Anna Erliyana
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Anna Erliyana has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ahmad Haidar Muiny
Universitas Indonesia
1 shared publication - Ahmad Novindri Aji Sukma
University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom
1 shared publication - Ali Masyhar
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang
1 shared publication - Alif Wili Utama
Universitas Indonesia
1 shared publication - Dewi Asimah
Mahkamah Agung
1 shared publication - Edmon Makarim
Universitas Indonesia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 39-66
The Legality of the Living Law in the New Indonesian Penal Code
Since the Netherland introduced a Penal Code, The Indonesian people are required to rely on the principle of legality as the primary source of law in determining criminal offences. The old penal code does not allow living law to function as an independent source of law. On January 2nd, 2023, the new Indonesian Penal Code was finally established, which will enter into force within three years after its issuance. The provision of living law in the new Indonesian penal code is formulated in article 2. In its first verse, it is written that “provisions, as referred to Article 1 (legality principle), does not negate the validity of the law that live in a society which stipulates that someone deserves to be punished even though the act is not regulated in this Law." In the explanation section, it is stated that “law that lives in society” (living law) refers to Adat Law, which should be codified through Regional Regulations (Peraturan Daerah). This raises two issues: first, it confines the concept of living law solely to Adat Law; second, it requires Adat Law to be formalized in the form of regional legislation. If Adat Law must be regulated through Regional Regulations, the necessity of Article 2 becomes questionable. The purpose of recognizing living law is to address gaps in legal principles that cannot always keep pace with a rapidly changing society.
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 39-66
Open AccessThe Legality of the Living Law in the New Indonesian Penal Code
Since the Netherland introduced a Penal Code, The Indonesian people are required to rely on the principle of legality as the primary source of law in determining criminal offences. The old penal code does not allow living law to function as an independent source of law. On January 2nd, 2023, the new Indonesian Penal Code was finally established, which will enter into force within three years after its issuance. The provision of living law in the new Indonesian penal code is formulated in article 2. In its first verse, it is written that “provisions, as referred to Article 1 (legality principle), does not negate the validity of the law that live in a society which stipulates that someone deserves to be punished even though the act is not regulated in this Law." In the explanation section, it is stated that “law that lives in society” (living law) refers to Adat Law, which should be codified through Regional Regulations (Peraturan Daerah). This raises two issues: first, it confines the concept of living law solely to Adat Law; second, it requires Adat Law to be formalized in the form of regional legislation. If Adat Law must be regulated through Regional Regulations, the necessity of Article 2 becomes questionable. The purpose of recognizing living law is to address gaps in legal principles that cannot always keep pace with a rapidly changing society.
- Open Access
- 6 December 2025
- Published by Universitas Mataram in Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan
- Vol. 13 (3) , 708-733
The Concept and Legal Protection Regarding Government Administrative Actions in the Form of Not Performing Concrete Actions (Omission)
After the enactment of Law No. 30 of 2014 on Government Administration (Government Administration Law or abbreviated as UU AP in Indonesian) and Supreme Court Regulation (Perma) No. 2 of 2019, the authority of the Administrative Judiciary has expanded. The Administrative Judiciary adjudicates disputes related to administrative decisions and handles disputes related to government administrative actions (Factual Conduct). Actions that can be sued include active (performing concrete/Factual Conduct - commission) and passive (not performing concrete/Factual Conduct-omission) actions. Although Government Administration Law and Supreme Court Regulation do not provide detailed explanations regarding the meaning and criteria of passive government actions, based on studies, several criteria can be used to assess whether passive government actions can be considered unlawful. These criteria include the existence of a legal obligation that must be performed by an administrative official. The action is within the scope of their authority, the official intentionally does not fulfill the obligation, the action violates legislation and legal obligations, or the plaintiff’s subjective rights, and the existence of a permissible claim for actual damages. In terms of legal protection, citizens can file a lawsuit in the Administrative Court against the failure of a government body or official to perform a concrete action. However, in practice, various problems still arise, such as the time limit for filing lawsuits, the obligation to pursue administrative remedies first, and issues related to the tacit authorization concept.
