LDL. Delbroek

L. Delbroek

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


L. Delbroek has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Simulations of massive star atmospheres and winds during giant eruptive and quiescent luminous blue variable phases

    by P. Schillemans, J. O. Sundqvist, D. Debnath, L. Delbroek, N. Moens, C. Van der Sijpt

    Context . Mass loss from massive stars located in the part of the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram (HRD) where we find luminous blue variables (LBVs) is profoundly important for stellar evolution yet very poorly understood. Aims . We used time-dependent radiation-hydrodynamic (RHD) simulations to examine the atmosphere and wind properties of massive stars in this region of the HRD. Methods . We computed 2D and 1D RHD models of the coupled envelopes, atmospheres, and wind outflows of massive stars, tuned to the region in the HRD where LBVs are located. Our unified simulations, which start deep in the stellar envelope (below the iron opacity bump) and range well into the outflowing wind, account for line-driving as well as radiative enthalpy and photon tiring. Mass-loss rates and wind speeds are thereby emergent properties in the simulations. A grid of models was created by slightly increasing the stellar energy at the lower boundary, which then controls the emergent radiative luminosity at the photosphere. Results . Increasing total stellar energy results in a natural transition from very turbulent atmospheres with line-driven winds to effectively stationary super-Eddington massive outflows. In the latter case, radiative enthalpy keeps the star below the Eddington limit in the deep layers where the wind is launched. However, as energy transport by enthalpy becomes inefficient as we approach the surface, the star was observed to become highly super-Eddington at its recombined photosphere. Our sub-Eddington models are essentially blue hypergiant stars ( T eff ∼ 10000–20 000 K) with very variable surfaces, effective mass-loss rates of Ṁ ∼ 2–5 ×10 −5 M ⊙ /yr, and wind speeds of ∞ ∼ 200–300 km/s, resembling quiescent LBVs, like P Cygni. The super-Eddington models have optically thick wind envelopes and extremely inflated red or yellow surfaces ( T eff ∼ 5000 K), with Ṁ ∼ 0.1–1 M ⊙ /yr and ∞ ∼ 400–500 km/s, thus resembling a massive star during a great eruption, such as that of η Carinae. Conclusions . Although not tuned to any specific star, our RHD atmosphere and wind models naturally reproduce the overall characteristic stellar and wind parameters inferred for massive stars in their quiescent LBV and yellow giant eruptive phases. It remains an open question whether the energy increase needed to trigger a giant eruption can be obtained solely by the internal evolution of the star itself or if it requires an external energy source such as a stellar merger or a close binary interaction.


  • Open Access

    Effects on v sin i determinations of O stars from 3D model atmospheres with high turbulent velocities

    by L. Delbroek, J. O. Sundqvist, F. Backs, T. Ceulemans, D. Debnath, P. Schillemans

    Context. When studying massive stars and their life cycles, rotation plays a key role. Hence, understanding the rotation of these stars is crucial when determining their properties, or for constraining evolutionary models. Aims. We examined the reliability of the standard methods to derive projected rotation speeds v sin i from photospheric spectra of hot massive stars in the presence of high turbulent velocities. Methods. We included rotation in the spectral synthesis of O stars by means of three-dimensional (3D) model atmospheres showing significant photospheric turbulent velocities. We then used these as mock observations to back-test the Fourier transform (FT) and goodness-of-fit (GOF) methods commonly used for empirical determination of v sin i when the turbulent velocity field is not known. Results. When the expected v sin i > v macro , with v macro the macroturbulent velocity, FT v sin i determinations (most of the time) give reasonable results. However, if v sin i < v macro the method is no longer reliable. Results from the GOF method show that if one parameter is not significantly larger than the other, empirical best-fit values may be located in a large region of the v sin i – v macro parameter space, independent of the true values. The degenerate region closely follows the shape of the empirical formula found by Howarth et al. (2007, MNRAS, 381, 433), C = √( v 2 macro /2+ v sin i ) 2 /4), with C i ≥ C e for C i the inferred value and C e the expected. Conclusions. Our analysis shows clearly that, generally, only the sum √( v 2 macro /2+ v sin i ) 2 /4) can be approximated through the standard spectroscopic methods used to infer these parameters individually. Only in the case where one of the two clearly dominates, can good constraints on the dominating parameter be derived. This demonstrates that previously found empirical correlations between v sin i and v macro as well as the derived statistical distributions of the observed rotation rates for O-star populations will need to be re-analysed and re-interpreted.

