proposed a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model of the common cold, and who first described the five interconnected pathophysiological mechanisms forming a self-sufficient symptom cascade independent of any viral agent. Objective. This narrative review critically examines the role of cold exposure and cold stress in the pathogenesis of acute upper respiratory tract disorders and proposes a novel conceptual framework distinguishing two fundamentally different clinical entities: Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome (ACRS) and Acute Viral Respiratory Syndrome (AVRS). The review introduces a three-phase model of ACRS in which cold-induced vascular dysfunction opens a "gateway" for endogenous microbiome activation, followed by neutrophilic inflammation as a second phase — a mechanism analogous to the ancient folk tradition of steam inhalation therapy (potato steam, warm dry air inhalation documented by British researchers approximately 20 years ago). The review further presents evidence supporting a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model, as proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025, 2026), and provides formal justification for WHO ICD-11 nosological reform. Methods. A comprehensive narrative literature review was conducted across PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases, covering publications from 1946 to 2026 in English, Ukrainian, and Polish. Search terms included: cold stress, thermoregulation, upper respiratory tract, mucosal immunity, vasoconstriction, common cold pathophysiology, mucociliary clearance, cold air inhalation, HPA axis immune suppression, TRPM8, TRPA1, nasal mucosa cold, respiratory microbiome, neutrophilic inflammation, warm air inhalation therapy, geomagnetic disturbances immune, aromatherapy nasal. Artificial intelligence tools (large language models) were used exclusively for auxiliary tasks — initial literature sorting, grammatical proofreading, and reference formatting — with all scientific content, analyses, and conclusions being the sole intellectual product of the authors. Original thermodynamic calculations of metabolic energy expenditure during cold air breathing were performed and are presented in full within the manuscript. Results. Convergent evidence from physiology, immunology, neuroscience, thermodynamics, and microbiology reveals a three-phase pathophysiological model of ACRS fundamentally distinct from AVRS. Phase I (Initiation, 0–30 min): Cold air activates TRPM8 (threshold <25–28°C) and TRPA1 (threshold <17°C) thermosensory receptors, triggering rapid sympathetically mediated vasoconstriction within seconds to minutes, followed by reactive vasodilation with ischemia–reperfusion injury, release of histamine, bradykinin, prostaglandins (PGE₂, PGD₂), leukotrienes (LTC₄, LTD₄), and substance P — producing the clinical triad of rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, and sneezing independently of any viral agent. Phase II (Microbiome Activation and Bacterial Phase, 2–24 h): Cold-induced vascular dysfunction, mucociliary paralysis, and local immunosuppression open a "gateway" for the resident upper respiratory tract microbiome. The shift from protective commensals (Lactobacillus spp., Dolosigranulum pigrum) toward opportunistic pathogens (Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pneumoniae) triggers neutrophilic recruitment and the classical inflammatory response — explaining why "pure" ACRS, if untreated, progresses to purulent rhinitis and sinusitis without any external viral agent. Phase III (Resolution or Viral Superinfection, 6 h – 3 days): Upon rewarming, pure ACRS resolves spontaneously. However, cold-induced mucociliary dysfunction, reduced sIgA, and suppressed interferon signaling create a "window of vulnerability" (2–4 h) that maximally favors viral invasion — explaining the clinical phenomenon of "severe cold after chilling." The comparative analysis of ACRS versus AVRS (Gozhenko et al., 2025, 2026) demonstrates that these two entities differ fundamentally in trigger (cold stress vs. external viral agent), incubation period (absent vs. obligatory 12–72 h), pathogenetic mechanism (thermoregulatory vasospasm → microbiome activation → neutrophilic inflammation vs. viral cytopathic effect → interferon response → adaptive immunity), seasonality (strictly temperature-dependent vs. year-round, as demonstrated by the COVID-19 pandemic), and...