- 6 December 2025
- Published by Universitas Mataram in Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan
- Vol. 13 (3) , 708-733
Open AccessThe Concept and Legal Protection Regarding Government Administrative Actions in the Form of Not Performing Concrete Actions (Omission)
After the enactment of Law No. 30 of 2014 on Government Administration (Government Administration Law or abbreviated as UU AP in Indonesian) and Supreme Court Regulation (Perma) No. 2 of 2019, the authority of the Administrative Judiciary has expanded. The Administrative Judiciary adjudicates disputes related to administrative decisions and handles disputes related to government administrative actions (Factual Conduct). Actions that can be sued include active (performing concrete/Factual Conduct - commission) and passive (not performing concrete/Factual Conduct-omission) actions. Although Government Administration Law and Supreme Court Regulation do not provide detailed explanations regarding the meaning and criteria of passive government actions, based on studies, several criteria can be used to assess whether passive government actions can be considered unlawful. These criteria include the existence of a legal obligation that must be performed by an administrative official. The action is within the scope of their authority, the official intentionally does not fulfill the obligation, the action violates legislation and legal obligations, or the plaintiff’s subjective rights, and the existence of a permissible claim for actual damages. In terms of legal protection, citizens can file a lawsuit in the Administrative Court against the failure of a government body or official to perform a concrete action. However, in practice, various problems still arise, such as the time limit for filing lawsuits, the obligation to pursue administrative remedies first, and issues related to the tacit authorization concept.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Universitas Islam Indonesia (Islamic University of Indonesia) in Jurnal Lex Renaissance
- Vol. 10 (1) , 222-248
Keabsahan Keputusan Tata Usaha Negara yang Berlaku Retroaktif (Studi Kasus Surat Keputusan Menteri Dalam Negeri Tentang Pemberhentian Sementara Wakil Bupati Mimika)
This research is motivated by the retroactive implementation of State Administrative Decrees (KTUN) in the implementation of government administration. This policy anomaly because it will impact the status of legal actions taken before the KTUN is issued. This research aims to answer first, the validity of retroactive administrative decisions based on the theory of authority and the General Principles of Good Governance, and their implications for the legal actions of the Mimika Regency Government; and second, the legal analysis and implications of the Minister of Home Affairs Decree No. 100.2.3-1245 of 2023 concerning the Temporary Suspension of the Deputy Regent of Mimika, Central Papua Province, which applies retroactively. This research employs a normative juridical method using theoretical and conceptual approaches, along with qualitative data analysis. The study concludes, first, that normatively, an administrative decision should not be applied retroactively except to prevent greater harm and/or to protect the rights of the public; thus, any retroactive administrative decision issued without fulfilling such conditions can be deemed invalid. Second, based on the analysis conducted, the Temporary Suspension Decree in question is invalid, and consequently, all legal actions carried out following its issuance remain valid by operation of law. The study also identifies a legal ambiguity in interpreting the condition of “preventing greater harm” within the provisions governing retroactive administrative decisions, thereby indicating the need for further research in the future.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Universitas Islam Indonesia (Islamic University of Indonesia) in Jurnal Lex Renaissance
- Vol. 10 (1) , 222-248
Open AccessKeabsahan Keputusan Tata Usaha Negara yang Berlaku Retroaktif (Studi Kasus Surat Keputusan Menteri Dalam Negeri Tentang Pemberhentian Sementara Wakil Bupati Mimika)
This research is motivated by the retroactive implementation of State Administrative Decrees (KTUN) in the implementation of government administration. This policy anomaly because it will impact the status of legal actions taken before the KTUN is issued. This research aims to answer first, the validity of retroactive administrative decisions based on the theory of authority and the General Principles of Good Governance, and their implications for the legal actions of the Mimika Regency Government; and second, the legal analysis and implications of the Minister of Home Affairs Decree No. 100.2.3-1245 of 2023 concerning the Temporary Suspension of the Deputy Regent of Mimika, Central Papua Province, which applies retroactively. This research employs a normative juridical method using theoretical and conceptual approaches, along with qualitative data analysis. The study concludes, first, that normatively, an administrative decision should not be applied retroactively except to prevent greater harm and/or to protect the rights of the public; thus, any retroactive administrative decision issued without fulfilling such conditions can be deemed invalid. Second, based on the analysis conducted, the Temporary Suspension Decree in question is invalid, and consequently, all legal actions carried out following its issuance remain valid by operation of law. The study also identifies a legal ambiguity in interpreting the condition of “preventing greater harm” within the provisions governing retroactive administrative decisions, thereby indicating the need for further research in the future.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Institute of Research and Community Services Diponegoro University (LPPM UNDIP) in LAW REFORM
- Vol. 21 (1) , 155-179
Digital Government Post-Reform in Indonesia: Normative Developments and Implementation by State Organizing Institutions
Digital development has had a positive impact on public services; however, it has also introduced various legal challenges. This study aims to examine the direction of policy, legal preparedness in Indonesia, and the participatory role of Indonesian society in the digital sphere, particularly in relation to the development and implementation of Digital Government in Indonesia since the post-1998 reform era. This research employs a normative legal methodology, focusing primarily on secondary legal sources.The analysis reveals that the implementation of Digital Government in Indonesia following the reform period remains hindered by sectoral egos, leading to a lack of integration among state institutions in enhancing public services through the Digital Government framework. The study concludes that there is an urgent need for the establishment of a dedicated law on Digital Government, as well as the creation of a specialized state institution responsible for regulating, implementing, and evaluating Digital Government initiatives in Indonesia. Such measures are essential to ensure that public services are delivered in an efficient, accountable, transparent, fast, accessible, and cost-effective manner.