  • Open Access

    Spectral synthesis of 3D unified model atmospheres with winds for O stars

    by L. Delbroek, J. O. Sundqvist, D. Debnath, N. Moens, F. Backs, C. Van der Sijpt, O. Verhamme, P. Schillemans

    Context. Spectroscopic studies of massive and luminous O-type stellar atmospheres and winds have primarily been done by using one-dimensional (1D), spherically symmetric, and stationary models. However, both observations and modern theoretical models show that such O stars have highly structured and variable atmospheres and winds. Aims. We present a first spectral synthesis based on three-dimensional (3D) time-dependent unified radiation-hydrodynamic (RHD) model atmospheres with winds for O stars. Methods. We first carried out time-dependent, 3D simulations of unified O-star atmospheres with winds. We then used 3D radiative transfer to compute surface brightness maps for the optical continuum as well as integrated flux profiles for select diagnostic lines. To derive occupation numbers and source functions, an approximate non-local thermodynamic equilibrium method was used, as well as scattering source functions. Results. Our continuum intensity maps of a prototypical early O star (⟨ T eff ⟩ = 40.2 kK, log 10 (⟨ L ⋆ ⟩/ L ⊙ ) = 5.79) in the Galaxy reveal a highly variable and time-dependent surface, characterised by local emergent radiation temperature variations exceeding 10 000 K. Our averaged synthetic line profiles of optical absorption lines have large widths, since the RHD simulations have large velocity dispersions in photospheric layers. Additionally, the absorption line equivalent widths are larger than for comparable 1D models. As such, to reproduce the 3D absorption line results in a corresponding 1D model, we need to apply isotropic Gaussian microturbulence, v mic ~ 10–20 km/s, and macroturbulence, v mac ~ 70 km/s, to the latter. First results using scattering source functions further demonstrate that characteristic features such as the softening of the blue edge of strong ultraviolet wind lines are qualitatively well reproduced by our models. Conclusions. Our 3D simulations clearly predict a highly structured and strongly variable O-star surface, in stark contrast with the smooth surfaces assumed by the 1D models currently used for quantitative spectroscopy of such stars. The first line profile results further suggest that several observed features are naturally reproduced by our models without the need to introduce ad hoc spectral fitting parameters. We also discuss how using 3D rather than 1D simulations as a basis for future studies may affect the derivation of fundamental stellar parameters such as surface gravities and chemical abundances.


  • Open Access

    An on-the-fly line-driven wind iterative mass-loss estimator (LIME) for hot, massive stars of arbitrary chemical compositions

    by J. O. Sundqvist, D. Debnath, F. Backs, O. Verhamme, N. Moens, L. Delbroek, D. Dickson, P. Schillemans, C. Van der Sijpt, M. Dirickx

    Context. Mass-loss rates, Ṁ , from hot, massive stars are important for a range of astrophysical applications. Aims. We present LIME, a fast, efficient, and easy-to-use real-time mass-loss calculator for line-driven winds from hot, massive stars with given stellar parameters and arbitrary chemical compositions. The tool is publicly available online. Methods. We compute the line force on-the-fly from excitation and ionization balance calculations using a large atomic data base containing more than four million spectral lines. We then derive mass-loss rates from line-driven wind theory, including effects of a finite stellar disk and gas sound speed. Results. For a given set of stellar parameters and chemical composition, we obtain predictions for Ṁ and for the three line-force parameters, Q̄ , Q 0 , and α, at the wind critical point. A comparison of our predicted Ṁ with a large sample of recent, state-of-the-art, homogeneously derived empirical mass-loss rates obtained from the X SHOOT U collaboration project demonstrates that the simple calculator presented here performs on average as well as, or even better than, other available mass-loss recipes based on fits to restricted model grids computed from more sophisticated but less flexible methods. Conclusions. In addition to its speed and simplicity, a strength of our mass-loss calculator is that it avoids uncertainties related to applying fit formulae to underlying model grids calculated for more restricted parameter ranges. In particular, individual chemical abundances can be easily modified, and their effects on predicted mass-loss rates can be readily explored. This enables direct applications also to stars that are significantly chemically modified at the surface.


  • Open Access

    Improving 1D stellar atmosphere models with insights from multidimensional simulations

    by G. González-Torà, A. A. C. Sander, N. Moens, J. O. Sundqvist, D. Debnath, L. Delbroek, J. Josiek, R. R. Lefever, C. Van der Sijpt, O. Verhamme, et al.