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Pedagogy and Psychology of Sport
- Vol. 31, 69792
Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome: A Narrative Review of Pathophysiological Mechanisms Beyond Viral Etiology
Background Acute respiratory illnesses, collectively referred to as the "common cold," represent one of the most prevalent conditions worldwide, affecting billions of individuals annually and imposing an enormous socioeconomic burden estimated at over $40 billion per year in the United States alone. Despite their ubiquity, the etiopathogenesis of these conditions remains insufficiently understood and scientifically contested. Contemporary medicine attributes all common cold episodes exclusively to viral infections — predominantly rhinoviruses (30–50%), coronaviruses (10–15%), and other respiratory viruses. However, this monocausal viral paradigm fails to explain several well-documented clinical and epidemiological inconsistencies: the onset of symptoms within minutes of cold exposure (far preceding any possible viral incubation period), the reversibility of symptoms upon rewarming, the absence of fever in a substantial proportion of cases, and the paradoxical age-related pattern of incidence in which elderly individuals — despite progressive immunosenescence — suffer fewer episodes than children or young adults. These unresolved contradictions call for a fundamental reassessment of the pathogenesis of cold-associated respiratory disease. Objective This narrative review critically examines the role of cold exposure and cold stress in the pathogenesis of acute upper respiratory tract disorders and proposes a novel conceptual framework — Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome (ACRS) — as an independent nosological entity with clearly defined pathophysiological mechanisms, distinct diagnostic criteria, and specific clinical implications. The review further presents a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model of the common cold, as proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025). Methods A comprehensive narrative literature review was conducted across PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases, covering publications from 1946 to 2025 in English, Ukrainian, and Polish. Search terms included: cold stress, thermoregulation, upper respiratory tract, mucosal immunity, vasoconstriction, common cold pathophysiology, mucociliary clearance, cold air inhalation, HPA axis immune suppression, TRPM8, TRPA1, nasal mucosa cold. Artificial intelligence tools (large language models) were used exclusively for auxiliary tasks — initial literature sorting, grammatical proofreading, and reference formatting — with all scientific content, analyses, and conclusions being the sole intellectual product of the authors. Original thermodynamic calculations of metabolic energy expenditure during cold air breathing were performed and are presented in full within the manuscript. Results Convergent evidence from physiology, immunology, neuroscience, and thermodynamics reveals five interconnected pathophysiological mechanisms underlying ACRS: Vascular dysfunction: Inhalation of cold air activates TRPM8 (threshold < 25–28°C) and TRPA1 (threshold < 17°C) thermosensory receptors in the nasal mucosa, triggering rapid sympathetically mediated vasoconstriction within seconds to minutes. This is followed by reactive vasodilation with ischemia–reperfusion injury, increased capillary permeability, and release of histamine, bradykinin, prostaglandins (PGE₂, PGD₂), leukotrienes (LTC₄, LTD₄), and substance P — collectively producing the clinical triad of rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, and sneezing independently of any viral agent. Mucociliary dysfunction: Cold air reduces nasal mucosal temperature to 15–20°C, decreasing ciliary beat frequency (CBF) by approximately 50% — from 12–15 Hz to 6–8 Hz at 20°C, with near-complete arrest below 10°C. Simultaneously, dehydration of inhaled cold air increases mucus viscosity and reduces elasticity, impairing mucociliary transport. Mucociliary clearance time increases from a normal 10–20 minutes to over 60 minutes, significantly compromising pathogen elimination and epithelial barrier integrity. Metabolic and thermodynamic stress: Original thermodynamic calculations demonstrate that conditioning cold air (0°C) to tracheobronchial conditions (37°C, 100% relative humidity) requires approximately 14.2 W — equivalent to ~18% of basal metabolic rate at rest. During physical exertion (minute ventilation 30–60 L/min) this proportion rises to 25–35%, and under extreme cold (−20°C) may reach 40–50% of basal metabolism. This substantial energetic burden induces local ATP depletion in ciliated epithelial cells, impairs ion pump function (Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase), reduces synthesis of protective proteins (mucins, defensins, lysozyme), and activates pro-inflammatory signaling pathways (NF-κB, MAPK). Neuroendocrine immunosuppression: Cold stress activates the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis, elevating corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH), adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), and cortisol. Concurrently, sympathetic activation releases noradrenaline and adrenaline, producing a biphasic immunomodulatory effect: transient stimulation followed by sustained suppression of mucosal immunity. Secretory IgA (sIgA) production is reduced through direct suppression of plasma cell function, decreased mucosal blood flow, and HPA-mediated immunosuppression — collectively increasing susceptibility to secondary viral infection. Resolution of the age paradox: The counterintuitive age-related incidence pattern (children > adults > elderly) is explained not by differences in immune competence but by quantitative differences in cold exposure: children spend more time outdoors in cold weather, dress less adequately, have a higher relative minute ventilation per kilogram of body weight, and possess less developed thermoregulatory mechanisms. This host-response model, proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025), provides a more parsimonious and evidence-consistent explanation than the traditional "accumulated immunity"...