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Institute of Research and Community Services Diponegoro University (LPPM UNDIP) in LAW REFORM
- Vol. 21 (1) , 155-179
Open AccessDigital Government Post-Reform in Indonesia: Normative Developments and Implementation by State Organizing Institutions
Digital development has had a positive impact on public services; however, it has also introduced various legal challenges. This study aims to examine the direction of policy, legal preparedness in Indonesia, and the participatory role of Indonesian society in the digital sphere, particularly in relation to the development and implementation of Digital Government in Indonesia since the post-1998 reform era. This research employs a normative legal methodology, focusing primarily on secondary legal sources.The analysis reveals that the implementation of Digital Government in Indonesia following the reform period remains hindered by sectoral egos, leading to a lack of integration among state institutions in enhancing public services through the Digital Government framework. The study concludes that there is an urgent need for the establishment of a dedicated law on Digital Government, as well as the creation of a specialized state institution responsible for regulating, implementing, and evaluating Digital Government initiatives in Indonesia. Such measures are essential to ensure that public services are delivered in an efficient, accountable, transparent, fast, accessible, and cost-effective manner.
- Open Access
- 17 January 2025
- Published by Yayasan Dharma Indonesia Tercinta (Dinasti) in Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, Humaniora dan Politik
- Vol. 5 (3) , 2433-2443
Penerapan Prinsip Transparansi AUPB Terhadap Putusan Nomor 20/G/KI/2021/PTUN.SRG
Pemerintah Indonesia berkomitmen untuk mewujudkan tata Kelola pemerintahan yang baik, bersih, dan berwibawa melalui pelaksanaan tugas yang luas dan kompleks, yang didasarkan Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945 dan Undang - Undang Nomor 23 Tahun 2014 tentang Pemerintah Daerah. Pemerintah berfokus pada tiga fungsi utama yaitu pelayanan, pemberdayaan, dan pembangunan, dengan perizinan sebagai alat hukum penting. Legalitas Asas-Asas Umum Pemerintahan yang Baik atau dikenal sebagai AUPB diperkuat oleh Undang - Undang Administrasi Publik Tahun 2014, yang berfungsi sebagai pedoman hukum bagi pejabat pemerintahan dalam menjalankan tugas mereka. Pedoman ini dibutuhkan agar setiap tindakan atau kebijakan yang diambil sebagai pejabat pemerintah tidak sewenang-wenang dan mempertimbangkan segala sesuatu dalam prosesnya. Salah satu prinsip penting dalam AUPB dan Good Governance adalah prinsip transparansi. Prinsip Transparansi merupakan simbol dari sebuah mekanisme promosi terhadap good governance untuk mendapatkan kepercayaan publik dalam sebuah demokrasi maupun administrasi publik modern. Prinsip transparansi dalam AUPB dan Good Governance penting untuk melawan maladministrasi, korupsi, dan memastikan akuntabilitas. Pentingnya Prinsip Transparansi dapat kita lihat melalui studi kasus mengenai sengketa di Kota Tangerang menunjukkan pentingnya transparansi dalam alokasi dana kelurahan. PTUN Serang menguatkan keputusan Komisi Informasi Provinsi Banten yang sebagian mengabulkan permohonan KITA-PD, meskipun Pemerintah Kecamatan Benda merasa telah bekerja sesuai peraturan. Hal ini menegaskan bahwa transparansi dan akuntabilitas adalah kunci dalam pemerintahan yang baik dan berwibawa.
