Anna I. Thoma
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Anna I. Thoma has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dirk U. Wulff
Max Planck Institute for Human Development, Berlin, Germany
2 shared publications - Ralph Hertwig
Max Planck Institute for Human Development
2 shared publications - Ben Newell
University of New South Wales
1 shared publication - Benito Kurzenberger
Department of Psychology & Ergonomics, Technische Universität Berlin
1 shared publication - Christin Schulze
Center for Adaptive Rationality, Max Planck Institute for Human Development
1 shared publication - Christopher Lazik
HU Berlin, Berlin, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 28 September 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in American Psychologist
Mapping the gender attrition gap in academic psychology.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in American Psychologist
Mapping the gender attrition gap in academic psychology.
- Open Access
- 21 September 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (39)
Human learning is an understudied but promising lever for boosting human–AI synergy
Humans collaborating with AI hold the promise of achieving superior outcomes compared to either acting alone (i.e., human–AI synergy). However, the conditions that facilitate such synergy when humans are advised by AI are not well understood. A recent meta-analysis showed that, on average, human–AI combinations do not outperform the better individual agent. We argue that this pessimistic conclusion arises from insufficient attention to human learning in experimental designs. To substantiate this claim, we reanalyzed all 74 studies included in the original meta-analysis and found that most previous research overlooked design features that foster human learning (e.g., outcome feedback to participants). Our reanalysis further revealed that studies providing outcome feedback show tentatively higher synergy than those without outcome feedback. Crucially, feedback paired with AI explanations was associated with positive synergy, while explanations without feedback were associated with negative synergy—suggesting that explanations improve synergy mainly when humans can learn to verify the AI’s reliability through feedback. Our reanalysis suggests that the current literature underestimates the potential of human–AI collaboration because it predominantly relies on paradigms that do not facilitate human learning, thus hindering humans from effectively adapting their collaboration strategies. However, experiments directly varying learning opportunities are needed for stronger, causal conclusions. We advocate for a paradigm shift in human–AI interaction research that explicitly addresses human learning and thus enhances our understanding of and support for successful human–AI collaboration.
- 21 September 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (39)
Open AccessHuman learning is an understudied but promising lever for boosting human–AI synergy
Humans collaborating with AI hold the promise of achieving superior outcomes compared to either acting alone (i.e., human–AI synergy). However, the conditions that facilitate such synergy when humans are advised by AI are not well understood. A recent meta-analysis showed that, on average, human–AI combinations do not outperform the better individual agent. We argue that this pessimistic conclusion arises from insufficient attention to human learning in experimental designs. To substantiate this claim, we reanalyzed all 74 studies included in the original meta-analysis and found that most previous research overlooked design features that foster human learning (e.g., outcome feedback to participants). Our reanalysis further revealed that studies providing outcome feedback show tentatively higher synergy than those without outcome feedback. Crucially, feedback paired with AI explanations was associated with positive synergy, while explanations without feedback were associated with negative synergy—suggesting that explanations improve synergy mainly when humans can learn to verify the AI’s reliability through feedback. Our reanalysis suggests that the current literature underestimates the potential of human–AI collaboration because it predominantly relies on paradigms that do not facilitate human learning, thus hindering humans from effectively adapting their collaboration strategies. However, experiments directly varying learning opportunities are needed for stronger, causal conclusions. We advocate for a paradigm shift in human–AI interaction research that explicitly addresses human learning and thus enhances our understanding of and support for successful human–AI collaboration.
- Open Access
DfE-DB: A systematic database of 3.8 million human decisions across experience-based tasks
Learning from experience is central to human decision making, but progress is limited by heterogeneous task designs and fragmented data formats that hinder systematic comparison across studies. We introduce the Decisions From Experience Database (DfE-DB), a structured, open-access resource comprising 3.8 million trial-level decisions from 11,921 participants across 168 studies and 13 paradigms. By harmonizing raw behavioral data and classifying studies along 13 key design features, the DfE-DB enables quantitative comparisons previously obscured by heterogeneous task and data structures. Using the database, we show that choice tendencies—toward higher risk, expected value, or experienced mean—vary substantially across paradigms and are strongly shaped by core design features such as feed-back type, outcome structure, stationarity, and sampling. These features explain substantial cross-study variability and reveal underexplored paradigm variants. By providing a unified and extensible data infrastructure, the DfE-DB facilitates reproducible research on testing the generality of behavioral phenomena and computational models, fostering a more integrated science of decisions from experience.
Open AccessDfE-DB: A systematic database of 3.8 million human decisions across experience-based tasks
Learning from experience is central to human decision making, but progress is limited by heterogeneous task designs and fragmented data formats that hinder systematic comparison across studies. We introduce the Decisions From Experience Database (DfE-DB), a structured, open-access resource comprising 3.8 million trial-level decisions from 11,921 participants across 168 studies and 13 paradigms. By harmonizing raw behavioral data and classifying studies along 13 key design features, the DfE-DB enables quantitative comparisons previously obscured by heterogeneous task and data structures. Using the database, we show that choice tendencies—toward higher risk, expected value, or experienced mean—vary substantially across paradigms and are strongly shaped by core design features such as feed-back type, outcome structure, stationarity, and sampling. These features explain substantial cross-study variability and reveal underexplored paradigm variants. By providing a unified and extensible data infrastructure, the DfE-DB facilitates reproducible research on testing the generality of behavioral phenomena and computational models, fostering a more integrated science of decisions from experience.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 154 (6) , 1523-1544
Emerging adaptivity in probability learning: How young minds and the environment interact.
Children often have to choose between two or more probabilistically rewarded options. How early in life do they learn to choose adaptively? Connecting research on ecologically rational probability matching in adulthood with research on the benefits of cognitive immaturity in childhood, we compared children's (3-11 years; N = 362) and adults' (N = 121) repeated choice behavior in a child-friendly probability learning task. We implemented two static and one ecologically plausible statistical environment as between-subjects conditions. Behavioral and computational modeling analyses provided converging evidence for perseveration tendencies in 3- to 4-year-olds and adaptive choice diversification from age 6 years onward. On average, school-aged children showed a stronger tendency for exploration, whereas adults were better able to overcome this tendency in favor of exploitation. Our findings emphasize the importance of implementing ecologically plausible task environments in research on cognitive development and contribute a novel repeated choice perspective to the discussion on the adaptive functions of wide exploration in childhood. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 154 (6) , 1523-1544
Emerging adaptivity in probability learning: How young minds and the environment interact.
Children often have to choose between two or more probabilistically rewarded options. How early in life do they learn to choose adaptively? Connecting research on ecologically rational probability matching in adulthood with research on the benefits of cognitive immaturity in childhood, we compared children's (3-11 years; N = 362) and adults' (N = 121) repeated choice behavior in a child-friendly probability learning task. We implemented two static and one ecologically plausible statistical environment as between-subjects conditions. Behavioral and computational modeling analyses provided converging evidence for perseveration tendencies in 3- to 4-year-olds and adaptive choice diversification from age 6 years onward. On average, school-aged children showed a stronger tendency for exploration, whereas adults were better able to overcome this tendency in favor of exploitation. Our findings emphasize the importance of implementing ecologically plausible task environments in research on cognitive development and contribute a novel repeated choice perspective to the discussion on the adaptive functions of wide exploration in childhood. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).