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Pedagogy and Psychology of Sport
- Vol. 31, 69792
Open AccessAcute Cold Respiratory Syndrome: A Narrative Review of Pathophysiological Mechanisms Beyond Viral Etiology
Background Acute respiratory illnesses, collectively referred to as the "common cold," represent one of the most prevalent conditions worldwide, affecting billions of individuals annually and imposing an enormous socioeconomic burden estimated at over $40 billion per year in the United States alone. Despite their ubiquity, the etiopathogenesis of these conditions remains insufficiently understood and scientifically contested. Contemporary medicine attributes all common cold episodes exclusively to viral infections — predominantly rhinoviruses (30–50%), coronaviruses (10–15%), and other respiratory viruses. However, this monocausal viral paradigm fails to explain several well-documented clinical and epidemiological inconsistencies: the onset of symptoms within minutes of cold exposure (far preceding any possible viral incubation period), the reversibility of symptoms upon rewarming, the absence of fever in a substantial proportion of cases, and the paradoxical age-related pattern of incidence in which elderly individuals — despite progressive immunosenescence — suffer fewer episodes than children or young adults. These unresolved contradictions call for a fundamental reassessment of the pathogenesis of cold-associated respiratory disease. Objective This narrative review critically examines the role of cold exposure and cold stress in the pathogenesis of acute upper respiratory tract disorders and proposes a novel conceptual framework — Acute Cold Respiratory Syndrome (ACRS) — as an independent nosological entity with clearly defined pathophysiological mechanisms, distinct diagnostic criteria, and specific clinical implications. The review further presents a paradigmatic shift from a pathogen-centric to a host-response model of the common cold, as proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025). Methods A comprehensive narrative literature review was conducted across PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases, covering publications from 1946 to 2025 in English, Ukrainian, and Polish. Search terms included: cold stress, thermoregulation, upper respiratory tract, mucosal immunity, vasoconstriction, common cold pathophysiology, mucociliary clearance, cold air inhalation, HPA axis immune suppression, TRPM8, TRPA1, nasal mucosa cold. Artificial intelligence tools (large language models) were used exclusively for auxiliary tasks — initial literature sorting, grammatical proofreading, and reference formatting — with all scientific content, analyses, and conclusions being the sole intellectual product of the authors. Original thermodynamic calculations of metabolic energy expenditure during cold air breathing were performed and are presented in full within the manuscript. Results Convergent evidence from physiology, immunology, neuroscience, and thermodynamics reveals five interconnected pathophysiological mechanisms underlying ACRS: Vascular dysfunction: Inhalation of cold air activates TRPM8 (threshold < 25–28°C) and TRPA1 (threshold < 17°C) thermosensory receptors in the nasal mucosa, triggering rapid sympathetically mediated vasoconstriction within seconds to minutes. This is followed by reactive vasodilation with ischemia–reperfusion injury, increased capillary permeability, and release of histamine, bradykinin, prostaglandins (PGE₂, PGD₂), leukotrienes (LTC₄, LTD₄), and substance P — collectively producing the clinical triad of rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, and sneezing independently of any viral agent. Mucociliary dysfunction: Cold air reduces nasal mucosal temperature to 15–20°C, decreasing ciliary beat frequency (CBF) by approximately 50% — from 12–15 Hz to 6–8 Hz at 20°C, with near-complete arrest below 10°C. Simultaneously, dehydration of inhaled cold air increases mucus viscosity and reduces elasticity, impairing mucociliary transport. Mucociliary clearance time increases from a normal 10–20 minutes to over 60 minutes, significantly compromising pathogen elimination and epithelial barrier integrity. Metabolic and thermodynamic stress: Original thermodynamic calculations demonstrate that conditioning cold air (0°C) to tracheobronchial conditions (37°C, 100% relative humidity) requires approximately 14.2 W — equivalent to ~18% of basal metabolic rate at rest. During physical exertion (minute ventilation 30–60 L/min) this proportion rises to 25–35%, and under extreme cold (−20°C) may reach 40–50% of basal metabolism. This substantial energetic burden induces local ATP depletion in ciliated epithelial cells, impairs ion pump function (Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase), reduces synthesis of protective proteins (mucins, defensins, lysozyme), and activates pro-inflammatory signaling pathways (NF-κB, MAPK). Neuroendocrine immunosuppression: Cold stress activates the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis, elevating corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH), adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), and cortisol. Concurrently, sympathetic activation releases noradrenaline and adrenaline, producing a biphasic immunomodulatory effect: transient stimulation followed by sustained suppression of mucosal immunity. Secretory IgA (sIgA) production is reduced through direct suppression of plasma cell function, decreased mucosal blood flow, and HPA-mediated immunosuppression — collectively increasing susceptibility to secondary viral infection. Resolution of the age paradox: The counterintuitive age-related incidence pattern (children > adults > elderly) is explained not by differences in immune competence but by quantitative differences in cold exposure: children spend more time outdoors in cold weather, dress less adequately, have a higher relative minute ventilation per kilogram of body weight, and possess less developed thermoregulatory mechanisms. This host-response model, proposed by Gozhenko et al. (2025), provides a more parsimonious and evidence-consistent explanation than the traditional "accumulated immunity"...