- 17 January 2025
- Published by Yayasan Dharma Indonesia Tercinta (Dinasti) in Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, Humaniora dan Politik
- Vol. 5 (3) , 2433-2443
Open AccessPenerapan Prinsip Transparansi AUPB Terhadap Putusan Nomor 20/G/KI/2021/PTUN.SRG
Pemerintah Indonesia berkomitmen untuk mewujudkan tata Kelola pemerintahan yang baik, bersih, dan berwibawa melalui pelaksanaan tugas yang luas dan kompleks, yang didasarkan Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945 dan Undang - Undang Nomor 23 Tahun 2014 tentang Pemerintah Daerah. Pemerintah berfokus pada tiga fungsi utama yaitu pelayanan, pemberdayaan, dan pembangunan, dengan perizinan sebagai alat hukum penting. Legalitas Asas-Asas Umum Pemerintahan yang Baik atau dikenal sebagai AUPB diperkuat oleh Undang - Undang Administrasi Publik Tahun 2014, yang berfungsi sebagai pedoman hukum bagi pejabat pemerintahan dalam menjalankan tugas mereka. Pedoman ini dibutuhkan agar setiap tindakan atau kebijakan yang diambil sebagai pejabat pemerintah tidak sewenang-wenang dan mempertimbangkan segala sesuatu dalam prosesnya. Salah satu prinsip penting dalam AUPB dan Good Governance adalah prinsip transparansi. Prinsip Transparansi merupakan simbol dari sebuah mekanisme promosi terhadap good governance untuk mendapatkan kepercayaan publik dalam sebuah demokrasi maupun administrasi publik modern. Prinsip transparansi dalam AUPB dan Good Governance penting untuk melawan maladministrasi, korupsi, dan memastikan akuntabilitas. Pentingnya Prinsip Transparansi dapat kita lihat melalui studi kasus mengenai sengketa di Kota Tangerang menunjukkan pentingnya transparansi dalam alokasi dana kelurahan. PTUN Serang menguatkan keputusan Komisi Informasi Provinsi Banten yang sebagian mengabulkan permohonan KITA-PD, meskipun Pemerintah Kecamatan Benda merasa telah bekerja sesuai peraturan. Hal ini menegaskan bahwa transparansi dan akuntabilitas adalah kunci dalam pemerintahan yang baik dan berwibawa.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin Makassar in Jurisprudentie : Jurusan Ilmu Hukum Fakultas Syariah dan Hukum
- Vol. 11 (2) , 82-96
Reformulation of Decision Execution and Honorary Council Position of Constitutional Court After Decision Number 604/G/2023/PTUN.JKT
This research analyzes the strength of the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 2/MKMK/L/11/2023 and its execution after Decision Number 604/2023/PTUN.JKT questioning the Appointment of Constitutional Judge Suhartoyo in the object of a state administrative dispute in the form of Constitutional Court Decree Number 17 of 2013. This type of research is a doctrinal research that examines literature sources and statutory studies. Furthermore, this paper uses a conceptual approach and comparative approach that combines the concept of legal certainty and comparisons of several countries in terms of seeing a broader prototype of Ethics Institute arrangements comprehensively. After conducting an analysis, it can be concluded that the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 17 of 2013 which contains ethical sanctions for violations of Constitutional Judge Anwar Usman is constrained by legal uncertainty in its execution. This is because there is no mechanism for the dismissal of the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court after the imposition of ethical sanctions and there is a potential dualism in the ethical enforcement system that can be convoluted. The uncertainty of the execution of the Constitutional Court Honor Council Decision which has the potential to be convoluted with the involvement of the State Administrative Court in adjudicating the Decision a quo should be a reflection to distinguish the authority of law enforcement and ethical enforcement and their scope. This can be encouraged by strengthening the status of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court in its position as a Supervisory body as well as the arrangement of the Supreme Advisory Council in the Armenian Constitution. Keywords: Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court, Decision ethics, execution
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin Makassar in Jurisprudentie : Jurusan Ilmu Hukum Fakultas Syariah dan Hukum
- Vol. 11 (2) , 82-96
Open AccessReformulation of Decision Execution and Honorary Council Position of Constitutional Court After Decision Number 604/G/2023/PTUN.JKT
This research analyzes the strength of the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 2/MKMK/L/11/2023 and its execution after Decision Number 604/2023/PTUN.JKT questioning the Appointment of Constitutional Judge Suhartoyo in the object of a state administrative dispute in the form of Constitutional Court Decree Number 17 of 2013. This type of research is a doctrinal research that examines literature sources and statutory studies. Furthermore, this paper uses a conceptual approach and comparative approach that combines the concept of legal certainty and comparisons of several countries in terms of seeing a broader prototype of Ethics Institute arrangements comprehensively. After conducting an analysis, it can be concluded that the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 17 of 