    Context. Classical Wolf-Rayet (cWR) stars are evolved massive stars that have lost most of their hydrogen envelope, presenting dense, extended atmospheres with strong stellar winds. Accurate descriptions of their line-driven winds and in particular the launching of the winds in optically thick layers have long remained enigmatic. Two different approaches have recently allowed for significant progress to be made, namely, one-dimensional (1D) atmosphere models with stationary hydrodynamics and time-dependent, multidimensional, radiation-hydrodynamic models. Aims. The computational demands and required approximations limit the applications of multidimensional, time-dependent atmospheric models. Therefore, 1D stationary atmosphere models remain an important and necessary tool, but there is also a need to incorporate reasonable approximations of the physical insights gained in multidimensional and time-dependent simulations. Methods. We compared averaged stratifications from recent multidimensional atmosphere models for cWR stars with 1D stellar atmosphere models computed with the hydrodynamically consistent branch of the PoWR model atmosphere code. We studied models that include winds launched by the hot iron bump, while varying several of the 1D model parameters to characterize any differences that occur and to quantify their impact on the 1D solutions obtained. Results. The 1D hydrodynamically consistent atmosphere models tested in this study match the averaged 3D density stratifications. Overall, 1D models with standard inputs obtained mass-loss rates ≲0.2 dex higher than their 3D equivalents, but minor adjustments in accordance with the mass-loss and luminosity dispersion obtained from the time-dependent multidimensional simulations are able to reconcile this difference. The 1D models are radially more extended, while displaying higher terminal velocities and lower effective temperatures. Although the 1D models reproduce the same velocity trend as the 3D calculations, they launch their winds a bit further out and reach higher velocities during the hot iron bump. The resulting differences in effective temperature and terminal velocity are also seen in the synthetic spectra computed from different 1D PoWR model approaches. Conclusions. The overall stellar atmosphere structure profiles for 1D and 3D averaged hydrodynamically consistent models follow a similar trend, providing stellar parameters that are well matched when accounting for the dispersion of the time-dependent 3D simulations and the different methodologies. For stars closer to the Eddington Limit, decreasing the Doppler velocities in 1D models can help reconcile the mass-loss rates, effective temperatures, and velocity profiles in the outer wind. Obtaining a match for the temperature structures in optically thin regions remains an open challenge.


  • Open Access

    Improving 1D stellar atmosphere models with insights from multi-dimensional simulations

    by G. González-Torà, A. A. C. Sander, J. O. Sundqvist, D. Debnath, L. Delbroek, J. Josiek, R. R. Lefever, N. Moens, C. Van der Sijpt, O. Verhamme

    Context. The outer layers and the spectral appearance of massive stars are inherently affected by radiation pressure. Recent multidimensional, radiation-hydrodynamical (RHD) simulations of massive stellar atmospheres have shed new light on the complexity involved in the surface layers and the onset of radiation-driven winds. These findings include the presence of sub-surface, radiatively driven turbulent motion. For some regimes, the velocities associated with this turbulence and their localisation significantly exceed earlier estimates drawn from stellar structure models. This prompts the question of whether spectral diagnostics obtained with the typical assumptions in 1D spherically symmetric and stationary atmospheres are still sufficient. Aims. For the foreseeable future, the inherent computation costs and necessary approximations will pose challenges to the common usage of multi-dimensional, time-dependent atmosphere models in the quantitative spectral analysis of populations of stars. Therefore, suitable approximations of multi-dimensional simulation results need to be implemented into 1D atmosphere models. Methods. We compared current 1D and multi-dimensional atmosphere modelling approaches to understand their strengths and shortcomings. We calculated the averaged stratifications from selected multi-dimensional calculations for O stars – corresponding to spectral types O8, O4, and O2, with log 𝑔 ∼ 3.7 – to approximate them with 1D stellar atmosphere models using the PoWR model atmosphere code and assuming a fixed β–law for the wind regime. We then studied the effects of our approximations and assumptions on current spectral diagnostics. In particular, we focus on the impact of an additional turbulent pressure in the subsonic layers of the 1D models. Results. To match the 2D averages, the 1D stellar atmosphere models need to account for turbulent pressure in the hydrostatic equation. Moreover, an adjustment of the connection point between the (quasi)hydrostatic regime and the wind regime is required. The improvement between the density stratification of the 1D model and 2D average can be further increased if the mass-loss rate of the 1D model is not identical to that of the 2D simulation; rather, it is typically ∼0.2 dex higher. Especially in the case of an early-type star, this would imply a significantly more extended envelope with a lower effective temperature. Conclusions. Already, the inclusion of a constant turbulence term in the solution of the hydrostatic equation is shown to sufficiently reproduce the 2D-averaged model density stratifications. The addition of a significant turbulent motion also smoothens the slope of the radiative acceleration term in the (quasi)hydrostatic domain, with several potential implications on the total mass-loss rate inferred from 1D modelling. Concerning the spectral synthesis, the addition of a turbulence term in the hydrostatic equation mimics the effect of a lower surface gravity, potentially presenting a solution to the ‘mass discrepancy problem’ between the evolutionary and spectroscopy mass determinations.