- Open Access
- 25 January 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 87
The Magic of Lateral Thinking and the Features of Its Implementation in Medical Education
Background: Enhancing teaching efficiency in clinical disciplines for medical students is critical for reducing medical errors and improving future medical practice. Despite advancements in foundational sciences, traditional teaching methods often fail to cultivate essential critical thinking skills. Lateral thinking (LT), a non-traditional approach emphasizing creativity and heuristic problem-solving, offers potential for innovation in medical education. Objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of LT-integrated pedagogy compared to traditional teaching methods in pediatric clinical training for master’s students, testing three hypotheses: 1. LT is incompatible with disciplines requiring strict protocol adherence (e.g., pediatrics).2. LT implementation requires minimal changes to traditional pedagogy.3. LT yields no significant difference in learning outcomes versus conventional methods. Methods: A quasi-experimental study was conducted with fifth-year Pediatrics master’s students at Odessa National Medical University. Participants were divided into: Control group (n=19): Traditional teaching (case analysis, protocol-based instruction). Experimental group (n=24): LT-integrated teaching (e.g., "Five Whys" technique, brainstorming, "medical tribunal" game).Both groups completed two lessons on "Diabetes mellitus in children." Twelve competencies (diagnostic/therapeutic skills) were assessed. Statistical analysis included t-tests, Pearson’s χ², and dispersion metrics (SPSS 17.0, Excel 2010). Results: The study refutes all five hypotheses. (1) LT implements evidence-based medicine while maintaining safety and applying innovative solutions in complex conditions. (2) Integration of LT required substantial structural changes (correlation coefficient = 0.298; χ² = 71.39, p<0.001). (3) After the second lesson, the LT group showed significantly higher skill acquisition (92.46% ±4.59 vs. 79.90% ±9.88; t=22.69, p<0.01; χ²=20.05, p<0.05). (4) LT reduced variance significantly (dispersion: 71.98 vs. 212.35; ratio 2.95:1). (5) LT accelerated mastery by 35% (13.26 vs. 17.86 hours; efficiency ratio 1.35:1). Conclusion of the study: The integration of lateral thinking in medical education enhances skill acquisition, promotes teamwork, and improves adaptability to complex clinical scenarios. Although it requires significant restructuring of teaching methods and additional preparation time, the benefits in terms of learning outcomes and efficiency are substantial.
- 25 January 2026
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 87
Open AccessThe Magic of Lateral Thinking and the Features of Its Implementation in Medical Education
Background: Enhancing teaching efficiency in clinical disciplines for medical students is critical for reducing medical errors and improving future medical practice. Despite advancements in foundational sciences, traditional teaching methods often fail to cultivate essential critical thinking skills. Lateral thinking (LT), a non-traditional approach emphasizing creativity and heuristic problem-solving, offers potential for innovation in medical education. Objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of LT-integrated pedagogy compared to traditional teaching methods in pediatric clinical training for master’s students, testing three hypotheses: 1. LT is incompatible with disciplines requiring strict protocol adherence (e.g., pediatrics).2. LT implementation requires minimal changes to traditional pedagogy.3. LT yields no significant difference in learning outcomes versus conventional methods. Methods: A quasi-experimental study was conducted with fifth-year Pediatrics master’s students at Odessa National Medical University. Participants were divided into: Control group (n=19): Traditional teaching (case analysis, protocol-based instruction). Experimental group (n=24): LT-integrated teaching (e.g., "Five Whys" technique, brainstorming, "medical tribunal" game).Both groups completed two lessons on "Diabetes mellitus in children." Twelve competencies (diagnostic/therapeutic skills) were assessed. Statistical analysis included t-tests, Pearson’s χ², and dispersion metrics (SPSS 17.0, Excel 2010). Results: The study refutes all five hypotheses. (1) LT implements evidence-based medicine while maintaining safety and applying innovative solutions in complex conditions. (2) Integration of LT required substantial structural changes (correlation coefficient = 0.298; χ² = 71.39, p<0.001). (3) After the second lesson, the LT group showed significantly higher skill acquisition (92.46% ±4.59 vs. 79.90% ±9.88; t=22.69, p<0.01; χ²=20.05, p<0.05). (4) LT reduced variance significantly (dispersion: 71.98 vs. 212.35; ratio 2.95:1). (5) LT accelerated mastery by 35% (13.26 vs. 17.86 hours; efficiency ratio 1.35:1). Conclusion of the study: The integration of lateral thinking in medical education enhances skill acquisition, promotes teamwork, and improves adaptability to complex clinical scenarios. Although it requires significant restructuring of teaching methods and additional preparation time, the benefits in terms of learning outcomes and efficiency are substantial.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2025
- Published by International Science Group in International Science Journal of Education & Linguistics
- Vol. 4 (3) , 11-19
The importance of hierarchy and classification of sciences in the educational process