2013 which contains ethical sanctions for violations of Constitutional Judge Anwar Usman is constrained by legal uncertainty in its execution. This is because there is no mechanism for the dismissal of the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court after the imposition of ethical sanctions and there is a potential dualism in the ethical enforcement system that can be convoluted. The uncertainty of the execution of the Constitutional Court Honor Council Decision which has the potential to be convoluted with the involvement of the State Administrative Court in adjudicating the Decision a quo should be a reflection to distinguish the authority of law enforcement and ethical enforcement and their scope. This can be encouraged by strengthening the status of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court in its position as a Supervisory body as well as the arrangement of the Supreme Advisory Council in the Armenian Constitution. Keywords: Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court, Decision ethics, execution
- Open Access
- 8 October 2024
- Published by Unived Press in JURNAL HUKUM SEHASEN
- Vol. 10 (2) , 637-644
Administrative Law Enforcement Concerning Disrespectful Dismissal of Civil Servants in the Perspective of the State Administrative Court
The administrative law enforcement regarding the dishonorable discharge of Civil Servants (PNS) or State Civil Apparatus (ASN) is a process that involves a series of legal procedures and mechanisms that must be followed by government agencies. From the perspective of the Administrative Court (PTUN), the decision to discharge a Civil Servant or State Civil Apparatus can be reviewed to ensure that the procedures used comply with applicable regulations and that the decision was made fairly and without discrimination. The Administrative Court has the authority to annul the discharge decision if violations of administrative law or principles of justice are found. This study aims to analyze how the Administrative Court evaluates and adjudicates cases of dishonorable discharge of Civil Servants or State Civil Apparatus, as well as to identify the obstacles encountered in the process of enforcing administrative law.
- 8 October 2024
- Published by Unived Press in JURNAL HUKUM SEHASEN
- Vol. 10 (2) , 637-644
Open AccessAdministrative Law Enforcement Concerning Disrespectful Dismissal of Civil Servants in the Perspective of the State Administrative Court
The administrative law enforcement regarding the dishonorable discharge of Civil Servants (PNS) or State Civil Apparatus (ASN) is a process that involves a series of legal procedures and mechanisms that must be followed by government agencies. From the perspective of the Administrative Court (PTUN), the decision to discharge a Civil Servant or State Civil Apparatus can be reviewed to ensure that the procedures used comply with applicable regulations and that the decision was made fairly and without discrimination. The Administrative Court has the authority to annul the discharge decision if violations of administrative law or principles of justice are found. This study aims to analyze how the Administrative Court evaluates and adjudicates cases of dishonorable discharge of Civil Servants or State Civil Apparatus, as well as to identify the obstacles encountered in the process of enforcing administrative law.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2024
- Published by Fiat Justisia in Constitutionale
- Vol. 5 (2) , 85-98
Discourse on the Application of Dwangsom on Execution Court Decisions: A Comparison with Netherlands and France
The classic problem in resolving State Administration disputes boils down to the process of implementing decisions by the parties, which in practice still does not fully meet the expectations of justice seekers. If the decision is not implemented, the State Administrative Court (PTUN) imposes administrative sanctions / coercive measures against the losing party, which can be in the form of sanctions for forced payment of money (dwangsom), in order to increase the executable power of the decision. Normally, the same as the General Court, even though currently there are not many cases, it is still a problem. Article 116 paragraph (4) of the PTUN Law regulates the mechanism for coercive measures against the execution of PTUN decisions, but it is still interpreted as containing a "rechtsvacuum". This research uses normative legal research methods through literature study, and uses descriptive analysis with deductive and comparative methods. The results of the research show that the emergence of discourse on the application of dwangsom is interpreted as a means of psychological coercion against the losing parties in order to order them to comply with the ruling. If we refer to the comparison of the French and Dutch State Administrative Court justice systems, in the Administrative Justice system in France, if the government does not implement decisions that are its obligations, then it can be subject to astreinte/dwangsom, likewise in the Netherlands, the longer the decision of the administrative justice body is not implemented, the greater the burden of dwangsom that must be borne by TUN officials.