The work is devoted to the current issue of a systemic nature. A positive attitude toward the need for the classification of sciences is justified. The arguments are the facts of the creative influence of the classification of sciences on: 1. Optimization of knowledge structuring. 2. A clearer identification of the specialization of sciences is needed. 3. Classification helps to see differences and connections between sciences. 4. Form the methodology of knowledge. 5. Forms the educational process. 6. Carries out synergism of scientific communications. 7. Potes the economic and managerial feasibility of structuring sciences. The work considers the task of substantiating a new modern methodology and reflecting the dynamics of the emergence of new scientific areas. Both structural-functional and hierarchical approaches are used. The subject of the study (subject) is the patterns of the emergence of new scientific areas in the modern world. The object of research is the possibility of logical and graphic interpretation of the formation of new scientific areas and their relationships. Models of a historical approach and classification of sciences in terms of fundamentalism and object of research are proposed. The trends of the 21st century, which should be taken into account by classifiers of science, are represented 1. Convergence of NBIC technologies: nano (material science), BIO (general engineering), info (quantum calculations). Cogno (neuro interfaces). 2. Revolutionary changes to the methodologists are presented: the fourth paradigm (given-oriented science): CERN: 30 petabytes/data year with a tank; Alphafold: prediction of 200 million protein structures. 3. The emergence of new disciplines: Cliodinomics: mathematical modelling of historical processes. Astrobiology: Search for life outside the Earth + synthetic biology. The forecast has been made that further studies should show that the real, relevant hierarchy of sciences should discard the image of the hierarchical staircase and take the form of a neural network with cross-bonds, where breakthroughs arise at the joints of the disciplines. With this approach, mathematics remains the “queen of sciences," but its power is now shared with science and complexity theory. A dynamic interference model is proposed to predict the development of new directions.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by International Science Group in International Science Journal of Education & Linguistics
- Vol. 4 (3) , 11-19
Open AccessThe importance of hierarchy and classification of sciences in the educational process
The work is devoted to the current issue of a systemic nature. A positive attitude toward the need for the classification of sciences is justified. The arguments are the facts of the creative influence of the classification of sciences on: 1. Optimization of knowledge structuring. 2. A clearer identification of the specialization of sciences is needed. 3. Classification helps to see differences and connections between sciences. 4. Form the methodology of knowledge. 5. Forms the educational process. 6. Carries out synergism of scientific communications. 7. Potes the economic and managerial feasibility of structuring sciences. The work considers the task of substantiating a new modern methodology and reflecting the dynamics of the emergence of new scientific areas. Both structural-functional and hierarchical approaches are used. The subject of the study (subject) is the patterns of the emergence of new scientific areas in the modern world. The object of research is the possibility of logical and graphic interpretation of the formation of new scientific areas and their relationships. Models of a historical approach and classification of sciences in terms of fundamentalism and object of research are proposed. The trends of the 21st century, which should be taken into account by classifiers of science, are represented 1. Convergence of NBIC technologies: nano (material science), BIO (general engineering), info (quantum calculations). Cogno (neuro interfaces). 2. Revolutionary changes to the methodologists are presented: the fourth paradigm (given-oriented science): CERN: 30 petabytes/data year with a tank; Alphafold: prediction of 200 million protein structures. 3. The emergence of new disciplines: Cliodinomics: mathematical modelling of historical processes. Astrobiology: Search for life outside the Earth + synthetic biology. The forecast has been made that further studies should show that the real, relevant hierarchy of sciences should discard the image of the hierarchical staircase and take the form of a neural network with cross-bonds, where breakthroughs arise at the joints of the disciplines. With this approach, mathematics remains the “queen of sciences," but its power is now shared with science and complexity theory. A dynamic interference model is proposed to predict the development of new directions.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2025
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 80, 60564
New horizons of medical education: Developing critical and logical clinical reasoning in students
Background. Quality management experts in medical services note with concern that despite the high energy intensity of modern medicine, the number of medical errors remains relatively high. Addressing this problem through administrative methods does not show visible effects. A concept has been proposed that one of the reasons for this paradox may be the peculiarity of clinical thinking among physicians. Objective. The aim of the study was to analyze the nature of medical errors made by young doctors (masters and interns) in diagnosing common diseases in children of the Odesa region of Ukraine. Material and Methods. In the analysis of errors, deductive and inductive methods were used, as well as methods of formal logic. 115 case histories were studied. Erroneous conclusions were revealed in 109 cases (94.78%). Results. The rating of erroneous conclusions by masters identified the structure of the "imaginary logical connection" - non sequitur (Latin) as the most common type, made by 42 respondents (36.52%). The next three places were taken by other reasoning structures: 2 - "After that, it means because of that" - post hoc ergo propter hoc: 28 respondents (24.35%); 3 - "Reasoning in a circle" - idem per idem: 23 responses (20.00%); 4 - verbal tricks, which are "ethically controversial rhetorical techniques": 16 responses (13.91%). Analysis of 109 erroneous logical conclusions for compliance with the four laws of logic showed that the first law, "The law of identity," was violated 53 times (48.62%), the second law, "The law of contradiction," was violated 29 times (26.61%), the third, "The law of the excluded middle," was violated 18 times (16.51%), and the fourth, "The law of sufficient reason," was violated 9 times (8.26%). Conclusions. It was concluded that the clinical disciplines program should include a systemic cognitive process—teaching critical thinking skills. Critical thinking in medicine is a systematic cognitive process, the training of which allows a doctor to accurately carry out a series of logical conclusions, integrate knowledge from fundamental disciplines, and minimize cognitive errors.
- 26 April 2025
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 80, 60564
Open AccessNew horizons of medical education: Developing critical and logical clinical reasoning in students
Background. Quality management experts in medical services note with concern that despite the high energy intensity of modern medicine, the number of medical errors remains relatively high. Addressing this problem through administrative methods does not show visible effects. A concept has been proposed that one of the reasons for this paradox may be the peculiarity of clinical thinking among physicians. Objective. The aim of the study was to analyze the nature of medical errors made by young doctors (masters and interns) in diagnosing common diseases in children of the Odesa region of Ukraine. Material and Methods. In the analysis of errors, deductive and inductive methods were used, as well as methods of formal logic. 115 case histories were studied. Erroneous conclusions were revealed in 109 cases (94.78%). Results. The rating of erroneous conclusions by masters identified the structure of the "imaginary logical connection" - non sequitur (Latin) as the most common type, made by 42 respondents (36.52%). The next three places were taken by other reasoning structures: 2 - "After that, it means because of that" - post hoc ergo propter hoc: 28 respondents (24.35%); 3 - "Reasoning in a circle" - idem per idem: 23 responses (20.00%); 4 - verbal tricks, which are "ethically controversial rhetorical techniques": 16 responses (13.91%). Analysis of 109 erroneous logical conclusions for compliance with the four laws of logic showed that the first law, "The law of identity," was violated 53 times (48.62%), the second law, "The law of contradiction," was violated 29 times (26.61%), the third, "The law of the excluded middle," was violated 18 times (16.51%), and the fourth, "The law of sufficient reason," was violated 9 times (8.26%). Conclusions. It was concluded that the clinical disciplines program should include a systemic cognitive process—teaching critical thinking skills. Critical thinking in medicine is a systematic cognitive process, the training of which allows a doctor to accurately carry out a series of logical conclusions, integrate knowledge from fundamental disciplines, and minimize cognitive errors.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2025
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 79, 59885
Anthropoetics as a super-system approach to the study of public health
Background: Health as a biosocial phenomenon is studied across multiple scientific disciplines, yet increasing specialization has resulted in fragmented knowledge and a loss of holistic perspective. Contemporary global challenges - including climate change, pandemics, and artificial intelligence - demand a new integrative ethical framework. Objective: This article introduces anthropoetics as a super-system approach to public health, aiming to unify existing ethical systems (bioethics, technoethics, noetics) into a comprehensive paradigm addressing modern civilizational risks. Methods: The study employs: Bioethical and systems theory analysis (ISO 9001:2015 standards). Ontological modeling (STCHH - space-time continuum of human health). Historical-dialectical review of ethical systems evolution Results: Anthropoetics emerges as an ethical super-system based on four pillars: Interconnectedness of all life and cosmic elements. Sustainable development principles. Consciousness as a foundation for ethical norms. Humanism respecting all life forms Conclusions: Anthropoetics provides a transformative paradigm for public health research and policy, requiring international collaboration for implementation. Its super-system structure offers novel solutions for harmonizing scientific progress with ethical imperatives in the Anthropocene era.