- 31 July 2024
- Published by Fiat Justisia in Constitutionale
- Vol. 5 (2) , 85-98
Open AccessDiscourse on the Application of Dwangsom on Execution Court Decisions: A Comparison with Netherlands and France
The classic problem in resolving State Administration disputes boils down to the process of implementing decisions by the parties, which in practice still does not fully meet the expectations of justice seekers. If the decision is not implemented, the State Administrative Court (PTUN) imposes administrative sanctions / coercive measures against the losing party, which can be in the form of sanctions for forced payment of money (dwangsom), in order to increase the executable power of the decision. Normally, the same as the General Court, even though currently there are not many cases, it is still a problem. Article 116 paragraph (4) of the PTUN Law regulates the mechanism for coercive measures against the execution of PTUN decisions, but it is still interpreted as containing a "rechtsvacuum". This research uses normative legal research methods through literature study, and uses descriptive analysis with deductive and comparative methods. The results of the research show that the emergence of discourse on the application of dwangsom is interpreted as a means of psychological coercion against the losing parties in order to order them to comply with the ruling. If we refer to the comparison of the French and Dutch State Administrative Court justice systems, in the Administrative Justice system in France, if the government does not implement decisions that are its obligations, then it can be subject to astreinte/dwangsom, likewise in the Netherlands, the longer the decision of the administrative justice body is not implemented, the greater the burden of dwangsom that must be borne by TUN officials.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Universitas Internasional Batam in Journal of Law and Policy Transformation
- Vol. 7 (2) , 121-137
REVIEW OF INDONESIAN CONSTITUTIONAL COURT DECISION NUMBER 135/PHP.BUP-XIX/2021
The determination of the elected Regent and Deputy Regent by the General Election Commission (KPU) of Sabu Raijua Regency was formed without paying attention to the provisions of the Legislation and General Principles of Good Governance. The reason is that Orient Riwu Kore was only known to have dual citizenship after issuing the KPU Decree. The Constitutional Court later annulled the KPU decree. In contrast, Article 24C of the Constitution mandates that the MK's authority decide disputes regarding the general election results. On the other hand, the KPU stipulation decree is related to the general election process, not a dispute over the vote results. The dispute resolution process should be done through administrative efforts to the BAWASLU and the PTUN. Therefore, it becomes a question regarding the basis of the authority and reasons for the Constitutional Court to resolve disputes over the general election process. This research is in the form of normative juridical. The approach used in this research is the statutory approach and the case approach. This research is categorized in a prescriptive research typology. The data that has been collected will be analyzed qualitatively, and the results of this study are categorized in the form of prescriptive-analytical research. The result of this research show if the dispute of the KPU decree should be solved by administrative efforts in the form of adjudication to Bawaslu. Only then can the PTUN lawsuit be filed. However, suppose the dispute resolution process is carried out through the Administrative Court, it will take a long time. So that it can be understood that the acceptance of the applicant's application by the Constitutional Court is due to the absence of a more effective mechanism that can be carried out for the determination of the KPU decree other than through the Constitutional Court. Keywords: election disputes; constitutional court decision; decrees; general election commissions.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Universitas Internasional Batam in Journal of Law and Policy Transformation
- Vol. 7 (2) , 121-137
Open AccessREVIEW OF INDONESIAN CONSTITUTIONAL COURT DECISION NUMBER 135/PHP.BUP-XIX/2021
The determination of the elected Regent and Deputy Regent by the General Election Commission (KPU) of Sabu Raijua Regency was formed without paying attention to the provisions of the Legislation and General Principles of Good Governance. The reason is that Orient Riwu Kore was only known to have dual citizenship after issuing the KPU Decree. The Constitutional Court later annulled the KPU decree. In contrast, Article 24C of the Constitution mandates that the MK's authority decide disputes regarding the general election results. On the other hand, the KPU stipulation decree is related to the general election process, not a dispute over the vote results. The dispute resolution process should be done through administrative efforts to the BAWASLU and the PTUN. Therefore, it becomes a question regarding the basis of the authority and reasons for the Constitutional Court to resolve disputes over the general election process. This research is in the form of normative juridical. The approach used in this research is the statutory approach and the case approach. This research is categorized in a prescriptive research typology. The data that has been collected will be analyzed qualitatively, and the results of this study are categorized in the form of prescriptive-analytical research. The result of this research show if the dispute of the KPU decree should be solved by administrative efforts in the form of adjudication to Bawaslu. Only then can the PTUN lawsuit be filed. However, suppose the dispute resolution process is carried out through the Administrative Court, it will take a long time. So that it can be understood that the acceptance of the applicant's application by the Constitutional Court is due to the absence of a more effective mechanism that can be carried out for the determination of the KPU decree other than through the Constitutional Court. Keywords: election disputes; constitutional court decision; decrees; general election commissions.