- 30 March 2025
- Published by Uniwersytet Mikolaja Kopernika/Nicolaus Copernicus University in Journal of Education, Health and Sport
- Vol. 79, 59885
Open AccessAnthropoetics as a super-system approach to the study of public health
Background: Health as a biosocial phenomenon is studied across multiple scientific disciplines, yet increasing specialization has resulted in fragmented knowledge and a loss of holistic perspective. Contemporary global challenges - including climate change, pandemics, and artificial intelligence - demand a new integrative ethical framework. Objective: This article introduces anthropoetics as a super-system approach to public health, aiming to unify existing ethical systems (bioethics, technoethics, noetics) into a comprehensive paradigm addressing modern civilizational risks. Methods: The study employs: Bioethical and systems theory analysis (ISO 9001:2015 standards). Ontological modeling (STCHH - space-time continuum of human health). Historical-dialectical review of ethical systems evolution Results: Anthropoetics emerges as an ethical super-system based on four pillars: Interconnectedness of all life and cosmic elements. Sustainable development principles. Consciousness as a foundation for ethical norms. Humanism respecting all life forms Conclusions: Anthropoetics provides a transformative paradigm for public health research and policy, requiring international collaboration for implementation. Its super-system structure offers novel solutions for harmonizing scientific progress with ethical imperatives in the Anthropocene era.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Academic Notes. Series: Pedagogical Science
- Vol. 1 (217) , 12-18
ASSESSMENT OF THE DIFFERENCE OF OPINIONS OF HIGHER MEDICAL EDUCATION APPLICANTS ON THE QUALITY OF TEACHING ACCORDING TO THE RESULTS OF AN ANONYMOUS QUESTIONNAIRE
Within the framework of the ISO 9001 quality management system for educational services implemented at the Odessa National Medical University (ONMedU). The quality of teaching educational discipline 228 “Pediatrics” was assessed in distance learning (DL) mode. The research method is based on statistical processing of data from an anonymous survey (AS) of higher education applicants (HEA) of senior courses at ONMedU. According to the inclusion criteria, questionnaires from 461 respondents were selected 368 (79,83%) domestic and 93 (20,17%) foreign). All HEAs (100%) took part in the DL under the condition of the martial law (spring 2023 to present 2024). The “null hypothesis” of this study was - the absence of significant differences between the assessments of domestic and foreign respondents, since they were all given identical questionnaires, and the subject was taught in a single department, using identical educational programs. The study refers to a cross-sectional design and includes identifying the significance of differences between different groups of HEAs based on the Pearson criterion, as well as identifying the degree of diversity of opinions of HEAs based on dispersion indicators. The results of the study showed that for 11 (42,31%) out of 26 questions, significantly different answers were received, which excludes the validity of the “null hypothesis”. AA also identified a number of DL risks, the elimination or reduction of which can increase the level of satisfaction from training among applicants: insufficient involvement of them in scientific work; insufficient volume of development of practical skills and shortage of study time in relation to the volume of material studied. The AA showed that diversity of opinions exists not only between domestic and foreign HEAs but also within each group, which was objectively reflected by the conducted dispersion analysis. Conclision: AA is an effective method of maintaining the ISO 9001 quality management system at the university. У рамках впровадженої в Одеському національному медичному університеті (ОНМедУ) системи управління якістю освітніх послуг ISO 9001 проведено оцінку якості викладання навчальної дисципліни 228 «Педіатрія» у режимі дистанційного навчання (ДН). Метод дослідження ґрунтується на статистичній обробці даних анонімного анкетування (АА) здобувачів вищої освіти (ЗВО) старших курсів ОНМедУ. Згідно з критеріями включення відібрано анкети 461 респондента: 368 (79,83%) вітчизняних та 93 (20,17%) іноземних. Усі ЗВО (100%) взяли участь у ДН в умовах воєнного стану (вересень 2023 по січень 2024 р.). "Нульова гіпотеза" даного дослідження передбачала відсутність суттєвих розбіжностей між думками вітчизняних та зарубіжних респондентів, оскільки як вітчизняним, так і зарубіжним респондентам були дані одні й ті самі питання, а викладання предмета проходило на одній і тій же кафедрі з ідентичних навчальних програм для вітчизняних та зарубіжних ЗВО. Дослідження відноситься до крос-секційного дизайну та включає виявлення достовірності відмінностей між різними групами ЗВО на основі критерію