- Open Access
- 29 June 2022
- Published by Universitas Internasional Batam in Journal of Law and Policy Transformation
- Vol. 7 (1) , 124-142
THE SETTLEMENT OF TWO CONTRADICT RECONSIDERATION VERDICTS IN DIFFERENT CHAMBERS (CASE STUDY OF COURT’S VERDICT NUMBER 162 PK/TUN/2015 AND 1053/PDT/2019)
Judicial review might be submitted by the parties as a form of objection to the judge's decision which has permanent legal force. In practice, it is possible for an object of dispute to be filed in two chambers of courts that cause two sentences with permanent legal force contradict each other as in between case Number 162 PK/TUN/2015 and 1053/PDT/2019. The two cases decide which party has the right to manage a mining business permit area, but when the two decisions are about to be executed, the two Mining Business Permit Areas between PT Pasir Prima Coal Indonesia (PT PPCI) and PT Mandiri Sejahtera Energindo Indonesia (PT MSEI) will still overlap. This paper uses a normative empirical research method with a judicial case study approach, which its normative research based on the provisions of the applicable laws and regulations is carried out in parallel by dissecting several related court decisions. The legal materials used in this study are in the form of books containing the opinions of legal practitioners and academics, legislations, and of course the court's decisions. In their considerations, the Panel of Judges in the general court room focuses on seeking material truth, and the Panel of Judges in the state administrative court looks at the administrative process in the issuance of a state administrative decision. The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court through his letter explained that the case could go through a second review where the composition of the panel of judges consisted of the chairman of the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court justices from civil chamber, and the Supreme Court justices from the state administrative law chamber, as stated in the Supreme Court Circular Number 5 of 2014 and Circular Letter of the Supreme Court Number 4 of 2016.
- 29 June 2022
- Published by Universitas Internasional Batam in Journal of Law and Policy Transformation
- Vol. 7 (1) , 124-142
Open AccessTHE SETTLEMENT OF TWO CONTRADICT RECONSIDERATION VERDICTS IN DIFFERENT CHAMBERS (CASE STUDY OF COURT’S VERDICT NUMBER 162 PK/TUN/2015 AND 1053/PDT/2019)
Judicial review might be submitted by the parties as a form of objection to the judge's decision which has permanent legal force. In practice, it is possible for an object of dispute to be filed in two chambers of courts that cause two sentences with permanent legal force contradict each other as in between case Number 162 PK/TUN/2015 and 1053/PDT/2019. The two cases decide which party has the right to manage a mining business permit area, but when the two decisions are about to be executed, the two Mining Business Permit Areas between PT Pasir Prima Coal Indonesia (PT PPCI) and PT Mandiri Sejahtera Energindo Indonesia (PT MSEI) will still overlap. This paper uses a normative empirical research method with a judicial case study approach, which its normative research based on the provisions of the applicable laws and regulations is carried out in parallel by dissecting several related court decisions. The legal materials used in this study are in the form of books containing the opinions of legal practitioners and academics, legislations, and of course the court's decisions. In their considerations, the Panel of Judges in the general court room focuses on seeking material truth, and the Panel of Judges in the state administrative court looks at the administrative process in the issuance of a state administrative decision. The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court through his letter explained that the case could go through a second review where the composition of the panel of judges consisted of the chairman of the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court justices from civil chamber, and the Supreme Court justices from the state administrative law chamber, as stated in the Supreme Court Circular Number 5 of 2014 and Circular Letter of the Supreme Court Number 4 of 2016.