Пірсона, а також виявлення ступеня різноманітності думок ЗВО на основі показників дисперсії. Результати дослідження показали, що на 11 питань (42,31%) з 26 отримані відповіді, що достовірно відрізняються та виключають справедливість “нульової гіпотези”. АА виявило також низку ризиків ДН усунення чи зменшення яких здатне підвищити рівень задоволеності навчання у здобувачів: недостатнє залучення в наукову роботу; недостатній обсяг освоєння практичних навичок та дефіцит навчального часу стосовно обсягу досліджуваного матеріалу. АА показало, що різноманітність думок існує не лише між вітчизняними та зарубіжними ЗВО, а й присутня всередині кожної групи, що об’єктивно відобразив проведений дисперсійний аналіз, який виявив ряд дискутабельних питань, та потребу у додатковому опрацюванні.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Academic Notes. Series: Pedagogical Science
- Vol. 1 (217) , 12-18
Open AccessASSESSMENT OF THE DIFFERENCE OF OPINIONS OF HIGHER MEDICAL EDUCATION APPLICANTS ON THE QUALITY OF TEACHING ACCORDING TO THE RESULTS OF AN ANONYMOUS QUESTIONNAIRE
Within the framework of the ISO 9001 quality management system for educational services implemented at the Odessa National Medical University (ONMedU). The quality of teaching educational discipline 228 “Pediatrics” was assessed in distance learning (DL) mode. The research method is based on statistical processing of data from an anonymous survey (AS) of higher education applicants (HEA) of senior courses at ONMedU. According to the inclusion criteria, questionnaires from 461 respondents were selected 368 (79,83%) domestic and 93 (20,17%) foreign). All HEAs (100%) took part in the DL under the condition of the martial law (spring 2023 to present 2024). The “null hypothesis” of this study was - the absence of significant differences between the assessments of domestic and foreign respondents, since they were all given identical questionnaires, and the subject was taught in a single department, using identical educational programs. The study refers to a cross-sectional design and includes identifying the significance of differences between different groups of HEAs based on the Pearson criterion, as well as identifying the degree of diversity of opinions of HEAs based on dispersion indicators. The results of the study showed that for 11 (42,31%) out of 26 questions, significantly different answers were received, which excludes the validity of the “null hypothesis”. AA also identified a number of DL risks, the elimination or reduction of which can increase the level of satisfaction from training among applicants: insufficient involvement of them in scientific work; insufficient volume of development of practical skills and shortage of study time in relation to the volume of material studied. The AA showed that diversity of opinions exists not only between domestic and foreign HEAs but also within each group, which was objectively reflected by the conducted dispersion analysis. Conclision: AA is an effective method of maintaining the ISO 9001 quality management system at the university. У рамках впровадженої в Одеському національному медичному університеті (ОНМедУ) системи управління якістю освітніх послуг ISO 9001 проведено оцінку якості викладання навчальної дисципліни 228 «Педіатрія» у режимі дистанційного навчання (ДН). Метод дослідження ґрунтується на статистичній обробці даних анонімного анкетування (АА) здобувачів вищої освіти (ЗВО) старших курсів ОНМедУ. Згідно з критеріями включення відібрано анкети 461 респондента: 368 (79,83%) вітчизняних та 93 (20,17%) іноземних. Усі ЗВО (100%) взяли участь у ДН в умовах воєнного стану (вересень 2023 по січень 2024 р.). "Нульова гіпотеза" даного дослідження передбачала відсутність суттєвих розбіжностей між думками вітчизняних та зарубіжних респондентів, оскільки як вітчизняним, так і зарубіжним респондентам були дані одні й ті самі питання, а викладання предмета проходило на одній і тій же кафедрі з ідентичних навчальних програм для вітчизняних та зарубіжних ЗВО. Дослідження відноситься до крос-секційного дизайну та включає виявлення достовірності відмінностей між різними групами ЗВО на основі критерію Пірсона, а також виявлення ступеня різноманітності думок ЗВО на основі показників дисперсії. Результати дослідження показали, що на 11 питань (42,31%) з 26 отримані відповіді, що достовірно відрізняються та виключають справедливість “нульової гіпотези”. АА виявило також низку ризиків ДН усунення чи зменшення яких здатне підвищити рівень задоволеності навчання у здобувачів: недостатнє залучення в наукову роботу; недостатній обсяг освоєння практичних навичок та дефіцит навчального часу стосовно обсягу досліджуваного матеріалу. АА показало, що різноманітність думок існує не лише між вітчизняними та зарубіжними ЗВО, а й присутня всередині кожної групи, що об’єктивно відобразив проведений дисперсійний аналіз, який виявив ряд дискутабельних питань, та потребу у додатковому опрацюванні.